Cover Image: Manga Classics: The Count of Monte Cristo

Manga Classics: The Count of Monte Cristo

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

This is the nth time that I've read a Manga Classics from that were published by Udon Entertainment. I still haven't the classic book of The Count of Mount Cristo and I didn't have the slightest idea about the story.

The original novel of Alexandre Dumas is a thousand-page book, hence it will took several days or weeks before I could finish reading it. However, through this adaptation, I was able to finish reading this classic story in just several hours. It's a great alternative for someone like me who wants to read this classic but don't have much time to spare to read the novel.

The tale of Edmond Dantes' and the revenge he did for the three people who deceived him will set readers to anticipate what will happened in the end. This story reminds everyone not to be naive and trustworthy just like Dantes in the beginning of the story. If only he was observant on the people around him, he would not be imprisoned because of the false accusation that Danglars and Fernand conspired.

The Count of Monte Cristo is undoubtedly one of the best classic story I've read so far. And these manga classics encourage not only reading, but also on promoting and appreciating the greatest classic novels.

Was this review helpful?

My rating 5 Stars.

Basically I am a comic book lover, first time I am reading a Manga. I have not read The Count of Monte Cristo book when it was available for review in Net galley I picked it up.

The graphic novel “The Count Of Monte Cristo” is 401 pages long, a classic tale of Alexandre Dumas adapted to Manga the art work by Nokman Poon and story adaption by Crystal S.Chan.
From the blurb
"A conspiracy and a miscarriage of justice turn the gentle Edmond Dante's into an implacable agent of fate: The Count of Monte Cristo. Obsessed by vengeance and empowered by providence, the Count avenges himself on those who have wronged him - but is this justice, or is this hubris? In the end, does even the Count know?"
The story is huge and complex plot with vast number of characters the team have worked very well in nicely trimming the story at the same time stick to the rule of showing how Edmond Dantes took revenge on those who did him wrong. A commendable work that we have to appreciate. The artwork is superb and excellent, the facial expressions of characters are worth mentioning, even the copy I had is un-edited and low resolution ones.

They have given a character design sketch book, character relationship guide, the artist have also shared his thoughts about the designing some of the characters such as Edmond Dantes, Haydee, Albert De Morcerf and Valentine De Villefort. Further they also added some photographs, the original locations related to the story. I enjoyed reading Manga Classic, recommended to Manga lovers.

Was this review helpful?

This manga adaptation of "The Count of Monte Cristo" by Alexandre Dumas is just...beyond words! It's
a visually stunning masterpiece that incorporates all of the classic elements of the original work, but also adds a unique, artistic perspective that elevates the story on another level. I truly loved the portrayal of the characters and the environment the artist created. The vividness of it all placed me right in the middle of all the action.

A must read and much needed addition to any literary collection. Will certainly do a write up on my blog!

Was this review helpful?

I am not sure that reproducing some classics into a more modern form of manga is the best idea. Sometimes it works this unfortunately didn't. The Count of Monte Cristo is originally over 1000 pages and this is around 400 I honestly think to do this tome of revenge justice the author and illustrator should have made it into a two part to show the tone of the original book. Also this seems to have modern slang being used which completely takes you out of the book and the setting. This just wasn't for me but I would suggest it to someone who wants to read the original work and this might give them an idea of what to expect.

Was this review helpful?

Amazing, I love it. The art is good and the story its strong.

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately, I wasn't able to read it. The file only downloaded one page, all in black. Tried multiple times and got the same result.

Was this review helpful?

I have only read the original text once and seen the 2002 movie. I liked it just not enough to read it over and over. The tale is about Edmond Dantes. Dantes spends his life plotting his revenge after he is wrongfully imprisoned just as everything is about to fall into place in his life. So when I was told that it was put in manga form, I decided I wanted to give it a try. Especially since I have read other manga classics and really enjoyed those. It was adapted well into manga form. The drawings came to life for me and helped the story flow in harmony. There was not a time that I was lost because of an image. The pages that had notes on different subjects such as different design was really helpful to read and helped me understand this version even more! This manga was delightful I recommend it to all especially those who love the original version.

Was this review helpful?

This manga definitely kept me on my toes! I can't believe that the author somehow managed to condense such a big book into a manga and still make you feel like you didn't miss out on any big details. I'm really impressed.
I'm in love with the Crystal's art style and how she puts so much detail into her characters. And once again I'm inspired to read the original book. Keep up the hard work Crystal!
5 Stars!

Was this review helpful?

A beautiful re-imagining of an classic piece of literature in a modern format. It stays true to the manga style without losing any of the features or plot points of the much loved novel.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you for this book! This is such an easy way for me to get more difficult texts into the hands of my lower readers ESPECIALLY because it utilizes the same language as the original However, the file was corrupt and I couldn't read any of it. I just know the quality of these books since I've read a few of the others so I assume it's just as good.

Was this review helpful?

Apologies this book expired before I was able to review it. I have been out of the country for work and that set my reading back. I have enjoyed other manga classics and I am happy to review it if you make the file available to me. Once more apologies for the delay.

Was this review helpful?

I don't know why, but I neve be able to tread this book, and not because I didn't want to or didn't try, but because the file never works. Not in my phone, not in my PC, not in the other PC.

So sad, The Count of Monte Cristo is one of my favorite books.

Was this review helpful?

I've always wanted to read the story but was too lazy to read the original because have you looked at the page number?I like thick books but not if I mainly want to read them because they're classics. Anyway, beautiful illustrations of the story, though I can't say how true to original the manga is in terms of character appearance and language I greatly enjoyed it.

Was this review helpful?

I received this copy from the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review

I really tried to read this manga but DNF'd it at maybe 100 pages in. I kept messing up on how to read it and so it made no sense I had to keep going back to reread it. That was a failed attempt on my part but the illustrations were very pretty and the story was interesting enough to want to make me pick up the actual book.

Was this review helpful?

A very good classic turned Manga! Definitely read it!

Was this review helpful?

Rating: 📚📚📚📚📚

The Count of Monte Cristo is a brilliant, dark tale of retribution, and the price of vengeance on all parties involved.

This story has all the intense drama and tragedy I am familiar with from other of Dumas’ works. Edmond Dantes, falsely imprisoned on the very day of his engagement, is abandoned in the bowels of Chateau d’If, forgotten for years until he manages escape. Through those long years, Dantes had plenty of time to dwell upon vengeance. I cannot even imagine how terrifying it must be to be locked away without trial, abandoned & forgotten.

A hidden fortune allows Dantes to crate the identity the Count of Monte Cristo. Deftly inserting himself amongst high society, he begins to weave the threads of his deviously masterful revenge. One by one, the lives of his oppressors begin crumbling around them. Sadly, Dantes gets a doubly harsh blow at finding his one-time fiancee married to one of the men responsible for his imprisonment.

Despite enjoying Dumas’ other works, this was my first experience with The Count of Monte Cristo. Like those other works, this actual novel is rather long, so I was impressed with how it translated to the manga version. By necessity, many things were simplified. I don't feel much, if anything, was lost from the story though. A section at the end of the book discusses the artists’ choices in what to focus on and how, in order to pack the greatest amount of story into the manga version.

*** Dos mere to Penguin/ Netgalley for providing a free copy of this book in exchange for a fair and honest review!

Was this review helpful?

I've never read the original source material, but now I'm kinda itching to do so. I feel like any of these Manga classics are making me feel like doing so. The art is amazing and the overall story wasn't confusing or difficult to follow, unlike how I usually feel when I read a classic. Overall, I really enjoyed it!

Was this review helpful?

I think the manga was drawn really well. An emotional storyline and a satisfying ending.

Was this review helpful?

It might be because I don't know the original, it might be because even at 400pp it's too abrupt, but this seemed seriously over-egged to me. Ooh a horse disaster bring just the right person to the right door, ooh a woman fainting at a back story involving a servant I really couldn't give a toss about... There clearly are problems with this book making everyone look and act as if they are in a manga and not historical France, but there are also problems with the cheesiness of it all, which I will charitably lay at the feet of M Dumas and not these creators. Not my thing - DNF at a third.

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely lovely. Perfect to keep to keep readers engaged and interested in classics. A must for teachers.

Was this review helpful?