Member Reviews

This is a REVIEW ONLY of The BOOK CLUB KIT for “If the Shoe Fits,” a romantic modern Cinderella novel by Julie Murphy about a plus-size shoe designer who just might find her Prince Charming on a national TV show. This fabulously created colorful 24-page e-book is with loaded with everything to make your Book Club meeting memorable. There are loads of discussion questions to stimulate insightful two-way conversations among reading groups, and is full of visual appeal because of its bright art and bold, eye-catching graphics. The Q & As are excellent and will be useful for Book Club Leaders, Librarians, as well as readers themselves who want extra insight into the background of the book and author. 💕 As all compelling Book Kits do by adding additional graphics and fun elements, this one truly rocks! It also offers recipes for pizza and cocktails; Book Club Bingo; a shoe design challenge; quizzes; additional suggested readings and so much more. This is a truly exciting Book Kit worthy of it’s designation. 💕

TheBookMaven graciously thanks NetGalley, Author Julie Murphy, and Publisher We Are Bookish for this Advanced Reader’s Copy (ARC) for review.

Was this review helpful?

I loved a lot of things about this book, but unfortunately the romance was not one of them. The Bachelor-esque premise, which did give this book a readable quality and fast paced feeling, just wasn't a good breeding ground for a spectacular romance. It was actually quite lacklustre, which I hate to say because I felt potential and chemistry between the love interests.

It was however, a good vehicle to discuss plus size representation in media and in fashion. And I think that's what I loved most about If the Shoe Fits.

Was this review helpful?

This is my first time seeing a book club kit and WHAT A GREAT IDEA!! My book club that I run is primarily fantasy/ fantasy romance, but I wanted to take a peek at what these look like, and hopefully in the future some fantasy options might exist.

It starts off with an author interview which I felt really got me excited about the book again (I read it last year), and was a great refresher on the book. Then the book club kit has a great variety of engaging things - discussion questions, a shoe design challenge, a quiz about the reality tv show (mostly C’s for me - making it to the top two!), some great bookmarks, a bingo board, some suggestions what to read next and some other fun and engaging things.

All in all it felt like a well rounded book club kit and was so much fun to read and review. All thoughts and opinions are my own and weren’t influenced by receiving an arc.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book - such a great premise and loved the twists on Cinderella and how Cindy is portrayed in such a positive light. Steamy and sweet balanced well too.

Looking forward to additional books in this series!

The Book Club items were fun and useful for meetings.

Was this review helpful?

This was a really great book for book clubs.
I loved the quiz and the bingo! Really nice to read this with people.
Also the recipes!!! Loved that.
Really recommend this if you’ve read the book.

Was this review helpful?

The Book Club Kit for If the Shoe Fits by Julie Murphy was a phenomenal addition to reading this book with a book club. The interview with the author gave amazing insight into Murphy’s development. This pack has awesome questions that we i can use in group. Thank you NetGalley. I can't wait until I can use my bookmark again from this book kit.

Was this review helpful?

This kit is an amazing way for people who have book clubs to do fun things after or whilst reading the book. This kit is fun and filled with amazing inside information for the reader.

Was this review helpful?

Julie Murphy can do no wrong! She is such a great writer! I loved reading this Cinderella re-telling! It's so good! I highly recommend reading it with a group and using this Book Club Kit. I'm so glad that this is the first book in a series.

Was this review helpful?

I think this is helpful for any book club or reading discussion. I also liked the recipes in the back!

Was this review helpful?

I mistakenly requested this book because I thought it was the actual book.
I liked that there were topics for discussions, short quizzes and a book club bingo!
I also liked the Disneybounding challenge, it looks like something I might want to try out.
There were also recipes in the kit

Was this review helpful?

There are all kinds of fun pages in this book club book! This is perfect for book clubs if you’re reading If the Shoe Fits.

Was this review helpful?

After finishing this short-but-sweet kit I feel it added to the reading experience and provided lots of topics for discussion among readers.

The author's interview is really great. Julie Murphy came across as down to earth and relatable in her answers and I loved the insight into her writing process.

I think content warnings are always appreciated. We can never be too prepared when starting a new novel and when it comes to triggers it's better to be overly aware.

The other elements in the book club kit, such as the challenges and quizes, further book recommendations from Julie herself and other authors and the food and drink recipes would be perfect for an in-person book club.

The only thing that may not be successful is presuming people are attending in-person book clubs when in reality, social media and virtual book clubs are more popular and prevalent in the book community, especially since Covid-19. The digital space among readers has exploded so I think targeting the online community is very beneficial.

Was this review helpful?

I love this book club kit. How fun to have a pizza recipe, a cocktail, recipe, handy discussion questions, bookmarks and even a craft project to go along with a book. I've been in book clubs for many years and we've never had anything like this. I hope they continue to make more of these.

Was this review helpful?

This book kit is intended to accompany the book "If the Shoe Fits" by Julie Murphy. Never having hosted a book club before, this book kit gave a plethora of different types of insight into the book that will guide me as my friends and I intend to start our own book club. I really enjoyed the author interview that gave insight into Murphy's writing processes, inspirations, and struggles with writing this novel. The discussion questions were good conversation starters about the plot, and some could even be used as inspirations for book club talks about other books. The bookmarks were adorable and the following activities were very cute. I also appreciated the food and drink recipes!

Was this review helpful?

This was such a fun book club kit! My friends and I read If the Shoe Fits for a book club, so when I saw this club kit I thought it would be fun to share with them and see how we liked it.

We loved the interview with the author to get some more insight into the book and all of the extras that were added into the the kit! The questions were all a great mix and allowed us to all come up with some different insights into what we read. There were recipes for pizza and a drink, so we made those for the book club too! The "read next" books at the end had some great recommendations that we added to our list of potential books to read for book club!

Overall, we thought this was a fun kit that enhanced our book club experience. While we didn't use all of the elements (the shoe design and bookmarks) it was fun to have some extras that made reading this book even better!

Was this review helpful?

Book club kits add a lot of value to group reading! My friends loved receiving the book markers as a surprise and it was really fun to do the BOOK CLUB BINGO worth a marguerita hahaha the list of recommended readings was very good too, I added several of those books to my "want to read" list. And, as is tradition in my book club, we made THE CINDY cocktail and it was a success!!!

Was this review helpful?

Loved this Book Club Kit! It's stacked to the brim with book extras! You're provided with an interview from the author, 14 discussion questions to bring to book club and 2 double sided bookmarks. You get a Shoe design challenge as well as a "How Far Would You Make It In Before Midnight" quiz. You also get two book club activities! My favorite parts of the kit the pizza recipe as well as the Cocktail Recipe. Can't wait to try these out!

Was this review helpful?

If the Shoe Fits by Julie Murphy will be next book for the book club!

It was my week to choose the book and after a little research this one caught my eye. This Book Club Kit is amazing, the proposal of the bingo, the quiz, the pizza and cocktail (that we already tried out) (it was magnificent) and the shoe design are things my book club would love to do. Creativity, artsy and hunger overtakes that room all the time, it was very nice to see how all of the activities related so well to the theme.

Julie Murphy has always been one of the favorites in the Book Club, we can't wait to read this and the books recommended as well. Definitely recommending this kit to more friends!

Was this review helpful?

Ahh this book club kit was just perfect!! Thank you netgalley can’t wait to continue using it! This is the perfect little kit for all book clubs and I love how self guided it all is!! I absolutely loved this book and so it was super fun to use!

Was this review helpful?

This maybe the next read in my book club. This pack has awesome questions that we i can use in group, and will make my group plan a lot easier.
I love the bookmarks included for printing - will definitely be printing them.

the challenge/game idea are pretty cool and will b fun to try out.
And without a shadow of a doubt I know already the signature cocktail recipe will go down a treat.

the recommendations are also really helpful for possible future reads
Thank you for this pack, it is really fun and I will be pushing for this to be our next book (we vote at the end of each meeting) my fingers are crossed for this book

Was this review helpful?