Cover Image: Our Missing Hearts

Our Missing Hearts

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

This book is very upsetting. It depicts a dystopian country where anyone of Asian descent is the enemy. Anyone who tries to rebel is hunted down. It becomes more disturbing because it is easy to see how something like this could happen.

Was this review helpful?

Very different from Ng's other novels and I had a difficult time getting into the story and relating to the characters.

Was this review helpful?

Excellent read! I enjoyed reading Our Missing Hearts and have purchased it for our library. I appreciate the chance to read a kindle version from Net Galley and the publisher.

Was this review helpful?

This book deals with a really important topic with great characters. However, it feel a little flat for me especially the end, which makes me sad because I was really looking forward to this one.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a free copy of the book in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

An excellent read; very " of the moment". In the scheme of things very little suspension of disbelief. Gives the reader pause...how would i respond in this situation.

Was this review helpful?

In this dystopian novel set in the not-to-distant future, ethnic differences are considered the "enemy" and many people (particularly those of Asian descent) have disappeared either into the prison system or in hiding. Although this is certainly a cautionary tale about censorship and racism, it's really the story of a boy and his mother and the bonds that hold them together.

I was surprisingly impressed with this book. I don't know why I was surprised since I have read and enjoyed other books by Celeste Ng. This one is particularly touching. The emotions are raw and the story is filled with tension and some surprises. There were moments that brought tears to my eyes, and the message is clear without overpowering the story of mother and child. Just wonderful!!

As a side note -- I loved that librarians are "heroes" in this story, both preserving the literature and culture and helping the oppressed.

Was this review helpful?

I read up to page 132 in Our Missing Hearts and had to stop. It was supposed to be a dystopian book but essentially pulled from history and tried to write it off as original ideas. The characters were not very developed up until the part I read up to which was a few pages before part two. When I heard from a friend the mother was the narrator for that part I was done.

Was this review helpful?

Our Missing Hearts is set in a United States not too far removed from our own, when an "anti-anti-patriotism" act called PACT has been enacted, stirring anti-Asian sentiment and separating parents from their children. Bird, an eleven-year-old whose poet mother left the family, is determined to find her and discover the truth about her leaving - and her work.

Ng is skilled at descriptions and evoking emotions, and these skills shine here. The subject material alone is enough to tug at one's heartstrings, but this is not overdone in a melodramatic way; the grief of parents who have lost their children is powerful but not overplayed to an extent that it feels gratuitous. The main characters themselves are interesting and feel like they have lived full lives, even the child characters, and the way Ng weaves folklore into the story gives it some added depth.

That being said, at least half the novel is summarized - to reveal which part might be considered a spoiler, but I do wonder if there might have been another way for the same information to have been relayed without having to rely on summary so much. Considering the size of the period of time these sections had to cover, it might have been difficult, but it always bothers me a little when so much of a book is devoted to getting the reader up to speed rather than actually showing what happened.

I've read Ng's other work when they came out, and from what I can remember of my impressions of them, this was my favorite. The story itself allows for a lot of poignancy, and the United States shown in the novel feels eerily realistic. This is a must-read for any Ng fan, or for those looking for an impactful read.

Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin for providing a copy for review.

Was this review helpful?

This had a really slow start, as did Little Fires Everywhere, but it built slowly and wonderfully. I ended up loving it, loving the characters, and loving the story and the historical connection. Definitely five stars.

Was this review helpful?

A sad, yet beautiful story of the bond between mother and son. If you enjoyed Celeste Ng's previous stories, this one will not disappoint.

Was this review helpful?

This book is incredible, and no description really does it justice. In a not-too-distant, just slightly more dystopian than present future, a boy loses his mother and goes looking for her.

Was this review helpful?

Bird lives with his father in a quiet apartment after his mom left them when he was nine. Bird knows not be loud, not to ask questions, or stand out. Bird and his father have lived under the PAC law for most of Bird's life- a law to help "preserve American culture." Bird receives a mysterious letter and he knows that it's from his mother. He decides to set out to find her. On his journey he finds a network of librarians, trying to reunite children who have been taken from their home because of PAC. Our Missing Hearts shows us what society is when we don't fight back for our fellow man.

I wanted to like this because this story needs to be told. With the anti-Asian hate that went around during the Pandemic (and currently), a "what could be" novel is important. But it felt too detached from the characters in a way that made me care about them as much as I should have. I feel like it should have either been Bird's story or his mom's, but not both.

Was this review helpful?

In 2022, with more books being pulled from shelves and banned/censored titles reported to ALA's Office of Intellectual Freedom than ever before, this novel has my heart. I love the dystopian genre as a whole and this timely book is set in the seemingly all too real near-future. In this version of "America," anything or anyone from China, including American Chinese families are looked down upon by the Preserving American Culture and Traditions Act (PACT). Any fowl play or suspicious activity should be reported to PACT, and sole allegiance should be to PACT alone - even if that means removing sympathetic parents from their children, because they are "unfit" to parent the upcoming generation.

I loved the fire of the main characters had to continue to search for answers and true justice, even in the face of a dangerous world. It made me consider how far I would be willing to venture to find the "truth" and impact the world for good.

Was this review helpful?

I don't know why it took me so long to read this one but when I started, I couldn't put it down. Part dystopian, part journey to discover parents as humans, Our Missing Hearts delivers on all fronts.

Was this review helpful?

Gut wrenching, compelling and uncomfortably close to current events this is a sobering look at a policy taken too far. Wonderful character development, beautifully written. Can be considered in the same class as The Handmaids Tale.

Was this review helpful?

This was rough. I really enjoyed Ng’s Everything I never Told you. I didn’t love the follow up little fires everywhere but this book sounded so great. A dystopian where librarians are helping the protagonists succeed. It just didn’t work for me. Bird was a likable character but the back and forth timeline was hard to get into and I had trouble following the story once he found his mother. It was a slow burn and didn’t really work for me.

Was this review helpful?

I read this ARC for an honest review
All thoughts and opinions are mine

Ive read this author and really enjoyed them

Another belter - loved it

Was this review helpful?

Another spectacular work by Ng. An adventure, a rumination, and ultimately a book about the power of words. Just loved this.

Was this review helpful?

Excellent novel - not the type of novel that I usually go for but I was so drawn into it. Ng has surprised me with this one. It is not the type of novel that I am used to from Celeste Ng. I've enjoyed her other two novels about families and family struggles. This one has family and family struggles but the heart of the novel is a portrait of what the world could become. I am a high school librarian and we are experiencing these very issues - people and organizations wanting to have titles pulled from our shelves. It is eerily reflective of current social and political situations. It is soul wrenching and frightening. Ng is a brilliant storyteller and this novel hits the ball out of the park. It is a novel to read and digest in parts not to hurry through - it is a great book for book club discussions. Sadly, the things she writes about have occurred in some forms in history and it is frightening that they could manifest themselves again. It is a cautionary tale.

Was this review helpful?

I was really looking forward to this book. The themes hit close to home and I could see the forced patriotism being not far away. Ng uses her character of Bird, and his search for his mother to highlight how families are forced to walk the line of forced patriotism.

This wasn't my favorite story. It was slow and I had to put it down at times. I was excited to read it but maybe it felt too real at times? That may be the type of reader I am, that I read to escape, and don't want to read about politics and patriotism. That doesn't mean the book is bad. It's necessary. It's just hard to read in days like these.

Was this review helpful?