A bit silly but a lovely Christmas read. It really got me in the Christmas spirit! Light hearted and fun. Recommended by me!

This is one of those books where over all I enjoyed the book, but there was probably more that I didn't like than like. Overall it was ok but nothing to write home about.

What I did like, and the reason I decided to read the book, was the really good refreshing concept.
Lyla partly owns her family’s toy company with the scrooge Mason Klaus. The company is slowly going under, and Mason seems to be making everything worse. Mason invites Lyla to go home with him for the holidays to the North Pole and imagine her surprise when she realises he is none other than the next inline to the sleigh, and destined to be the next Mr Klaus.

This book could have been so much fun and a really good festive read, but unfortunately there was just no chemistry at all with the characters, no was Masons character particularly likeable to be honest.

Thank you to Netgalley for a ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.

I loved this book. The concept was interesting. My kind of fantasy. I read this book awhile ago. But I keep thinking about it. I really like the author’s writing style. I will be looking for more of her books.

LOVE LOVE LOVE! This is the perfect Christmas read. It made you feel so many feelings. I cant wait to read this every season!

This was so much more fun than I thought it would be! I really enjoyed the Santa lore and didn't mind the kidnapping haha. It was funny and sweet but also hot. Didn't know hot St Nick was my vibe, learn new things all the time. Recommend!

When the annual Christmas party ends in disaster, Lyla owes her nemesis and co-ceo Mason Klaus a favor. She certainly doesn't expect that favor to be that he magically whisks her away to a Christmas lover's dream village where it turns out Klaus is more than a last name. This was such a fun, whimsical holiday romance.

This book was not what I was expecting but I absolutely loved it. Extra Christmas magic for a cosy Christmas read. I loved that the characters initially despised each other. I loved the magic and the setting of the plot. The characters were engaging and I read this book in one sitting. Thanks netgalley

Who said Christmas can’t be in July?! Okay, I’m late to the party butttt better late then never and let me tell you, I don’t regret this party at all! This book was so cozy and fun and my fave trope: enemies to lovers!! This is perfect for Christmas and I kinda wished i had read it on Christmas

The dynamic between the protagonist is addictive to read and lets one enjoy the story that seems to naturally progress with them!

This was such a fun read! I loved the holiday vibes, the spin on the idea of Santa Claus & of course all the spice! the enemies to lovers PLUS fake relationship tropes make such an interesting read for this romance lover. An quick and enjoyable read for sure!

I loved the premise for this book. While I enjoy a good Hallmark movie, the added fantasy element wasn’t for me. I would still recommend the book for anyone trying to get into the Christmas spirit.

Thank you to Kate Callaghan, Callaghan Writer, and NetGalley for an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.

The premise of this book caught my attention and I thought it had so much promise. However, I ended up not caring for it. For the romance to be such a big deal between Mason and Lyla, it didn’t feel genuine. The dialogue was lacking … just stilted and blah. I’m not a romance fan to begin with, but if it’s done right, then I can appreciate the story and the dynamics of the relationships, etc. Unfortunately, this one didn’t appeal to me. Though as someone who adores Christmas, the presentation of the magic of Christmas was entertaining.

Thank you to NetGalley and CallaghanWriter for my advanced review copy. All opinions and thoughts are my own.

For more reviews, please visit my blog at: https://www.msladybugsbookreviews.com/. Over 1000 reviews posted!

I just didn’t connect with this book. The characters didn’t resonate with me and I felt like their conflicts were too easily resolved.

I downloaded this book a long with a bunch of others before I was able to finish reading it, but I did ended up getting it on my Kindle so I could finish it.
Overall it was a cute Rom-Com that is perfect for Christmas!

Kate Callaghan writes romcoms that I love, so I was so excited for this holiday version. It reads like a cheesy, holiday Hallmark movie, in all the best ways.

I did not like the writing nor the flow. This was not for me and I can admit I might not be the audience.

Not a book I'd usually choose yet was pleasantly surprised, great book and characters. Would recommend

This was so cute!! I wish I had read it a lot sooner, I would have loved to display it on a table in the Barnes and Nobles location I work at!
This was an enemies to lovers, fake dating and Hallmark christmas movie vibe all wrapped into one book, which was exactly what i wanted! Our female main character Lyla is a holly jolly all things holiday loving girly (like myself), and our male main character Klaus is the polar opposite. I loved that this book combined my favorite tropes and mixed in the magical element of a cozy christmas read so flawlessly.

"The Naughty or Nice Clause" by Kate Callaghan offers readers a delightful premise filled with holiday charm and romantic tension. Set against the backdrop of a family-owned toy company and a fantastical winter wonderland, the novel promises a festive escape.

The narrative follows Lyla, who unexpectedly finds herself in a difficult situation when her father's retirement and the company's bankruptcy force her to work alongside Mason Klaus, a cold and unyielding investor. Their initial animosity and apparent differences set the stage for a classic enemies-to-lovers trope, adding an element of romance and tension to the story.

The whimsical setting of the secret village and its magical Christmas holidays adds charm and provides a delightful escape for readers. Kate Callaghan skillfully paints a picturesque winter wonderland, allowing readers to immerse themselves in the enchanting atmosphere and experience the joy of the holiday season.

Super cute and fun read. Adorable Christmas romance that’s perfectly cozy and entertaining. Enemies to lovers, with a Christmas twist. Definitely pick this one up any of time of year. I read it in June and still enjoyed it tons!