Laura Frantz sure knows how to write a good historical fiction romance!
This story is based in Scotland between Blythe and Everard.

I loved the historical aspects. The author is so good at keeping things true to the period.
I loved the slow burn! Yes! Yes! Yes!!! So good!!!
I loved the Scottish setting and elements. The story painted a very immersive picture of the time and place.
Blythe was a lovely FMC full of strength and grace.
Everard was bold and intriguing.
I can't get enough of his interactions with Blythe!!! *all the heart eyes*

Great for catching up on Scottish history, especially for those of us who have family links there. History learned solely from textbooks can be ‘a bit dry’, but a book like this adds feelings to the names – a reminder they were real people, & a glimpse of what it was like to have lived through such times. The story itself became more involving as it went on, & by the end – well, I didn’t see how it could possible be resolved in the diminishing number of pages left!
(The language is a bonus, too : I had been learning Scottish Gaelic since lockdown, but the Scots used in this book is what I would have preferred...)

So, this story was intriguing from the cover and description, and I enjoy reading historical romances/dramas. However, I really struggled to read this book. First, I recognize that this book must have taken a long time to research, and it shows how much time and effort was done. And just because this book wasn’t in my wheelhouse, I know that others have really enjoyed it and will enjoy it. I will commend the author for how much research had to go into creating this world. The historical information is vast.

I struggled the most with the writing style. The vocabulary is elaborate and the dialect is historically accurate, and it’s difficult to understand what is happening plot wise and invest in the characters because of them. In my opinion, it takes away from the reader really experiencing and getting hooked. As I tried to get into the story, I felt separated from the characters because of the language and the third person point of view also created distance for me as the reader.

I’m a huge fan of historical fiction, but I find that when you write too true to the time period without any connections to the present time via language, you can lose your audience.

I ended up not being able to finish the book.

I received an ARC PDF of “A Rose and the Thistle” from Net Galley for my unbiased and honest review.

In 1715 Lady Blythe Hadley is forced to flee from her beloved home in northern England to the home of her god parents in Scotland. Sadly, both of them have died and their eldest son, Everard Hume, is now laird. To put it mildly, he is not thrilled at her arrival. He is a decent man and takes her in and offers protection, but nothing more. So, he says.

Filled with political intrigue and beautifully described settings, history comes alive. Readers are pulled into the narrative as the protagonists come to grips with the conflict, danger and unrest swirling around them. In spite of it all, a romance develops. Will their love survive the violence and turmoil around them.

The author is a master story teller. She has crafted an intriguing and engrossing work of historical fiction that is well worth reading. Highly recommended.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from Revell through NetGalley. The opinions expressed in this review are my own.

With hauntingly beautiful prose, Laura Frantz has delivered an epic tale that deftly transports readers to 18th century Scotland. Ms. Frantz skill as a storyteller is unsurpassable. Her vivid descriptions and rich historical detail provide a strong sense of place, allowing readers to get lost within the atmospheric backdrop of the Jacobite uprising of 1715. I absolutely loved the captivating plot and gently unfolding love story. I cherished every single word, every emotion that flowed through my heart, slowing down because I did not want the story to end. A perfect blend of history and romance, readers won't be able to put it down.

I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author/publisher. I was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.

I found this to be such a well written and well researched story. Blending historical fact with historical fiction. It's not an era I've read a lot about so it was quite entertaining to hear about this period.

I really loved reading this book, it was a really wonderful read. I enjoyed the characters as well. This was a beautifully written book that just flowed so well. This book will go on my keeper shelf.. I just cannot express my delight in this book it was so good.

Thank you NetGalley for this digital copy!

This is a very sweet romance with an underlying Christian theme and plenty of factual historical basis which I love. There are some great accurate dates and Scots/Gaelic language which I really appreciate. I adore the MMC and FMC- the nature of their relationship is lovely. It’s a clean and cozy historical romance.

I would rather spend it all on books than silk and ribbons.

An engaging slice of history with a sprinkle of beautiful romance.

This book is delightful! It was my first read by Laura Frantz, and when I started I wasn't sure what to expect. It took me a while to get hooked by the story but once I did, oh my! The history of this really comes alive on the page.
I adore the main couple. They really sparkled.
I will definitely be reading more by Laura Frantz. This book was a little heavy- I'm not sure if that's because of my mood or because of the writing. There were some slow parts where I found myself wandering. However, I would recommend this.

Stars: 3/5
CW: Violence, war

5 stars for this lovely novel! Wish I could give it more!
Laura Frantz is my most favorite author ever! Her writing is wonderful and I love getting "lost" in her stories!
I simply couldn't put this story down until I was finished! I didn't want to return to the present.
I learned much by reading this novel What an interesting time period!
I never knew this happened until I picked up this book.
The characters were wonderful and the plot was interesting.
My favorite part of the story was the romance between Lady Blyhe and Everard.
My 2nd favorite thing about this book is that I loved was that I got to "travel " to Scotland without leaving the comfort of my home.
I most definitely love secrets! In my opinion, this is what makes me want to keep reading because you'll want to see what happened next and this book has done that for me.
The faith filled themes scattered throughout reminds us that God is always near. He never leaves us or forsakes us.
This book has left my heart feeling full and satisfied!
Well done! I highly recommend! Such a gorgeous cover!

The Rose and the Thistle is an intelligent, and well written book that held my attention throughout. There are so many books written about Scotland, Jacobites, and Lairds, but this one is exceptional. The authenticity immersed me in the time period of the story, making me feel as if I were right there with the characters. And they were beautiful, admirable people who exuded goodness, honor, and intelligence. The MC, Everard, was swoon worthy and his love interest, Blythe, was so refreshingly honest. I detest heroines who are coy, whispering asides to the reader. They are unrealistic and ridiculous, but these characters seem like real people. The Laird’s little brother, Orin, was lovable and sweet. Blythe’s lady’s maids were warm, funny and an integral part of the story. Everard’s brothers (except one) were wonderful too.

Initially (and very briefly) I had slight difficulty understanding the dialogue and customs of the time, but Laura Frantz did not dumb down the book by having characters explain things they wouldn’t have needed to explain in real life. Very quickly I was immersed in the time period and followed it quite easily.

I absolutely loved this book and didn’t want it to end. In the Author’s notes Laura Frantz explains that she is a descendant of the Hume family. No wonder she wrote this with such evident love and respect.

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

#TheRoseandtheThistle #NetGalley

This was my first book of Laura Frantz's, but it will not be my last. Set in beautiful Scotland during the first Jacobite rebellion of 1715, this book is rich in historical details with layers of political and religious intrigue.

It did take me a couple of chapters to really get into, but once I did, I adored every second of it. I loved seeing a glimpse of both sides of the rebellion. The faith was masterfully interwoven through each page. The characters were wonderful. Even the side characters were well developed more than one-dimensional.

The banter between Blythe and Everard was so much fun. I loved the Hume brothers (most of them). I honestly would read an entire series based on them.

I look forward to reading more of Frantz's work!

*Thank you to NetGalley and Revell for the advanced copy. All opinions are my own.

"Sin oft comes disguised glittering and crowned, not reeking and clad in rags."

"God Himself sets rulers upon thrones, does He not? And topples those He wills."

"You are still my English rose. While I remain your Scottish thistle."

"Though much was beyond her control, she could still rejoice the Almighty ruled over earthly kings and military commanders."

The Rose and the Thistle
By Laura Frantz
Publisher: Revell
Series: None
Rated: 3-4
Obtain: Borrow
Back of the Book: “In 1715, Lady Blythe Hedley's father is declared an enemy of the British crown because of his Jacobite sympathies, forcing her to flee her home in northern England. Secreted to the tower of Wedderburn Castle in Scotland, Lady Blythe awaits who will ultimately be crowned king. But in a house with seven sons and numerous servants, her presence soon becomes known.
No sooner has Everard Hume lost his father, Lord Wedderburn, than Lady Hedley arrives with the clothes on her back and her mistress in tow. He has his own problems--a volatile brother with dangerous political leanings, an estate to manage, and a very young brother in need of comfort and direction in the wake of losing his father. It would be best for everyone if he could send this misfit heiress on her way as soon as possible.
Drawn into a whirlwind of intrigue, shifting alliances, and ambitions, Lady Blythe must be careful whom she trusts. Her fortune, her future, and her very life are at stake. Those who appear to be adversaries may turn out to be allies--and those who pretend friendship may be enemies.”

Impressions: I was overwhelmed at the beginning of this book trying to keep up with what was happening because of the thick Scottish brogue of the characters. As I continued reading, the story began to flow, and the language was less distracting. The story was well-paced, and the characters were interesting. It was a nice historical romance however I would be remiss not to mention one part that frustrated me. Lady Blythe is portrayed as a devout Catholic however considers being a mistress and ultimately converts to become Protestant to be wed. Part of the conflict in this story was Catholicism and its followers. It was strange to have it all work out as it did.

Quotes:
“A man who weighed what he said before he said it was worth listening to.” - Or woman. I am an awkward talker, so I tend to talk before thinking to fill the air. I strive to be slow to speak and quick to listen, however, and was reminded of that in this quote.

“’Surely there are praiseworthy things about her, as she was made in the Lord’s image.’” - What a great thought to ponder when struggling with others.

“’There are no titles in His Kingdom, Grandmother used to say, just worshipful sons and daughters.’” - This is such an interesting thought because so much of our earthly admiration is dependent on titles and fame.

“Would he stand on his faith or his fears?”

I enjoyed the famous quotes used in this book as well:

“’You have such a February face. So full of frost, of storm, and cloudiness.’” -Shakespeare quote

“’Hide not your Talents, they for Use were made. What’s a Sundial in the shade?’” - Benjamin Franklin

“’What worries you masters you.’” - John Locke

“’That which is striking and beautiful is not always good, but that which is good is always beautiful.’” -Ninon de l’Enclos

I received an ARC of this book via the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for my honest review shared here. For more book reviews go to: https://thebluestockingbooknook.wordpress.com

Love love love love love love love etc.

I mean, I feel like I say this with every Laura Frantz book, but she's just forever one of my favorites, and this book in particular hit all my sweet spots. I loved the Scottish setting. The slow-burn romance is so well done. The writing is beautiful. The history is intriguing. The plot moves at just the right pace—with plenty of conflict alongside the story's emotional tension. I just loved every moment of this one.

I loved this read. It was filled with memorable characters, well plotted, and a thoroughly enjoyable romp through history.

4 Stars!! Well written story with tons of suspense, mystery, surprising twists, romance, love, war, happiness, peace, and intrigue. The book is well written & I liked the main characters, Everard & Blythe. I would’ve liked more backstory on Everard. The secondary characters were lovable too! I love fictional books with lots of factual history in it. I feel like I’m learning but I’m enjoying it!
*I received this at no charge & I voluntarily left this review.*

This is the second Laura Frantz book I have read and I am becoming a big fan. I love books that teach me more about history and I really enjoyed learning about this fascinating time in history. The book takes place in 1715 when the Jacobites are seen as enemies in England and must go into hiding. Lady Blythe is sent to her God Father’s to hide away in Scotland, however her welcome is less than warm and staying hidden proves difficult. As she and the new laird, Everard Humes, get to know each other, romance blooms. But is there a future with someone who is in hiding? I loved the twists and turns of this novel. I loved the depth of the characters and the complicated families. There were so many layers and fascinating tidbits of history. I will definitely read it again.

Lady Blythe Hedley has little hope of finding true love, much less a suitable marriage partner. While the French court of Louis XIV praises voluptuous and vacuous, Blythe’s slim figure towers above most men, and her academic talents match the most learned in England and France. Men looking to make an advantageous marriage with the Duke of Northumbria’s only child and heir could overlook her physical and mental disadvantages—but they hesitate to wed the daughter of the notorious gilded harlot, Clementine Hedley.

The emptiness of the Stuart court in exile leaves Blythe longing to return to her beloved father and the family seat in northern England. But when her father arranges for her return, Blythe discovers her dream of a peaceful home and return to her studies has vanished in the turmoil of a Jacobite uprising.

Everard Hume, Lord Fast, has his hands full with his father’s illness, his second brother’s Jacobite activities, and supervising the activities of his five other brothers. In his early thirties and heir to the Earl of Wedderburn, any titled lady would welcome his suit. But he has yet to find a lady—first because he spent time soldiering for Queen Anne and now because his duties with his father’s large estate take all his time.

When his parents’ goddaughter arrives uninvited at Wedderburn Castle in the middle of the night, Everard must choose—to send her away or honor his father’s dying wish to provide shelter for the daughter of a notorious Jacobite. His conscience rebels at the first choice, and his heart quails with the ramifications of the second.

From the moment of their first encounter, Blythe and Everard both feel a spark. Will it lead to love or disaster?

What I Loved About This Book

Frantz weaves a luscious tale set in 18th-century Scotland. Her attention to historical detail will delight history buffs, and her powers of description will sweep the reader to heather-covered hills and drafty castles.

As the child of a notorious woman, Blythe has struggled her entire life with feelings of guilt by proxy. As she gets to know Everard, he affirms her identity as a child of God, not the offspring of a sinful parent. For the first time, a man looks at her for who she is, not what she can do for him.

Fans of Michelle Griep and Julie Klassen will enjoy this book.

“Are you adept at fencing as well as languages, Lord Wedderburn?”
“I am.”
“I don’t doubt it, but I do find this verbal swordplay between us wearisome.”
“Och, I am rather entertained by it,” he said. She detected that maddening hint of mockery again. Confound it, he confounded her!

I already know this is going to be one of my top historical romances of 2023 because it’s one of my favorites this year! This is the kind of story you just get lost in and you can’t believe when it’s over. I was completely swept away by this story and the love between Blythe and Everard.

From the beginning, I was immediately hooked by the secrecy and intrigue as well as the lush descriptions of the Scottish Lowlands. Everard and Blythe’s first meeting is an intense one and immediately puts them at odds. As new frenemies, I loved their verbal sparring and witty dialogue. Blythe had such a quiet manner, but also a fierce tenacity that made her so endearing. And Everard was the perfect Scottish hero. Though he begrudgingly protected Blythe, he was always the gentleman. I love how Blythe’s intelligence and humility slowly chipped away at the differences between them and turned their friendship into the most achingly beautiful romance.

Blythe and Orin’s relationship completely warmed my heart as well as Everard’s relationships with most of his brothers. Peg and Mari turned out to be wonderful companions to Blythe; I loved their unfailing loyalty. There was also a secondary romance that was so beautiful, but plenty of action as well to make this an easy page turner. There was such an intensity about the last 25% and I couldn’t put it down. I definitely shed a few tears along the way. I can’t recommend this enough for historical romance fans.

Thank you to NetGalley and Revell for an advanced copy. My thoughts are my own.

The Rose and the Thistle is a lovely story set in early 1700’s of Scotland. Two unlikely characters of different religious and political leanings end up falling in love in the midst of the Jacobite rebellion. As usual, Laura Frantz’s work is well researched and immersed in history. I did find the political situation a bit difficult to follow, but I didn’t find that my inability to keep the history intact hurt my enjoyment of the story at all! Blythe is a strong female protagonist who meets her match with Everard who is a perfectly complements her strengths.