Cover Image: Hijab Butch Blues

Hijab Butch Blues

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I loved this book -- could not put it down! I enjoyed Lamya H's writing style in this coming-of-age memoir about their experience growing up between countries as a Muslim immigrant and eventually landing in the United States where they attempt to figure out who they are and where they fit in with American society (as well as various subcultures). It serves not just as an insight into their lives, but also a critique of various societal beliefs, misconceptions, and structures of power. While they make it clear the importance of Islam to them in their life, I particularly enjoyed how they used stories from the Quran throughout the book and connected them to their experience at that particular moment in time in their lives, further illustrating the guiding importance of the religion to them. The book also makes an impact in the visibility of queer, gender-nonconforming Muslim immigrants in the United States. My only critique is that I think the cover, including the font style, does not do the book justice. A more captivating cover that pulls you in like the text does would be better suited. Overall, I highly recommend this book, which was such a pleasure to read.

Was this review helpful?

I got a netgalley arc of this and starting it i was terrified of it being blasphemous because? I, too, am Muslim. But honestly going through it i could see how deeply the author felt about everything, i don't generally like reading memoirs but having quran stories recited back to me, stories i grew up with, but with a newer perspective, it was honestly a lovely experience. this is definitely a yes from me, it tackles Islamophobia, homophobia and alot of things in between. Truly a breath of fresh air please do read it if you can.

Was this review helpful?

A memoir awash with deep feelings about the complicated intersections of faith, race, queerness, family, and community. The last chapter had me welling up. Sitting on a lot of complicated feelings after this one that are going to stay in my head for a while.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this memoir that shows just how religious texts can be read in a multiplicity of ways and in ways that are more inclusive that many think. Lamya H's writing is confident and clear, and she makes reading about her journey feel like a conversation. She depicts the fragile lines present when you live multiple lives, and the fear of losing one community when you find another; the difficulty of handling family and friends when you're scared to offend either and have them reject you; and the joy of finding support in community and belief. I'd love to see this book in every high school, being read by parent-offspring book groups, and by everyone who thinks they know what Islam is and isn't.

Was this review helpful?

When i was maybe 25 pages into this book, i realized that the writing style was very familiar, and just knew that i had read work by this author on Autostraddle. I checked, and i was correct--her writing is so unique and her style so specific that i could place her even in a very different context.

I really appreciated this memoir, though i don't think the parallels to Stone Butch Blues were as direct as i would have expected from the titles. I found myself really slowing to engage with the interpretations of stories from the Quran, and loved how the memoir was structured by theme in those ways. I am generally interested in people being chronological and linear, but in a memoir that is as thematic as this one it can work for me.

I'm not sure this book would be great for high schools, but i am not sure it wouldn't, either. It is not explicit and could be a good fit for a library.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher to grant me an ARC for this book.

I am never a fan of memoir but this book gave me a pleasant first time I cried. This book taught me things that I didn't know I needed to know, things that were left unasked or unspoken because I thought it was taboo, things that only stayed in the back of my mind because I was scared someone might judge me for asking such an issue. This book became my friend because it offered so many stuff that I was too scared to say it out loud.

I can't exactly write down how amazing this book is, but I want to make sure that I genuinely adore this book. Some parts are thought-provoking that I want to read it repeatedly so I grasp the whole idea, some parts hit close to home that I need to step back for a while to breathe.

This book makes me feel like I have a friend. I cannot wait for it to be released so I can purchase it and kiss it because I love it that much.

Was this review helpful?

Nonfiction has never been my genre, but this book has changed my mind.

Stories from the Quran are interwoven with Lamya's life story, from early childhood to adulthood, which I found to be particularly moving. The writing style itself was beautiful, and does no sugarcoating of the racism, Islamophobia, and homophobia that Lamya goes through in her life. I learned much more about Islam through this read, but I especially saw more of how Lamya's Muslim faith intersected with her queerness.

This was a five star read, and I highly recommend it to anyone and everyone who lives in today's day and age.

Was this review helpful?

Wow. I've read 127 books this year, and this is in the top four.

Do you think you'd have nothing in common with a memoir titled <i>Hijab Butch Blues</i>? Same here. I'm not brown, female, Muslim, queer, a New Yorker, an immigrant to the US, or good at organic chemistry. I'm not even good at basic chemistry. But I was drawn into her life, almost welcomed, by the graceful and clear writing. She didn't talk down to the reader, but everything was still clear, despite quite a bit of cultural and religious terminology in Arabic. The only thing I looked up was "suhoor", and I was glad to a little learning on my own. That is the theme of the book, in a sense, a life informed by study and discussion and learning.

Along the way, I learned a lot about the Quran and the practice of Islam. I was starting from nearly zero knowledge, but now I have one good example of how it is and isn't similar to Christian practice.

If this book seems like it wouldn't appeal to you, give it a try anyway.

The other top books this year? [book:Eleanor & Park|15745753], [book:The Light Brigade|40523931], and [book:An Army at Dawn: The War in North Africa, 1942-1943|541920] (Pulitzer Prize winner).

Was this review helpful?

Hijab Butch Blues covers a swath of complex of territory. From islamophobia to transphobia to found family to immigration policies there is a lot to unpack in this story.

Lamya is a queer, Muslim woman who shares her life through the pages of this memoir. Interspersed with contemplative musings about the Quran the story focuses on Lamya's navigation of spaces previously considered forbidden in the country she grew up in. This book is about finding yourself and your people.

A few things to note - this book is not told chronologically and there are a few references that feel purposely omitted for the privacy of the author. In the latter half of the book every other chapter is a recap of a relevant story in the Quran. The interweaving of these stories into Lamya's story was particularly impressive.

The underlying theme of the book is one of hope - hope for self, hope for others, and hope for a more accepting world.

ARC provided via NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

What an honor it is that Lamya H shared their story with us in this beautiful and vulnerable memoir. She is a gifted storyteller, bringing to life numerous friends, family members, and bad dates alongside figures from the Quran. Lamya's journey navigating their faith and queerness resonated strongly with me, particularly her complex relationship with her family and community. Their writing style is both sharp and warm, witty and earnest. Hijab Butch Blues was a delight to read and I already want more!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you for the advanced copy of this book! I will be posting my review on social media, to include Instagram, Amazon, Goodreads, and Instagram!

Was this review helpful?

From their childhood in South Asia and the Middle East through their young adulthood in the U.S., Lamya H struggled to reconcile their queerness with their Muslim faith. But stories in the Quran have given them many ways to explore their identity, beliefs, and communities. In these essays, Lamya H ties stories from their life to characters in the Quran in thought-provoking and life-affirming ways. Lamya's writing includes moving and meaningful lessons on friendship, love, and fitting in that will speak to readers of all sexualities and religions. I'll be thinking about this book for a long time to come.

Was this review helpful?

This book was not at all what I expected. Instead o a book about being gay and Muslim and the hatred to ensue, Hijab Butch Blues was an emotional charged book about a young Muslim trying to reconcile her gayness with Islam. She was determined that the two things should exist together and used the Quran and many interpretations of it along with tarifs and surahs to find her way. Her religion helped her accept herself, her friends, and lose her need to disappear.

Lamya found a way to live as a gay women, protected in some areas of her life while being out in other areas. She seemed to possess an innate sense of who she should be at certain times. This sense allowed her to find happiness, acceptance, and remain a devout Muslim.

I have to say I learned more about Islam in this book, but all references were used by the author to explain how she found her way and obtained the reconciliation she desired.

Was this review helpful?

This memoir is authentic, wonderfully written, and so special. Reading about a queer person who resonated with a religious text and found themselves a supportive faith community was such a beautiful experience. Lamya H maintains a voice that is so real and poignant throughout, this memoir read like a conversation with a loved one sharing their wisdom they’ve gained through their experiences.

Was this review helpful?

This book is really good. The copycat title made me expect that the writing wouldn't be good, that it would be something people mainly read for the unusual story. But I was pleasantly surprised to be wrong. I liked Lamya a lot and appreciated both her reflections on her life and the ways she is inspired by the stories of the Quran. I am going to be recommending this one to friends.

Was this review helpful?

Hope-filled and relatable, Lamya connects stories from the Qur'an to lessons she's learned through her own life experiences as a queer Muslim immigrant. Growing up Christian, I could relate to the stories found in both religious traditions, but this gave me the opportunity to look at them through a different lens, and I found myself interested in studying the Qur'an more thoroughly.

Thank you, NetGalley, for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Hijabi Butch Blues is a memoir about a queer Muslim hijabi, Lamya, in a coming-of-age story that is told alongside stories from the Quran.

Hijabi Butch Blues follows Lamya's life as they navigate an Islamphobic, racist, transphobic, and homophobic world while finding out how to love themselves and others around them. The novel follows Lamya's life from her childhood in South Asia to moving to America for college and Lamya's own navigation of these differences. Throughout their life, Lamya uses the Quran to relate to their life and find answers for different challenges they face.

As someone who is a fan of memoirs, I found this to be very unique and interesting. Being told alongside the Quran was such an effective way to show how heavily religion influences Lamya's life and how everyone can interpret religious texts in their own way. The personal perspective of being Muslim, darker skinned, and queer in America was an insight on the injustices many people face but in a way that came to acceptance and finding one's place and people among these injustices. My one critique would be the timeline of this novel in that it was not chronological-- while I found it interesting, it was hard to follow and often left you unsatisfied because many problems were not resolved but rather mentioned at another time off-handedly.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you, Random House Publishing Group - Random House, The Dial Press, for allowing me to read Hijab Butch Blues early!

My eyes got teary reading this memoir. I don't read biographies usually, but this one had something special that caught my eye and I was right. I loved it.

Was this review helpful?

As someone who was raised with a Christian background, despite ending up wiccan, I am amazed, probably rather naively, how many of the tsories of the Koran are also stories in the Torah, the first five books of the Old Testiment. These are stories most people of Christian background would recognize, such as Joseph and his coat of many colors, and Noah and his arc. Except, they have different names in the Koran, and so at first, when Lamya brings them up to explain something that is happening in her life, I dont’ recognize who she is talking about, until the story unfolds, and then I say, oh, she is talking about Jonah and the Whale, only here he is known as Yunus.

And so the author uses prophets from the Koran to explain how things are with her life. The reason she brings Yunus up is because she at first things he has run away, to be thrown into the sea and swallowed by a whale. But her friends explain that no, he just left to get a break. He didn’t run away. ANd then she explains that is what Lamya has done with her life. Sometimes you just have to retreat.
This is an amazing memoir, looking back on how she came out, how she gained friends, how she learned to live in America. And interwoven with stories from the Koran to relate how life is similar and different.

And because the three religions spring from the same roots, we get stories that are the same, but different. We still get Moses freeing the Jews, but it is told with a different name, Musa, and the story is slightly different, but the red sea still parts.

Very accessible story. Very engaging memoir. Thoroughly kept me engaged.

<em>Thanks to Netgalley for making this book available for an honest review.</em>

Was this review helpful?

In this beautifully written memoir, you will find a meticulously woven tapestry of warm childhood memories, personal growth and coming of age intertwined with a relatable read of stories in the Quran. The author's voice is clear and gives a portrait of a complex, self-conscious, strong and compassionate person. Near the end of the book is a valuable analogy of the whale that sheltered the prophet Yonus and about picking one's fights as holding space to protect oneself:

"A whale that allows me to keep fighting, to fight with my writing. A whale that allows me to save my energy for curious, kind dialogue and to support those I love -- instead of fighting to fend off racists, sexists, homophobes, transphobes, Islamophobes who could look up where I live, where I work, who and what I hold dear."

She describes a journey to hold onto her family of origin by holding onto her religious values and creating her own chosen tribe and family who reflect back her integrity as a queer person. I wasn't able to put this book down once I picked it up -- and look forward to more from Lamya H.

Was this review helpful?