Cover Image: The Radcliffe Ladies' Reading Club

The Radcliffe Ladies' Reading Club

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I went into this book blind, meaning when I requested it from NetGalley it sounded like something I would enjoy, and by the time I read it last week I had totally forgotten what it was about. Which is a great way to read, imho.

Alice is the owner of the book shop having recently relocated to Boston from Chicago. She starts a book club that garnish the attention of Tess, a Radcliffe student. Tess in turn convinces her roommate, Caroline and fellow classmates to join. The bookclub part was a nice touch. I have never read any of the books that were featured but am curious now, given that I was a fly on the wall listening to the discussions. Suffice to say I have since added them all to my TBR.

This story takes place in the 1950s, a time when women pursuing higher education was uncommon. Most women were expected to focus on getting married and starting a family. But then there are these four older teens, each with their own unique backgrounds, personalities, and goals.

The Radcliffe Ladies' Reading Club is a well written coming of age story that was true to the times. It's about friendship, status and pulled at the heartstrings. It would make a great book club read - lots of themes to discuss. This is my first time reading a Julie Bryan Thomas book, I will be on the lookout for more of her books.

My thanks to the publisher via NetGalley for a digital art and exchange for a honest review. This book releases tomorrow.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book and the slice of life it offered of a Boston girls college in 1955. For those that love Mona Lisa Smile movie, then they’ll love this book. I wish we got more of the bookstore owner’s life, but I did enjoy how in depth the author went of the 4 main characters. Will definitely recommend!

Was this review helpful?

I just finished The Radcliffe ladies’ reading club by Julia Bryan Thomas and here are my thoughts.

Alice loves her little book shop. It’s 1954 and women are rarely allowed to aspire to want things outside of a house, husband and kids but not Alice. Books are her life.

She wants to share her love of reading with other women so when she sets up a book club at the store, she is over the moon when college students Tess, Caroline, Evie and Merritt all show up to discuss the first book.

The girls all find safety and independence within the walls of Alice’s bookstore and when the worst of the worst happens to one of the girls…. Alice is there to help get her through it.
Wow, this book was so good. I am a sucker for historical fiction that empowers women and this one really warmed my heart. Women in the 50s were pretty much just homemakers and trying to figure out who you are back then must have been so hard.
Alice became the mother figure to the 4 girls in a way that she not only protected them and encouraged them to voice their own opinions but she showed them that you don’t have to just be someone's wife to be fulfilled. The setting of 1950s Massachusetts was brilliant and it made me want to go there during fall. The writing was lucid and I thoroughly enjoyed the whole book.
I don’t usually put trigger warnings in but I will add one this time.
TW Rape resulting in pregnancy/miscarriage.
I would have liked some more development on the characters. I felt like I didn’t understand why Tess was the way she was and that left me with a slightly empty feeling. It would have been more well rounded with some more back story on all 4 of the girls and Alice but maybe it was leaving it open for spin off books. I could get on board with that.
4 stars. I finished it in one sitting and I was so entertained the whole way through. If you love historical fiction that discusses books, this is a winner.
Thank you @netgalley and @sourcebooks for my gifted copy
#netgalley #sourcebooks #juliabryanthomas #theradcliffeladiesreadingclub #booksaboutbooks #bookstagram #bookstagram #bookblogger #bookalorian #booklover

Was this review helpful?

This story takes place in Massachusetts, 1954. Alice Campbell escaped a marriage that she was ill-suited for, and opened a bookshop in Cambridge. She puts out flyers advertising a book club, hoping some of her customers may be interested in joining. Four Radcliffe students - Tess, Caroline, Evie, and Merritt- decide to join her for the book club, and they soon view her shop as a safe space, and Alice as a confidante. As they read and discuss such famous works as " Anna Karenina", "Emma", "The Age of Innocence" and "A Room Of One's Own", their friendships are put to the test as their differences in opinion create huge chasms at times, Before their freshman year is up at Radcliffe, all four will have to make decisions on the trajectory they want their lives to take - marriage or career, move back home or strike out on their own.

This book was excellent. It started out a bit of a slow burn for me, but once I got into it, I didn't want to put it down. I really liked Alice. She was a feminist who wanted to empower other women to think for themselves, and not rely on a man to think for them. Caroline and Tess were roommates, and even though Caroline was really wealthy, she was a lot more likeable than Tess. Tess was at Radcliffe on scholarship, and was very high strung and, well, I can't think of a nice way to say this - she acted like she had a stick up her butt, She was judgmental, jealous, and generally unpleasant. Evie and Merritt were also roommates and Evie was boy-crazy and mainly wanted to get married, while Merritt was an art major and was more interested in a career than finding a husband. This was an emotional read that I think any woman would enjoy.

Was this review helpful?

If the movie Mona Lisa Smile was set around a bookstore instead of an art class you'd have the perfect description for the feel of this book.
Your focus is more on the experiences, and lives of a group of young women who just so happen to join in the particular book club. Said book club feels much more like an afterthought in comparison.
If you're into self, discovery chick-lit then this is right up your alley.

Was this review helpful?

4 young woman attend a woman’s college in Massachusetts’s in 1955. They form a friendship and meet Alice, a bookshop owner, who starts a book club and gets to know the young women.

I enjoy books about books, and loved the premise of this one. Unfortunately, I’m sad to say this book just wasn’t for me. I liked how many of the books the women read could be connected to their real life, and how as women they were seen as property of men and just in college to find a husband. I felt the pace of the story to be too slow for me, with a lot of character development, and the big problem of the story gave me the icks (check TWs: sexual assault). I feel this book will be a favorite for many, it just wasn’t something I loved.

Was this review helpful?

This is an easy quick read perfect for summer.
It’s 1954 and Alice Campbell has decided to make a big change in her life, giving up everything for independence. So she buys a small book shop in Boston and makes it her own. One day, Alice decides to create a book club where individuals will meet once a month to discuss books of her choosing…and they just so happen to be books about and/or written by women who are, themselves searching for a life to call their own. Alice's little book club is made of four young women (Tess, Caroline, Evie, and Merritt) who just happen to be attending nearby Radcliffe College, all are young and edited with their own new found independence.
I liked this book well enough. It was a very quick read that was suitable after a work day where I had to tax my brain. I found the description of Alice’s bookshop and the details of the simple life she has created for herself is simply charming. I also enjoyed the simplicity of characterization, it was easy to understand the choices and motivations of each. My favourite part of the novel was how the author attempted to weave the various themes of the books studied in the book club with the lives of the characters who read them. (Jane Eyre, Age of Innocence, Essays of Virginia Wolfe).

Trigger warning for sexual assault and miscarriage.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC!

2.75/5 stars

I think I had different expectations for this book going in - I expected more historical fiction and it turned out to be more women’s fiction in the past. Which is fine, but not my taste.

I think the writing was strong, and the characters were well defined. For me, the plot just made me bored and, toward the early end, cringe. The lack of character development by some characters wasn’t quite balanced by the large growth in others, and I just….it wasn’t enjoyable suspense or shock, it was just difficult to read.

I definitely think there is a large audience for this story, I’m just not it.

Was this review helpful?

This book intrigued me with its potential to create a reflection on independent women who seemed to be trapped in the ideals of the 1950s. Set in Boston at Radcliffe College and a sweet little bookshop in Cambridge, we meet Alice who owns that said bookshop and starts a book club. Four roommates and friends join Alice every month. In the bookshop and Alice, they find a safe haven from the world. Each of the young women attending Radcliffe College are quite different, and each of their experiences are not what I would expect from the stereotypical characteristics they portrayed.
The linking of each of the books the young women read each month to the lives and times of the era was clever. The themes from each book seemed to be lightly woven into the chapters and stories of each young woman. I was hoping that there was a much more indepth look into each of the college women to really bring out their personalities and provide a deeper look into 1950s life for women.

Was this review helpful?

This review will be posted on June 5, 2023 to: https://instagram.com/amandas.bookshelf

Intriguing historical fiction set in post-World War II Boston. A new bookshop opens in Cambridge, owned by Alice, a determined and independent woman. Four freshman Radcliffe students (Caroline, Tess, Merritt, and Evie) join the new shop's monthly book club. From there, all four girls experience growth and the opportunity for change over the course of a year. I found the traditional gender role mindset of some of the freshmen infuriating, but the author did an excellent job of presenting the inner thoughts of the characters. At times, some of Alice's thoughts about the freshmen and her goals for book club seemed repetitive and, therefore, boring. But, overall, this was a really satisfying novel about a time period I don't often read too much about. #TheRadcliffeLadiesReadingClub Rating: 🙂 / liked it

This book is scheduled for publication on June 6, 2023. Thank you @bookmarked for providing me this digital ARC via @NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Oh this one sent me back to the bookshelf to pull out a few of my old favorites! Julia opens a bookstore in Cambridge, Mass, using a small inheritance, and starts a book club. Tess, a serious student, brings her roommate Caroline and friends Merritt and Evie along to the first meeting, where they discuss Jane Eyre and then it becomes part of their lives. Their freshman year at college brings changes in their lives but mostly for Caroline, a wealthy woman who is presumed to be interested only in marriage. Tess is an enigma with a back story that's mysterious and not well explained but golly is she rigid. Merritt, an artist, and Evie, who is most interested it seems in her Princeton boyfriend are not particularly well fleshed out. In fact, this loses something in characters that's made up by discussions of the various books they read (although these get less detailed). Thanks to Netgalley for the ARC. A good read

Was this review helpful?

<b>2.75⭐️</b> Books and book clubs opening minds and drawing people together, mid-‘50s Radcliffe, young women on the brink of the discoveries of life -- the blurb for <i>The Radcliffe Ladies Reading Club</i> is brief, but at least somewhat promising in its premise (I too immediately got “Mona Lisa Smile” vibes), but the story falls short of this setup early and often. While the readability is there, it goes from the most bland potato salad tone to aaall the drama in the blink of an eye without really getting you to care or even be all that interested in the characters and their lives before it takes off with a frankly over-used plot device (see CW below).
Now, I get that the status quo needs to be established before a good shake-up, but the first third or more of those book extremely safe and ho-hum for way too long, with almost nothing about the story or characters pinging your brain to start asking questions or seeing any path this story could possibly take; I felt like I would be reading about these girls’ day to day life at Radcliffe forever. Most of the characters are pretty stereotypical and almost wooden in their depictions, though I still did like Caroline and Alice to a degree, but I wonder if what happens to Caroline really informs my gravitating toward her character and narrative vs. actually building up an interesting, well-rounded character. And I say, “to a degree,” for Alice because we never get to truly know enough about her.
The runaway pace of the drama does kind of sweep you up, but overall this story and its characters felt shallow when I was expecting a lot more. I did root for Caroline and was concerned for her through her ordeal and was touched by Merritt standing by her, but it wasn’t enough to carry this mediocre story for me. Might be more interesting if you’re not very familiar with the time period or want something a little faster and fluffed out, but this historical fiction lacked a lot of depth all over the place for me.

<b>CW:</b> rape, assault, teen pregnancy, depression

<i>Thanks to NetGalley and Sourcebooks Landmark for an e-ARC of this book.</i>

Was this review helpful?

*Many thanks to Sourcebooks Landmark and NetGalley for my gifted eARC. Publication date 6/6/23*

2.5 stars

Set in the 1950's four girls instantly become friends after meeting at college. They see an ad to join a bookclub at The Cambridge Bookshop and they befriend the shop owner Alice. They meet once a month to discuss the book and also talk about their lives, boys, opinions on life and other stuff going on in the world.

I was so excited to read this book. I love books about books, bookstores, and bookclubs, but unfortunately this one was not my favorite. The bookclub meeting parts bored me as they talked about the book they read for that month, and all the ramblings of their personal lives. Just a little too much talking and preaching for me.

Was this review helpful?

Alice’s book shop and especially her book club becomes as safe space for the four girls — Tess, Evie, Caroline and Merritt. All of these women have unique backgrounds and personalities. I struggled with Tess at times with some of the things that transpired.. especially near the middle and end of the book.

It started off strong, fell a little flat in the middle for me but then picked up again at the end. We learn a little bit about Alice but not a lot of information on her. And I know it’s so small and doesn’t matter to the story but the book club was only Alice and the four girls. Was no more advertising done? No one else could join? Ha!

It was fun reading the book that was centered around a book club and some classic books. Made my book lover heart happy.

Overall, a good book that explores themes of coming-of-age, expectations, and friendships.

***cw/tw: rape, pregnancy, miscarriage, suicidal thoughts***

[ Thank you to the publisher & netgalley for the eARC. All thoughts and opinions are my own! ]

Was this review helpful?

In 1954. Alice Campbell escapes halfway across the country in front of a derelict building tucked among the cobblestone streets of Cambridge, and turns that sad little shop into the charming bookstore of her dreams.
Tess, Caroline, Evie, and Merritt become fast friends in the sanctuary of Alice's monthly reading club at The Cambridge Bookshop, where they escape the pressures of being newly independent college women in a world that seems to want to keep them in the kitchen. But they each embody very different personalities, and when a member of the group finds herself shattered, everything they know about each other—and themselves—will be called into question.

A gripping, inspiring, homage to books set against the backdrop of one of the most pivotal periods in American history, The Radcliffe Ladies' Reading Club explores how women forge their own paths, regardless of what society expects of them, and illuminates the importance of literature and the vital conversations it sparks.

This is such a well written book focusing on women's roles and expectations in the 50's. it is hard to believe that this is only the author's second book. The characters are all so well written, each with their only backgrounds, and how these backgrounds affect them as they feel out their independence in a college setting. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for introducing me to a new author that I look forward to reading again in the future.

Was this review helpful?

I was intrigued from the second I saw this cover and even more so as I read the blurb on the back. Overall I was pleased with it and thought it was well done. I will say that I didn’t think any of the characters were as fully developed as I would have liked and at times that made the story feel like it wasn’t fully flowing well. This story is about 4 girls who start Radcliffe College at the same time and become fast friends. They are all different and want different things from their education, but they form a quick friendship and join a Cambridge bookshop owner for a book club. The book is set in the 1950’s and while women are slowly gaining some momentum but women still lack a variety of options as the girls discover. I loved the glimpses of the book club meetings and questions about various books which added something additional to the story.

Was this review helpful?

What do we tell our girlfriends or the people closest to us?  What do we choose to share or choose to hide?   How do we perceive others and how do we thrive in a world that believes an education for a young lady is merely a passing frivolity before moving into our true calling of marriage and motherhood in 1950s Boston? And what masks do we wear to make us fit the perceptions, perceived or otherwise, that society has in droves?  

Alice, newly independent, hosts a monthly book club at her shop, while Caroline, Tess, Evie, and Merritt are just discovering a taste of freedom in their fist year at Radcliffe. The five meet at Alice’s shop. As Tess states, “Weren’t they here to get an education…  Or was their time at Radcliffe merely something they dabbled in to brag about later at dinner parties when they were married and running households of their own?”

I loved that the novel was told from each of the five main characters’ viewpoints allowing us a glimpse into their thoughts and rationales.  I particularly enjoyed how each chapter began with a quote from the month’s book club selection which reflected the chapter’s climate.  Each of the novels they read and discussed in book club was a classic and I want to read those I haven’t already read as a result.

It’s rare that a character surprises me in quite the way that one of these young ladies did.   And at that, repeatedly.  I may or may not have raised an eyebrow higher than it ought to be raised on more than one occasion.  I’d love to say more, but even saying that much is a spoiler of sorts.

Overall, “The Radcliffe Ladies’ Reading Club” serves as a reminder of the importance of withholding judgement and not jumping to conclusions; of female friendships and the ties that bind; of conformity and questioning social norms; of learning to think for oneself.

Thank you @bookmarked for providing an eARC of  “The Radcliffe Ladies’ Reading Club” by @juliabryanthomas_author via #netgalley Released June 6; preorder today!

I loved this novel! 

#juliabryanthomas #sourcebooks #bookstagram #bookstagrammer #historicalfiction #bookgeek #femaleauthor #femalewriter #radcliffeladiesreadingclub #radcliffe #womensrights

Was this review helpful?

It's 1955 and 4 women are experiencing a taste of freedom for the first time. They are freshmen and roommates at Radcliffe College. Although very different, the girls form a bond and are having the time of their lives - until an event that will change them forever. The aftermath pulls them apart and not only strains the friendship but reveals attitudes best left hidden.
I loved the grirry reality portrayed by this book. It's examination of women on the cusp of adulthood, figuring out who they are and what they want, is intense and insightful. Definitely recommend.

Was this review helpful?

*****Publishing June 6, 2023*****

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ After Alice’s husband died, she decided to move from Chicago to Boston, where she found an apartment and opened a bookshop, The Cambridge Bookshop! Alice started a book club where they read classics.

Tess, Evie, Caroline and Merritt all attended Radcliffe College. They became friends as they lived in the same dorm and had classes together. Tess convinced them to join the book club at The Cambridge Book shop even though they seemed skeptical at first.

These ladies supported each other, took each other out of their comfort zones with their differing opinions, gave each other advice, and encouraged each other to do things they might not have done on their own. After all, they each had a different upbringing and social class. Caroline, the wealthiest, had felt more accepted by these friends than any past friendship.

With each book read at the book club, Alice challenged them to think about topics such as men, relationships, money, social class, in a way that they might have not thought about before. This challenged their ideals and expanded their horizons. When a crisis arises for Caroline, their friendship is put to the test. Will they remain friends? Can they support Caroline in the way she needs or does it make it worse?

This book has great character development that highlights what it was like to be a college student during the mid 1950’s at Radcliffe College. The societal pressures/expectations, social class, and friendships played a role in these ladies’ college experience. It also played a role in how they reacted and handled a tragic situation. I loved Alice’s character, where she was not only a support to the ladies, but opened their minds to think differently through books. It helped them to grow and handle new situations.

A well researched and well told story that will bring out all kinds of emotions, but will leave you feeling satisfied in the end. A great book for book clubs as it will lead to many great discussions.

Thanks to SOURCEBOOKS Landmark, I was provided an ARC of The Radcliffe Ladies’ Reading Club by Julia Bryan Thomas via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Radcliffe College was the all female counterpart to Harvard College in the 1950s when the story is set. This story follows 4 woman from very different backgrounds, views, and collegiate expectations. They are rooming in the same dormitory and are drawn together by location initially. When they attend a book club at The Cambridge Bookshop they meet owner Alice pushes them to explore different topics in their monthly reads. I really liked this part of the book because their was such a wonderful discussion. It also brought to lights the very deep seated difference in views held by the woman. I think this allow me to understand some of the actions taken by the women though out the book.

Reading about the views on woman, and their place in society during the 50s was, at times, jarring but undeniably realistic. The students are all flawed and the dynamics and relationships of the woman change over time. Some of the woman grow and develop more than others. Readers should be aware that a sexual assault takes place.

Thank you NetGalley and Sourcebook Landmark for the advanced reader copy. This is my honest review.

Was this review helpful?