Cover Image: Was It Good For You?

Was It Good For You?

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Sophie has spreadsheets for all aspects of her life . When a romance she thought would last goes awry, she writes a spreadsheet to show her if a romance will last. Unfortunately, Dr Michael scores badly after their first date and challenges her to 10 dates to show her her spreadsheet idea is rubbish. Funny and enthralling ,I could not wait to find out the ending .

Was this review helpful?

What is the worst thing that could happen to someone who tries to control everything…? Sophie has a spreadsheet of everything what she eats what she does things about her job and the men she dates in it all gets a rating but when she accidentally send it to everyone Sophie has a start an apology tour and this is how she meets Mike’s mom and their puppy Fudge. Mike is over it before it even begins but when they agree to go on 10 dates… Thanks to his mom… They’re not happy about it but agreed to it. I loved this cute sweet romcom and thought those dates felt authentic and found this book to be really heartwarming and one I will definitely read again. It is a feel good read and a sweet romance. I want to thank the publisher Annette galley for my free art copy please forgive any mistakes as I am blind and dictate my review.

Was this review helpful?

I just adored this book so much, it has the usual @kathryn.freeman_author sparkle and flavour - the result it completely stole my heart. With the perfect balance of love, humour and chemistry it's a heartwarming romance with beautifully written characters with emotional depth and personality. If you want a romance to get lost in that's easy to relate to then this is the one.

Was this review helpful?

OBSESSED with this book. I totally adored it. It was SO heartwarming and adorable, but also spicy - a perfect combination. I just loved reading it and waiting on these two dough balls to fall in love 🥰

Sophie is such a likeable protagonist and Michael was just a chef’s kiss of a book boyfriend. I loved that she eventually saw him for who he truly was, it was a sweet journey for them both getting there.

What to expect:

- opposites attract
- bad first date and they agree to 10 dates to make up for it and test her scoring system
- slow burn
- city girl/country guy
- small town vibes
- he falls first
- medium spice

Was this review helpful?

A fun, feel-good read!

I finished this book super quick, which is a good sign!
Although I'm not a fan of the whole miscommunication trope as it can be frustrating and unbelievable, there was enough good stuff to keep me reading:

Grumpy sunshine, opposites attract, tension, and humor.

Add to that some great characters and an easy reading style of writing equals a great read :-)

Was this review helpful?

I adored this book!

Such a great premise, really well executed!

All the characters were likeable and the duel narrative really enhanced the story.

5*

Was this review helpful?

This was an infinitely readable book. And that isn’t to minimise it - it is one of those books that is so easy to read that you don’t realise that the time has slipped past (and you’ve forgotten to feed the dog again).

Simmering tension, fabulous characters who skip off the page, and a romance you will want to happen - this book has it all.

Was this review helpful?

I have been putting off reading this for so long and I'm not even sure why.. but now I hate myself because it was SOOOO GOOD!

The premise was fun and original and the characters were written exceptionally well. There was the perfect amount of depth that made Sophie & Michael not only likeable, but lovable. I wanted to bang their heads together but also completely loved seeing their relationship grow.

The book relies quite heavily on the miscommunication trope which I know isn't a fan favourite, but it's done with such adorable humour that I adored it. I loved that Sophie pushed Michael out of his comfort zone and that he was able to be the calm in her storm.

Main tropes:
• Opposites attract
• Grumpy x sunshine
• Miscommunication
• Past trauma
• Amazing side characters
• Sexual tension & angst

Thank you so much to @netgalley @harpercollinsuk @onemorechapterhc & @kathryn.freeman_author for the e-arc in exchange for an honest review

Was this review helpful?

A laugh out loud romcom with plenty of emotion.
I loved the characters, especially those in Little Brook, Betty was obviously the star as grandparents usually are.
I loved the dates and the fact that they were both being pushed out of their normal lives for them.
Michael was an absolute sweetheart, definite book boyfriend from the off!
The ending was so cute, I only wish we had seen further into the future after that, too, in a bonus epilogue!

Was this review helpful?

I always love a Kathryn Freeman book!

Now, I received the ARC for this so long ago but convinced myself that it wasn't gonna be the book for me, despite the amazing author.

I got to the point where I thought just read it, it's been long enough. I wish I'd read it sooner!

I love how Kathryn writes her characters, how even the superficial seeming ones have hidden depths and make you love them in a way that you didn't think you would. Betty was incredible, in fact, there was a great ensemble cast!

I'm now desperately waiting for the next Kathryn Freeman book to come out because it's just reminded me how much I love her writing!

Was this review helpful?

Opposites truly attract in this captivating book that had me hooked from the very first page. The dynamic between the characters with contrasting personalities adds a delightful layer of tension and chemistry that's impossible to resist. The author masterfully weaves a compelling narrative, making it an absolute struggle to put the book down. Exploring the nuances of relationships and the unexpected connections that can form between seemingly incompatible individuals, this story is a true gem for anyone who loves a good dose of romantic tension and a plot that keeps you guessing. Highly recommended for those who enjoy a fun and engaging read!

Was this review helpful?

A fun read! Sophie and Michaels stories. Sophie runs her life on spreadsheets which is sad but helped the reader to understand the character she was, Michael is a very busy Doctor who certainly doesn’t live his life on spreadsheets. On paper they were both poles apart , but both are slightly broken after past relationships.
Their story was fun as they both helped each other, great supporting characters and I , loved Betty ( Michaels Nan )
A heart warming book and a great holiday/ ,me time read
Highly Recommended
Thank you to Netgalley, Harper Collins One more Chapter and Kathryn Freeman for letting me read this book in exchange for an honest review

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this his and hers romance. I love getting two perspectives on things as it's crazy how different they are, especially in this where the overriding message is not to judge a book by its cover. It also really added to the character development, for example at first main character Sophie’s obsession with spreadsheets seemed at odds with her spontaneous personality but later made total sense. Then, throw in a strong multi-generational supporting cast of friends, family, village cricket team and two adorable dogs, and you've got a another great romcom from this author.

Was this review helpful?

I definitely liked the spreadsheet basis for this, even if I feel like maybe she had a few too many categories, or some that wouldn’t be ones I felt were important. There were a lot of things the characters had to come to terms with for themselves about themselves before things were going to work between the two of them. Both had their own issues with relationships and both were not really trying to find anything new at first. Michael was definitely ready to give it more of a try first, as obvious in his thoughts on their first date. But it was a mistake that he didn’t explain to her about the phone call or why he was late. That was definitely due to his own quiet personality and so made a little bit of sense in why it happened.

Sophie had her own reasons for using the spreadsheet, and we got even more reasons for why she fell into using it like she did as the story went on. We got so much more of the characters’ backgrounds and reasons for behaving like they did as the story went along. And I did really like the characters, as well as the other people in their lives. There were some emotional bits and some funny times as well. And while Sophie was supposedly more of a cat person, I felt like we got more time with Michael’s dogs than we did with her cat.

I enjoyed the story and the characters as I’ve mentioned. I was kind of annoyed with all the protesting to themselves over and over about how it wasn’t going to be anymore than just the 10 dates to prove the spreadsheet worked or didn’t work. Yeah, I know, that’s a romance common thing. But it still irritates me, especially when it seems like the people are being totally oblivious to what is in front of their faces. The story was also a bit long for me at times. But I know again that there was a lot for us to learn about their characters and back story that is probably why it was that way.

Overall a cute story though!

Was this review helpful?

"Love is not just about finding someone who can make you happy, but about finding someone who helps you become the best version of yourself.”

A captivating tale of love, self-discovery, and unforeseen bonds. Kathryn Freeman skillfully unravels Pippa's journey from heartbreak to renewed purpose, centered around Jamie – her former crush turned boss. Their chemistry propels Pippa's quest to rediscover herself, with Jamie as her unwavering support.

The novel adeptly navigates intimacy's role in personal growth, portraying Pippa's relatable post-breakup struggles. Kathryn Freeman weaves resilience and new beginnings into a seamless narrative, highlighting the intricate dance of human connection. Guided by Jamie's presence, Pippa's vulnerability transforms into revived passions.

"Was It Good For You?" is more than a romance; it's a testament to love's transformative power. Freeman's storytelling resonates deeply, inviting readers to ponder their own journeys of healing and self-discovery. For a brief yet impactful read, this novel hits all the right notes.

Was this review helpful?

An interesting, enjoyable read. It took a little while for me to get into it and to warm up to Sophie but as the story unfolded a bit more of her background came out I started to like and understand the character more. I thought Sophie and Michael had good chemistry and liked that they helped each other rediscover themselves/ get to a healthier emotional place because of their ten dates. The author bounces between both leads mindsets/pov’s so you get insight to how each is feeling throughout which I like.

Was this review helpful?

This book was fun to read, although there were some difficult themes. I liked the slow burning romance and I enjoyed reading about the dates. Michael and Betty were definitely my favourite characters in this book.
Thank you to Netgalley and the Publisher for my ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I buddy read this with a couple of friends, and oh my god, it was brilliant! Highly organised, spreadsheet obsessed Sophie finds herself questioning her spreadsheets, specifically the romance one, after a disaster of a first date with Dr Michael, who scored a 3 out of 10. When she accidentally sends her spreadsheets to all her contacts, the aftermath follows. Dr. Michael and Sophie find themselves taking part in ten dates to prove her spreadsheet theory does/does not work. Slowly, they get to know each other better and fall in love. This is funny in parts, fun, romantic and a really cute rom-com. I really enjoyed it. A well-deserved four stars from me.

Was this review helpful?

Sophie has a spreadsheet for everything even dating but when its sent to everyone she knows including the men she has rated, Sophie has some apologies to give. Can a spreadsheet really determine compatability with a partner, its time to find out.

This was such a good read. its funny, touching and sweet. You go through a range of emotions through the story. Its a steady build to a perfect ending. Aww i loved the ending so much. What a way to finish the story. The writing is fun and its rare you see a love story with cricket mentioned, not in a bad way. The characters are very likeable but my favourite after the dogs of course was Betty, She was such a legend in this. A fun modern romance.

Was this review helpful?

Sophie is structured and records everything on an Excel spreadsheet, but when she accidentally sends the list of her ‘love life’ to her entire contact list instead of her best friend, she has some explaining to do.

But it may just be an accident to second chances.

I have read a few novels by this author and I am never disappointed, this was a novel with an interesting storyline and characters that develop as you read. I did struggle a little to get into Sophie’s character but I feel this was slightly the point; as the novel goes through to tell us how the main characters find out a little bit about themselves and explains their behaviour.

Was this review helpful?