Sophie has her whole life planned out through excel sheets, she records absolutely everything about her self right down to her dates and what score she has given each one of them. She has Dr Michael Adams on this list and poor Michael only scored a 3 on her list.

One day Sophie accidentally sends her excel sheet out to everyone on her contact list and when she goes to apologise to Michael he issues an unexpected challenge: ten dates to prove that her spreadsheet is wrong. yikes!

This book is a hoot! I laughed so hard and also cringed so hard because I just cannot imagine accidentally sending out an email like that to anyone let alone my whole contact list!

An original story that has stayed with me ever since highly recommend!

Was It Good For You? is delightful, blanket-hugging and endearing. Sophie excels with her spreadsheets, each tab monitoring different aspects of her life. When she is set up with Dr Michael, who appears dishevelled and distracted on their first date, she scores him a 2/10. An accidental send to all contacts means everyone has access to her spreadsheet. After coming to gripes and acing accountability, Sophie reaches out to Michael, who counters that he can prove the ineffectiveness of quantitative measures with ten dates.

One of the biggest wins of this book is its reliability. Technology surely helps us become more productive and effective, but does it fully enable us to discover the power of time, connection and taking in our environment? At first, I was reserved with Sophie but with every page; she grew on her. Her character growth and development were simply remarkable as she holds space for Michael's views, to truly digest his words and try something new. Dr Michael Adams is one of my favourite protagonists of 2023. He was a quiet and humble man who challenged Sophie's synonyms of quiet (timid, aloof and distant) with a dry sense of humour and his wisdom made my heart soar. The progression of their relationship was delightful and magical. Though it appeared repetitive, Sophie not letting go of her spreadsheet and Michael's insecurities show the power of words and how old habits truly die hard. The supporting characters, be it Sophie's city friends and the seniors, were wonderful additions.

Do not skip this book if you're looking for a gradual romance etched with wisdom, vulnerability and challenging your comfort zone.

Thank you, NetGalley & HarperCollins UK, One More Chapter, for this e-ARC. This honest review is left voluntarily.

Sophie tracks everything, from finances to meal plans to her love life, in her Excel spreadsheets. Obviously these pages are meant for her eyes only, but she accidentally sends them to every contact in her phone…including her previous dates. Suddenly it seems like she’s receiving texts from just about everyone, from her boss about her bikini wax appointments, to her previous dates about the secret scores she’s been giving them. One of those guys is Michael, a doctor from a local village, who unfortunately has the lowest page on the score after a not so successful date. After meeting with Michael to apologise, he proposes a bet where she'll give him ten dates to prove that her spreadsheets are useless for finding love.

It’s a cute little second chance/he falls first romance. The whole spreadsheet theme of the story worked better than I anticipated and I just really enjoyed reading it! It was cute seeing Sophie, the outgoing party loving Londoner, get to know Michael, a quiet cricket-playing doctor from a nearby village, and how they both change for the better over time.

Absolutely brilliant, loved it. Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for allowing me an advance copy, I will definitely be recommending.

Dnf after 33%. Unfortunately, this story was not for me. I had a hard time struggling to get into this story from the beginning.... I tried to continue reading but after 33% I just couldn't anymore. I think others will enjoy this one, but unfortunately not me.

After receiving a digital ARC of one of Freeman’s other books, ‘The Italian Job’, I was so excited to see a digital copy of this book in my emails. It never crossed my mind that I would be disappointed with this one, and I definitely wasn’t disappointed! This book was absolutely adorable, and what brought the main characters together was unlike anything I’ve ever read before. I love a good spreadsheet as much as the next person, but clearly not as much as Sophie does, and I know the key takeaway was probably not to make a spreadsheet like this. But, now I kinda wanna do it. As soon as I started this book I just HAD TO KNOW how to would play out, and whenever I had spare time the first thing I did was reach for this book. Even waiting for a band to come on stage at a gig. I’m so in love with Michael and he’s so boyfriend material, I wasn’t a fan of Sophie for a lot of the book, but she did up growing on me too!

Michael and Sophie are brought together after being set up by mutual friends. However, due to a few issues along the road, the first date didn’t go so well and they both agreed that they would not be seeing each-other again. This was until the spreadsheet incident. Sophie is extremely organised, maybe too organised, and her whole life is planned to the minute in a spreadsheet. This includes her appointments, her meal plans… and the scores of who she dates. In order for her to see the person again, they must score over a 7. She gave Michael a solid 2.5. Usually, this would go unnoticed and they would both carry on with their lives. But, when Sophie accidentally sends her spreadsheet to all of her contacts and Michael does learn of his low score, Sophie is mortified. He agrees to meet her for a drink so that she can apologise, one thing leads to another, and they both agree to an experiment. 10 dates. 10 dates to see if Sophie’s spreadsheet scoring is a help or a hinderance. However, when they find themselves changing for the better, and understand who they are more than ever due to the others company, they must try and prevent themselves from falling in love.

Again, this book was absolutely ADORABLE, and was the ultimate feel good rom-com. I loved how much they learned about themselves through the other, and the understanding that they had between them. I wasn’t really a fan of Sophie because in my head, what she did was pretty messed up and Michael had every right to not what to speak to her, but as they connected more with one another, she did grow on me. I loved the side characters too, and the DOGS!! The story was so entertaining and I was hooked from the start, Kathryn Freeman you’ve done it again!!

Thank you Netgalley, Kathryn Freeman and One More Chapter for providing me with the E-Arc of this awesome book!!

‘Was it Good for You?’ by Kathryn Freeman is a fun, witty and easy romance.

When Sophie accidentally sends her spreadsheet which rates and plans every aspect of her life (from finances to meals to the men she dates) to everyone in her contacts she's left red-faced.

Her last date Dr Michael Adams, who is mortified her scored a 3 after he arrived late and flustered (due to a medical emergency he hadn't explained to her), challenges her to ten dates before she makes up her mind about him. Of course Sophie is adamant that her spreadsheet will ensure she help her pick her perfect man, but what if the perfect man can't be scored by the qualities listed on her spreadsheet?

I enjoyed the banter and personal growth between the two. Both of them were nursing heavy baggage - Sophie forcing herself to live a regimented life packed with activities as a way of coping after her twin sister's death. Meanwhile Michael is nursing a sore heart after discovering his girlfriend was cheating on him because he was 'boring' which Sophie's spreadsheet reinforced.

While I liked this book and recommend it, I personally found the pacing a bit too slow and started to get repetitive between Sophie and Michael - Sophie rigidly sticking to her spreadsheet, which in turn kept triggering Michael's insecurity. The spicy scenes also seemed a bit jarring as I didn't feel much of that chemistry between them in the lead up that I think a fade to black would've worked better, or it needed more of that build up. Characterisation was also uneven with her best friend Grace. I didn't understand why, despite it being clearly evident Michael was perfect for Sophie, that she was also on Sophie's side that he didn't fit the spreadsheet ergo he's unsuitable.

The end resolution as well I also found a bit too neat. I'd have liked to have seen Michael give up something for her given Betty had a network of friends who could've stayed with her or kept an eye on her.

Overall though, this was an enjoyable book and Kathryn Freeman will always be on my auto-buy list.

Thanks to One More Chapter/Harper Collins UK and NetGalley for the ARC.

After a relationship goes horribly wrong, Sophie decides that she'll create a spreadsheet with all the characteristics that she values in a man, just like she does for all other aspects of her life, and then let it decide whether she should continue to date them. Unfortunately instead of sending it to a friend after a blind date with Dr Michael Adams, she sends it to all her contacts and the bad date finds out what she really thought of him.

Her sister in law (who set them up) is obviously annoyed that he only scored 2.5/10 and to make amends, she goes for an apology drink with him and all the other bad dates again. Only Michael decides that the spreadsheet is flawed and they should go on 10 dates to prove his point.

Another enjoyable, predictable in all the right ways, rom-com from Kathryn Freeman. Sophie and Michael are a likeable pair who you really root for. Loved it!

Thanks to NetGalley for free copy of the book in return for an honest review.

Sophie has a method for choosing the right man - a spreadsheet where she rates them in different categories, making it scientific rather than relying on her feelings so she won’t get hurt again. When she meets Michael and rates him low, she thinks that her spreadsheet is right and her instincts are not. What a cute story of hurts from the past needing to be dealt with so that they don’t mess up the present. A love story with a difference with lots of lovely characters to entertain along the way.

Are you looking for a light and fun romantic comedy that will take your mind off of the stresses of everyday life? Look no further than Kathryn Freeman’s latest book, Was it Good for You? In this book, we follow the story of Sophie, a woman who keeps meticulous spreadsheets to keep track of every aspect of her life, including her love life. But when she accidentally sends her spreadsheet to all her contacts, including the men she’s dated, Sophie has much explaining to do. Enter Dr. Michael Adams, who challenges Sophie to ten dates to prove that an equation can’t quantify love.

The first thing that stood out to me about Was it Good for You? is the dynamic between Sophie and Michael. Their chemistry is undeniable from the moment they meet, and it’s easy to get swept up in their story. Sophie is a character who, on the surface, seems to have it all together, but as the story progresses, we learn more about her vulnerabilities and fears. On the other hand, Michael is charming and confident, but even he has insecurities. Watching them grow and develop as individuals and as a couple is what makes this book so compelling.

One of the unique aspects of this book is how technology plays a role in the story. Sophie’s spreadsheets are an integral part of her character, and they reflect how many people, especially in today’s world, rely on technology to organise their lives. But the book also shows how sometimes relying too much on technology can prevent us from fully experiencing life and the people around us. Michael challenges Sophie to step outside of her comfort zone, and through this challenge, she learns to embrace spontaneity and live in the moment.

Another aspect of this book that I enjoyed was the humour. Freeman has a way of injecting humour into even the most awkward or tense situations, and it had me laughing out loud at many points throughout the story. The dialogue between the characters is witty and well-written, and it’s easy to see why Freeman has become such a popular author in the romantic comedy genre.

As someone who loves a good rom-com, I appreciated how Freeman handles the story's romantic and physical aspects. While there are definitely steamy scenes between Sophie and Michael, they never feel gratuitous or forced. Rather, they are natural and add to the development of their relationship. It was refreshing to see a book without physical intimacy as the sole basis for a successful romantic relationship.

In conclusion, Was it Good for You? is a delightful and charming book that will surely put a smile on your face. The combination of well-developed characters, witty humour, and a unique story make this book stand out in the romantic comedy genre. Whether you’re a fan of Kathryn Freeman’s previous work or looking for a new author to add to your reading list, I highly recommend picking up a copy of Was it Good for You? You won’t regret it!

This is a great book to read which is a lot of fun throughout. Thoroughly enjoyed it and would recommend it highly.

As a spreadsheet girlie myself, I was so intrigued by the premise of this book! The idea of documenting all my romantic encounters on excel and then accidentally sharing it with everyone I know is beyond anxiety inducing (Sophie handled this way better than me I would have 100% changed my name and run away to the most remote place I could fine) so immediately I’m invested. I could not imagine ever having to look one of those men in the eyes after roasting them so thoroughly so… rather Sophie than me!
I loved the idea of this being a “how to get your guy in 10 dates” and Michael and Sophie’s dynamic was adorable. He’s able to make her question her rigid beliefs and habits without being overly patronising and I loved you you could feel Sophie loosen up as the dates progressed.
This was a fun, lighthearted rom com that was enjoyable throughout!

I’d like to take a moment to thank One More Chapter for reaching out and offering me the opportunity to read and review this book.

I really enjoyed this book and the themes within it were so well addressed. Sophie’s character was brilliant and her development was excellent. I really loved Michael and think people like him are definitely underrated. The relationship between the two was really lovely to watch grow. I didn’t think there was too much miscommunication because it was addressed quickly so that definitely increased my enjoyment of the book.

I think it was well written and in my opinion, is one I would recommend to people getting a first dip into romance.


the quiet ones really are the ones to watch out for 👀

I have never read a kathryn freeman book I have never enjoyed and this is no exception. Full of fun and humour and really great book

This was a simple, fun, easy and quick read. The perfect type of book for your holiday, beach, pool kind of read. This is a first for me by the author and one I enjoyed and I would read more of their work. The book cover is eye-catching and appealing and would spark my interest if in a bookshop. Thank you very much to the author, publisher and Netgalley for this ARC.

I really enjoyed this one, it’s cute and funny in all the right places! Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for early access to this book.

This fun trio of friends is a laugh a minute, and from the first page you can tell what is going to go wrong towards the middle of the book.

The story felt familiar, like I'd read it before, but it was still enjoyable, empowering to see women owning their lives, choices and sexualities.

Easy to read.

I've only ever read one other Kathryn Freeman book, but this might become a new go-to author for me.
This story touches on a very tech-driven version of the miscommunication trope, and as a data-driven person and a lover of spreadsheets and order, this really spoke to me. I could completely relate to Sophie, who wants her life to be easily governed by data so she doesn't have to really LIVE it.
I also really loved Michael in this story. Freeman did such a good job giving Michael a real voice: his frustration, pride, and tenderness really shown through on the pages. It made him really relatable, which I loved.
I was rooting for this couple so badly, enjoyed every cute date they went on, and in the end really loved how the story wrapped up. A really great rom-com that I would recommend whole-heartedly!

If you're ready to dive into a romance that blends technology, humor, and a dash of vulnerability, then "Was It Good For You?" by Kathryn Freeman might just be the perfect book for you. Get ready to laugh, swoon, and cringe alongside Sophie as she navigates the ups and downs of love and spreadsheets.

Sophie, our beloved FMC (Female Main Character), is the ultimate spreadsheet aficionado. From tracking her daily steps to rating her dates, her life revolves around the colorful cells of Excel. But when an accidental email sends her dating spreadsheet to her entire contact list, things quickly take an awkward turn. Sophie finds herself on a mission to make amends, leading her to a surprising challenge from Dr. Michael Adams, the recipient of her unflattering rating.

The story takes off as Sophie and Michael embark on a series of ten dates, aiming to prove that love cannot be confined to cells and formulas. What follows is a delightful journey filled with witty banter, unexpected moments, and a growing connection that defies calculations. Freeman's execution of this unique premise is a joy to read, as she balances lightheartedness with genuine emotional depth.

The characters of Sophie and Michael are the heart and soul of the book. Sophie's transformation from a data-driven, box-checking individual to someone willing to step outside her comfort zone is both relatable and endearing. Michael's charm and willingness to challenge Sophie's spreadsheet philosophy make him an ideal match for our analytical protagonist. Their chemistry leaps off the pages, and it's a delight to witness their blossoming romance.

While the story overall is a delightful ride, I must admit that the writing felt a bit clunky at the beginning. However, once I reached the 20% mark, the narrative gained its momentum, and I was fully engrossed in the tale. From that point on, the book flowed smoothly, keeping me engaged with heartwarming moments and a cozy ambiance that made me want to curl up under a blanket.

"Was It Good For You?" is a perfect choice if you're a fan of Lynn Painter and Amy Lea's charming romances. It offers a unique twist on the genre, injecting humor and warmth into a modern love story. Freeman's ability to create relatable characters and immerse readers in their journey is commendable.

So, grab a cup of tea, find a comfy spot, and indulge in this delightful, heartwarming read. Just be prepared to view your own spreadsheets with a newfound sense of curiosity and wonder. Happy reading!

[Note: I received an advanced copy of this book for free through NetGalley, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.]

What happens when you live your life to an Excel spreadsheet? No room for intangibles and misunderstandings. Then you accidentally send to all contacts. embrassment and apologies required.
It also leads to understanding and dealing with past issues. What you thought you needed isn't what you actually need.
But can hurt feelings be put aside and go forward.
Follow the relationship and root for a happy ever after.