Cover Image: Watership Down

Watership Down

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I have to say I loved this graphic novel form of Watership Down. I read this regular edition a while back and loved it. I even watched the movie and loved it as well. I highly recommend to everyone

Was this review helpful?

Beautiful art that highlights how intense and gorgeous this story is. Definitely helped heal the trauma of being made to watch the movie of this at way too young of an age :).

Was this review helpful?

4 out of 5 stars

The art is absolutely stunning and looks amazing. I have not read the original book but I saw the film as a child so I’m not familiar enough to say how faithful this graphic novel is to the book but I still enjoyed it. However there was a few times where it felt like they cut out scenes for the sake of keeping the page count down. And a few panels had dialogue that was laid out in a confusing manner and left me confused as to the order the dialogue is suppose to be read in.

Was this review helpful?

The illustrations were amazing, but I don't know if graphic novel is the right medium for Watership Down. It was one of my favorite books when I was in high school and while the pictures are great, they gloss over a lot of the depth and nuance of the book. A lot of symbolism is missing.. it reads more like a storyboard than a complete novel. I didn't love it, however I'm giving it three stars because people who didn't read the original work might still like it.

Was this review helpful?

This is a lovely and beautifully-condensed graphic treatment of Richard Adams's beloved novel. There was beauty on every page--the art was just perfect in approach and texture and color for the stories being told. There is tragedy and sacrifice and all of the pathos and suspense and politicking of the novel, but perfect for younger readers or people who just didn't get into the novel, and for anyone who was traumatized by that 80s movie adaptation, because it is a balm for your soul.

Was this review helpful?

As a longtime fan of Adams’s Watership Down, I was leery about a graphic novel adaptation. I have never been happier to admit that I was wrong.

The source material is admittedly hard to adapt. There’s a ton of world-specific vocabulary, the storyline is very much “hurry up and wait” action alternating with pastoral scenes, and it’s confronts the violence of a wild rabbit’s life head-on.

Sturm and Sutphin handle these all beautifully. The pacing is excellent, avoiding the choppiness that would be so easy to fall into. The rabbit-speak is scattered throughout judiciously so that we still get the flavor of their world without being overwhelmed.

I especially love how Sturm handles the differences between the overall story, Fiver’s visions, and the legends of El-ahrairah’s exploits. Each segment has its own unique style that’s easy to recognize and they all share enough common ground to flow seamlessly.

I opened this book full of excitement and the knowledge that I would probably be disappointed. Instead I was riveted to the story just as I was the first time I picked up Adams’s masterpiece.

Was this review helpful?

incredibly beautiful drawings, I was delighted to get to know this classic story through each pages, would really recommend to discover (or rediscover) this classic!

Was this review helpful?

Having heard a lot about this series from both the show and original book I thought this would be a fun one to review. I was not let down for being a newbie to the story. It was simply spectacular! The artwork was great and I felt like it was clear who each of the characters were, which seemed important as the animals are anthropomorphic.

Was this review helpful?

<i>Watership Down</i> remains one of my favorite stories even after first experiencing the story through the first animated film as a child. No, I was most likely unprepared for such a story at that age, but I will say that it stuck with me. 4 years later, I sought the film again and found out that it was based on a novel, which I had to read. I just didn't realize I would love it so much that I'd read the book 4 times that year. All of this is to say that this graphic novel is certainly true to the source material. James Sturm did a splendid job of adapting the novel into a condensed form that allows the story to shine. And the art from Joe Sutphin really captured the style of the animated film along with the illustrations from the sequel collection <i>Tales from Watership Down</i>. This adaptation will likely please readers who loved the novel while also hopefully attracting new readers and inspiring them to look at the source material.

Highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

How do you feel about Graphic Novels?

This is my 3rd and I really enjoy them! Brings me back to my comic book days.

If you have read and loved Watership Down, definitely check this new #graphicnovel .

The adaptation kept enough of the original text to keep everyone happy.

This one is out in October. Thank you to @netgalley and #tenspeedgraphic for my #arc copy.

#comics #classics

Was this review helpful?

Watership Down is my most favorite book of all time. This graphic novel was a beautiful intrerpretation of that book. I greatly enjoyed reading it and remembering my love for the story and the Rabbits of the Down. Thank you for choosing me to read this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Watership Down was assigned to me as a high school summer read many years ago. I remember it being daunting and I had struggled to finish it. So, I was pleasantly surprised to come across James Sturm's adaptation of the classic, in graphic novel format. This time, the read was quick and I easily remembered the characters from before. Even the story line came back from the nooks and crannies of my brain!
Sturm has done a wonderful job retelling the original story. His illustrator, Joe Surphin, brings the characters alive, and both did an excellent job of sharing the characters' individual traits and contributions to the story.
You are in for a treat if you decide to pick up this delightful graphic novel. And if you have the time, read the original as well--it's worth the read afterall.

Thank you for NetGalley, Ten Speed Graphic, James Sturm, and Joe Surphin for my egalley!

Was this review helpful?

I had never read the original story before and thought that maybe the graphic novel would make it easier to understand. Though I didn't particularly enjoy this story I will admit this graphic novel is well done. The story isn't bad necessarily, I just didn't find it engaging.

Was this review helpful?

4.25ish stars.

I honestly liked this a lot more than the novel. It's streamlined and leaves out all the fluff. The illustrator does a great job of distinguishing each of the rabbits from each other, not an easy feat.

Was this review helpful?

Watership Down has been one of my favorite books since childhood. This graphic novel is a faithful condensed version and I greatly enjoyed reading it!

Was this review helpful?

An absolutely beautifully illustrated graphic novel from James Sturm that follows Richard Adams’s classic novel. I love that this wasn’t abridged, and that the illustrations so gorgeously captured the themes of heroism, freedom, family, and so many more.

Absolutely five stars, and worth the read for anyone that loves the original novel and any graphic novel lover.

Many thanks to Netflix and Ten Speed for the opportunity to review this beauty of a digital ARC in exchange for an honest review. My opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Beautifully illustrated GN will open this classic up to many new readers and reignite the love of many re-readers.

arc provided

Was this review helpful?

This is a perfectly solid rendition of an odd, but beautiful book. The artwork is clear and beautiful, while helping to clearly and wonderfully tell the story. The storyline stays engaging and smooth without the clunk that some graphic re-tellings ultimately have. I think this is a exceptionally accessible way to get through this book.

Was this review helpful?

Continuing to work through some classics, we come to “Watership Down: The Graphic Novel”, original novel by Richard Adams, adapted by James Sturm and illustrated by Joe Sutphin. Having not read the original novel (yet), I cannot comment on how true to the book this graphic adaptation is, but it is still a wonderfully illustrated story about rabbits, friendship, and a search for a home.

When Fiver, a rabbit with some psychic abilities, foretells the destruction of their warren due to the encroachment of man, a group of rabbits go off and try to find a new place to call home. Bigwig, Hazel, and others have a wide-ranging variety of adventures, from finding a warren of rather too-tame rabbits, to encounters with birds and mice, to farmyard dogs and cats, and finally a militant warren run through terror. The rabbits finally group together and decide that this is where they make their stand, this is where they defend all that they have built.

The illustrations are wonderful, the ability to differentiate each rabbit through their look was nothing short of amazing. I don’t think one is supposed to read into this for some deeper meaning, or philosophy, or a parable to apply to today’s world. It is just a good story about rabbits, about how they see the world, and how they deal with issues that arise and hope for the future. If that’s what you’re looking for, then this is an enjoyable story. I must now go and read the original book!

I requested and received a free advanced electronic copy from Clarkson Potter/Ten Speed Press, Ten Speed Graphic via NetGalley. Thank you!

Was this review helpful?

I haven't read the original book so please take my review with that context in mind. I have of course heard of Watership Down and it's one of those books on my someday TBR list so I jumped at the chance to read the graphic novel to get a taste of the story. In the afterword, the author who did the adaptation did a good job of explaining how and why they've cut things from the original story to make it fit into a graphic novel and it all sounded very reasonable to me.

The design of this book was lovely. It really created a very powerful and effective sense of place. The illustrator did a good job of differentiating the rabbits. I didn't always know for sure but I think someone familiar with the story would have kept up better and it was certainly a tricky task.

The story itself is intriguing and a little bit weird and - while the author has maintained it's not allegory - these anthropomorphized rabbits certainly offer an interesting reflection of humanity. The story was quiet at times with interesting little lessons. And toward the end the action really picked up and I didn't want to put it down.

Reading this version of the book has certainly kept me intrigued about the original book, which will move up a little higher on my someday TBR.

Was this review helpful?