A predictable, easy read. Nothing profound or fascinating here. But gets the job done if you want something simple to read.

This was a good beach read. A unique “what if” story. I think the characters were lacking some, but overall enjoyable read!

Overall, I enjoyed this book. The book's premise caught my attention, and I was engrossed in the story. Liv and Jake are meant for each other, and I found my heart breaking for them throughout the story. It’s also wild to think about how much one person’s life can affect others. The impact that Liv’s existence had on her friends and family’s lives was fascinating. Things that I would never think would change were different in the alternative universe, which made me reflect a lot.

That said, it would have been fun to see Liv do some things she never did in her ordinary world. We didn’t see much of that, and I think it would have added a fun layer to the book.

What threw me for a loop was the switch between first-person POV in Liv’s chapters to third-person POV in Jake’s chapters. It grated at me, but that might be because I prefer the first-person POV. That said, it didn’t take away from the book so much that I wouldn’t recommend it. Also, the ending was a bit abrupt, and I would have liked to of seen a little bit more or an epilogue.

An intriguing read for which I had no expectations it having read this author’s first book. I loved the way the story was narrated and I enjoyed the characters.
A refreshingly unique read but not a traditional romance.
4.5 stars

The premise of this book was so intriguing to me! I felt like the story had great potential, though I realise I should have tempered my expectations a little given that this is a New Adult romance. As a result, the plot centred around the romance (duh) and didn’t really unpack the other elements. I felt it didn’t really deliver on Liv having “a chance to do all the things she never did”, as she never really attempted to do things differently or alter her life course in any significant way.

The main thing I didn’t love about this book was that it switched between first-person POV (in Liv’s chapters) and third-person POV (in Jake’s chapters). This may have been a stylistic choice that was just lost on me, but it felt jarring every time it switched. I sort of thought it may have been leading up to an “and then I woke up” style ending where it turned out Liv had been thinking as Jake which would have explained the POV switch, but THANKFULLY it didn’t end that way, so idk what the POV switching was about.

Overall I had a pretty good time with this book, I would definitely recommend it for anyone interested in New Adult romance or ‘what if’ style stories.

I quite enjoyed this book - I found it to be quite intriguing.

Olivia and Jake are childhood sweethearts, engaged to be married and are celebrating this engagement anniversary in a secluded spot that has a quarry. Olivia goes for a walk, loses her balance and falls over a rocky cliff's edge into water.

It is here that the book splits into two parallel worlds; one with Olivia's 'real' present and the 'present' that she falls into - the one where she died in the same spot as a twelve year old. The 'real' present is told from Jake's perspective and the world that Olivia falls into is seen from her point of view. She enters a world where her family have trouble believing who she is as they buried her years ago and Jake is no longer hers. Everything is different.

Jake's perspective tells the story of searching for his missing Olivia and the trauma that he endures after she goes missing.

I thought that the entire parallel world concept was pretty well executed. The only downside for me was that the actual ending was very abrupt; it just seemed to lack closure. The ending could have really done with an epilogue.

I thought “The Love of My Other Life” was an amazing debut novel by C.J. Connolly, and her second published work, “The Love I Could Have Had” was a wonderful variation on similar themes.

The book is the story of Olivia, whose perfect life is upended when she becomes displaced in an alternative reality in which she died as a young person. Seemingly back from the dead, so many things are similar in this new world, yet fundamentally different.

In the “original” world, Olivia worries that her life choices have limited her or if there are better possibilities should she have made different choices. Faced with a new reality, in which her fiancé, Jake Johnson, is happily with another woman she has time to consider what makes her happy and what she wants. But, can she make her way back to that perfect life?

This book was a bit harder than Connolly’s first novel, which does explore the ideas of different choices and other versions of our lives. The story moves between Olivia’s experiences in the new world and Jake’s perspective in the original world. He is devastated by Olivia’s disappearance, there is a criminal investigation, people wonder if he’s murdered Liv, and he struggles with both the loss of his only lover and with not knowing what became of her.

Yet, there were wonderful things to think about in the book – the possibility of endless realities that play out as a cosmic choose-your-own-adventure. Set in North Carolina, the beach town vibes also helped warm up the story.

Thankfully the book is not too long, which makes the separation of our romantic couple bearable, and each of Olivia and Jake recall their time together so that we have happier memories to balance out heavier moments.
C.J. Connolly writes books similar to Emily Henry and Mhairi McFarlane – happy/sad novels exploring people’s daily lives in entertaining, heartfelt ways.

I received an ARC of this novel from the publisher / NetGalley but the review is my own.

I received an ARC of this novel from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

A woman goes missing amd returns in an alternate reality. So many unanswered questions.

And another one… I just adore C.J. Connolly’s books so much! Her stories are super easy to read, unforgettable, intriguing, and very well written! I absolutely devoured this story of Jake and Olivia and felt so invested in them and what would become of them by the end of it all.

I know a few readers that wished for a little more at the end, but I just enjoyed every second of this book. I cannot wait for her next one!

I recommend this book if you enjoy:
- Multi-verse tropes (I love them!)
- Dual POV
- Emotional yet heartwarming stories
- Likeable characters
- Quick reads that keep you intrigued and wanting to know what happens at the end
- The thought that life can change in the matter of an instant or if you ever stopped to think if you made one different choice, how your life may have looked instead
- A little bit of mystery in your romance story
- Reading about destiny and soulmates

Liv and Jake have been together since they were kids and are engaged to be married. They are out near a lake one day celebrating and after contemplating what could be missing from her seemingly perfect life, Liv slips off the cliff and falls into the lake. Her body is never found and to her family and Jake, Liv is missing and is never found. When Liv wakes up, she is in the hospital. Her engagement ring is missing. Nobody knows who she is. Her family doesn't know her and Jake is in love with someone else.

OMG, this book! I was so back and forth about whether or not I wanted Liv to go back and end up with Jake or whether or not I wanted her to end up with the hunky cop. Then, I felt bad because Jake was so wonderful. Okay, enough of my inner struggle...

There is a very powerful love story in this book. It is obvious from the very beginning how much these two love each other. Connolly weaves that truth throughout the entire story. Jake never wavers. Even multiverse Jake can't stay away from the Liv that comes back to his reality. And while Liv questions it at the beginning...well, you just need to read it to see how she comes to terms with it and what she's willing to do for it. I love how Liv comes to appreciate her family and I hope there continues to be growth there.

What I didn't like- the abrupt ending. I get it, but I didn't like it. I needed more, such as an epilogue. Can we get a bonus epilogue out there somewhere?

Thanks to NetGalley and Joffe Books for this ARC! All thoughts and opinions are my own.

The premise of this book is what sparked my initial interest…who hasn’t thought about what life might be like if you made different choices along the way? Olivia, our protagonist, has these thoughts as she celebrates her engagement anniversary with her childhood love, Jake. But when a celebratory outing at a quarry has Olivia slipping off a waterside cliff, instead of waking on the shore she wakes in a hospital bed without a soul knowing who she is and no engagement ring on her finger. All of a sudden, with nothing certain, Olivia has a chance to see what her life could have looked like and decide whether that’s better than the life she’s already lived.

As I said, the premise is what got my interest peaked and I did find myself wanting to learn more about Olivia as I read. I found her relatable and her romance with Jake to be charming. Curiosity on how she tackles being an unknown in her otherwise familiar life kept me turning the pages, and I found myself invested in whether she was able to build new relationships with her family, and whether those relationships kept her in her new reality, or if she ended up going back to her new life.

However, I felt that there were other parts of the books that distracted from the main plot. I think Olivia’s story would have been better told if this story had one main storyline and one narrator. I kept trying to figure out where Jake’s viewpoint played in the overall storyline and still can’t figure out the answer to that question. If I skipped those chapters, I don’t think I would have missed anything from the overall story. I also found the non-linear timeline to be a distraction. There is no reason we needed to see Olivia on Aug 17th on one chapter, and the next chapter see Jake on Aug 8th. I found myself having to flip back and forth to keep track and it took my attention away from the story.

This story fits the bill as a lighthearted, fast beach read, something that can keep the reader entertained without much effort. I finished this book with a smile on my face, and while there are pieces of it that didn’t fit my taste, I think it was still an endearing story overall. Anyone looking for something light and sweet should enjoy this book.

**A special thank you to Joffe Books and NetGalley for an advanced copy of this book in exchange for my honest opinion!**

This was a fun read. I didn’t read the description closely and thought this was just going to be a “wakes up with amnesia” story, but it was much more than that! I usually don’t like alternating narrators but it worked so well here. My only complaint is once you know what is happening it’s predictable. The ending is abrupt, I definitely wish there had been a few more chapters or even just an epilogue.

This book was so good! But boy did it put me on an emotional Rollercoaster, but I wouldng have it any other way. I started this book and read it in one sitting. I could not stop reading it until it was done! I loved this!
I just reviewed THE LOVE I COULD HAVE HAD by C.J. Connolly. #THELOVEICOULDHAVEHAD #NetGalley
[NetGalley URL]

Olivia and Jake have been together since childhood and now the wedding is approaching. Although they are madly in love Olivia can't help wondering if she is missing out or is Jake missing out? A few years down the line will Jake wonder what it would be like to be with another woman? Then a freak accident and she was transported to her life in a different timeline one where she doesn't exist. Now she can do all the things she thought she may miss out on.

This is a brilliant story that had me hooked. The characters fit the story well, some I liked and some I didn't. Some I would have liked to know more about. Deb the friendly server flits in and out of the story without knowing much about her likewise Savanna. However the main characters were realistic and developed well.

I like the theory of alternate timelines but this one didn't seem to work for me I suppose in my logical mind I am willing to believe there may be windows to another time but for me those windows would need to be accessed in strict criteria - the same date and time etc whereas in this book just falling from a cliff could cause you to end up in a different timeline.

I also felt the ending left too many unanswered questions.

However, a very enjoyable read.

I really wished I loved this.

The writing was so good and it started off fantastic until the storyline went a complete different way to what i was expecting. I would understand if the plot was like ' what if I took this path instead of this one' etc, but this was pure fantasy stuff. And i LOVE FANTASY. but this was not it.
My logical brain could not handle the swapping of 'lives' and how the FMC could just return to her previous life... and that ending? It was so so abrupt and I was left confused and disappointed.

This book follows Liv and Jake. Liv is in her late twenties and is engaged to her first love, Jake. They celebrate their anniversary of the engagement and Liv falls off a cliff. When she wakes up, she’s in an alternate timeline where she is dead. Can Liv and Jake survive this?

I really liked the author’s debut novel. This one was pretty much the exact same story, with a few changes. It’s a okay formula and it mostly worked, but it’s not a book I’d read over again. The dialogue is a little clunky at times and some characters make questionable decisions. It was a quick read too.

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC In exchange for an honest review.
I was excited about this book based on the description and premise, but it ended up being much different than I expected in a lackluster way. It felt as though the story was so much more focused on the mystery of Liv’s disappearance and timeline jump rather than her exploring the “what could have been in another life” theme. I did enjoy most of the writing style/voice however, the plot and storyline was overall I enjoyable for me. 2.5⭐️

I really loved the premise of this books. It reminded me of Maybe in Another Life and I was so excited to read this. It fell a bit flat for me? I think I just never got into the characters because the flipping between timelines. And the ending came a bit abruptly, I think if this was a bit longer I may have liked more!

wow, this was such a unique, fascinating, heartwarming story! I loved the twist of this trope where you wake up to a new reality where you seemingly have it all (13 going on 30 style) but instead it’s you wake up and have nothing—no money, no possessions, no identity. this happens to the FMC Olivia who wakes up in a reality where she actually died at 12 years old, leaving behind a whole world of family, friends, & fiancé who love her deeply. she has to convince these people in her new world she actually is their Olivia.

I read this in one sitting, and was absolutely enthralled by the back and forth timeline between Olivia’s new reality & her fiancé Jake’s reality that Olivia left. It kept me on the edge of my toes, wondering how anyone—from both perspectives— could handle this impossible, heartbreaking situation. I felt Olivia’s fam in her new reality handled about as I expect with the grieving parents going extreme in two directions, the mom embracing having her dead daughter back, & her father being exceptionally cynical & unbelieving. I don’t think I can even imagine how I would react in any of their shoes in such a situation. And my heart just bled for Jake in his reality where he lost Liv. He loves her so freaking much, and he was dealing with such grief by living in such a tragedy.

I loved the ending, but I would have loved an epilogue showing maybe a year later, just how it was all handled once the story concluded (especially from both timelines, if that’s even possible). I know this book was listed as Romance genre, but it felt more to me like General Fiction with dashes of romance, fantasy (parallel universes), & suspense. But I couldn’t nail down just one genre for this book, I don’t think.

overall, very heartwarming, tearful, suspenseful, unique story! thank you so much for the ARC!!!

I was apprehensive going into this book, I read CJ Connolly’s Love in Another Life earlier this year, and part of me thought this would be a similar book with both having a split timeline “what if” set up. But I was wrong. This book is in a different league!

From the end of the first chapter, I was hooked! This book, whilst retaining the sliding-doors-esque feel to it, is entirely different to the first book I read by this author. This “what if” story sees Liv enter go from her blissful life on the eve of her wedding to a universe that looks exactly like hers with the same people, but no one knows who she is. The parallel plot lines were really cleverly linked together, with the same events taking place in each world but being slightly different in both. This book had many twists and turns, giving a real Gone Girl feel to the timeline where Liv is considered to be disappeared.

What this book does well is showing us how the smaller moments of life, the day-to-day decisions and friendships we form, do change our lives. When Liv suddenly finds herself in a life where she knows everyone, but no one knows, and how different their lives are for it, you see the impact that she's had without even knowing it I didn't expect this book to take me on such a roller coaster of emotions. One minute (especially with the timeline where Liv isn't there), I was on the edge of my seat, and the next, I was grinning at the romance elements.

The only thing for me that I perhaps wasn’t a massive fan of was the ending, it did feel a bit rushed, and I would like to have seen more of the characters. But that’s a testament to how gripped I was by the story!

This book is tender, thought-provoking, and a page-turner. A great summer read! If you wonder about the “what-if”’s of life, then you'll love this book.

Thank you to NetGalley and Joffe Books for providing me an advance reader copy in exchange for a fair and honest review.