Cover Image: Ink Girls

Ink Girls

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I loved the plot line of this graphic novel. I really enjoyed looking at all the art and how the panels and backgrounds were used. I can’t wait to add it to my library’s collection!

Was this review helpful?

This is not only a stunning and fun graphic novel but once I wish many kids studying the Middle Ages might read! Poignant and even relatable to current life, but especially an eye-opener of what the Middle Ages were, instead of just the dark ones we might have learnt about.
I especially loved the Italian atmosphere the author and illustrator created both through the beautiful illustrations (those double pages had me pausing!) and through the language. The strong themes of friendship and found family and of community fight, team work and justice. And the fact that Cinzia and Elena are special in their own ways but that that is not the main focus of the story at all. Ah, and there’s a cat, and bad guys, and censorship and poverty, but also togetherness and beauty.

Was this review helpful?

Cinzia is a young printer's apprentice with a crippled leg. She loves printing news and watching it spread. When her Mestra is arrested for printing the truth about the ruling family, Cinzia joins with the princess and other village girls to track down her Mestra's sources and prove that what was printed is the truth. Along the way, Cinzia discovers new friendships and that words have power.

Was this review helpful?

(Full disclosure: I received a free e-ARC for review through Netgalley/Edelweiss. Content warning for allusions to child abuse.)

When she was just eight, Cinzia left her home in the country for Siannerra - and Mestra Aronne. For three years, she's served as the printer's apprentice (and found family). It's Mestra's belief that trust is the glue that holds Siannerra together: the citizens trust the Principessa to keep the city safe and protected; the guilds trust the council to keep trade and justice fair - and "together, we flourish." That, and the truth will always come out.

So when Mestra Aronne uncovers evidence that the Lord Magistrate is corrupt - engaging in extortion, bribery, and threats - she doesn't hesitate to print the story in her avviso. She trusts that the truth will protect her. But the Principessa's guards come for her in the dead of night; before long, she will be convicted of treason and sentenced to hang.

Luckily, Cinzia escapes the Palazzo - and stumbles upon Contessina Elena, alone in her garden. Rumors abound about the Contessina: that she's odd, never smiles, and has no friends. In short, that she's an unsuitable heir to the throne. Cinzia makes quick work disproving all of these. Elena is everything her mother the Principessa is not: brave, curious about the city around her, and empathetic, with a wide circle of compassion. Elena vows to help Cinzia free her Mestra, and get justice for the people of Siannerra. Along with a scrappy group of girls - including Carlotta the runaway pirate - Cinzia and Elena aim to prove that the pen is mightier than the sword.

Inspired by Italia in the late Middle Ages/Renaissance period, INK GIRLS is a tale of resistance that's both charming and inspiring. Cinzia, Elena, Carlotta, Anneqah, and Mestra Aronne all make for engaging protagonists - and the city, a beautiful backdrop - and I love to see girls from different walks of life coming together to fight for the truth, their city, and those it has left behind. There's great representation, in terms of disability as well as race, ethnicity, and religion. The artwork is just lovely and masterfully encapsulates the time period.

Though the target audience is readers aged eight to twelve years, INK GIRLS is a graphic novel that's suitable for children and adults alike.

Was this review helpful?

A very engaging and interesting alternative take on censorship in many countries. I loved the individual characters but feel that a little more fleshing out in the storyline would take this over the top.

Was this review helpful?

Ink girls was a captivating story with a beautiful art style. It was unique in its narrative and powerful in its theme of getting your truth out in the world. The story, primarily metaphorical (or at least it feels that way), is about standing up for what you believe in, girl friendships and the empowerment they bring and the ever changing narrative from those in power to harm those that aren't.

This book was a fast paced read with a very compelling cast of characters, but what I loved most about this graphic novel was the atmosphere created by the art itself alongside the written narrative. A thoroughly enjoyable read!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and Greenwillow Books for the ARC!

- I loved this book so much!! The setting, the plot, the characters-everything fit together so well!
- the Italian Renaissance setting was fantastic, and I loved how it focused on a normal city/working class people in the city. The way the market was drawn was so incredibly inviting, and I love how thorough the worldbuilding was.
- Any kid who is interested in journalism should absolutely read this book!
- I loved the character design! They all felt stylistically coherent, while being really easy to recognize quickly.
- the inclusion of disabled characters was so well done, and I appreciated the information included in the author’s note about the real life diversity that is reflected in this book!

Was this review helpful?

Ink Girls is a historical fiction graphic novel about 3 girls who become unlikely friends after the corrupt government of the imaginary city state (Siannera? I think) set in middle ages Italy. This story follows a very real issue that occurred where nobility and the government tried to suppress avviso to control the common people from learning of current news and affairs.

Ink Girls has beautiful and colorful art, with some beautiful light cool tones mixed with sepias and terracotta backgrounds. The architecture features is beautiful and perfectly sets the environment as middle age Italy. The story is beautiful as the art.

I truly loved the friendship that is formed between the 3 main girls, but especially between Cinzia (the apprentice of the printer who is being persecuted), and Elena (young city-state royal who is locked away within the Palazzo). Cinzia has a physical disability that requires her to use a cane as a mobility aid, and it is hinted that Elena has autism so she sometimes doesn't understand the people around her easily. However, these two girls, commoner and ruler team together to fight for truth and justice. They meet with Carlotta and another girl to take down the corrupt commissioner and free Cinzia's mestra.

This graphic novel touches on the fact that just a few people can push forward a movement for justice, even 4 young girls. It also makes it known that people back then in history were like us, fighting for causes, loving their families, they had dreams, and that they could be like Elena and Cinzia.

I highly recommend picking up this book for yourself or any young one in your life. I will be getting a copy for my younger cousins.

I received this book from the publisher through NetGalley for free in exchange of an honest review. All thoughts and opinions on this work are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Justice through journalism and speaking up in an Italian Renaissance-inspired setting! A great tale about the power of the press and doing what's right paired with beautiful illustrations. Also, a subtle-smooth representation of women of color and disabled people. I also really loved reading the author's note at the end about some of the history of journalism in the Middle Ages/Renaissance.

Was this review helpful?

Bestselling YA author Marieke Nijkamp knocks it out of the park with her debut graphic novel for middle grade kids.

In a fictional city full of guilds and overseen by a female ruler during the early days of the printing press, we find two 11yo girls who couldn't be more different than their city's people, and each other.

Cinzia, who walks with a cane, is on a mission to free her mentor and guardian who has been imprisoned for exposing the ruler's brother's extortion and theft. She meets Elena, the ruler's socially awkward, not-so communicative daughter, who has been pent up in the palace her whole life.

Elena and Cinzia escape the palace, and try to evade the guards throughout the entire city while searching for proof, to expose the rotten uncle and free the printer.

Sylvia Bi's illustrations make me think of that of the Lumberjanes: great hair, lanky girls, expressive. It's hard to believe it's her debut too!

Full of subtle nods to classism, normalizing disability, the truths sought by journalism, feminism, and strong women of color.

Was this review helpful?

Corrupt politicians vs a bunch of girls with a printing press. The politicians are definitely not ready for what's coming. This historical fiction comic shows a side of the medieval world not often seen; one that's filled with so much more than able-bodied straight cis white men. The art is beautiful and intricate and every page has so many details you'll want to spend hours just looking at one page. Plus, its themes of friendship, telling the truth even when it's hard and dangerous, and standing up for the rights of yourself and your neighbors are incredibly relevant to today's readers.

Was this review helpful?

The illustrations are really lovely in this graphic novel.
I liked Ciniza and how she believed in fighting for what was right. I loved the theme of ink and newspapers to get out the written word.
A middle grade graphic novel that many kids will read again and again.

Thanks NetGalley for this ARC

Was this review helpful?

Ink Girls was so good! This is one of the best middle-grade graphic novels I have ever read. And do not get me started on the beautiful artwork.

We start with Cinzia she is a printer apprentice. Mestra Aronne has taken Cinzia under her wing to show her the ropes of printing. Cinizia notices that the next printing could change their lives forever because it goes against the ruling family. Cinzia was right because once the next printing is out.Cinzia and Mestra Aronne are imprisoned. But Cinzia escapes and bumps into Elena, the next heir to the ruling family, and the story takes off from there.

I am blown away. I requested this graphic novel because of the beautiful cover and artwork (I know, shallow.) Once I got into the story, I noticed how much I was involved, and I couldn’t wait to see what happened next. Ink Girls sucked me as we overhear the gossip from the townspeople on the street to the guards chasing children through the town to meeting other lovable characters. I don’t want to say too much, but there is one character in the story that is my favorite, but you will have to read it to find out which character I am talking about. I also loved the found family trope. This graphic novel brightened my day.

If you have not noticed, this was a 5-star for me. Thanks, NetGalley and Publishers for sending this book for review consideration. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I received an advanced copy from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
For eleven-year-old Cinzia, working as a printer's apprentice is a dream. But for one moment of telling the truth to the citizens about the royal family's lies, her world is upended completely. When, on the run from guards, she meets the royal princess Elena, who the country knows as quiet and shy. Together, Cinzia, Elena, and the few folks from the guilds come around and fight for the honesty of the royalty. It's up to them to stop Elena's uncle from overtaking control of all of its citizens.
A bit historical and a bit adventurous, Ink Girls weaves together two young girls' lives in a world of guild-making and censorship in a time where having the power to create change is everything. I enjoyed the friendship between Elena and Cinzia and the pirate lady. And how the whole city comes together to fight injustice. I liked how the ending was wrapped up in a satisfying way.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and HarperCollins for providing me with an eARC in exchange for an honest review!

This book was super cute! I loved the story, it's a really important message about trust and revolution. The illustrations were gorgeous, I really loved the color scheme and world building. Overall, I think this was a really cute, fun graphic novel.

Was this review helpful?

This was a great read! The art style is vibrant and expressive, something I find very important when reading a graphic novel. The story itself was also excellent, I really liked the way the author portrayed censorship and prosecution of journalists in a realistic and digestible way for the age range it is intended for. The message is empowering, touching on trust, community, power disparity, and friendship. The main character, Cinzia, uses a cane, and I think Elena is neurodivergent, which was great to see in a story like this. Overall, a powerful and compelling read.

Was this review helpful?

I received this book for free from netgalley for an honest review.

I wanted to be a beta tester for this book so that I could tell my niece about it. It had great representation and it really held up. Although I'm not as crazy about graphic novels as other people I really found it engaging.

Was this review helpful?

girls who want to make a difference are the backbone of society and that is clear in this graphic novel. ink girls details the story of cinzia, the printer's apprentice and elena, the principessa of their city as cinzia's mentor gets thrown in jail for "falsely accusing" the magistrate of stealing and the two young girls resolve to try and save cinzia's mentor and keep true to her motto of always speaking the truth, even when it's not the easy choice.

this was incredible, both how the art was very pleasing to the eyes with all the warm colors and beautiful beautiful illustrations of the city cinzia and elena live in and the message was empowering about censorship and trust and simply what one can do if they want to make a difference. the cast of girls helping them on their journey was super nice to see and the casual representation and discussion of topics for children was just so wonderful! very happy books like these exist and also the historical note at the end was great!

thanks to netgalley and greenwillow books for the arc!

Was this review helpful?

Ink Girls is a powerful story about doing what is right and sharing the truth, no matter the cost. It was inspiring to read of three young girls who saw a wrong and chose to be a catalyst for change in their city. The overall story was a little wordy. I find that I enjoy graphic novels more when the pictures tell just as much of the story as the words. I also wonder if this story might go over some young readers heads with the elaborate detail to politics. Nonetheless, the story was fleshed out well, featured a diverse cast of characters, and bore beautiful illustrations to accompany a timey tale. I think readers of all ages will enjoy this one.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this graphic novel. The illustrations were beautiful and the story was fascinating. I appreciated all the topics that were tackled in this novel. I know my students will enjoy it, and I cannot wait to add it to my classroom library.

Was this review helpful?