I could not get into this book. The manner in which relationships were treated did not appeal to me and since it seemed to be a major theme in the book I could not read around it to follow the plot.

I really wanted to love this book, the cover drew me in almost instantly. I had such a hard time getting into the story line. I do however want to say the LGBTQ+ representation was so well written.


Thank you NetGalley for an arc.

Honestly, I wasn't sure what to expect going into this book. However, I absolutely loved EVERY second of it! The fact that there was not only trans representation, BUT polyamory too? I loved that this book seemed to be a giant message about personal identity and being yourself. Definitely a book thats fun and honestly had me screaming at the characters in a good way.

I really enjoyed this! I thought the world of alchemy was so interesting and I really enjoyed the characters especially Ash. There was such fantastic representation and I felt like it was quite the unique story. I will say the pacing was a bit off for me as it took me a little while to really get into the story. Still enjoyed though and will be adding to our library!

Infinity Alchemist is a riveting young adult fantasy that immerses readers in a world where alchemy is forbidden for many. Ash, an untrained alchemist, crosses paths with Ramsay, a prodigious practitioner, sparking a journey to find the legendary Book of Source. Along the way, they navigate personal struggles and romantic entanglements, exploring themes of identity and acceptance. While I found the LGBTQIA+ representation and premise engaging, I felt the pacing was uneven at times, and certain plot elements were underdeveloped.

Thank you Netgalley for the e-ARC!

I'm such a huge Karen Callender fan, so hearing that they were writing a fantasy book had me ecstatic. Everything about Infinity Alchemist should have been right up my alley - poly rep, nonbinary rep, trans rep, unique magical society, queer-normative world... It was like it was written for me in mind. Sadly, it just didn't live up to its potential.

Ash is an untrained, unregistered alchemist. Only the most rich and elite are eligible to study magic, so after Ash is rejected from the Lancaster College of Alchemic Science, he takes whatever chance he can get to get as close as possible to alchemy by accepting a job on the property as a groundskeeper while he studies in secret. But then, he's discovered training by the young prodigy Ramsay Thorne - and instead of having him arrested, she makes him an offer: work with her to find the mysterious and legendary Book of Source, and she'll teach him alchemy. But a lot of strong alchemists will do whatever it takes to get their hands on the Book, and Ash is way out of his depth as feelings develop between himself and Ash, who has secrets of their own.

This story had so much potential. I just... couldn't vibe with it. I'm not sure this book knew quite what it wanted to be. Romantasy? A lot of the story focused on the romance to the detriment of everything else. Middle grade? Ash's actions are very... young. Illogical and childish to the point of being frustrating. Young adult? The plot felt like a solid YA plot, just sadly not fleshed out enough. New adult? Things got a little... spicy at times, which was oddly out of place compared to the behaviors of our lead. And the narrators were oddly chosen - while Ash was our lead character, we had weird moments of glimpses of other characters that seemed almost at random. Long periods of little action were followed by short bursts of plot that would devolve into nothing. And yet none of the major plot points were ever fully explained to satisfactory detail. For a mostly character-driven story, the characters' actions were... baffling. We watched Ash fall in love with first Ramsay (who treated him terribly) within the span of about two weeks, and then with another character (who was his captor and also untrustworthy) within another two weeks. And the plot itself took a backseat to the romance and love triange/poly love story that was taking place to the point that the ending was too hastily wrapped up and gave me whiplash.

It had so much potential, and I think it still does. It just didn't quite get there.

The author and the cover captivated me with Infinity Alchemist by Kacen Callender. I liked the LGBTQ representation in the book. The plot didn’t hold my attention and the pacing felt off. Thanks to Tor Teen and NetGalley for the ARC. I received an advance review copy for free and I am leaving this review voluntarily.

This was a great fantasy novel with amazing representation of LGBTQIA+ community.

It gave clarity to how teenagers and young adults sometimes have to work through their feelings to figure out what they want most in life. Ash, the main character, is different. You can see that, he talks about how he feels different, and he just wants to be acknowledged by a father who wasn't present and find family that will actually listen and support him.

Thorne, also looking for family, switches their gender back and forth, because they feel comfortable in both gender bodies, and trying to prove themselves due to their upbringing, with parents who committed the most heinous crimes, and ruining their name. No one wants to associate with a Thorne. But with determination, and showing that you can atone for your loved ones, no matter the time between the crime and atonement, you'll also learn that you can find yourself at the same time.

Review:
Alchemy is a crime but that won’t stop Ash from learning it in secret. When Ash is caught by Ramsay Thorne, he is sure he will be arrested for practicing Alchemy but instead Ramsay makes Ash an offer, help Ramsay find the Book of Source.

Their mission becomes more dangerous than ever when feelings for each other grow. The journey takes them through cities and into the wild, grappling with formidable alchemists making Ash unearth his own power.

I liked the characters, both Ash and Ramsay were incredible characters. At first Ramsay Thorne was kind of annoying but I soon grew to love her character. I loved to see the LGBT representation. I thought the characters were fully developed and flushed out.


Thank you to Tor Publishing and NetGalley for this e-copy for my honest opinions.

Infinity Alchemist by Kacen Callendar was a fun YA fantasy. I liked the characters and the world building. There were many times that I wished there was an explanation of how things worked so I could truly get swept up in this magical system and world. It wasn't a terrible deficit, however, but would have been an added bonus. I'm a Star Wars fan so every time "The Source" was mentioned my brain automatically thought of "The Force," which led to many mental redirects on my part. The pacing was good throughout most of the story, but then the ending felt rushed, obvious and easily solved. Overall, it was a good book.

Unfortunately, this is a DNF for me. I just can't get into it. I don't care about Ash and what happens. The world isn't interesting, and the characters aren't either. I really wanted to like this book because the queer representation is great. I've also seen others really like Callender's other book, so I went into this hopeful. In the end, this just isn't for me.

INFINITY ALCHEMIST was, overall, a very fun YA fantasy book. I really liked the three central characters (Ash, Ramsay, and Callum), and what a sweet throuple they are. The character building was far superior to the world building in my opinion. The magic in this universe was a bit confusing for me, and the constant references to the "source" (especially when used in place of a swear word) got old after a while. I almost wish all of the magical adventure had been tossed out the window in favor of Ash, Ramsay, and Callum sitting around arguing and drinking tea together. I want to hang out with them some more! I look forward to doing so in the sequel that I hope will come out.

Thank you to NetGalley and TOR for the ARC.

⭐⭐⭐⭐
Contains closed door romance

In the world of Infinity Alchemist, practicing unlicensed alchemy is a punishable offense. This story follows Ash Woods, who wants nothing more than to be a licensed alchemist. One day he's caught by shunned alchemist, Ramsay Thorne doing just that. Ash is recruited by the former to assist at locating the mythical Book of Source in exchange for Ramsay not reporting him and teaching him alchemy. Though they are hunted by those who wish use the book for nefarious reasons along the way, a romance unfolds with new and old.

I've been seeing other reviews say the pacing was not their favorite but I thought it was fine. The writing style reminded me of Lessons of Chemistry, but the story gave Grishaverse and Ninth House vibes.

The romance between Ash, Ramsay, and Callum was just so sweet. It was new for me to read such a fleshed out LGBTQIA+ and polyamorous romance and characters in a YA novel no less. The MCs gender and sexuality were really well written, and handled in a way where it was not confusing to read on the page. Not that I mind the "touch the MC and die" vibes I get from reading my why choose RH OV books but it's nice to read compersion which is opposite of jealousy.

The last 90% did feel a little rushed but I was also strangely transported back to the last philosophy class I took lol. It does have a HEA but a minor cliffhanger so it'll be interesting to see where the story goes.

Overall, I enjoyed it and will definitely be checking Kacen Callender's contemporary works too.

Thank you Netgalley for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

I really wanted to love this book, but I just couldn't. The queer representation in the book is amazing and I'm so happy to see more of that showing up in books.

Now I don't think this is a bad book, it was just not for me. I didn't really enjoy the main character so it was hard to keep going when I wasn't invested in them. The book's pacing was a little odd to me. The plot was going very slow then it just hits you all at once. Then the romance went from nothing to 100 in no time.

I am a bit sad, I have to be honest. I was so pumped for this book, I loved Felix Ever After by the same author so I got excited for Kacen Callender's new YA fantasy. Sadly I struggled with the first half of this book and even considered dropping it, but I am happy that I finished because I did end up enjoying it.

The magic system is a bit underdeveloped, but I loved how organic it feels. It had a really strong Full Metal Alchemist and I am all for it. The world-building was quite fun and complex, playing with a lot of themes of classism and the elite being on top while your common guy doesn´t have a lot of choices.

“Energy is infinite, and love is energy, so love has the potential to be infinite too” 

The cherry on top and the reason I pushed through was the queer representation. Love triangles that end up in polyamory is one of my favorite tropes, and on top of that we have enemies to lovers, friends to lovers, and second-chance romance, which was amazingly done. I loved that Ramsay got the time to be mad and process his feelings before forgiving Callum, even if all the relationships felt a bit rushed.

This was one of my biggest complaints with the story, Ash falls very quickly for both Ramsay and Callum, and they for him in return. everything happens in the span of a few weeks and while Ramsay and Ash have some time spent together, connecting their spirits, Callum decides to trust Ash after exactly one day.

A lot is happening and I would have loved for the book to be actually split into at least two stories and give the relationships more time to develop, and the plot more space to grow, it felt quite rushed by the end. I am still on the fence if I will continue with this series (I was not aware it was a series until halfway through), but this has a pretty closed ending that works as a standalone in my opinion.

Thank you NetGalley and Tor Publishing Group for providing an ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Ash Woods (he/him) loves alchemy but there’s one problem, he doesn’t have an alchemy license. When he tries and fails to secure his spot at an alchemic institute, he does the next best thing and applies to work as a groundskeeper. When he’s caught illegally practicing alchemy on campus, Ash is forced onto a quest which not only changes his life, but the future of alchemy forever.

This was a very unique novel and I’m having a hard time deciding how I feel about it. The magic system and world-building were very intricate and at times a bit confusing, but very unususl and interesting. There’s much to be expanded on for sure.

The characters definitely acted their age which I appreciated. They’re flawed and real and I love that. Also, the diverse representation in race and gender expression is amazing. We have trans rep, we have gender fluid rep and we have poly rep.

There was some pacing issues that kind of made some things feel drawn out and others rushed. If it was a smidgen more balanced I believe I would’ve been sucked in a bit more.

Overall, this was an extremely unique read with strong characters and great representation, all while touching complex societal issues. I personally didn’t connect with this one as much as I hoped, but it was an interesting read nonetheless.

Big thanks to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for providing me with this ARC.

Infinity Alchemist was such a refreshing take on YA fantasy.

It is set in a world where alchemy (magic) exists, but only the elite are invited to learn it.

Our main protagonist, Ash (he/him), is unfortunately not amongst this elite. As such, he takes a job as a groundskeeper at a Mage College. He ends up studying alchemy in secret with the help of Ramsay (she/her/he/him) in exchange for helping her search for the legendary Book of Source (think like, the Holy Grail, but for magic users), which essentially provides unlimited power to its user. Through their quest for the Book, Ash and Ramsay develop feelings for each other and go through some truly intense trials/battles.

This book features trans, genderfluid, queer, and polyamorous characters of color in a way that I have never seen done so seamlessly. All of these elements are important to the characters/storyline, but they aren’t the sole focus of the book. Also, despite the fact that there are systems of oppression presented in the book, those systems were not tied to sexuality/gender identity, which….honestly? Thank Glob. FINALLY.

This book definitely needs to find its way into the hands of more readers. There’s a rad magic system, a lot of action, and just a hint of spice (like not even a full 🌶️, it’s YA, y’all). I absolutely loved this book, and I’ve rated it 4.75 stars (rounded up to 5)!

Thank you to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for an ARC of this book in exchange for my honest review.

I have a deep love for Felix Ever After, it was one of my favorite contemporaries back in 2021. When I saw the author was publishing a fantasy novel I was over the moon. I love fantasy and I love this author, it was looking like a win-win situation. The plot and themes had me intrigued from the beginning, I went in with high hopes. Those high hopes got squashed a little bit.

I want to say the queer representation was incredible. I adored that from start to finish, Kacen never disappoints with the representation in their books. The ideas and themes were something I did like, it was just the execution that felt very lacking.

I am going to try not to be too negative, I was just bummed that I found more things that I didn’t like than I did like. The pacing, world building, development of characters and relationships were lacking. World building is so crucial in fantasy and when that isn’t fully developed things are more likely not to come together. I barely understood the world in Infinity Alchemist, it felt all over the place. You got tidbits of the world throughout the book and it didn’t feel cohesive at all it was more like afterthoughts.

The conversations and inner monologues felt repetitive constantly. I was waiting to learn knew things but it was the same thing 9/10 times. Some of the characters I’m still confused as to why they had focus on them when they brought nothing to the table. Tobin for example, I know the idea of why he was there but it felt unnecessary to have as much as focus as he had on him in the beginning.

Overall, pretty much everything felt surface level and that was also a big factor in why I was struggling throughout the book. I wanted more of pretty much everything. The potential is very much there and I wish I was able to enjoy what was present more. I hope others enjoy this book, it just wasn’t for me.

a fun, genderfluid poly young adult fantasy about ash woods, an aspiring alchemist rejected from the mage's college where he would learn the craft. after taking a groundskeeper job at the school & forced to learn alchemy in secret, he meets ramsay thorne, who decides to teach ash what she knows in exchange for help finding the 'book of source', a sacred text that gives the reader power. this book is an adventure from beginning to end, and i loved the representation of queer nb poly characters. ultimately this book read a bit too young for me, and was a bit longer than necessary to pack a punch.

Rating:
⭐️⭐️⭐️.5
.
Genre:
Romantasy
.
Tropes:
Found family, enemies to lovers, not a trope but polyamory
.
Main Concepts:
Ash lives in Hedge and works as a groundkeeper all while holding on to a secret that could get him killed. He’s practicing illegal alchemy. Ramsey discovers his secret and uses it to his/her advantage. The two team up together to find the Book of Source. Lots of little twists and turns to go along with their journey.
.
Favorite Scenes:
1.) Ramsey and Ash practicing alchemy to reach the higher realms. Lots of character/relationship building going on in the moments that I enjoyed.
2.) Callum being so sweet to Ash with making sure Ash is wearing enough clothes in the cold and preparing his meals.
3.) Ramsey going grocery shopping?!
4.) Ramsey, Callum, Ash sharing a bed for the first time.
5.) Ramsey, Callum, Ash saying goodbye when Ash went to find the book.
.
World building:
Okay, so this is where my 3.5 rating really comes into play. The world building was honestly really fricken confusing to begin. Everything was kind of all over the place and I specifically remember a chapter that was in the past but we didn’t get any warning or header indicating the entire chapter was in the past. That just really confused me for about a chapter and a half.

Now I do really like the elements of magic in this world, I do just feel like things could have been a little bit more organized.
.
Spice level:
1/5. Doesn’t really have detailed smut scene, kinda just fade to black but definitely has some adult explanation of character bodies.
.
Overall thoughts:
So, I did struggle to get into this book at first with how the writing tends to be a little all over the place. Some chapters have a lot of jumps and you don’t really know it’s a jump right away. I do also feel like somethings were just over explained or way too detailed. I did want to DNF in the beginning but I am glad I pushed through.

The magic or alchemy aspect of the book is a really cool concept and I liked getting all the details about the different tiers of alchemy and how each House uses alchemy or does not.

I do think that this book handles aspects like pronouns, sexuality, and identity very well. Ash seems to be trans and Ramsey identifies with she/he pronouns depending on the day. The author has Ramsey as a character switching between male/female and readers can tell what gender Ramsey associates the most with that day with Ash’s use of pronouns. I just think that’s pretty awesome tbh and haven’t had a single book like that thus far. There is also polyamory included in this book and the author does go into detail on the different emotions like jealousy, feelings of not being loved, and confusion about going into a polyamory relationship. I really enjoyed this aspect of the book as well. Ramsey, Ash and Callum are just so perfect for each other, they all three really balance each other out.

Overall, I do recommend this book because of the neat concept with alchemy, the representation of pronouns and the representation of polyamory relationships. The author handled all of these themes very well and I am excited to see what comes next for these three. The cliffhanger at the end has also got me pretty interested in what journey they will be going on next because I know it’s going to be a wild ride.