Cover Image: The Shelter (A Fiona MacLeish Crime Thriller Book 3)

The Shelter (A Fiona MacLeish Crime Thriller Book 3)

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

The Shelter is book three in the Fiona MacLeish series. In this book she finds herself in a storm at the Scottish Highlands with a group of hikers and another murder case. A case that starts out has an accident but clearly there is a killer in the group. But who is it?

I love a story that is set in a good snow storm. Personally I am not a fan of snow at all. It’s cold and it’s dangerous. And I would rather stay in the house where I’m safe. But this isn’t the case at all for Fiona. When we follow a locked room who dun it story. Smith makes you feel right there in the story and sets the scene perfectly with his cold crisp descriptions. Making you feel right there in the story.

I couldn’t put it down and read it in a day. The Shelter is full of twists and turns and will having you guessing until the end. It will certainly keep you on the edge of your seat with all the tension.

For me the first two books are tasters of what’s to come and then Smith throws everything into The Shelter making this one the best in the series. I absolutely loved everything about it……this book is a must read.

Was this review helpful?

A Fiona MacLeish Crime Thriller.
This is the 3rd book in this series. I have previously ready books 1 and 2 and enjoyed them. ~This thriller was no different. Really an enjoyable read.
If there is one thing I could certainly say about the writing of this book is that the author certainly knows what the readers want.
Thrilling and exciting. This read will keep you on the edge the whole way thorough.
I do feel a little sorry for Fiona as she always seems to be in the thick of things, why can't she just enjoy a couple of days off. Does she attract trouble. Maybe it's just because she's so good at what she does.
Out for a hike (maybe a book club would be less stress for Fiona) With Friends Fiona stumbles upon another group of people in trouble. Set in the Scottish mountains this thriller sets off at pace and holds it the whole way through.
Bravo G N Smith, and Bookouture this was an absolute pleasure to read and more so being able to read the three books back to back.
Will certainly keep you entertained, get stuck in to reading these 3 books.

The Flood
The Island
The Shelter

Was this review helpful?

Fast paced, full of tension and a real page turner. Left me on the edge of my seat and kept me guessing, incorrectly, all the way through

Was this review helpful?

Just as stellar as the other books in this series, I couldn't put this book down. Sure to keep you guessing until the very end, this is one book I won't be forgetting any time soon.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this! It has a lot of twists and turns and is quick paced. It's very atmospheric and is written where you feel as if you're right there with the characters which was awesome! I would recommend this! Special Thank You to G.N. Smith, Bookouture and NetGalley for allowing me to read a complimentary copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The third book in the Fiona MacLeish series set in Scotland finds her on a mountain in dangerous conditions with a group of people with secrets; after a sudden death, she realises it wasn't an accident and again finds herself in danger as she tries to discover the guilty party. The atmospheric and menacing setting is immersive, and introspection gives way to adrenaline-fueled action as the story progresses. I like the page-turning suspense, the untamed setting and the immersive investigation.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher.

Was this review helpful?

While I haven't read the first two books in the Fiona MacLeish series, I'm planning to now! This book is a great winter mystery -- a scream on a snowstormy day begins this mystery. G.N. Smith has some great characterization and really makes a page turner. I'll definitely check out the first two books!

Was this review helpful?

Love this book and this series. Enjoyed this one so much. tense, brilliantly plotted. a real pleasure to read. i whizzed through it in one sitting. Very highly recommend this series and especially this book.

Was this review helpful?

I was not too keen on this book to start off with, stuck upon a mountain in the snow , Fiona (the policewoman) decides that a man has been murdered. When going either up or down the mountain is deemed too dangerous, the group shelter in a shepherds cottage. Hoping to get help, Fiona and others start to make their way down the mountain. Not once, but twice. There are a couple more deaths .
Besides the foolhardiness of being on a Munroe mountain in the depths of winter , with less than optimal physical condition, the drawn out thoughts of what Fiona determined had happened, based on feelings and little physical evidence did not really make for exciting reading. However after the half way mark, there was more action and the pace picked up. My interest was aroused and I enjoyed the last third of the book .
Thanks to Net Galley for the ARC. A mixed bag for me .

Was this review helpful?

A good solid thriller but Fiona Macleish find herself in the same position as the last two book. Good characters with an isolation plot with a killer amongst them. I received this book from Bookoutre and Netgalley for a review.

Was this review helpful?

Police woman Fiona MacLeish is having a bit of downtime. Along with her friend Donna & Jack Donna's husband they are climbing a Monroe near Loch Fyne. However on the way down, the weather looks like it is taking a turn for the worst. They meet up with another group of 'Monroe Baggers' when there is a yell as someone falls - & meets his death. The other group are all connected with an upmarket hotel. The faller is the owner. As weather shows no sign of improving the group head towards a bothy. Fiona discovers that the victim didn't fall- he was murdered & once again she finds herself cut off by the weather with a killer in their midst.

The author does an amazing job at creating the setting for these stories. I felt I needed to put on an extra jumper! I have enjoyed the previous two books in the series but I found Fiona being in the same situation a third time a bit herd to accept. The whodunnit bit kept me guessing though! I would like to read more about Fiona but I think she needs a change of format now.

Thanks for Netgalley & the publisher for letting me read & review this book.

Was this review helpful?

The Shelter is the third book in the Fiona MacLeish crime series and I am really loving this series. This one has a great setting and interesting characters who all seem to be full of secrets and lies. It can be read as a stand alone book but I recommend reading the previous books as they were also so good.

Thank you to NetGalley and Bookouture for my ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This is the third book in the Fiona MacLeish series and I think it’s the best one yet, I’ll tell time why below.

This is one is the perfect book to read during the winter months, it’s so atmospheric, you’ll want to head to a snowy Scottish mountain asap or maybe not after you’ve read it but I certainly did.

It’s the same format as the previous ones, Fiona is alone and is the only law enforcement when a murder is committed, she’s got no back up and is isolated on a mountain, she has to use all her skills to painstakingly uncover the truth and I just loved uncovering the truth right alongside Fiona.

I hope we get more and more of this series and more people get to love it as much as I do.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Bookouture for inviting me to be part of the Books on Tour for "The Shelter"
by G.N. Smith. This is the third book in the Fiona MacLeish series. I highly recommend reading the books in order because you will enjoy this series.
Fiona is hiking with her best friend when someone gets murdered. It looks like an accident, but things aren't always what they seem.
This book will have you flipping the pages so fast to see what happens. Many thanks to the author, Bookouture and NetGalley for a complimentary copy of the book. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
#TheShelter #GNSmith#NetGalley #NetGalley
#Bookouture #BooksOnTour #BookLove
#BooksSetInScotland #Bookstagram #NewBook
#ILoveBooks

Was this review helpful?

Police officer Fiona MacLeish is hiking with friends when suddenly the weather changes and they run into another group of hikers. Strange things are happening people are disappearing, getting injured and sick. Can Fiona catch the culprit before it is too late? This is the third book of the series but I believe it can be easily read as a standalone. Once again I was in awe of Fiona and her detective skills. The settings are beautiful a isolated cabin in a snowstorm and are described vividly. The incidents kept me trying to guess what would happen next and I could feel the tension throughout. I also could feel the fear of not knowing what would happen. I felt my heart racing the whole time. A book that you don't want to miss!

Was this review helpful?

The Shelter is book 3 in the Fiona MacLeish. The remote Scottish moutains take center stage as a group of hikers get caught in a blizzard. Someone is murdered - who in the group is a killer?
While hiding out in a shelter, Fiona must figure out what is going on.
Locked space, small group, suspense driven - will keep you up!

Was this review helpful?

The Shelter is the third in the Fiona MacLeish series. It's a series that I've been on board with from book one and I would definitely recommend you give them all a read. Although saying that it can read as a standalone, but for further context...don't miss out!

Set in Scotland, you knew things were going to get bumpy when snow was mentioned. Can you imagine being trapped in a snowstorm, in a shelter, atop a mountain, with a killer on the loose?

It's a slow starter that builds up into a pacey thriller as the heat hots up and it's time to catch a killer.

Having previously enjoyed the last two books I'm enjoying the character development in MacLeish and am already anticipating book four.

Thrilling, compelling and full of suspense, The Shelter is definitely one to recommend and G.N. Smith an author to look out for.

Was this review helpful?

Our Fiona MacLeish was back! We knew when she’s here, which meant someone was in trouble.

A huge snowstorm was hitting the Scottish highlands, not only a scream caught Fiona interest, also a person in a group missing. Lucky enough, Fiona and the group of hikers stayed in the shelter. Fiona asked questions, until she realised everyone was hiding secrets. The murderer was among them.

I was always drawn into the theme of isolated place with a group of people, a body and loads of secrets. It kept me guessing who’s lying and why. The relationships among these people needed to be untangled.

Fiona MacLeish was one of my favourite fictional characters. Strong, brave and intelligent. Could not wait to have more cases solved by her.

Was this review helpful?

“Fiona had three thoughts all of which arrived together. … Fiona’s third thought was the one to pierce her psyche with the precision of a surgeon’s scalpel; not again. Twice in the past year Fiona had been trapped in a solitary location by freakish weather, and on both of those occasions a murderer had been among the people isolated alongside her.”

My thanks to Bookouture for an eARC via NetGalley of ‘The Shelter’ by G.N. Smith. I was also invited to take part in the publication week blog tour.

This is Book 3 in the Fiona MacLeish series of crime thrillers.

Police officer Fiona MacLeish is on a mountain hike in the Scottish Highlands with her long time friends Donna and Jack. Then the weather quickly turns as a blizzard is on its way. They decide to head down the mountain, passing a group of six hikers. Shortly after a scream cuts through the air and turning Jo sees that only five hikers remain as one of their party has fallen off the path!

On the way down the slope to attend to the critically injured man, Fiona finds evidence that it was no accident. Yet who would do this and why? With nightfall approaching and the snowstorm increasing, the two groups of hikers only just make it to a nearby stone hut that has been outfitted as an emergency shelter. Two other hikers are waiting there, both associated with the larger group of hikers, thus adding to Jo’s suspect pool.

Concerned that one of the group is a potential murderer, Fiona shifts into investigative mode while concealing her role as a police officer. She questions the hikers, unearthing secrets along the way. Then another attack occurs, removing all doubt that there is a dangerous killer in their midst. No further details to avoid spoilers.

As the quote above demonstrates PC Fiona MacLeish is quite aware that she has again found herself in an isolated location during extreme weather conditions with a murderer about. She is still not a detective as due to previous trauma, she panics in exam situations and so hasn’t been able to sit the required Detective Exam.

With that ‘not again’ at least Fiona (and by extension the author) is aware that this is the third time that she’s found herself in this kind of situation. If I were her I might decide to stay at home unless it’s a bright sunny day with no mega storms, floods, gales, or blizzards in the forecast.
Maybe the universe is trying to tell her something?

Fiona’s inner dialogue certainly is brimming with anxiety almost to the point of paranoia as she suspects pretty much everyone is the guilty party poised to kosh her or knock her down the mountain. Only Donna escapes suspicion as she was standing next to Fiona when she had heard the scream.

As with the previous two novels G. N. Smith creates a powerful sense of the ferocity of the weather and how it affects his characters and their environs. There was also the claustrophobia experienced as the group squeezes into the small hut with the snowstorm howling around them. Every time anyone went outside, I was reaching for an extra jumper.

Overall, I found ‘The Shelter’ an engaging mystery that was enjoyable. I certainly wasn’t able to figure out whodunnit before the final denouement.

However, I do hope that ‘three’s the charm’ and that if the series continues Fiona MacLeish won’t be faced with further singlehanded sleuthing in such extreme weather conditions. The woman deserves a break though I would suggest avoiding tropical islands during hurricane season….

Was this review helpful?

This book was not for me. I could not find any empathy for the FMC, Fiona. Her constant paranoia was draining. She was suspicious of everyone without any valid reason other than her conjectures. It felt like she was jumping at shadows which didn’t inspire any confidence in me about her capabilities as an investigator.

Was this review helpful?