Cover Image: Undiplomatic

Undiplomatic

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I found this piece to be exceptionally well-crafted, and I'm eagerly anticipating the opportunity to delve into more works by this author. Given its potential popularity among our library patrons, we're certainly looking forward to adding it to our collection

Was this review helpful?

Before I was asked to review an advance reader copy (ARC) of Deesha Dyer's book, I was not familiar with her. However, I can fully relate to the kind of attitude that propels us into situations where we must either sink or swim—an attitude Dyer embodies. Her story is truly inspiring. I particularly enjoyed reading about her time in the White House, which provided candid insights into its inner workings as well as her life before and immediately after her tenure there. Dyer's narrative was both enlightening and entertaining. Her writing style vividly brings her experiences to life, allowing readers to live vicariously through her words.

One aspect of the book that resonated with me was her treatment of impostor syndrome. Although she only briefly touches on the topic, the discussion was sufficient to convey her feelings effectively. It's common for readers to expect exhaustive revelations in such memoirs, but I appreciate that Dyer balanced sharing with discretion.

Additionally, Dyer's exploration of the need for personal boundaries in relationships was particularly impactful. She emphasizes the crucial stage of recognizing and enforcing these boundaries—a lesson vital for all, but especially resonant for Black women, who may not always realize its importance. Her proactive steps in seeking both a personal trainer and a therapist offer valuable lessons for young women who might benefit from similar professional guidance. Overall, Dyer's book is a great share.

Thank you to Legacy Lit for the opportunity to read and share my thoughts relating to this book.

Was this review helpful?

Deesha Dyer's Undiplomatic takes the audience along with her as she works her way from Philly to an internship with the White House all the way to Social Secretary in the Obama administration, while examining the all-too familiar feeling of imposter syndrome.

Overall, I really enjoyed Undiplomatic. Dyer has a clear, very engaging voice that makes it easy to fly through the novel itself. She never loses her integrity throughout it, opening herself up to vulnerable moments and memories. She doesn't shy away either from her own negative traits, instead calling herself out for what they are and why she acted a certain why—but also taking a critical look at where these ideas come from.

It was a bit more self-help-y than I personally realized, which threw me off. This isn't a slight on the memoir itself, but I did find myself taken aback at the amount of advice that was given, until I realized the billing also included self-help.

I think my only critique is that I wanted Dyer to stay a bit more in the pocket of certain memories. She has a beautiful way of reflecting but there were chapters that felt a bit rushed or glossed over. There's so much that she briefly references—especially when discussing how she worked to over come the imposter syndrome—but I felt like we needed a bit more extrapolation and explanation.

There were also a few grammar/editing errors, but I assume those will be cleaned up by the release date.

Overall, I did really enjoy Undiplomatic! I just felt like there were missed opportunities to really dig deeper into the memoir.

Was this review helpful?

I had the privilege of experiencing one of Deesha's speaking engagements at a fundraising conference in Philadelphia a few years ago. She was engaging, funny, and honest. Her speech touched on imposter syndrome (the common denominator of this memoir) but what I remember most is her unconventional path towards a life of public service. I was working for an HIV-focused non-profit at the time and her journey began as an HIV community activist. I remember her saying during the presentation that "'Social impact' is the new gentrified term for doing what you're supposed to do." Amen.

This memoir is different. It focuses on her internal struggle with imposter syndrome, self-worth, and people-pleasing--to the point of sacrificing her own health at times. It is honest, well-written and immensely relatable, despite her not-at-all traditional career. If you can relate to those internal struggles, this book is for you--it's nice to feel seen. Also, if you are interested in politics, the inner-workings of D.C., and the Obama family, it's a great fit for you, too!

My only critique is I feel that there were parts of her story that were missing. By the end, Deesha mentions she's put in a lot of work and therapy hours in overcoming her struggles. However, I would have liked to see that journey as well. Especially since the thesis of the book is an immensely relatable topic.

I am grateful for the free ARC Kindle copy that was provided to me by NetGalley and Legacy Lit. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Undiplomatic by Deesha Dyer is truly the story of an "underdog". I say that lightly with all the intention to mean that it does not matter where you start, you just need to start to get to the place that is your wildest dreams. I so appreciated this narrative work, I related so much in being from Philly myself and just feeling out of place in a lot of rooms that I have been in so far in my life. It takes courage and perserverance to stay there not only to show others that you can handle the "hard" things but to prove it to yourself to in the midst of imposter syndrome especially as a black woman in America. Thank you for sharing your story Deesha and I am sad to say I was not aware of you and your work as social secretary while you held the position, but am grateful that you made the choice to share your story. Thank you to NetGalley and Hachette Publishing Group for this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

"Learning to be yourself isn't easy because our selves are constantly shifting as we evolve."

This memoir is a beautiful blend of personal anecdotes, some sweet, some bitter, and some bittersweet; that feels like an older sister giving you advice based off what she already knows.

The reflection and introspection throughout Deesha's lived experiences make you feel like you know her personally while reading only fragments of her story. I felt like a long lost friend getting caught up over lunch.

Was this review helpful?

my review:
thank you to net galley and deesha for the opportunity to read this arc.

this was such a dope and beautiful memoir to read. one thing that really stuck to me was the topic of imposter syndrome. something that i catch myself dealing with at times.

it was really great seeing someone like her, who i can relate to in different ways, get such a huge opportunity like being an intern for the white house. also her realness was something i enjoyed in the book, because yes girl we love the authenticity!

i may not know her personally, but reading this i feel like she could be one of my friends and i love that. i’m so damn proud of what she accomplished and was her own boss afterwards.

also look how bomb the cover is????😍

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book. I was interested in it because I thought hearing about inside the White House stories would be fascinating but it was so much more. It was an extremely candid and inspiring adventure of an amazing woman. One particular quote really hit me hard. So much so that I wrote it down for future inspiration. I would recommend this book to anyone who's ever felt less than, unworthy or not enough.

Was this review helpful?

This book was a pleasant surprise - I’ve been wanting to read more nonfiction in 2024, especially by Black authors.

I was surprised by how relatable this book was - although we come from different walks of life, I related deeply to the imposter syndrome and putting your career first. I loved learning more about the Obama administration and how she tackled her position. This book is definitely geared toward young Black professional women, but I think many readers can gain something from
this memoir.

Was this review helpful?

A well written, thoughtful memoir by Deesha Dyer, the Obamas’ last social secretary. We all have built in biases, as did Deesha, and assume that all White House interns fit a certain mold, including attending a top-tier university. Deesha had no credentials, connections, or a college degree. What she had was the grit to apply to be an intern at the age of 31, which started her career in the White House. Even as she moved up the ladder, she suffered from “imposter syndrome.” That voice in her head kept telling her she didn’t deserve to be there, which made her only work harder to prove herself. Eventually, after many years, she comes to realize that she must put herself first and that her career does not define who she is.

The memoir is easily readable and relatable. The author is very frank and writes like she speaks, someone from Philadelphia, which might offend some readers. I think many of us suffer from “imposter syndrome” at some point in our lives. The memoir does not delve very deeply into politics, but is more a story about Deesha, from childhood until the present. I think the book is truly inspirational, especially for young African American women, but really for anyone who feels they don’t belong or aren’t good enough.

While it was interesting to learn what a social secretary’s duties are, the book glossed quickly over some other areas. My biggest concern is for Ms. Dyer herself, who seemed to put her work duties above everything else, to the detriment of her health. That might have been due to her “imposter syndrome,” but I hope she has learned a better work/life balance.

Thank you to NetGalley for providing an eARC in exchange for my honest review. I requested this book to learn more about how someone with Ms. Dyer’s background could rise to such a powerful position. On that, the book delivered.

Was this review helpful?

I give the book 4.5 stars. I received this book from Netgalley in exchange for a fair review. I am a huge Obama fan, so I was excited to read this book. I had never heard of Deesha but the story sounded amazing. I was really hooked on Deesha's story.

The author's story was so relatable to me. I am a white woman but could really relate to her imposter syndrome. I was, also, hooked on how amazing this woman was before even going to the white house.

The book was part self help and her story. I felt her rooting for the reader by carefully telling her story. Her story was very authentic and real.

The book covers everything that has happened to the world in the last decade. She talks about Obama, Trump, covid, Black Lives Matter, and more. It brought me back to everything we, as a society, has gone through recently.

It's a book that has a happy ending. She goes through a lot ( if are honest, most of us have gone through a lot too). She encouraged us to take care of ourselves in all ways.

The books target audience is probably young black women. I loved the book. I think there is something for everyone in this book. I can't wait to read her next book.

Was this review helpful?

This was a good read! I loved Deesha’s story, and the look into her life leading up to her time in the White House as well as the inner workings of what she did there. She has a unique voice that pulled me in and made me want to keep reading.

In a way, this book left me wanting more. It felt like a very high-level overview of her life, and I wanted more details of just about everything—from her time at MHS to the actual work she did at the White House. At the same time, I didn’t feel like I learned much about impostor syndrome—either how it affected her or how to overcome it. Rather than diving into how certain situations made her feel, it was a “welp, that was my impostor syndrome” and she’d move on to the next thing. I would have liked a deeper look, to see how she really felt about it and how she pushed through to eventually overcome it. It would go a long way in helping people understand their own and work through those limiting beliefs to get to the point she was at at the end of the book—not letting it hurt her mindset and hold her back.

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

gorgeous 5star read. a memoir by a very impressive person. thanks so much for the ARC! i especially loved the later sections of this one.

Was this review helpful?