Cover Image: Manga Classics: Great Expectations

Manga Classics: Great Expectations

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I'm loving reading these manga classics! This one, like the others I've read are true to their novel counterpart. Enjoyable!

Was this review helpful?

So lovely and dark and moving. I loved more the adaptation of "Jane Eyre", just to make an example, but objectively, this one, based on Dickens's "Great Expectation", probably is technically superior.

Recommended, just as I recommend all the other adaptations UDON Entertainment has published so far.

Was this review helpful?

I received a copy of Manga Classics: Great Expectations from NetGalley in exchange for a fair and honest review.

I love the concept of Manga Classics; I just can’t say that enough. Not only is the artwork beautiful, but it makes classics such as Great Expectations more approachable for so many readers. I’m steadily working my way through all the Manga Classics I can get my hands on; regardless of whether or not I’ve read the original versions. I sincerely hope Udon Entertainment continues to publish these works, as they’re just absolutely beautiful and brilliant.
I remember laboring my way through this beast of a book back in middle school. And I was one of the only kids in my class to actually finish the book (as opposed to pretending they did and hoping for the best). I can’t imagine how much something like Manga Classics would have helped back then. While there have always been ways to sneak around actually reading a classic, most of those methods will only give you facts, not an idea for the feel of the book or the manner of its characters. Manga Classics bridges that gap, allowing for a shorter (and sometimes more pleasant read) while keeping true to the story, characters, and intents the author has established.
Great Expectations is one of those stories that’s basically been begging for an adaptation like this, I just never realized it until I read the manga version. Suddenly I found myself reading the core of the plot, getting right to the vital points of the story. A lot of the verbal descriptions were cut from the book (to make it fit of course) but the artwork more than makes up for that. Most of the images contain the intended details anyway, so there’s no real loss when one looks at it like that.
I greatly enjoyed reading through Great Expectations for the second time, and found myself finishing it in only a couple of sittings. This is the perfect adaptation for anybody that’s either wanted to read the original but hasn’t, or has wanted to reread it again but can’t see to find the time.

Was this review helpful?

Whenever I visit a bookstore, I always check the classics book corner and the story of Great Expectations always catch my eye. I want to purchase a copy but what's holding me is that aside that it's thick – the size of the font is quite small – which made it hard to read. Thanks to this graphic novel, I've finally read the beautiful and poignant story of this classic.

Was this review helpful?

This is a fantastic rendition of Charles Dickens story Great Expectations. The artist did a beautiful job capturing every character's emotions as well as beautiful scenery.

The story is about a young boy named Pip who is being raised by his sister and her husband Joe, a blacksmith. Pup is never happy with what he has and only seeks to better his education so he can be a gentleman one day. He falls into many misfortunes and favors.

I really enjoyed how the author reworded this story and was pleasantly happy with the ending.

Copy given by NetGalley & publisher for a fair & honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Manga is such a fun way to revisit these classic stories. Also the graphics are gorgeous!

Was this review helpful?

I couldn't clearly wrap my head around why the title is the title. I blame it on my lack of comprehension. Classic works just have too deep a meaning most of the time.

I would've ranted with the way the story ended if I hadn't done further research. Turns out the end is just as vague and letting the readers come up with their own conclusion. It broke my heart when Biggy married Joe but they both deserve to be happy. I was also happy when Estella finally became a human person with feelings and no longer a cold, heartless living robot.

Gave it four stars because I wasn't really all over it. Maybe I'm an Austen fan rather than a Charles since I'm a die hard romance fan.

Once again these Manga Classic adaptations are truly helpful.

Was this review helpful?

While I love the Manga Classics line as a whole, Great Expectations may be one of my favorite thus far. I have to admit I have never read the original novel, but I followed the story perfectly with this adaptation and I really appreciate that. The art in Great Expectations is particularly nice and fits the story well.

Was this review helpful?

Some scenes felt a bit jumpy, but overall the graphics were great! I love seeing these classic novels being turned into manga!

Was this review helpful?

I didn't know about this story beforehand, which was kind of great. I got to experience this as anyone else, and with a fresh perspective!

I really enjoyed this story, much to my surprise. I've always been hesitant to read any Charles Dickens. The art was pretty great, also! I would recommend this to anyone wanting to try either classics or manga!

Was this review helpful?

The rich are different, and not better, than the poor. More timely than ever!

Charles Dickens classic novel, Great Expectations, is reformatted into a manga. The result is an excellent way to convince teens to read a classic tale.

Great Expectations is the story of Pip, a pleasant helpful child, who is thrown into high society in the early 1800s. Young Pip is randomly called to entertain and assist rich, old and crazy Miss Havisham. There he falls in love with her stepdaughter, Estella, and even more with the idea of being a gentleman. Once old enough Pip becomes an apprentice blacksmith under his brother-in-law. But greater adventures await Pip as he receives news that an anonymous benefactor is paying for him to become a London gentleman. He has Great Expectations now.

Personally I have tried slogging through the original 500 page novel and never made it even 10% in. This graphic novel makes reading the plot entertaining and faster though it is also over 300 pages long. The artwork makes keeping the multitude of characters easily recognized.

I chose this version of Great Expectations because I have great memories of reading Classics Illustrated comics when I was a child. This manga gives the exact same feeling of making a great story accessible to modern readers. Great Expectations, the manga, is highly recommended for students who want more entertainment and enjoyment than simply reading the wiki. It is also recommended for adult readers who have always been curious about Dickens' story but don't want to invest 10+ hours to read the book.

Thanks to the publisher, Udon, and netgalley for a copy of the book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Udon Entertainment and Net Galley for giving me a chance to review this book. This is my honest opinion.

This is the second book I've read in the Manga Classics series. The first being The Scarlet letter, which I reviewed previously. I'm a fan! I have read The original Great Expectations and I think they did a lovely job adapting it to a manga format. The art was how I'd expected. It reminded me how much I enjoyed the original book. I think it would be great for teens and young adults who enjoy the visual format of manga. Hopefully it would be inspire them to read the original.

Was this review helpful?

If you have read Great Expectations by Charles Dickens then you know what this book is about. And if you haven’t read it, then you still probably know what this is about. I enjoyed reading this and it was an interesting format to give me a good change of pace. If you haven’t read this well loved classic because you either tried and couldn’t get into it or this doesn’t seem like your type of read, then I recommend giving the Manga version a try. The pictures give it a whole other level to the story

Was this review helpful?

If any of you love Dickens please stand up and buy this comic on the spot. It is both accurate and thoughtful as a visual rendition of one of Charles Dickens's best known novels. So my warnings are not against the manga, but against Dickens and this novel in particular.

This novel has all gothic elements of Christmas Carol without delivering and end with a real hope of a better future for the main character. Little Pip is redeemed from penury thanks to a good deed he did to a convict, but fails to see past appearances and as a poor judge of character fails at understanding what is really best for him beyond nice clothes, gentlemanly manners and a life of general comfort. He thus loses what was probably his only real chance at genuine mutual love to an illusion, the infatuation for a girl who has been brought up not to believe in love and to deceive men to her personal benefit by the very grotesque character of Miss Havisham, an old lady clad in white who had her heart broken by a rake as a young lady. The connections between the characters are revealed during the novel, but Pip fails to see the truth until it is presented to him on a gilded plate, thus putting his life in danger more than once. His last meeting with Estella has the bitter-sweet taste of the realisation of precious things lost forever and I am grateful that this manga does not make any attempt to let the reader believe there can be anything other than forgiveness, but not a second chance, in Pip's and Estella's future.

In conclusion, if you are already familiar with this novel, you will enjoy the artwork and script, if you are not, make sure you are ready for a tale with no real happily ever after, at least for the main character.

Was this review helpful?

I've never really liked this story, but reading it as a manga was definitely better! Seeing Pip as a manga character, and being able to read his expressions, brought the story to life for me. I also appreciated that the story is condensed and clear, making it easy to follow what is going on.

The best part is seeing all the characters, both good guys and villains, strongly reflected in the beautiful artwork. Joe has an angelic face, peaceful and kindly in every circumstance. Miss Havisham is old and gaunt and ghastly. And Pip's face is innocent and wishful. The brilliant thing about the artwork is that their whole character is written in their faces!

I enjoyed this manga adaptation, even reading a story that I originally didn't like when I read it as a novel! That is the power of manga, I guess! It softened the story to a place where I could enjoy it.

Disclaimer: I received an ecopy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley, in exchange for a free and honest review. All the opinions stated here are my own true thoughts, and are not influenced by anyone.

Was this review helpful?

Like Pride and Prejudice, this is a fantastic introduction to the classic for learners at the K-12 level. The manga adaptation makes it both accessible and appealing for a younger audience. I would absolutely adopt this text for the classroom.

Was this review helpful?

Remember using CliffNotes or SparkNotes in high school? Sometimes for books you hadn't read? (I know I wasn't the only one. Sorry, The Iliad.)

Imagining what my book report would have looked like if I had used this adaptation as my source for Great Expectations (I did read that one, though) is kinda hilarious. This manga is entertaining and a good way to review the novel in a quickly digestible format, but only if you have some idea of the plot beforehand.

It's been about twelve years since I read GE so I only have brief impressions left of it now. I know that the plot is cray... Miss Havisham wears an old wedding dress... an
d Pip is in love with Estella for God knows why. According to the manga, I remembered it correctly. But it also helped me to remember other important plot points - so, hey, success! The story is all over the place, but so is the source, so I commend Stacy King for keeping all of the storylines together.

Like with Pride and Prejudice, I enjoyed the art for the most part. It's not particularly memorable... In fact, the only parts I remember are the not-so-great panels combined with awkward writing. (See right.) Miss Havisham looked a little too similar to a Sailor Moon villain at times.

Manga Classics: Great Expectations is a good review and teaching tool, especially when trying to make the classics accessible to different audiences.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed reading Pip's story in manga form and tried to remember as much of the book as well. All the characters were portrayed very nicely.

Was this review helpful?

Classics in manga form are always fantastic. I love to read any classic that's made into a manga.

Was this review helpful?

I've read a few of these Manga Classics and this was another great adaptation. It is the first one that I've read without reading the original first, but I'm familiar with the basic plot. It told the story with clear artistic differentiation between all of the characters, and I enjoyed all of the artwork. I highly recommend this and the other books in this collection for people who are interested in a succinct and beautiful graphic novelization of a classic story.

Was this review helpful?