Cover Image: Deadly Proof

Deadly Proof

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Kate became a plaintiff’s lawyer because she wants to help others in need but she soon finds that she can’t help or protect herself. She hires Landon and his company to help with some investigation work but her need for them continues to grow as her troubles mount. It was interesting to see how they interacted but I was a little disappointed that they didn’t deal much with computer forensics after that was highlighted as a skill set of the firm.

I was not, however, disappointed with the main story line. It was fascinating getting to look inside both camps’ war rooms. I learned more about the legal process and hope I never have to be a part of it. 🙂 I was not surprised to learn that the author was a litigator as the trial/case prep felt so authentic.

I loved the action, the suspense and the twists. I would recommend this book to anyone who likes legal thrillers.

Thank you to Bethany House for providing me with a free e-copy of this book. I was not required to leave a positive review. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I received an advance electronic copy of the book from Netgalley.

Other reviewers have provided synopses so I won't repeat their efforts here.

Overall, I enjoyed the plot, but I thought the budding romance budded far too quickly, especially between a devout believer and a prospective partner who had basically lost his faith. For me, this veers a little too close to unequal yoking. Also, a young lawyer working on the case of a lifetime hardly has time to get romantically involved with anyone.

I also felt like the protagonist never missed an opportunity to lob a "Christianese" platitude at a friend who might have been better served by a simple "Yeah, I hear you. Life can be tough." Especially when that friend has already been preached the gospel, and now it's a waiting game to see whether the seeds planted will take root or not. In my experience, those seeds are best watered with the gentle rain of observed example, not the "if you would just let God in, everything would be all right" hammering hailstorm.

Was this review helpful?

This is a fairly fast paced, well written, suspenseful legal thriller with a light touch of romance. The legal terms are well explained for those who aren't familiar with legalese and it was interesting that we got to read about both sides of the case. I think it added to the drama of the whole story line.

I liked how Kate had such a strong work ethic along with a compassionate heart for the people she is trying to get justice for. It is encouraging that in spite of her personal issues she keeps her faith and isn't afraid to share it. When the suspense and danger increase, former Army Ranger turned private investigator Landon James is the perfect hero to provide security and romance for Kate. In spite of his own personal struggles, he is a strong support for Kate.

Although this book is well written, I found the wording a little over-descriptive at times and I think personally, I just wasn't all that interested in the lawyer/legal process aspect of this book. But that's just my personal feelings. I do think it was well written and will be enjoyed by many who enjoy legal drama/thrillers.

*Thanks to Celebrate Lit for a complimentary copy of this book. I was not paid or required to write a positive review and all opinions stated are my own.*

Was this review helpful?

Oh. My. Goodness. This book was fantastic. First of all, the writing. Rachel Dylan is a gifted author, not doubt about that. Not only does she tell a wonderful story, but she shares her knowledge of the legal field in a way that we can all understand. Her depth of knowledge is amazing, and it just brings this added layer of appeal to the book. There were scenes that could have been totally confusing, but Ms. Dylan found a wonderful way to bring the talk to our level and understanding. I felt as if perhaps I was learning something about the legal field.

Then there’s the storyline itself. So interesting, full of suspense, a little romance, and the issue of right versus wrong. A few of these characters really had to dig deep and make some ethical choices. But isn’t that what we are faced with everyday? Much like the characters, you either choose good or bad. But on top of this was a message of God’s grace and forgiveness. Rachel Dylan is able to spread the gospel in such a way that is very inviting. I believe readers will thoroughly enjoy this, and maybe even come a little closer to the Lord because of it. Not one time did I feel the context of the gospel was out of place. It was all natural dialogue, and quite frankly the characters acted naturally in their responses as well. The truth is, we’re not all ready at the same time. We all move at our own pace when it comes to serving the Lord and returning to Him. This story was beautiful proof of that.

Dare I say there is a wonderful swoon worthy character? Landon James…..yes I could see him in future installments. I hope. He’s not only manly and rugged, he is loyal and trustworthy, and is quick to admit he is not perfect. Do I see a book boyfriend hashtag coming in the near future? Possibly. At any rate, he was for sure my favorite character. He had a lot of issues to sort out, but underneath all that was this really caring and generous man. I loved seeing his growth throughout the story.

This book will have you guessing. It will have you looking over your shoulder. It will certainly keep you turning the pages until you get to the very end, breath a sigh of relief that it’s over, and then cry because the characters have to go away for awhile. But…good news. There is a book two! Woohoo. I can’t wait 🙂

I received a complimentary copy of this book. I was not required to write a favorable review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Ms. Dylan’s new book, Deadly Proof, is a plot twisting story about a major civil lawsuit. Her writing is very descriptive especially in describing the legal aspects to this case. She provides the reader with the background to understand what occurs in the court of law of a civil case. Her detailed account of the case against Mason Pharmaceutical is superb. The leading character Kate Sullivan and her friendship with Landon offers the reader a romantic twist to this legal suspense novel. This is a Christian suspense book. Ms. Dylan’s does a superb job of including pertinent information of the characters’ lives that includes the status of their spiritual state. I thoroughly enjoyed reading Deadly Proof and highly recommend reading it. I have read some of Ms. Dylan’s past books and found this one to be just as well written as the others.
***I was given a free electronic copy of this book from the publisher to review. This is my honest opinion. Even though I received this copy free, I have purchased her books before.

Was this review helpful?

Kate is a strong woman, a really awesome leading lady/heroine. She's a lawyer, smart and driven. This book is a thriller and suspense as well as legal story. The Atlanta Justice series is off to an amazing start. I like that it has Atlanta, because I am familiar with the area. This book has a fast pace with a story that didn't let up. I read it much faster than I expected to. It didn't bog down in the legal parts, but instead, pulled me in rooting for Kate and James and for justice to be served. I enjoyed the strong Christian faith elements woven into this book as well. I would read another book in this series, with anticipation.

My copy came from Celebrate Lit. My review, thoughts and opinions are my own left of free will.

Was this review helpful?

I was really excited about this book. It’s got all the things I love. Suspense, intrigue, a bit of action (perhaps not enough but that’s just here or there), mystery, and a clean story-line. Romance is neither here nor there for me in these stories, sometimes I get burned out on happily ever after. Sometimes I just want real life. There I go sidetracking myself again! Brass tacks: team of lawyers lead by the indomitable Kate takes on a major pharmaceutical company in a class action lawsuit, Big Pharma doesn’t like their odds and may or may not have done some shady dealings in their drug testing, where’s the truth lie and who is trying to sabotage the case from within? My synopsis. Intrigued yet? You should be!

I have just have to say it. Sometimes the omission of something is a bright red flashing neon arrow pointing at it. This alone is what created the situation where I knew who the culprit was entirely too close to the beginning of the book. Don’t get me wrong, I loved the reveal, I loved how it carried throughout the story, but… Perhaps no one else caught this (or will catch this) and you are wondering if we read the same book. That’s OK. I realize that more often than not I pick up on things no one else does while missing glaringly obvious things that no one else misses. Welcome to Me-ness! The other things I need to address is the way faith was introduced into this book. I know, I know that’s almost a recurring theme for me … sometimes. Don’t count me out here. The way it was first introduced to the story wasn’t awkward at best and carried forward to a few more awkward interactions. By the time those conversations would have made more sense it wasn’t just awkwardly on the table already. It felt like ‘I need to get faith to the story so blam here ya go’.

That aside this book was intricately woven with twists and turns and missed exits and high speed action that created a story I didn’t want to put down. I didn’t care that I knew who did it, I still wanted to know how it ultimately got there. It didn’t matter that faith was awkward it still enhanced and added depth to the characters. I needed to know the outcome with this drug. I needed to know how the court case worked out. I even needed to know if they fell in love and stayed together. There was so much I needed to know. This book was well written and ticked off all the mystery/suspense/intrigue that I love in a great book. For that alone you need to read it.

I was provided a complimentary copy of this book by CelebrateLit, NetGalley. I was not compensated for this review and all thoughts and opinions expressed are my own. I was not required to write a positive review.

Was this review helpful?

In this novel, a young idealistic lawyer takes on the jaded villains of a giant pharmaceutical company that will stop at nothing--including murder--in its efforts to block a mass tort action where consumers of a leading drug are injured on a large scale by the drug's side effects. I was delighted to find a legal thriller that contained a high degree of suspense. I cared about the characters, who were believable and well-drawn out. Although I generally prefer a bit more action than romance in the novels I read, I enjoyed the balance between the two. The legal backdrop struck me as accurate, and I might only wish that there had been more courtroom scenes.

Was this review helpful?

Kate Sullivan had no idea what she was getting herself into when she took on the Mason Pharmaceutical (MPC) litigation! Sure, she knew it was big; thousands of cases had been filed on behalf of victims who had died or been injured taking their migraine drug, and as lead counsel, she was determined to get the justice they deserved. But was she really prepared for just how far someone would go to make sure the truth never came to light?

The key to unlocking this case for Kate is in the discovery phase, so there’s not a lot of court action in this novel. If she can find proof in the documents produced by MPC that they were aware of potentially harmful side effects, it will blow the case right open, and so that’s what she’s focused on. But that’s exactly what Ethan Black, Kate’s long-time friend and opposing counsel on behalf of MPC, doesn’t want to see happen, and he’s under a lot of pressure from the CEO of MPC to make sure any ‘hot’ documents, as they’re referred to, don’t end up in Kate’s hands.

I really enjoyed the legal side of this story, and in this respect, it’s obvious Rachel Dylan knows her stuff. Explanations of the legal process were worked naturally into the story where necessary, which meant that the reader was able to follow what was going on without getting bamboozled by legalese. We also got to experience the legal process as it played out from both sides of the case—Kate’s determination to get justice on behalf of her clients, and Ethan’s increasing struggle against the ethical dilemmas he faces, which was great for the tension.

The disappointment for me was that I didn’t really connect with these characters as well as I wanted to. I felt as though the distinction between Kate, the uber-ethical lawyer focused on achieving justice, and Ethan, the ambitious lawyer looking for wealth and prestige, was overemphasised to the point where they became one dimensional, and Landon wasn't really developed beyond your 'standard' ex-military character. I would have liked to have felt more of an emotional connection between Kate and Landon, too.

Nevertheless, those who enjoy a solid legal suspense with a hint of romance will find this a satisfying read.

I received a copy of this novel from the publisher. This has not influenced the content of my review, which is my honest and unbiased opinion.

Was this review helpful?

What a fast-paced thriller! Deadly Proof may keep you guessing all the way to the end. The characters are realistic and flawed. The female lead is a workaholic lawyer struggling with depression. Dylan makes you care about Kate and her struggles. Read it!

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoy reading legal thrillers and while Christian Suspense is not a genre I have ever read before I was intrigued by the description of this book. I'm glad I took the time to read it, which actually took very little time as I didn't want to put it down! The connection to a case involving big Pharma was also of interest to me. If you have any interest in legal thrillers and getting an inside view of how lawyers prepare for cases then I think you will enjoy this book!

Was this review helpful?

I am never disappointed in Rachel's suspense filled books. This was a intriguing read. Just when I thought I had it figured it out I would read something that left me "Whoa, where did that come from?" And I love that in a book. Within this book you will find crime, murder, theft, suspicions, struggles of all kinds, hustling to make one's mark in society, danger and always being on guard because one doesn't know who can be trusted. The past comes forth to be faced, memories flood places that shatters the hope that no one find out about the past lives of the characters. Be prepared-you'll be surprised at the ending. I totally was, it was great!

Blessings,
Karen Hadley
Rating: 5*
I received this book as a gift and all opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/2135584127

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this novel of high stakes litigation. I had no idea the huge teams legal firms put together for a big case. The amount of work that needs to be done is mind boggling. In this novel, our heroine, Kate, is lead counsel in a case against a huge pharmaceutical company. In the discovery phase of the work, her teams has to go through tens of thousands of documents.

I liked Kate. She really has a heart for those she is representing. People had suffered greatly from the side effects of a drug for migraines. Some had died from tumors believed to be caused by the drug. But as Kate pursues the case, problems arise. A potential informant is killed. Kate's life is threatened. She is sure the attorney's across the aisle are hiding damaging material. And then it seems someone in her own office is sabotaging her work.

This novel could well represent a story from today's headlines. There is big money in pharmaceuticals and the drive for profit might cause some to do unethical acts. There is big money for the lawyers too and they are tempted to cross the ethical line.

This novel has a good balance of character development, legal procedure, suspenseful action, and a hint of romance. There is also a good message about forgiving one's self for mistakes done in the past, accepting God's forgiveness too.

I received a complimentary egalley of this book from the publisher. My comments are an independent and honest review.

Was this review helpful?

"Deadly Proof" is a Christian legal suspense novel. There was some romance as well, but that consisted of a few scenes where they told each other about painful events in their pasts. While there was some danger to Kate, Landon and Kate believed that the bad guys were just trying to scare her. Due to the threat not apparently being deadly, it added some suspense, but not a lot. The other two viewpoint characters underwent more obvious pressure as they were dealing with high stakes and being pressured into legal wrongdoing. Most of the suspense came from developments in the case--trying to prevent information from getting out on one side and trying to find proof of what they suspect on the other.

While I liked the main characters, I didn't feel engaged by Kate and Landon at an emotional level. Too much of the character development involved being told what the person was like, not actually seeing it. For example, we're told that Kate struggled with depression and also pride, but we never see that struggle. But we do see that Kate is a nice balance of tough but kind, independent but willing to accept advice and help from others. Still, I felt more emotionally engaged by the other two viewpoint characters.

Landon felt guilty about a war experience and felt that God didn't care about him. The Christian element was prayer for help plus Kate helping Landon heal and come back to God. There was no sex or bad language. Overall, I'd recommend this novel.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this.The faith aspect was handled well and not preachy,I connected with the characters especially Kate and it was mostly engaging. I would have loved to see more of Landon and Kate's relationship and the ending was anti-climatic but it was enjoyable over all.

I wouldn't re visit this book but I was engaged while I was reading.
3 1/2 stars

Was this review helpful?

This is legal thriller that doesn't have the typical cursing or violence that is characteristic of this genre. The legal case in the story is interesting but what makes the book enjoyable are the characters that Dylan has created. Kate is an attorney who is tough and accomplished but also full of heart. What I really enjoyed was the way Dylan wove the redemption of God into the story. The way she shared the Christian faith was the strongest part of the story.

Additionally, the supporting characters were not only likable but they are introduced in a way that the readers knows their story will be told later.

Was this review helpful?

As a person with a degree in paralegal studies, I found this book to be very interesting. It contained more legal terms than some "legal" thrillers which made it more engaging to me. I liked the main character and how she stuck to her principles and remained true to her relationship with Christ while also pointing others to Him. This is a great legal read - would highly recommend for fans of John Grisham and anyone who enjoys reading books centered around a legal case.

Was this review helpful?

This is book one of the Atlanta Justice series. I look forward to reading more in this series, if they are as good as this one. This is a fast paced mystery full of legal issues, friendship, romance and more.

Kate Sullivan is a good hearted woman just trying to find justice for those who have suffered. When she is placed in the biggest role in her carrier against a huge pharmaceutical company she is determined to find justice for her clients, no matter what. Kate must rely on the handsome PI for more than just background issues. When her life is in jeopardy, will she back out or get stronger.

Former Army Ranger, Landon James, is now the handsome PI. When Kate starts to take down so many walls he has built will he rise to the challenge or is his past more than he can overcome.

I loved the mystery and suspense in this book. The dialogue is well written and the characters are well developed. I look forward to reading more from this group of people.

Was this review helpful?

This book was SO good!! I could not put it down! I am sure that this will be a great series. Legal thriller written by an real-life litigation and trial lawyer which makes the book more real. Lots of legal details especially in the courtroom and they are well-written and easy to understand. Fast=paced story line with lots of twists kept me guessing until the end. Kate Sullivan is the lead attorney investigating a case for a large pharmaceutical company. She is great character, driven and also a Christian which is something new that I really loved about this book. There are not many strong Christian women characters, at least in books that I have read, so that was something refreshingly new and different. Kate enlists the help of PI Landon James, hired to help find more evidence which adds romance and more intrigue to the story. Lots of action and a steady pace kept the story on track and mesmerizing. I really enjoyed this book and look forward to more from the same author! Great legal thriller!! Thanks NetGalley for the ARC!!

Was this review helpful?