Cover Image: The Hazel Wood

The Hazel Wood

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

There are a good number of negative reviews out there for this, but I liked it. I thought it would be similar to The Book of Lost Things (one of my favorite books), with its protagonist descending into a fairytale world more Grimm than Disney. It definitely had a lot of those same creepy vibes, but this was more Alice in Wonderland than Coraline. Regardless I was very much along for the ride.

Some of the language was a bit flowery, but as someone who tends to gets really annoyed by that, I actually didn't think it was that bad. It wasn't the best writing I've ever read, but it certainly didn't reach The Star-Touched Queen levels of purple prose.

Alice was unlikable at first, but not all female heroines need to be likable. And her personality is part of the overall mystery, which had some twists I wasn't expecting. I also enjoyed Finch's character, but wish the rest of the gang had more distinct personality traits. We barely scratch the surface on the other Hinterland characters!

The best parts by far were the interstitial fairytale stories. I would 100% read a copy of Tales from the Hinterland.

Was this review helpful?

I kept putting off reading this book, though I couldn't put my finger on what was turning me off. Once I started the book, I enjoyed the premise; a reclusive grandmother who is a fantasy author with a cult following but whose books are surprisingly difficult to find is basically a massive "read me" sign that calls out to bibliophiles everywhere.
I really wish this book had stopped halfway through. I think that the realism portion at the beginning is great, and I could see myself enjoying the more fantastic ending, but I was so tired by the time that the magic really got going that I couldn't get into it. This means that I really rushed through the ending just to be done, which is never a good way to read a book.

I received an egalley of this book in exchange for an unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

This was a good one. Ella and Alice are constantly on the run, trying to escape the fairy tales that are pursuing them. These are not nice fairy tales. It's sort of creepy and dangerous and I thought it was really well done. The tales seem to be unique (or at least I had never heard any of them) which is also pretty impressive. Fairy tale themes tend to get recycled and to encounter new ones was refreshing. I also quite enjoy dark and twisty, so it's getting extra props for that. If you like fairy tales, definitely give this a go.

Was this review helpful?

I loved The Hazel Wood. It was charming, enthralling, and a wonderful read! I continue to recommend it to new and experienced readers and have received great feedback!

Was this review helpful?

This dark and intense story gives a fairytale feel, more like Grimm’s than Disney movies. The darkness and mood of the story are it’s dexond bigger appeal, with the world the story takes place in being a big draw.

Was this review helpful?

The Hazel Wood is a dark urban fantasy following Alice Crewe, a somewhat bitchy and self-centered teenager who has traveled all over the country with her mom, Ella, trying to escape the evils that follow. Some will describe this as a delicious, dark and cold burning fantasy and I have to say I don't agree.

The book wasn't poorly written but it didn't hold my attention throughout. The story seemed like it was being turned in every which direction and it was hard for me to understand where it was exactly going, especially towards the end. It was too much in such a short time span. Too much time leading up to The Hinterland and so little time actually being there.

I appreciated the point of Alice not having a secure home life, constantly moving from place to place, seeing as how most teenagers in YA do have a secure home life. It was a good change for me to read. On topic of Alice, she is one of the hardest characters to relate to that I've ever read. There were so many points in the book where I thought I was about to show her empathy but then Alice decides to ruin it by being rude to someone. I understand there are reasons for this behavior (no spoilers, I promise) but it was still hard for me to like her. 

Overall, I understand this is a unpopular opinion but this book wasn't my favorite. I can see why people do love it so I do recommend it for those who love dark fantasies...just go in with low expectations.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book and decided it was perfect for addition to our collection.
The magical element combined with the spookiness should be a big hit with my readers.

Was this review helpful?

I have a lot of mixed feelings about The Hazel Wood. I think there were elements I was so happy to see and feel, but then there were so many things that I didn’t enjoy and left a sour taste in my mouth.
What I absolutely loved about this book was the elements of magic mixed into the modern day world. That was done on point and in ways that made my heart sing. There is one scene in the beginning where Alice returns to her apartment and it’s so full of magic you can smell it. The level of intensity in this scene reminds me just what suspense is in prose, but sadly this moment is one of the few that has any build to it.
One thing I will say The Hazel Wood brings to the table is the ability to suspend your disbelief. That is what fairytales and fiction are about after all, and what many are missing. For me, I like it when a world doesn’t explain itself; in fact, I prefer it that way. As a reader I find exposition to get in the way of story because an author feels the need to tell us about the world or make the world believable, and The Hazel Wood just throws you to the wolves and says have fun with it. This was the biggest satisfaction during my read, that the world felt genuine and real, like I could spot a character out in the street and not miss a step. In my notes I say something along the lines of it’s Stranger Things meets Alice in Wonderland, and it’s that level of belief in the world that makes The Hazel Wood hard for me to talk about.
The Hazel Wood is hard to review because of the last half of the book. It reaches a point where I felt like I was reading a completely different book. This is where the trigger warnings should come into play. This is where I got lost and never really came back. I’m all for dark atmosphere and aesthetics, but this got too dark, too absurd, for me to follow. And there is a “story within a story” element going on later in The Hazel Wood, but it wasn’t earned. I guess that’s where I have a problem; the pay off isn’t worth trudging through the slop of darkness and bogged down characters with no development and jumpy plot twists to make it worth my while to read. If The Hazel Wood read more like the first half of the book, I would have bought it. Unfortunately, it meanders down a path I can’t follow into a dark place that I don’t feel like exploring.
That’s about all I have to say on the subject. It had such high ambitions and was so close to achieving them, but The Hazel Wood fell in on itself before realizing and trying to dig itself out.

Was this review helpful?

This book was a hot mess... but in a good way. There were bits and pieces of it that were disjointed and rushed, but overall I found it a very creepily good read.

Was this review helpful?

The Hazel Wood wasn’t my favorite but I still really liked it. It took me forever to be in the mood to get into it, and once I did I enjoyed it from start to finish. I loved the fairy tale style more than the plot BUT I still ended up binging the book once I started it, reading it in one sitting.

Was this review helpful?

When THE HAZEL WOOD came across my path, it absolutely sounded like it was my kind of book. Fairy tales, but the dark side of them, blending into reality. What wasn't there for me to enjoy? Plus, the cover art is absolutely stunning. One hundred percent I was into this book. And I was delighted to find that it seemed to absolutely live up to every expectation I had.

...Yeah, you hear that "but" coming too, don't you?

Alice Crewe is the granddaughter of an author, named Althea Proserpine. (I think I'm spelling that right; unfortunately I ended up reading this as a library book, and my loan's expired.) This author is famous for having penned a book of rather dark fairy tales, and then locking herself away in her estate (the Hazel Wood) never to be seen again. Alica and her mother Ella (the fairy tale names are a bit thick here) live as nomads, never staying in one place for too long, since bad luck seems to follow them around. Alice takes this as normal...until one day, the world flips on its head and she begins to wonder what exactly her mother has been running from all this time. And perhaps more importantly, whether or not she ever should have been running. Maybe it's about time to meet this mystery grandmother, and read the tales she wasn't permitted to as a child.

All in all, the story is essentially predictable, but that's not a mark against it. There are only so many plots in the world, and only so many ways you can twist it to your will. The companion Alice meets on the way, the Althea Proserpine superfan Ellery, is a welcome addition, and a nice dose of both fanboy nature and reality check for Alice, who doesn't deal well with the former and hasn't really experience much of the latter in her life. The Hinterland--the place where all these fairy tales take place--is a fascinating concept, and I honestly wish we got the full proper stories of all the Tales from the Hinterland. But the reasoning behind Althea's reclusive nature and why it's always so hard to find a copy of Tales from the Hinterland is all detailed well, and leaves the reader with a comfortable knowledge of why we can only know so much.

What really let me down about the book, unfortunately, was the ending. It takes all the wonderful beginnings we saw...and leaves half of them unanswered and the others tossed aside for reasons unknown. The choice for Ellery's plot line equally baffles me and makes sense, though I feel like her was built up to be so much more of a character than he ended up being. The explanations of it all at the end seemed rushed, and never seemed to give a deep feeling for what was actually happening.

But here's the kicker, and this will have mild spoilers, so skip to the next paragraph if you don't want to know. ... At the beginning of the book, it's always the mantra of "Alice and Ella against the world." Nothing else gets to come in, nothing stays, it's just them. And that's all well and good...but at the end, nothing's changed. I mean, Alice herself certainly has, but it's still just Alice and Ella, with no one else. Can they start finding that life to settle into and find other people? Sure, but we don't see that far into the denouement as it were. We see mom and kid at the start, we see a thousand amazing potentials along the way, and they're all cast off by the end. It leaves me with a sour taste in my mouth, the bitter tang of wasted development potential. While I appreciate the choice not to hold tight to the teenage love story, Ellery's loss to the story comes just shy of making me feel like his role there was pointless. He was a tool, and when the tool was no longer needed, he was discarded. Ellery's a better character than that. Why else were we told so much about his family? To prove he was disposable? Eh.

In any case, it's still an enjoyable read that kept me up until close to 2 in the morning so that I could finish reading it, because I had to know how it ended. Even though it didn't live up to everything I'd hoped for, it's still definitely something I'd tell people to read if they found it on a shelf near them. I'd love to see what else the author has done, because she's got a nice way with words.

Rating: **** (Recommended)

Was this review helpful?

Alice and her mom Ella basically live like gypsies, moving from one place to the next, usually staying with a friend, until the bad luck catches up to them- making them "bad luck guests". After the death of her estranged Grandmother Althea, a woman Alice never met and Ella refuses to talk about, but has a strangely large cult following for her odd fairytale book, Ella decides they will settle down. And then Alice gets a new family of sorts with her stepfather and stepsister- both she barely tolerates for her mother's happiness, and it seems everything is peachy. That is until a man from Alice's past shows up and then Ella goes missing.

Everything about this book was odd and super creepy and I absolutely loved it! This was such an interesting adventure, with different types of "fairytales" and scariness and twists. I was so into this book, more so than any other than I have read recently. The mix of adventure, scariness and random dark humor filled my heart with joy and I found myself laughing at the most inappropriate of times. And ps mentioning crickets are creepy (which they are) made this book my soul sister.

"The air around her shivered and prismed like the heat over a blacktop. She was what I was looking for, the hot moving point at the center of this island of charged quiet. I watched her with a feeling I couldn’t name—fear or awe or recognition."

I read a review recently where someone compared this to Alice in Wonderland and I can totally see where that reviewer was are coming from, but I personally mean that in the best of ways- it was an epic, dangerous, crazy journey with some wonderfully strange encounters that I just ate up. I would gladly take another adventure in these same circumstances, no complaint.

The few stories recited from the Tales from the Hinterland were absolutely horrifying, amazing and I need to get my hands on them asap. They were just the way I like my fairytales, scary and surprising. No feel good fairy godmother here.

My one teeny tiny complaint with the story was that the ending felt a little anticlimactic, but as long as I know this is not the end end, I can pretend I am content. If this was a standalone (which is 100% what the ending felt like and I would have assumed so if I hadn't already seen on Goodreads there is another book for next year), I would have been really disappointed. I will try not to get too desperate while I (pretend to) patiently wait for more from the Hinterwoods. In case I was too subtle, I really loved this book.

Stop by and say hi at https://smadasbooksmack.blogspot.com/

Was this review helpful?

Though I liked the book, I made the decision when I finished not to review it on my site because it didn't fit into my editorial schedule. I may include it in a review post or possibly a book list post in the future.

Was this review helpful?

It reminds me of a fairy-tale version of The Thirteenth Tale in YA format. I did like the part about an alternate reality

Overall the novel strong start but weakened in the 2nd half The main character started out likeable but became less so throughout the duration of the book. Some of the character development started out better than it finished. I would read this author again but hope that she is able to carry the story at the same pace and quality from start to finish.

Was this review helpful?

In one word: this book felt Dark... Which is a growing trend in the Young Adult/Teen genre, so thank you to the Brothers Grimm for providing us with such incredible source material?

I definitely considered this one of those divisive 'LOVE it or HATE it' titles; which is rather ironic, since I find myself on the fence. Ultimately, I found the premise fascinating and truly appreciated the themes running throughout--family, loyalty, the fight to choose your own destiny and allow those around you the same choice. That said, it still left me feeling a little lost? Hollow? I cannot quite put my finger on it, but I just wanted a little more of...something. And I will be honest and I say that maybe with a reread my opinion and rating would lift a little because I am just that torn (and sometimes particularly stingy with my stars).

Ultimately I would still recommend this to anyone who loved the original fairy tales from Hans Christian Anderson and company. That aspect of the book was absolutely incredible and worth exploring! It was just not my favourite read.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book a lot!! Albert took the essential delight and longing we have for fairy tales and coupled it with things from the Brothers Grimm’s nightmares to give us this book. Spooky, gripping, vivid, the perfect dark fairy tale. Highly recommend. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Was this review helpful?

DNF
I loved the sound of the book and the cover completely drew me in. Going in, I was very excited. However, I struggled to connect to the writing. Therefore, I decided to set it aside.
Thank you to publisher for considering me for a review copy.

Was this review helpful?

The Hazel Wood is a solid book for a debut author. I loved Melissa Albert's world building and wish she had focused even more than she did on Althea's novel and the stories of the Hazel Wood which I found more compelling than that of her main character Alice. I hope she returns to this world in the future.

Was this review helpful?

Alice has lived a nomadic life until now. She and her mother forced to keep moving after they are stricken with bad luck circumstances everytime they stay in one place for too long. Finally, they are able to settle in New York City. Alice and her mother are living the life of luxury, for better or for worse, when their bad luck suddenly catches up with them. Alice's mother is stolen away and Alice is left to try to make sense of family herself and her family history.
Melissa Albert has created a stunningly original fantasy world where fairytales are real. Unfortunately the fairytales are not those of the princesses and ponies where the characters live happily ever after. Hinderland is more alike the original Grimm fairy tales of blood and gore. I would highly recommend this book and await the sequel with bated breath.

Was this review helpful?

I just had trouble getting through the book. It just did not hold my interest. I can see others enjoying the book. It’s not the first book I would recommend. I did enjoy the world the author created and the descriptions.

Was this review helpful?