Cover Image: The Emerald Circus

The Emerald Circus

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Jane Yolen is no stranger to short fiction. As one of the preeminent authors in the field of science fiction and fantasy, she's written over 300 books, including short stories and poetry. She also writes fiction and non-fiction picture books for kids. She's also been called the Aesop of the twentieth century by the New York Times and the Hans Christian Andersen of America by Newsweek--massive praise that she very much lives up to.

Honestly, I don’t know when Jane Yolen finds time to sleep but I'm selfishly glad she's been able to produce wonderful stories filled with deft turns of phrases, palpable atmosphere, and interesting, flawed characters.

Her forthcoming short story collection, The Emerald Circus, published by Tachyon, is another rich entry into Yolen's catalogue. Holly Black, author of Tithe and The Spiderwick Chronicles, provides a glowing introduction. Many of the stories featured in this collection have been published previously, while others are brand new. This collection also features an appendix where Yolen talks about her inspiration for each story and includes an accompanying poem. The poems were my favorite part of the collection, not only because they're beautifully written, but also because they enhance the story with which they're paired. I almost wish every short story collection were constructed this way, but I also realize that not every prose writer is a poet. Yolen happens to be excellent at both. (Another SFF author who executes both forms equally well is Theodora Goss.)

The Emerald Circus has a story for everyone. Yolen selects old tales and makes them new and surprising and yet instantly recognizable. The collection features a slate of disenfranchised Wendys (from Peter Pan); Guinevere, Lancelot, and Merlin of the Arthurian legends; Alice and company from the Wonderland stories; Dorothy and the gang before the big twister. These stories are also rich in atmosphere inspired by Yolen's travels, particularly "A Knot of Toads," which is spooky and moody and makes me want to move to Scotland immediately.

Yolen is also not shy about writing about historical and literary figures such as Hans Christian Andersen, Edgar Allan Poe, Emily Dickinson, Queen Victoria, and Benjamin Disraeli, and her perspective on their lives feels fresh while still remaining respectful. My favorite story in the collection is "Sister Emily's Lightship," which won the Nebula a few years ago. In this story, Emily Dickinson struggles with a new poem, hosts afternoon tea, and takes a spacefaring jaunt with an alien before finally completing her poem. The plot is relatively straightforward, but Emily feels both delicate and strong, and like someone I'd very much like to befriend, which makes the story sing.

I also enjoyed Yolen's post-Arthurian tale, "The Quiet Monk." Those of us who love the grandeur and glory of the Arthurian legends often rue the bitter betrayals that bring the tales to a close. Although we know that Arthur lies sleeping, waiting for that fabled moment England might need him again, the legend feels incomplete without much-needed absolution. "The Quiet Monk" addresses the mortal failings of Guinevere, Arthur, and Lancelot, and allows at least one character to seek much-needed redemption. After reading about Yolen's planned Arthurian anthologies in the appendix, I really hope some publisher decides to pick them up.

For lovers of fairy tales, folklore, and a cracking good yarn, I highly recommend The Emerald Circus.

The table of contents for The Emerald Circus is as follows:

Andersen’s Witch
Lost Girls (Nebula Award Winner)
Tough Alice
Blown Away
A Knot of Toads
The Quiet Monk
The Bird (Original story)
Belle Bloody Merciless Dame
Jewel in the Toad Queen’s Crown
A Gift of Magicians
Rabbit Hole
Our Lady of the Greenwood
The Confession of Brother Blaise
Wonder Land
Evian Steel
Sister Emily’s Lightship (Nebula Award Winner)

Thank you to NetGalley and Tachyon for providing an advance reading copy for review.

Was this review helpful?

The Emerald Circus is a collection of Jan Yolen's stories that have appeared in other anthologies or magazines first. But do no hold that against these stories. They needed to appear somewhere and it is very nice that they have been gathered here for the reader to enjoy. In the book are tales of adventure, trickery and magic woven into familiar stories that have been bent out of their normal shape. There is a tale of Beauty and the Beast after the end of the normal tale. Dorthy of Oz fame gets a backstory from one of the farmhands. There are a trio of Arthurian tales scattered through the book along with a young Hans Christian Anderson making deals while Emily Dickinson manages to take a very far trip. And one must not forget Alice or Wendy and their adventures. So if you enjoy good storytelling, sit your self down with your favorite beverages and snacks and settle in for an enjoyable read!

Was this review helpful?

For those not in the know, short stories have a habit of sending me into a bit of a reading slump but The Emerald Circus was such an interesting kaleidoscope of some of my favourite stories that I stayed interested throughout.

A lot of these feel a little like a writing prompt gone awry, not that it’s a bad thing, but you can see how ‘what if we combined Peter Pan and labour strikes?’ could turn into a great short story? (The Wendy plot has always been one of my least favourite plots in classical literature and annoys me because I love Peter Pan so fixing it was appreciated).

So yes, these are twists and turns on some of the most well known stories, The Wizard of Oz, Arthurian Legend, Alice in Wonderland and similar. Some of them, like Dorothy’s retelling, were strange and sinister in a great way, some of them worked less well and felt a little like a great idea executed in a mediocre fashion.

What I think is most important is that these stories will stir up your curiosity and will help you to see some of the more interesting elements of the original stories in a different light. Well worth a read, maybe one to keep on the bedside table when you’re burning the midnight oil?

My rating: 3/5 (I liked it, but I don’t think I need to reread it)

The Emerald Circus releases on the 14th of November so keep your eyes peeled!

By the way, I received a digital advanced review copy of this book from the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

The Emerald Circus by Jane Yolen is a collection of short stories with an introduction to the works done by author Holly Black. I do believe some of these by Yolen at least have been published before but I was not familiar with her work so the entire collection was new to me. I’m not a huge fan of short stories myself but when seeing this I realized that some of the collection included stories on some of my favorite stories such as Peter Pan, the Wizard of Oz and Alice in Wonderland so of course I had to check this one out.

Of course when all was said and done my favorites are the ones I was looking forward to reading although there were a few others within the book that I also quite enjoyed too. There were however a few stories that I wondered why they were even included as there didn’t seem to be much to them but perhaps someone that loves short stories overall would enjoy them more than myself who is always thinking were is the rest of this when it comes to short stories or books. I think though that regardless of being a huge fan of this type of read if you are interested in retellings and new twists on old classics then you’ll at least enjoy those stories.

I received an advance copy from the publisher via NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

I have mixed feelings about this book. In general I love Jane Yolen's writing especially her retellings. However, I had a hard time getting through this book. There are definitely stories that I liked such as Andersen's Witch, Lost Girls, Blown Away and The Bird to name a few. But there were others that just took me some time to get through like A Knot of Toads, Belle Bloody Merciless Dame, The Gift of the Magicians and Rabbit Hole. My favorite part of the book is actually the Author Notes and Poems at the end of the book where Jane explains the inspiration behind each of the stories and included a Poem for each as well. I would still recommend this to people who enjoy Jane Yolen's other works or retellings in general.

Was this review helpful?

[Disclaimer: I was provided a free e-copy of this book from NetGalley for review purposes.]

Jane Yolen has been a longtime favorite of mine. I guess you could say, a lifelong favorite of mine. I started reading her in middle school, I think (at least, that's the point at which I became aware of the authors of the books I enjoyed). Her Sister Light, Sister Dark trilogy, and the Jackaroo books are probably the ones I enjoyed the most. But in all my years of being a Yolenite, I've never actually read any of her short stories or poetry.

Jane Yolen has published over 300 books. And I have yet to find one that I don't enjoy. This collection of short stories, mostly published elsewhere before, were almost entirely "twists" on the traditional. The opening story about Hans Christian Andersen started the book off with a punch to the gut. I loved almost every story that followed. The one with the take on Red Riding Hood wasn't very interesting to me, and I wasn't sure exactly what to think of the one with all the frogs and witches (although I did enjoy it). I think my favorite of the bunch was the story about the island of women, where Guinevere gets her start. The story about the monk's confession did not immediately strike me as being about Merlin's birth because I'm not wholly versed in his mythology, but once that was explained (in the notes at the end - make sure you read those!), I liked it a whole heck of a lot more.

This was a quick read, as I find most short story collections to be. It is definitely one worth reading. I loved it! It's a little funny that this is being released this year, as I just re-read Sister Light, Sister Dark a few months ago. Up until then I hadn't read a Yolen book in years. It was sitting on the shelf in my bedroom staring at me, and so I picked it up and loved it all over again. Seeing this on the NetGalley roster brought back a flood of emotions. I was excited to read The Emerald Circus, and was not disappointed in the least.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you for the opportunity to read this book. I enjoyed it very much!

Was this review helpful?

This is a delightful collection of short stories based on some classic books from your childhood. From Wendy in Peter Pan to Dorothy in The Wizard of Oz we have a premise that starts with the original story and takes a strange turn. Most of the stories are great for all ages of readers. The fantasy element is the common thread that keeps you turning the pages.

Was this review helpful?

I will first give my praise to the cover art of this book, which is bright, eye-catching, and truly wonderful to look at! Some of my favourite reads of this year have been circus related, and whilst I knew that wasn't what this book was about, I couldn't help but be drawn to it nonetheless.

"The author has been called the Hans Christian Andersen of America and the Aesop of the twentieth century." - A Note from the Publisher

I certainly cannot argue with the above statement; her story telling is truly wonderful, and Jane's ability to weave our well-loved tales from childhood into something modern and in many cases, very funny and relatable, is really something to be admired! From all the stories I am certain we all know and love, Jane brings new tales; Andersen’s Witch, Lost Girls, Tough Alice, Blown Away, A Knot of Toads, The Quiet Monk, The Bird, Belle Bloody Merciless Dame, Jewel in the Toad Queen’s Crown, A Gift of Magicians, Rabbit Hole, Our Lady of the Greenwood, The Confession of Brother Blaise, Wonder Land, Evian Steel, and Sister Emily’s Lightship. I think from the list my favourite were Andersen's Witch, Blown Away, and Lady of Greenwood. Though I still very much enjoyed many of the others.

One problem for me that there were stories that I did not recognise, and I felt that you had to at least have an idea of the original in order to make sense of the retelling, though I am sure that many others will know and recognise all of these! For those which I did not know, I found it hard to stay motivated, particularly when they came one after another. But I am glad I stuck with it, since I did always come across another which I would thoroughly enjoy!

I would have also liked some of the stories to be a little longer, with more detail and storyline to them. But equally for some, the brevity worked well.

I would not discourage anyone from reading this book, it is well written, imaginative, and I think for people who love short stories, fables, and fairytales, this would be the perfect book. You don't even have to read it all in one go! Just have it sitting on your bedside table for that sneaky little bedtime read, one "chapter" = one story! Perfect for those of us who can't resist knowing what else happens when reading a regular novel!

My overall rating for this book is 3/5. I wasn't a huge fan of it, though there were elements I did enjoy. I cannot fault the writing, if at times a bit brief; but hey - it's a book of short stories. Although it wasn't for me, I would recommend it to you if you like retellings of tales, and especially those with a humourous or unexpected twist in places.

Was this review helpful?

I was really interested in this book when I heard about it, and there were some definite high points: “Evian Steel”, “The Confession of Brother Blaise”, and “The Quiet Monk” we’re particular favorites. None of the stories were bad, but some were definitely a slog to get through, despite my initial interest in them. The book was well written, but I just didn’t get into it like I thought I would. Still, a fun way to revisit some old fairy tales and fantasy stories.

Was this review helpful?

This story collection was really hit and miss. While I expect that from a story collection (they can't all be winners), I was disappointed to have that occur with a Jane Yolen collection. Anyone familiar with he'd knows she is one of the most consistent and solid authors in YA. She is a legend and rightfully so. That being said, some of these stories were excellent (her take on Beauty and the Beast meets Gift of the Magi was particularly fun), but most were either readable but forgettable or simply unreadable.

Was this review helpful?

I don't know what I was expecting when I went to read this story. The author intrigued me because I have read some of her other stories and absolutely loved them. I wasn't expecting a short story collection but I was not disappointed by this at all. Actually, I really really enjoyed that format., it fit perfectly with the atmosphere. There are so many different tales that there will be one (or more) for anyone!

If like retellings with twists you should really pick this book up!

Was this review helpful?

This collection of Jane Yolen's short stories was sometimes a hit, sometimes a miss, but introduced me to a new author I'll definitely be trying again. When I saw Holly Black wrote the intro for this, I knew this was someone I would love but had just not stumbled upon before.

Inspired by classic literature and folk stories, Yolen puts her spin on everything from Peter Pan to Alice in Wonderland. The great thing about this collection is that each story felt different from the last and it was fun to see where her next inspiration would come from. Beautifully written and engaging from start to finish, The Emerald Circus is perfect for anyone with a soft spot in their heart for fantastical spins on the classics. While I did prefer a few stories over others, this is a solid collection worth anyone's time.

Was this review helpful?

I'm a fan of Yolen, but I've found she doesn't re-read very well. That's a problem for a collection like this where there's only a couple of new stories. Luckily, I don't read a ton of multi-author anthologies, so I'd only read about 1/3 of the stories before.

If you haven't already read "Lost Girls", you should definitely find a collection that has it and this is as good as any! I loved that story the first time around, though it's anthologized so often I'm a bit tired of it by now.

A couple of my favorites were:

"Andersen's Witch", which is Hans Christian Andersen's life told as a fairy tale, as if it were the inspiration for his "The Snow Queen." It's a bit preachy in spots, but since HCA's work itself is a bit preachy, that works just fine.

"Blown Away", which is the titular story of the collection. It's <i>The Wizard of Oz</i>, but focusing on the family Dorothy left behind when she was blown away to the Emerald Circus.

"The Bird", which is a fun little tribute to Edgar Allan Poe.

Sadly, most of the rest of the stories seemed to be 3 star reads for me but, again, I don't find Yolen very re-readable and I remember liking several of these better the first time around. So if I were coming at these all from a new-to-Yolen perspective, that probably would have bumped it up to 4 stars.

You can check my status updates for individual story notes, though a couple of the last ones got misplaced.

-------

August 10, 2017 – Started Reading
August 10, 2017 –
12.0% "Andersen's Witch - Reprint, but I had not read this one before. 4 Stars - HCA's life, told as a fairy tale with him as Kay in the Snow Queen. A bit preachy in regards to love, but it's about HCA so preachiness is to be expected."
August 11, 2017 –
21.0% "Lost Girls - Reprint - I loved this story the first few times I read it, but it's one of Yolen's most often anthologized works and I'm rather tired of it by now. Skipping it this time around. However, if you've never read this one, it's well worth reading!"
August 11, 2017 –
24.0% "Tough Alice - Reprint - 3 Stars - I'm not a huge Alice fan to begin with, and this one isn't as interesting when you already know what's going on and what the message is. I liked it better the first time around, as I recall."
August 12, 2017 –
31.0% "Blown Away - Reprint, but I've never read this - 4 Stars - Dorothy, with "Oz" being a the Emerald Circus rather than the Emerald City. Focuses on her family rather than Dorothy herself, which was a neat change of perspective."
August 15, 2017 –
42.0% "Knot of Toads - Reprint, but I've never read this - 3 Stars - Decent enough story, but not that memorable. I was all set to give it 4 stars yesterday, but even just overnight it's lost some of its shine."
August 19, 2017 –
48.0% "Quiet Monk - Another reprint that I hadn't read - 3 Stars - Neat King Arthur story with a nugget of historical validity to it. In the notes Yolen mentions that she was planning a trilogy of stories in the vein of Merlin's Booke - one with King Arthur and one with Queen Guenivere. I'm quite disappointed this never came to pass! I really enjoyed Merlin's Booke!"
August 19, 2017 –
49.0% "The Bird - New- 4 Stars - really fun tribute to E.A. Poe"
August 22, 2017 –
65.0% "Belle Bloody Merciless Dame - Reread - 3 stars
Jewel in the Toad Queen's Crown - Never read, reprint - 3 Stars
Gift of the Magicians With Apologies to You Know Who - Reread - 3 Stars - Doesn't re-read very well
Rabit Hole - Never read, Reprint - 3 Stars
Our Lady of the Greenwood - Reprint, never read - 3 Stars"
August 22, 2017 –
71.0% "Confession of Brother Blaise - Reread - 3 Stars - I think this one works better within the context of Merlin's Booke."
Wonder Land /Evian Steel / Sister Emily’s Lightship - Last 3 story notes misplaced.

Was this review helpful?

This is an absolutely delightful collection of short stories by the masterful Jane Yolen. When I saw this on Netgalley I knew I had to read it, and read it I did! I cannot resist re-tellings, I just can't. Jane Yolen's BRIAR ROSE is to blame for this affliction of mine.

The stories in this collection run the gamut from Alice in Wonderland to Edgar Allen Poe. There is a good variety here, with a short and brutal retelling of Beauty and the Beast being followed by Arthurian legend. I think my favorite has to be Lost Girls. What an unabashedly feminist take on Neverland! Telling Dorthy's story from the POV of her family is sheer brilliance. And she was a circus performer?! Be still my beating heart.

I can't say enough good things about this collection. Maybe I was in the right frame of mind. Maybe it's just what I needed when I needed it, but I devoured this book. I will definitely be doing a re-read and a more in-depth review to post online closer to the release date.

Was this review helpful?

This is a mixed bag of stories, in all genres and styles, all combined by their (sometimes tenuous) links to original fairy tales, myths, and legends. These short retellings received a mixture of responses for me, with some being deceptively clever and poignantly written, to others falling short and feeling rather pointless. Whilst I enjoyed finding the myriad of original tales mentioned and did find this a well-written anthology, I wasn't sold on every one of the tales gathered within, and therefore could only give a mediocre star rating. This is, however, well-worth a read as some gems await to be discovered within.

Andersen’s Witch - 4/5 stars

This focuses on the son of a washerwoman and a shoemaker. Right from the very beginning this seemed to evoke the classic fairy tale vibe, even before the intermission of any magical disturbances. Discontent with his life of poverty and struggle young Hans makes a bargain with the Ice Maiden that will see his current position in life reversed as he ages. But making a deal with the Ice Maiden is fraught with difficulties and loop-holes, as Hans will soon find out for himself.

I enjoyed this tale but right up until the last few paragraphs wondered what the point of it all would be. Once the ending was revealed it completely changed the tone of the preceding writing and turned this into a joyful, lovely little piece.

This also showcased some truly lovely penmanship. Peppered with lovely expressions, such as “a low cloud cover, like a well-made bed, kept everything neat and tidy”, I was eager to carry on with this collection to see if the others would prove to be as captivating.

Lost Girls - 4/5 stars

From the title I had assumed this to be a Peter Pan retelling, but with switched genders for the young island inhabitants. The appearance of Captain Hook in the very first paragraph proved this assumption correct.

This revoked the darkness of the original Peter Pan tale, rather than retelling the Disney version, as Peter isn’t content with just one Wendy and has stolen a total of sixteen young girls to serve him and his horde of lost boys.

This is a modern feminist re-visioning of the Wendys’ fate. The expectations of the females to serve the males is accepted by all the previous Wendys, taken from throughout history and seen as figureheads of their individual time periods, but it takes the modern-day Wendy to inform them of the unfairness of this treatment. With new notions of gender equality invading their thoughts, the Wendy’s revolt! And through this political uprising the reader is made aware of the satirical and political edge to this tale, and a democratic community is created to replace the previously accepted dictatorship.

Tough Alice - 4/5 stars

The original Alice is one of my favourite books so I was eagerly anticipating reading this re-telling. I was initially disappointed,as the first portion of this was just a whistle-stop tour of the events from the original. That is, until the battle with the Jaberwock.

This felt most like a traditional fairy tale, as it was tinged with a moralistic edge that gave the events a wry feel. Despite its shortness this left the reader much to mull over and, again like the original tales, had an ageless and timeless appeal because of this.

Blown Away - 3/5 stars

This Wizard of Oz retelling began much like the original, only with Toto’s fate being decidedly less wholesome than in the original. Once the tornado hit Dorothy’s farm and she disappeared with the winds, this follows the lives of those left behind to mourn her.

When Dorothy returns she tells the story of what happened whilst she was far away. As part of the Emerald Circus, which this anthology is named after, she lived an extraordinary life before returning, seven years later, to her rural farm life. She changed the way the farm folk viewed their lives and inspired a yearn for otherness in some, or an acceptance of their lot in others. I found the ending of this as poignant as the others but it just missed out on the insightfulness the others seemed to achieve.

A Knot of Toads - 2/5 stars

This probably had the best title of the collection and, so, I was intrigued and excited to begin reading it.

It was easy to fall in love with a protagonist who loves books but the rest of the story kept me at a distance. For such a short piece there seemed too much preamble before the main point of the story. I also think the fantasy of the story is obvious to a reader who is aware of fables including amphibians. Once set up nothing happens for some time and I found this a dull addition to the anthology.

The Quiet Monk - 3/5 stars

The Quiet Monk has come to join the brotherhood and share the burden that haunts him. His mysterious past makes him the focus of much speculation and eagerness to learn what drove him to wandering and religion.

This brought some much needed diversity to the collection and, whilst I was not aware of any original tale it was based from, enjoyed the legends evoked in the piece. This was another slower paced story, like the last three, yet I thought it worked well in this instance.

The Bird - 4/5 stars

This begun with a hilarious anecdote of a bird who defecates wherever it lands. Its owner is at the end of his tether with his uncontrollable pet. But however negatively he feels towards it, he feels quite the opposite for Virginia. This object of his affections is brought to meet the bird but It ends up delivering far more than just amusement.

Despite the shortness of this piece it managed to deliver a surprise ending that belied the frivolity of its beginning. In a Gothic twist of events this managed to completely turn the tone of the tale around in just a few paragraphs.

Belle Bloody Merciless Dame - 3/5 stars

The reader is invited to feel nothing but dislike and distrust for the protagonist, who willingly cheats on his betrothed during his bachelor party. I adore stories with unlikable focal characters, so this immediately intrigued me. Before this even got started it seemed to end, however, which stunted my enjoyment.

The Jewel in the Toad Queen’s Crown - 3/5 stars

This follows on, in dual perspectives, from one discussions between two individuals - Disraeli and Queen Victoria. Whilst with a distinct magical twist, the basis for this story is authentic and an unlikely friendship did, in fact, form between the renowned duo.

This is a fascinating insight to the historical period detailed. Discussions of religion and belief dominate and form much of the text’s focus. Through these conversations a heartening relationship is formed and the reader is privy to its conception.

The Gift of the Magician’s - 2/5 stars

The note by the title exclaims ‘with apologies for You Know Who’, which evoked a link to Harry Potter, in my mind. Immediately, though, the reader is introduced to Belle and the Beast, which confused me, before this quickly transforming into an Alice in Wonderland retelling. There was too much going on in this one for me to understand any of it.

The Lady of the Greenwood - 4/5 stars

I believe this is my first ever Robin Hood retelling so I was intrigued with what I was going to discover. This begun nothing like the original tale and with no discernible links to it. A boy is born on the stroke of midnight and, with instructions from his now deceased mother, the midwife is to deliver him to the fae who reside in the forest. The woman’s journey through the glade is penned with a poetic beauty that made me feel the dappled moonlight and gentle stroke of leaves, as we made our way to the forest’s heart together. It also made me feel the creep of dread with what possibilities could lay in the shadows.

Despite enjoying this tale I wondered where the links to the renowned Robin Hood would come about. The reader is not provided with this information until the very last line. This, like the earlier pieces in this collection, used the withholding of information to the story’s power and made this a far stronger piece by doing so.

The Confession of Brother Blaise - 3/5 stars

This tale was set in the year 1125, in a monastery. A young girl falls pregnant within the confines of the monastery walls and claims it to be the product of a liaison that happened entirely inside her dreams. Despite the brothers of the monastery crying of the devil’s work, I could not help but to see links between this story and that of the biblical birth of Jesus. Whether that was the author’s intention or not, I can not say.

Was this review helpful?

This review will be posted on my blog, Foxes and Fairy Tales on 14 October 2017.
https://foxesfairytale.wordpress.com/2017/10/14/review-the-emerald-circus

I'd never heard of Jane Yolen before I picked up this book but the description as "the Hans Christian Anderson of children's literature" and the idea of quirky retellings had me sold.

The stories themselves were a bit more hit-and-miss. While there were none that were truly bad, I found some a little dull. On the other hand, there were several I really enjoyed. There's takes on Peter Pan, Robin Hood, Queen Victoria, Alice in Wonderland and Hans Christian Anderson himself. The top three I especially liked were:

Blown Away - I loved this take on The Wizard of Oz. Instead of Oz, Dorothy loses her memory when she is carried off by the tornado to a quirky circus. The 'voice' is so good in this and you can really feel that little Kansas town.

Evian Steel - On the Isle of Women, an order of female blacksmiths forge the very best blades. The future Guinevere struggles to create Excalibur. In the notes, Yolen says that she had ideas of this as the middle act of a novel or as a trilogy of novellas. I would definitely read that if she ever writes it.

The Gift of the Magician - A sort of old-fashioned 'story-with-a-moral' and full of atmosphere. Struggling for money, Beauty tries to find a Christmas present for the Beast.

Overall this collection was interesting, although some stories were better than others. It did intrigue me as to Yolen's other work though, and I think I'd look up some of her other stories.

Was this review helpful?

I like collections of short stories because when you are not in the mood or have the time to read a full length novel sometimes it’s nice to pick one of these up, blow through a quick story to pass the time and still feel like you achieved that satisfying ending. No lingering questions of what is going to happen, who did what, how is the author possibly going to make this all work, etc because you got all your answers in those few minutes you had to read – hence ‘short’ story.

Yolen kind of screwed me over with this one because I found her writing so intriguing and was absolutely captivated by her take on well-known fairytale and literary figures I couldn’t stop at just one or two I had to read through her whole collection including the poems and story notes at the end. If you know someone who likes fairytales, who is even a fan of Hans Christian Anderson, then you’re going to want to pick this up which luckily for you comes out before the Christmas holiday – there I just helped you mark an item off your list.

Yolen’s story notes with the poems at the end are worth it all by themselves to pick this up as you feel like you get to know her, as if she’s sitting with you by the fire one late wintry night spinning tales to enthrall and bemuse you. She is the epitome of what the title “storyteller” hopes to define.

I have never read anything by her before and more is the pity that I have missed out on years’ worth of being entertained by her talent. In the Irish culture from which my family comes the Storyteller, or SeanchaÍ, was held in high esteem. They kept the histories alive and were heavily relied on since they were the only way to keep them from getting lost. Yolen does a remarkable job of taking up the torch in spirit.

You get to relive stories and people from long ago in a whole new way such as Peter Pan, Wizard of Oz, Anderson’s Snow Queen, Alice in Wonderland, Edgar Allen Poe with his Raven, Robin Hood, legends from Arthur’s genre and nods to works from across time periods and cultures. Her work entertains certainly but it also leaves you feeling intellectually satisfied.

Was this review helpful?

Jane Yolen’s collection THE EMERALD CIRCUS is pure delight for anyone who craves inspired retellings of classics from literature, or re-imaginings of the lives of real literary figures. Yolen takes a slanted look at the lives of Emily Dickinson, Hans Christian Andersen, and Edgar Allen Poe, and she creates some stellar “what if” moments for Lancelot, Dorothy (from Oz), Alice (from Wonderland), and others. Yolen’s writing is beautiful, her pacing is perfect, and the way she takes stories that have been done over and over again in a whole new direction is sublime. My favorite part of the collection (if I have to choose just one) is her take on Peter Pan and Wendy’s story in which Peter and the Lost Boys are pretty contemptible, and the girls of Neverland exist only to serve them until… well, you should read it and find out.

It’s rare to find a short story collection that doesn’t contain at least one “meh” story, but THE EMERALD CIRCUS nails it, and my sincere thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for a copy of the e-book in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

A collection of short fiction by Jane Yolen. Yolen is known for her fairy-tale retellings, but she doesn't restrict herself to fairy tales here, by any means - though several of the stories combine fairy tales with other literature, history, or author biography. The first story, for example, blends the real life of Hans Christian Anderson (to whom Yolen has been compared) with his story of the Snow Queen; the last has Emily Dickinson in space. In between are several Alice in Wonderland stories, a Peter Pan and Wendy story, a Robin Hood story, a Wizard of Oz story, several Arthurian stories (something else for which the author is known), and stories that play off such diverse originals as Keats' "La Belle Dame Sans Merci" and O. Henry's "The Gift of the Magi" (mashed up with "Beauty and the Beast"). There's one based on Scottish history and legend, with no specific literary model that I noticed, and another on the relationship between Queen Victoria and Disraeli (involving kabbala).

The author's note at the end talks interestingly about each story, interleaved with poems.

Frequently, especially early on in the book, the fictional heroines fight (with some effectiveness) against the patriarchy, but that's not the only theme of the book. The lure and terror of the wonderful is probably the most dominant impression I took away, which is a very fairy-tale element.

Did I love it? I'd have to say I didn't completely love it, and one or two of the stories (such as the Oz one) fell a bit flat for me, being more a series of odd events than a story with an arc of development. That could just be a matter of my taste, or mood at the time I was reading. Yolen is a highly skilled, and highly literate, author, and at their best the stories were moving and thought-provoking.

I received a review copy from Netgalley.

Was this review helpful?