Cover Image: Manga Classics: The Count of Monte Cristo

Manga Classics: The Count of Monte Cristo

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I really enjoyed this. The art was absolutely gorgeous. I am a sucker for a retelling, especially a Count of Monte Cristo retelling! Wonderfully done, from someone who does not read a lot of manga but just dips their toe in whenever the mood strikes. Great adaptation!

Review also submitted to Amazon pending review on my profile, will attach link to my profile, since I don’t have the link to the review available at this time.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley for a copy of this manga in exchange for an honest review.

I loved the art in this, my only critique is that this had a lot of characters in it and at times it was hard to follow - it was very ambitious of them to fit the whole story into one book. I actually think they would have been better off splitting it into two books so that they skipped over less, however all-in-all, I think it was well done.

If you like manga, this is a worthwhile adaptation to wet your whistle with.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley & UDON for letting me read a copy of this in exchange for an honest review!

I've read the original novel by Dumas, and it's a beautiful book. I think it can be quite difficult sometimes to adapt classic literature for manga or comics. However, this version of The Count of Monte Cristo has been done beautifully.

The characters are each distinct in appearance and recognisable. Edmond Dantes (The Count) is especially superb in design. I was curious to see how well the story could be condensed into a manga and I have to say that the abridged manga version is just such a good read, and I think is a good way for people to read the story who aren't necessarily able to read entire classics.

I would definitely recommend this version to anyone!

Was this review helpful?

This was my introduction to manga. I chose this because I know the story well. This did a great job of illustrating the pain and suffering of betrayal.

Was this review helpful?

Manga Classics: The Count of Monte Cristo, an adaptation of Alexandre Dumas' classic novel, is a beautifully illustrated and engaging retelling of the timeless tale of revenge and redemption. The story follows Edmond Dantès, a young sailor who is falsely accused of treason and imprisoned for many years. After escaping from prison, Dantès transforms himself into the mysterious Count of Monte Cristo and sets out to exact revenge on those who wronged him.

The manga adaptation does an excellent job of capturing the essence of the original novel, while also adding its own unique visual style. The illustrations are beautifully detailed and provide a vivid representation of the story's characters and settings. The action sequences are particularly well-done, with dynamic panels and fluid movements that bring the story to life.

One of the strengths of this adaptation is its ability to condense the lengthy novel into a more manageable format without sacrificing the complexity of the story. The pacing is well-executed, with each chapter building upon the previous one to create a gripping and suspenseful narrative. The dialogue is also well-crafted, with the characters' motivations and emotions coming through clearly.

Overall, Manga Classics: The Count of Monte Cristo is a fantastic adaptation of a literary classic. It is a must-read for fans of both manga and classic literature, as well as anyone who enjoys a good revenge tale. The book is accessible to readers of all ages and provides a fresh take on a story that has captivated audiences for generations. I highly recommend this manga to anyone looking for an exciting and visually stunning retelling of Dumas' masterpiece.

Was this review helpful?

While I'm embarrassed to admit that I haven't read the original text of The Count of Monte Cristo, it was also a good litmus test for me as the first Manga Classic whose original work I hadn't read. This adaptation turned out to be one of my favorites among the Manga Classics, although how fair that is might be subjective.

I will say that the art continues to be gorgeous and the attention to details continues to be superb. Certainly, the anime and manga style might not be for everyone. While anime and manga remain a big part of my life, their styles have long stopped being my favorite due to the simplification and same-face phenomenon present in so many anime/manga styles. Nonetheless, Manga Classics' art continues to be a delight to look at, with the artists managing to make most characters distinctive. I really liked the character designs in this adaptation in particular; the Count looks every bit as elegant and regal as he's supposed to be. I also like that the villains aren't all uniformly ugly, which is a tiresome trope in a lot of mangas.

The story does feel a bit rushed in some parts, but that can't be helped given the adaptation and the need to trim the original story. This Manga Classic definitely has piqued my interest on the original text though. The accessibility of a manga format might very well be a great way to introduce the classics to potentially hesitant readers.

Was this review helpful?

I have always wanted to read the count of monte cristo but was always intimidated by how long it was. The writers/illustrators did such a good job condensing this huge classic into a 400 page manga, making it accessible and also really fun to read. The artstyle was gorgeous and so immersive too.

Was this review helpful?

It has been years since I read The Count of Monte Cristina, this was a fun way to return to the story. I don’t read much Manga but I’m trying to expand my reading genres. This style allowed me to get through the story quickly.

Was this review helpful?

I’ll be honest, I don’t usually read manga. However, it was part of a reading challenge and this one was “read now” on NetGalley so I decided to give it a try.

The Count of Monte Cristo is a classic that I remember enjoying in the past and having it retold with these fantastic illustrations was great. The story was covered well and told in a way that holds the attention more than a classic writing style. So if you want to read the classics but can’t handle the style of the classics, give the manga versions a try! They’re solid!

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ because it is a pain to read manga as an ebook since they start at the end - the app kept marking it as “complete” because I started at the typical end.

Was this review helpful?

It`s sad, I could not read the book because graphical designs do not work with the ebook reader. But I am sure that the book is good, I do love classics and I read manga sometimes. I'm sure that people who don't usually read novels have a good chance to appreciate classics in another way. Love to see it in the bookshelves.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this manga so much. I’ve never read a manga before but I’m glad this was my introduction into the world!

Was this review helpful?

I didn't like the art style!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Manga Classics for access to a digital copy of Manga Classics: The Count of Monte Cristo by Alexandre Dumas in exchange for an honest review.

CW: imprisonment, murder, violence, see full list on StoryGraph.

Not having read the original text, I would say this Manga Classics version of the Count of Monte Cristo is a great introduction to this classic novel of revenge. This would be a great way to get teens to read this book and get the broad strokes of the plot.

Personally, I didn't love the simplified version of this book in manga form. It wasn't poorly produced by any means, but I feel like I lost a lot of the nuance of the book because a manga is primarily action and dialogue.

Was this review helpful?

I don't have much to say about the story itself since it's a classic, of course. But let me just say I absolutely adore the art style! I've always wanted to read the actual classics but delay them anyway because I don't have the time and the mental bandwith but this is an awesome way to start reading! I liked this art style better than the Romeo and Juliet one.

Was this review helpful?

So I've read Le Comte de Monte Cristo before, and let me tell you I didn't enjoy it. I enjoyed this version a lot more. Is it an abridged version, yes, but the main story and plot points are there, and the added traditional Manga elements helped move the story along, and it was overall a much more enjoyable read. I would definitely read more Manga Classics.

Was this review helpful?

I went into this adaptation with high hopes after reading other Manga Classic adaptation and unfortunately I was let down. While the art was well done I feel like the intricacies of the story and deceptions were hard to keep track of in manga format and did not translate well into a great reader experience.

Was this review helpful?

❗This is a spoiler-free ARC review from NetGalley❗

I tried to read The Count of Monte Cristo when I was younger and could not get through it. That book was huge! But, most Manga I can read in one sitting. So when I saw this version on NetGalley. I wanted to read it immediately. It did not disappoint.

A lot of thought and care was taken in creating this Manga. They kept true to the time period dress and setting. The language was more digestible and interesting. I couldn't put it down! A very simple rundown of the plot is a good man who was betrayed and now wants revenge. I will be picking this up and reading time and time again.

Was this review helpful?

To start out, The Count of Monte Cristo is one of my favorite books of all time. This adaption to manga must have been a massive undertaking and I would just like to take the time to commend the art and the artist, With abridging something and plot heavy and long as the source material some risks are always taken, Personally i think the manga does a good job maintaining the main spirit and essence of the story. I think this is something that would be a pretty good jumping off point in getting someone who may not be interested in reading into literature.

Was this review helpful?

The art is nice and I am always happy to explore a classic in a new form. My one complaint is with formatting when I downloaded the book and opened it it starts immediately at the end of the book which took me a second to figure out that I needed to scroll to the "end" to actually start the book.

Was this review helpful?

An old story, a style of our time
I first discovered this story in musical form, falling in love with the songs, the characters, and the plot. Now I got to experience way more details and elements of Dumas’ heritage, falling for this story once again. Although I do not count myself as a fan of manga (not anymore), I was highly intrigued by the opportunity to read this adaptation. The Count of Monte Christo is known to be a very long, detailed book, so I took the advantage of discovering it in a shorter, condensed version. Nevertheless, I had my pleasure with the many twists and characters the manga could, despite its decreased length, convey.

Reading through the notes on the production of this manga at the end of this book, one gets to know about some of the changes made to Alexandre Dumas’ novel. Still, I believe that this manga has caught the essence of the story and the main characters quite well. Although I seldomly appreciate this art style nowadays, I was intrigued by the Count’s detailed expressions and his handsomeness, as well. But he is not the only figure of the book that comes to life on these pages. Although condensed, the manga does not fail to convey many side stories, motivations, and faults of minor characters.

Experiencing the story in this way allowed me to discover the genius that is Alexandre Dumas without suffering through hundred and hundred of pages. I loved every twist and turn of his story that I read and saw in this manga. I was pleased by how the plot turned out and how one could, respectively, recognize many details in one single frame. Surprisingly, this manga is not only for lovers of this artisan genre, but also for admirers of the writing of classical authors like Dumas.

In conclusion
I fell in love with this story due to its highly simplified adaptation as a musical, but now discovered more and more details. Enjoying the many shades of the characters and the depth of the story itself was fully possible within this condensed version that did not omit the most shocking, surprising twists. I will surely pursue some more of these amazing adaptations that are the Manga Classics.

Was this review helpful?