Cover Image: Manga Classics: The Count of Monte Cristo

Manga Classics: The Count of Monte Cristo

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Um clássico atemporal da literatura francesa recebe uma nova releitura, agora voltada ao público jovem adulto e que curte Mangá e HQ

Com ilustrações muito bonitas, a edição merece ser lida.

Gostei bastante dos traços do artista e da adaptação.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley for the e-reader's copy of this book in exchange of an honest review.

I've loved Count of Monte Cristo since I was in high school, I find no bone to pick with the plot whatsoever-- a personal bias, perhaps but also a impeccable slow burn plot for revenge. It's a classic after all.

While it took me awhile to get a hang of reading the manga, I've never had the pleasure of reading this book in a comic form and it really gives more life to the characters (Dumas' language isn't as easily digestible/accessible as comics are, English majors can disagree). I'm not the biggest fan of the way some of the subplots were truncated in the manga with respect to the book, but as a standalone, it's pretty damn close to the original and also deeply enjoyable.

Was this review helpful?

This Manga Classic exceeded my expectations though it shouldn't since I've been wowed by all the Manga Classics I've read. This manga perfectly captures the essence of the original novel and presents it in a beautiful, and vivid format. The characters come to life and the story unfolds with all the drama and suspense as intended in the original classic.

Was this review helpful?

Incredibly refreshing to read a clasic of literature in a manga style, the author knew how to translate well what ws written to drawings, and I wasn't dissapointed with the result of it. Edmond Dantes was perfectly portrayed with his expressions and afflictions.

Was this review helpful?

I liked this rendition of The count of monte Cristo. I really liked how closely it stayed to the original book. I would recommend this this book to anyone who likes classics and manga. It is a beautiful mix of the two and I will read it again.

Was this review helpful?

The Count of Monte Cristo is a classic I've been wanting to read for a while, but to be honest, I've felt too daunted to tackle it. So when I saw the opportunity to read this manga version on Netgalley, it seemed a great chance to become familiar with the story in a more approachable and manageable way.

It tells the tale of a man who is on the brink of great happiness - promotion to captain of a ship and wedding to his love - when jealous rivals frame him and have him sent to rot in prison. After 15 years he escapes, comes upon great fortune, styles himself as the Count of Monte Cristo, and vows to avenge himself on the men who stole his life from beneath him.

The story is interesting but complex, with many intertwining characters and motives. I have to admit I got a little confused at times about all the various names and characters, although I did discover a chart at the back with pictures of the characters and how they relate to one another, which is a great idea. Our main character is an intriguing mix of kindness and vengeance, honesty and duplicity, honour and madness. He thinks that he is the hand of God himself, passing judgement on those who wronged him.

It is, of course, a story of its time and must be taken as such - the sketchiness of the storyline involving Greek slave girl Haydee and her Stockholm Syndrome included.

I have not read the original story but the manga adaptation seems to do a pretty good job of rendering such a complex story into a more simplified version. There are a few pages at the end about the choices made in terms of storyline for the adaptation, and a few artist sketches.

The story is read in traditional manga fashion from right to left - this is explained in the book for those who've not read manga before. It was my first time reading like this and I had no difficulty getting used to it.

After reading this manga, I feel like I have a better understanding of this classic story, and I might even have the confidence to attempt the original one day.

Was this review helpful?

What is there to say about this other than it takes a beloved classic and give you a condensed yet accurate portrayal with beautiful artwork? I've been meaning to read The Count for quite some time, but the size of the novel is intimidating. I would definitely recommend this if you're looking to consume the story in a much easier to digest format.

Was this review helpful?

* Thanks to NetGalley and Udon Entertainment for providing an advance copy for review purposes *

I've read a few retellings of "The Count of Montecristo" recently, like "Queen of the South" and "The Baron of Magister Valley". But the revenge dished out in the original is so satisfying, I was intending to re-read it. And then I ran into a manga adaptation of it, and was curious how true to the original it is, and whether the manga format would suit such a sobering story.

I was very pleased with this adaptation. There is not much humor in the story, so this manga adaptation does not get to enjoy the moments of levity that "Anne of Green Gables" did. Although typical manga tropes to depict anger or tension do appear (e.g. the scene where Fernand and Edmond). However, we get the full details of the unjust imprisonment of naive Edmond Dantes, and his transformation into a powerful force for revenge. The original is a very complex story, with a huge cast, and lots of twists and turns in the plot, and I was happy to see that most of it was preserved. There is even a handy character relationship chart at the end of the book. The details of the life of Edmond in prison, his escape, and the origins of his fortune are glossed over in this adaptation, but that is understandable given that it is already over 400 pages, and managed to keep even minor plot lines around, as long as they were relevant to the revenge. There is a lot going on, and every page is there for a reason in this trimmed down version.

The artwork itself is beautiful, with distinctive character designs. Emotions come through very clearly, so not much text is needed to convey anything on key encounters - the eyes tell it all. The design for Edmond Dantes reminded me a bit of the design for the main character in the Gankutsuou anime (albeit beardless and less blue), but based on the notes at the end of the book, it is based on an actor/model. I appreciated how his depiction subtly changes as he grows older and colder after his imprisonment. I also really enjoyed the designs for Haydee and Albert.

If you haven't read "The Count of Montecristo", I would highly recommend giving it a shot, and if the original seems dauting, this faithful adaptation is a good starting point. And then read Dumas' version, because it is just so good. And if you are a fan of the original and like your revenge not just cold but beautiful, this adaptation is a treat.

Was this review helpful?

A surprisingly faithful adaptation with very good art. The original tale is a massive book with many complicated subplots, but the manga does a superb job of condensing and simplifying without losing too much of the original's flavor. This would be an excellent adaptation to give to children too young for the original.

Received via NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

I'm happy to read this book and got to find this. I enjoyed the adaptation of story and how it was presented in a manga style although I haven't really read the actual novel but I still enjoyed it.

The art design is truly lovely on this one. This reminds me so much of any shoujo manga before and ughhhhhhh they are so pretty. I can't get over how pretty the art is that it made it even more appealing to get into and to read.

I'll definitely gonna read the actual novel!

Was this review helpful?

A great manga on a great classic. I enjoyed reading this book. Thank you to NetGalley for allowing me to read this book.

Was this review helpful?

It was fine but I had to scroll to the beginning. I felt like I really wanted to read this after reading Les Miserables so this was another goodie for me

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley for a copy in exchange for an honest review!
This book was one that was significantly nicer and easier to read than the manga version of Romeo and Juliet, which I disliked. I'll start by saying this. The art and coloring were stunning. I also liked the storyline much more, and I enjoyed hearing about the main character. The only things I disliked is the pacing of it because sometimes it moved at an excruciatingly slow pace, and I didn't enjoy that. It also got confusing at parts to read because the pages seemed to melt into one another, but that might be because I was reading it an ebook format. Overall, I enjoyed this book a decent amount.

Was this review helpful?

Love the artwork! Especially the cover work. There’s much to say about this—the visual storytelling was beautiful and well drawn and the designs for the characters were superb. The writing and plot felt a bit lackluster in comparison, but even so it was engaging and delightful to read!

Was this review helpful?

First, let me just say, I haven't read the original source material - so my review is solely on this Manga classics's adaptation of the original story.

All in all, I thoroughly enjoyed this manga classic. There was good characterisation with well drawn facial expressions and gestures giving the character's personality and conveying their characteristics beautifully. The story was also well paced as it never felt lagging in any areas. I also loved the varied use of images from full page to close ups, they added a dynamic aspect to the reading experience that I thoroughly enjoyed. Furthermore, the details in the drawings were perfect for scene setting as the backgrounds and use of white space and shading made the images and story beautiful and easy to follow.

The only recommendations I would say were that the eReader addition on my laptop started at the end of the book. This lead to some initial confusion with the storyline but once I realised my mistake a few pages in I was able to start at the last page and read the backwards.

Like I said, all in all it was a very enjoyable read - with easy to follow, beautifully drawn images and an engaging, fast-paced story that kept me reading to the very end in one sitting! Loved and would certainly recommend!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. It has been published in April 2017.

"Manga Classics: The Count of Monte Cristo" was a pleasant surprise to me: I chose it because I love the novel and I was curious about this adaptation, but I have to admit, I was also a bit worried that a manga might not do justice to Alexandre Dumas' masterpiece.
Therefore, I was pleasantly surprised to find that the story, the characters and the atmosphere from the original were all skillfully rendered.
This manga definitely lives up to Dumas' classic.
I really enjoyed the artwork and the excellent characterization of this vast cast.
I would have liked it better if the part about Edmond's escape from prison had not been skipped, but I understand the reason behind this choice.

Was this review helpful?

ARC provided by NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. (English and Spanish)

A perfect book for those who love to read, but do not have much free time for it. The first time I read The Count of Monte Cristo, it took me several days to finish it; while reading this book, I devoured it in a matter of hours.
Although it simplifies the original work a lot, it continues to transmit its essence with integrity. In addition, the illustrations provide an incredible aesthetic and support the text with fidelity. Being very enlightening with the plot.

Without much more to add, I will only highlight how suitable this work is for the youngest, being the perfect complement to their teaching activities; although I extend myself to recommend it to adults who have just immersed themselves in the world of Alexandre Dumas.


°°°•••°°°•••°°°•••

Un libro perfecto para aquellos que aman leer, pero que no disponen de mucho tiempo libre para ello; la primera vez que leí El conde de Monte Cristo, me tomó varios días poder terminarlo, mientras que este libro, lo devoré en cuestión de horas.
Ya que aunque simplifica bastante la obra original, sigue transmitiendo con entereza la esencia de esta. Además, las ilustraciones aportan una estética increíble y respaldan el texto con fidelidad. Siendo muy esclarecedoras con la trama.

Sin mucho más que agregar, solo resaltaré lo adecuada que resulta esta obra para los más jóvenes, siendo el complemento perfecto para sus actividades docentes; aunque me extiendo a recomendarla a adultos que recién se sumergen en el mundo de Alexandre Dumas.

Was this review helpful?

The manga version of The Count of Monte Cristo is really good. This is the best choice for those who find reading the novel long and tiresome. The illustrations are beautiful and keep you interested. I really enjoyed it.

Was this review helpful?

I tried to reading the actual book years back and never could finish, even the abridged version. I'm glad that a graphic novel has been created, and as a manga no less.

I enjoyed it. I liked the illustrations & felt that the story was more capturing this way.

Totally recommend -- especially if you're like me in that you don't always get along with the original format of the classics.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Udon Entertainment and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this title of Manga Classics.
This is a nice way to read a classic of French literature. It has all the drama, historical style of Dumas' novel.
I like the Japanese manga style, respecting that the characters are Europeans.

The only thing as an ebook is that you have to go manual till the end to start reading it. Of course in the physical one it's easier.

Was this review helpful?