Oh man, this was like going on a first date and ALMOST feeling a spark but not quite, haha. From the blurb, I was all in. Dystopian society? Check. Carnivals? Check. Rival queens? Oh yes please.
However, sadly, the execution fell flat. The idea and the strong writing is there, but I think this book should have had a lot more editing. It felt long and aimless at certain points and I really had to push myself to finish the last 10% (and shouldn't that be the best part to want to read?)
I was also sorely disappointed that so much of the book was about other characters aside from Aurora. I thought it was going to center with her and even have a first person POV, but instead there were a lot of other main characters that I did not connect with. John and Marvel felt like the exact same person to me, to be honest. I know they weren't but it was hard as a reader to sense any difference in their development, they both fell flat. I think this could have been alleviated by a first person perspective for different narratives, instead of the passive and seemingly removed third person perspective that the book has.
I had even MORE disappointment that there was not more world-building. We never get an explanation of what exactly Bent Head is as a disease and why the setting is post-apocalyptic. What exactly happened, other than a disease? Why did all these carnival factions rise up with this blood magic and Heads? I was also confused about Kansas versus the Cape and the differing power dynamics there... The overall world was pretty unclear to me.
So what did I like? I liked Orchid as a strong and fierce female character. I liked the (small) portions with the Green Butterfly prophetess - I wish she had been integrated more. I liked the writing and Game of Thrones-esque beauty and brutality (don't read if you are sensitive to imagery of gore and violence). But I can't recommend this as-is, I really think it could have been a slam dunk with significantly more editing and investment in the characters and world-building.
Sincere thank you to the author, the publisher, and Netgalley for an ARC.