Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Books UK for the ARC which contained only the first of the three stories which make up this book.

The short story “Un Noël de Maigret” was first published in 1950, the last of 28 written by Georges Simenon. It is translated here by David Coward. It takes place on Christmas Day.

The story tells us a lot, very subtly, about Jules Maigret’s relationship with his wife, Louise and is full of interesting detail of life in contemporary Paris.

With the help of his colleagues, Lucas and Torrence, and through some interviews and telephone calls, the Inspector investigates the mysterious appearance by Santa Claus in the bedroom of the adopted daughter of one of his neighbours.

it is a beautifully-crafted tale of greed and deception, of crimes which Maigret slowly untangles over the course of the day. It has a slightly melancholy flavour, although there are glimmers of happiness for many in the ending.

Most enjoyable and highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

I was a fan of Simenon's work so many years ago it almost (!) embarrasses me to admit it. Maigret was certainly one of the early crime fiction characters that really worked for me. There is a relaxed ease in his handling of his cases that I still find endearing. This one is no exception.

It's Christmas Day and Madame Maigret is out shopping for croissants for breakfast. Two people from a neighbouring building cross the road wanting to talk to their legendary detective neighbour. The niece of one of the woman says she saw Santa during the night taking up a floorboard and he left her a gift. Is this really a case of Monsieur Maigret?

Of course it is. It has all the usual characters in including Lucas and Torrence. It has an interesting tale and I thoroughly enjoyed reading it. Sadly my review copy only contained the one story so I'll not give a rating for the book. However I'd be surprised if fans would not want to read this.

Was this review helpful?

This is the first of the three stories of this collection and I really enjoyed it. It was so intriguing and kept me reading. The plot is perfectly worked into a brilliant short story set on Christmas Day. I’m just disappointed I didn’t get to read the other two stories in the collection.

Was this review helpful?

Susan: @thebooktrailer

What a perfect read for the first French Friday here on The BookTrail! Ah I've read these stories in French but now they're in a lovely little collection which is perfect for Christmas and any time you want to be transported to Paris really.

Maigret is an iconic French character and it's a treat to have him in bite size here so to speak. The three stories are nicely chosen and very smoothly translated whilst encompassing all the French flourishes Maigret is so well known for. I found the stories so different yet they complemented each other well. No spoilers here but a good collection and there might only be three but three is the magic Maigret number in this case.

Maigret and Paris At Christmas. What's not to like?

Was this review helpful?

This has been such an enjoyable read and short enough to follow the plot without having to check back. I adore the age that this is set in, when people took note of everyday occurrences happening around them and life was lived at a gentile pace.

Was this review helpful?

A interesting short story that kept moving and your interest going. Examining personal relationships as well as playing the detective.

Was this review helpful?

This ARC only includes the first of the three published stories so this review is only partial. As ever, Simenon concocts a taut tale in his characteristic tight-lipped prose. It's Christmas day and Maigret finds himself drawn into a case that starts with a neighbour's child waking up to find Santa in her room... The plotting spins out from here, and Mme Maigret has a strong role to play, adding a bittersweet feel to the story. An excellent taster.

Was this review helpful?

I was really looking forward to this collection of three Christmas stories, as I have really liked the Maigret books. So I settled down for this festive read, looking forward to spending Christmas in Paris. To my horror, there was only one story, the two others are missing. I really enjoyed it albeit I would have preferred it to be longer. I think it was a shame the trio of short stories had two missing. It is difficult to write a review on this collection on the basis of one. Perhaps the publisher will correct this? Many thanks to Penguin Classics for the one story ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This is a short story of a Christmas Day with the detective Maigret ad his wife when a nei9ghbour has an uninvited visitor. An enjoyable short story with a sad window into Maigret's personal life.

Was this review helpful?

My first taste of Simenon did prove the likes of Dard and Garnier do have the same DNA, which I was very happy to have proven, but it sucks this file was a third of the finished book. Netgalley should enforce a notice to the effect before every download. I loved what I read, but I haven't read this book, and so I'm not in a position to give it a positive mark.

Was this review helpful?