Cover Image: Just Under the Clouds

Just Under the Clouds

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I really enjoyed the writing in this book, but it didn't really seem to go anywhere. Cora does not have an easy life- her father died, her mother struggles to keep a roof over their head, and her sister has special needs. At first I really enjoyed the story, but then realized it wasn't really working towards any sort of resolution. I don't care for ambiguous endings and I don't think they really fit well in middle grade- my students really want an ending.

Was this review helpful?

I listened to this book, and the narrator did a good job with Cora’s voice telling the story. The story itself, though, really didn’t do it for me. I didn’t have a sense of any character growth by the end: Cora actually learns to settle for whatever her mother can provide for them in terms of housing, finally getting an apartment a step above a shelter.
Cora’s mom seemed pretty out of touch with her family’s dire circumstances. She left the girls in some potentially dangerous situations and did not always take the help that was available to them, most notably, school lunches and appropriate special education placement for Adare.
Willa was the character I most identified with, and she tried to help and had a loving heart, thankfully. Cora would’ve stayed with her in a heartbeat if she could, and I almost wanted that to happen.
Another thing I’ve been thinking about was that the family lived in NYC. If you’ve read books set in the city, you know that it takes upon a life of its own, and I did not feel that at all. The setting was so bland, and the things the girls did were so *not* stuff people do in NYC that I wondered if the author had ever been there.
I absolutely think we need books for middle schoolers that reflect their reality, and I know we have food-insecure and housing-insecure students at my school who might be looking for a mirror of their own lives to read about, but I don’t think this book will help them see hopefulness, only more despair.

Was this review helpful?

A wonderful book about a family who must learn how to survive after the death of their father/husband. The sisters, Cora (12) and Adare (10), learn to adjust to their new surroundings as they go and live with a friend of their mothers. Core must learn how to navigate her new life as she takes care of her little sister who has mental challenges. Learning about her mom when she was younger, and learning to adjust to her new surrounds, Cora learns that life changes quickly and plans do not always go as planned. A great book for bookclubs for those in elementary.

Was this review helpful?

After Cora's father dies, her mother struggles to keep the family afloat. She works long hours in low paying jobs, but their circumstances are precarious at best. Cora is usually in charge of her mentally challenged sister. Against the backdrop of dangerous living conditions, crows that follow Cora and her sister as they move from place to place, and the trees Cora catalogs in the hope pf finding the Ailanthus altissima, the "tree of heaven”, which can grow anywhere even under adverse conditions, the story emerges as one of growth, family and home.
This is a great middle great read and belongs on the shelf alongside Katherine Applegate's, Crenshaw and Paula Fox's Monkey Island.

Was this review helpful?

Cora Quinn, her sister Adare, and their mother have been moving from shelter to shelter and in and out of kind friends' residences since Mr. Quinn died. It's been awhile since they lived in a real home and haven't had to worry about their safety. Adare has a mental disability due to complications from birth, and Cora has to take care of her because their mother has to work long hours. Cora just wants to stay put in a real home and be able to make friends and do well in school. Through a series of circumstances, Cora will try to make a friend and will learn important life lessons as she finds out what a real home is.
This is such a heartbreaking, necessary book. Many families are forced to live like this, and this is the first middle grade book I have come across that directly and powerfully addresses the issue of homelessness. The addition of Adare's mental disability and the way Cora and her mother have to adapt to that is also a relevant and necessary topic that is just now starting to be addressed in children's and teens' fiction. The characters seemed so real to me that I could see them and their difficult circumstances in my mind. I think this book teaches great lessons about living with tough circumstances as well as different types of relationships. I was very satisfied with the ending, though it seemed a little open ended. I highly recommend this book!
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley. A positive review was not required, and all opinions expressed are entirely my own.

Was this review helpful?

There are children that struggle quietly with things that they never expose at school, and they need to be seen and heard. This book does just that.

Was this review helpful?

Brooklyn based middle schooler Cora never knew a real home. after her father died. Together with her mom and little sister Adare, they go from one place to another, from homeless shelter to stay at a friends house for a while and back, untill they hopefully one day find a place of their own.
While their mother works fulltime to make ends meet, Cora has to look after her sister Adare, wo is lightly disabled, rarely speaks and needs special care. Cora is doing well in school, although has been moved around so much that she struggles to make friends.

When their room in the shelter they currently stayed in was broken in and made into a giant mess, the little family seeks refuges at the house of one of their mother's old friends.
Cora tries to find some dristraction by mapping trees, which connects her to her late father. And then there's the budding hope of friendship, and maybe even a glimmer of stability.

This is quite an unusual read. At sometimes I found it even a bit weird. The story and synopsis got my interest and it started of quite interesting. Then it became somewhat difficult to follow at many points. The most interesting part of it was them being homeless and how and if they would find somewhere stable to live in the next place and eventually a place of their own in the end. The part with the trees and everything came over to me like fantasy. Somehow I just couldn't follow that part and it was quite unclear where or what was happening.

Overall I found this a book that had and interesting main topic, but it got a little lost in storyline that wasn't worked out in all of the parts or maybe it was just not my cup of tea.

Was this review helpful?

A heart wrenching and heartwarming story of a single mom and her two daughters struggling together to deal with the changes in their lives after losing dad. They move frequently and finally become homeless when Cora's mom seeks refuge with an old childhood friend, but that's not the end of the story. They just keep trying to find their place in the world. The kids are good kids, albeit kids who make mistakes. What kids don't? Mom is a strong and capable woman who continually works to make things better for her girls. This is a family that loves each other and tries, even when it's hard, to do the best they can for each other. I can't recommend this book enough! Truly heartwarming!

Was this review helpful?

Homelessness is an important topic for youth fiction. Most of us will never experience it so wee need insight to give us a measure of sensitivity and understanding .What makes this one stand out to me is the time frame. Most of the books about homeless families I've read are about the newly homeless. We see an extreme situation, lost jobs and a few months of desperation. In this book we see a family in persistent homelessness. We see rotating shelters, temporary apartments, couch-surfing. We see the struggle of a single parent with a low paying job who can never get her feet under her. There are no simple solutions to their trouble, just patience. The narrative is a bit scattered, so not the easiest to follow.

Was this review helpful?

A great novel, for middle school students, dealing with the sad reality of homelessness and a special needs sibling. I will definitely recommend this one to out media coordinator!

Was this review helpful?

Middle schooler Cora, her Mexican-American mom, and younger sister, Adare, are homeless. After her father died, she and her family have lived in a series of temporary homes and shelters in Brooklyn, New York, while her mother tries to make ends meet at an hourly retail job, giving up her art to keep her family going. Adare sustained brain damage at birth, so Cora must look after her when their mother isn't around. When they get back to their room at the shelter and discover it's been broken into, the family heads to Cora's mom's childhood friend, Willa, a successful lawyer with an apartment of her own, hoping to stay until a better, safer, placement comes through. Cora loves life in Willa's stable home, but the girls' mother is frustrated by what she sees as Willa's meddling. Meanwhile, at school, Cora struggles with math and bullies, and meets a friend named Sabina, who lives on a houseboat and was homeschooled until this school year. Cora has both parents' passions within her; she keeps her father's tree diary with her and searches for a special tree that her father wrote about, paired with her mother's artistic talent - with an arborial bent. She has the stress of caring for Adare, the stress of being homeless, and being bullied.

Just Under the Clouds is narrated in Cora's voice; author Melissa Sarno creates a strong, moving narrative where we meet a family that often falls through the cracks in our society: the working poor. Cora's mother, Liliana, is working at a job that doesn't cover the cost of living for a family of three, let alone in metro New York, and her daughters are in school, clean, and fed, if not full. It's a tale of poverty, grief, empathy, and hope. The book addresses childhood stress, which comes with long-lasting fallout, and caring for a special needs child, and how poverty affects those children receiving necessary services to help them. It's a sensitive, painful look in our own backyards and courtyards, our own classrooms and workplaces, and deserves a space on bookshelves and in readers' hands. Pair this with 1958's The Family Under the Bridge, by Natalie Savage Carson, and ask readers how things have changed - and how they've stayed the same - over 60 years. Start a booktalk by asking your readers, "How would you feel if you lived in a place that wasn't safe to go to alone?"

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this story, but it made me think that so many books that are being published now are devoid of subtlety. I would argue that the story was unnecessarily harsh. So many of the lessons that this book was striving to convey could have been shown without the harshness of the plot. Still, the cover was enticing enough to make me want to buy this book. Also, the story is one that I have put on my book list to give to teachers when they ask for books on diversity and empathy. This book will fit the need for both. An important topic, but I wish that some of the plot could have been portrayed differently without the harshness.

Was this review helpful?

A definite add to my collection. Your heart goes out to Cora as she tries to deal with all the difficulties in her life at such a young age. It would be a great read aloud with a lot of discussion points. I just love the character of Sabine. She’s quirky but she’s also kind and stands up for what is right. She’s the perfect friend for Cora. “Sabine, even when you’re standing on your head, I like you a gazillion times better than anybody right side up.”

Was this review helpful?

I had the opportunity to read a digital ARC from NetGalley of this middle grade novel. This book gives readers so much to think about. Cora, her special-needs sister, and her mother are homeless after the sudden death of her father. They have to move to different shelters all the time, many of them not very safe or pleasant. Cora struggles academically, socially, and emotionally as she has to deal with bullying, moving around so often, and missing her father. All she has left to remember her father is his Tree Book, which he used to identify trees in the community.
Sadly, many kids in our communities and schools experience homelessness. I think this book and others like it help young readers develop empathy and respect for their neighbors that are affected by poverty. This book could help start some great discussions about what makes a home, ways to respond to bullying, and ways to support friends that might be experiencing the things that Cora experiences. This book would be appropriate for middle grade kids in grades 4 – 8.

Was this review helpful?

Just Under the Clouds is a middle-school book about two young girls and their mother living in NYC struggling after the death of the father. Essentially homeless, moving from place to place, the family does what it can to stay together. Cora, a middle-schooler, deals with bullying and taking care of her special needs, younger sister. She loves and protects her little sister, yet at the same time, she feels the weight of that responsibility. Cora struggles with math, but is artistic like her mother and enjoys the science of trees like her father. She desires friendship but isn't really sure how to be a friend when her life is constantly being uprooted. She desires a home, but how do you have a home when you don't know if you'll be sleeping in the same place tomorrow night?

I thought this was a well-written, realistic story about the struggles of this family and how Cora deals with the adversity in her life. I think this book could open up some good discussions in the classroom or at home.

=======
At my request, I received a free electronic copy of this book from NetGalley. I was not required to give a positive review. This review reflects my honest thoughts and opinions on the book, and I received no compensation for this review.

Was this review helpful?

Just under the clouds is an honest heartfelt account of the gray areas relating to homelessness and a family seeking to get back on their feet and finding their independence.

Was this review helpful?

Not many middle grade novels talk about homelessness. Still fewer take the perspective of a child experiencing homelessness. Here, Cora and her family shuffle from one questionable shelter to another, or between friends' couches. She watches her sister, Adare, and she waits for her mother. There's no long-term stability--only a daily life of right-now. Right now, her mother is working. Right now, Adare wants to take off her shoes and run. Right now, they have a teapot and windowsill treasures. There's no way to think about what will happen later.

Cora manages by mapping trees, which connects her to her late father. And then there's the budding hope of friendship, and maybe even a glimmer of stability. This story is quietly realistic, giving readers either a window into a different life or a much-needed mirror of their own.

Was this review helpful?

While contemporary is not generally my cup of tea, there need to be more books like this. There are very few books, especially MG books, that deal with the issues of homelessness despite the fact that many, many, many children are homeless. Cora is a very real character, and her struggles and triumphs felt authentic. Her relationship with her sister, Adare, who was deprived of oxygen at birth, was at time sweet and frustrating as Cora became frustrated with her and with how people perceived her sister. However, the pacing was a little slow for me. This is good book for anyone who enjoys contemporary novels and for fans of Crenshaw.

Was this review helpful?

I like the last sentence of the description by the publisher "Just Under the Clouds will take root." It is heart breaking and sweet and I cannot help but root for these characters. Cora, as the big sister who must be older than she wants to be has so much hurt and pain that she must swallow and I just wanted to yell at the mother to wake up!!! I know that when adults are sad and barely holding it together, it is ever more difficult for children. I also know that when adults cannot get their sadness under control, sometimes other adults need to step in to take care of the children, especially as they leave middle school and go to high school. I just felt like if the mom didn't really look at Cora, and try to understand what she was hiding, she would lose her within a few years.



Perhaps that is why this story got so rooted in me. I could see the future for this little family and I just hoped that by the end of the book, I would be reassured that the future I could see was not going to come to pass. That kind of dread, waiting for the third strike, makes this kind of reading both gripping and daunting.



This is a solid middle level read that will appeal to both males and females. I personally chose this to fulfill my Goodreads summer June challenge for It's the End of the World: Read a book about the end of the world as we know it. For Cora, this is the end of the world. Her floating, untethered existence, her feet anchored when all she wants to do is climb, the letters that do not turn into numbers, the loss of a father, these are all part of Cora living at the end of the world. This is not a dystopia. This is real life shoving your head under the water.


Digital advanced copy provided by Net Galley and the publisher for an honest review

Was this review helpful?

Just Under the Clouds is a sweet poignant YA novel about a young girl and her family. They are homeless due to unfortunate circumstances. The narrator is the main character Cora, a 12 year old girl who is struggling. Beautifully written with believable characters.

Was this review helpful?