Member Reviews
Vicky D, Reviewer
This was the first book that I have read by Lisa Scottoline and it will not be the last! I read this book in no time. I could not put it down! There are so many twists and turns that you think you've got it figured out and something changes. It will keep you on the edge of your seat throughout the whole book. Wow...just wow! You have to read it! |
4.5 Page Turning Stars 🌟🌟🌟🌟.5 “Two can keep a secret if one of them is dead” I haven’t read a Lisa Scottoline book in quite some time, and I’m not sure why but after reading this book I’m going to go back and pick up some of those I have missed.... this book grab me from the very beginning and did not let go until the bitter end..... A combination of both legal thriller and domestic thriller it was fantastic.... The only reason this book did not get a full five stars is I felt as though the ending was a bit rushed and tied up a little too neatly.... Maggie and Noah have the perfect life.... A beautiful home, fulfilling jobs, and a 10-year-old adorable son Caleb..... The only thing missing from Maggie’s life is her estranged 17-year-old daughter Anna... so when Anna reaches out to her she is beyond thrilled... Anna comes to live with the family and now the happy family of three is a happy family of four, but not for long..... not long after Anna arrives and has caused much tension..... she is found murdered and Noah is charged with her murder..... Told from alternating points of view between Maggie and Noah... I think I enjoyed Noah’s point of view a bit more.... I loved all the court scenes.... there was so much tension and it kept me on the edge of my seat..... and there were times I wanted to yell at him think about yourself not about Maggie... he was almost too good of a guy..... my heart did break for Maggie.... here is what should be the happiest time in her life the reunion with her daughter.... and things have gone unbelievably wrong.... i’d always say a woman should believe her child and stand by her child no matter what... but this was such a different situation.... she didn’t really know her daughter and she knew her husband, I just couldn’t see a good answer for her in the situation.... Throughout this book I kept trying to figure out what the twist was.... Who murdered Anna and the even bigger question why? And what Game was Anna playing? There of course were plenty of twists and turns none of which I saw coming.... and some of these twists if anybody saw coming then they are clairvoyant.... because they were a little out of left field..... even if some of the parts of the ending of this book were a little unrealistic, I don’t care the book as a whole was fantastic... and it is fiction after all..... Strongly recommend to all fans of legal thrillers, domestic thrillers,and books that keep you turning the pages as fast as you can! *** thank you so much to the publisher and Net Galley for a copy of this book *** |
Lori Z, Educator
Another great story from Lisa. After Anna is a suspense filled thriller that starts in the most personal and private of places, a family home. Maggie and Noah are married, Maggie divorced for many years and lost custody of her infant daughter due to her post part psychosis. Those aspects were handled so well by the author. Maggie and Noah have son, happily married when one day Anna shows up and that moment and every page that follows was all consuming. The lengths to which Anna would go knew no bounds. Happy to have her daughter back home, Maggie tried to appease and smooth over or ignore certain situations, that is until Anna is found strangled and Noah is arrested and charged with her murder. The book then runs between story line and courtroom proceedings which at times bothered me a little but not enough to ruin the story. The rest of the book runs through past history, trial and what seemed to me a deck stacked against Noah, but I'm just the reader. Until the day Maggie gets a phone call. A phone call that throws her and her son into action and the story moved so quickly and darn those twists and wicked hairpin turns! And oh the end..... read the book!!! This wasn't my favorite book from Lisa but it was a great read and certainly worth reading. **arc from NetGalley and Publisher for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own** |
This thriller is told with two timelines. The one that takes place 'after Anna' is told backwards: Dr Noah Alderman is on trial for the murder of his stepdaughter, Anna, and is just about to learn the jury's verdict. Next we learn what happened in court the day before, then the day before that...and so on. But sharing centerstage with that is the story of 'before Anna' and what led up to her murder. At about the 75% mark, the two storylines converge, Noah hears the verdict and then the story completely explodes! I was constantly trying to guess the killer's identity but never in my wildest imagination would I have come up with the twists and turns this story takes. Well done! I enjoyed this thriller immensely and highly recommend. Many thanks to NetGalley, the author and publisher for providing me with an arc of the book for my honest review. |
Anna T, Reviewer
I have always particularly liked Lisa Scottoline's standalone books - this one was no exception. Like her other standalones, it was suspenseful and I loved the structure (alternating POVs), so you really were kept (enjoyably) in the dark. |
Leslie R, Librarian
Title: After Anna Author: Lisa Scottoline St. Martin’s Press ISBN: 9781250099655 Copyright 2018 Publication Date: April 10, 2018 Scottoline’s latest novel opens with the trial of Dr. Noah Alderman, who is being charged with first degree murder. The story is told from the alternating perspectives of Dr. Alderman and his wife, Maggie. Noah’s version starts from the end of the trial, working backwards while Maggie’s version starts several months before and moves forward. Their stories feel like they are literally hurtling towards each other as the reader starts to tease out what has happened to their lives and their marriage. The story starts out as a courtroom thriller, but once the trial is over the plot increases dramatically in pace, reaching that “must-finish” level that will have many readers staying up past bedtime. The heart of this story is made up of Maggie’s reunion with the daughter who was taken from her as an infant. Maggie, struggling from a severe case of postpartum psychosis, loses custody of her child to her ex-husband. While she has built a happy life with Noah and her stepson, Caleb, she has never stopped wondering about her daughter, sending letters and gifts, even doing a little cyber-stalking to get a glimpse of what her life has become. So when Anna, the daughter she lost, is suddenly back in her life, Maggie looks forward to finally having it all, but disaster is waiting to strike. The story moves at a quick pace and readers who think they see every twist and turn coming will be surprised. Scottoline throws several curve balls into the last few chapters. This book is for any reader who is tired of figuring out their whodunnits half-way through the book. The most significant criticism I can offer for this book is that it wraps up too quickly. As a frequent reader of mysteries and thrillers, I enjoy the tying up of loose ends at the end of the story, and I felt a little cheated of that experience here. I appreciated the complexity of the story, but I would have loved to have delved deeper into the issues that were presented in the final chapters. As a Scottoline fan, I felt After Anna lacked the complexity of One Perfect Lie, but is still not to be missed. I got access to this title for free through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. |
Clear your schedule when you start After Anna because you won't be able to put this captivating novel down. Lisa Scottoline definitely has written another best seller. The story begins with a murder suspect in a court room awaiting his verdict. The man on trial is Dr. Noah Alderman. He is accused of killing his step daughter, Anna. Maggie has been happily married to Noah, a widower, for two years. Noah has a ten year old son, Caleb. Maggie has a daughter, Anna, from her first marriage. When Anna was an infant Maggy was hospitalized with postpartum psychosis and she lost custody of her daughter. Maggie has not spoken to or seen Anna since that day, seventeen years ago. One day Anna calls Maggie and Maggie is shocked and overjoyed. Maggie and Anna meet and soon Anna is living with the family. Scottoline skillfully makes the reader question both Anna's and Noah's reliability. The chapters are narrated by Maggie before and Noah after. Although the plot is disturbing, this book is a joy to read. |
A thrilling physiological novel that will keep you turning page after page. Very good character development that will pull you in and having you feeling their ups and downs. There are plenty of unexpected moments to hold your interest from page one all the way to the end.. If you enjoy a good women's fiction novel with mystery this is a great book and I would recommend it to friends. |
I received a free copy from NetGalley. Mom tells the story from the point of view of before Anna. Step-dad tells the story from the point of view of after Anna. Together is makes for an interesting tale with some great twists and turns that continue after the two stories merge in time. Engaging story with some interesting modern issues and family dynamics, that were tackled in a new and different way. Once you reach about the half way point, you won't want to put it down. |
This book was full of twists and turns. It was highly suspenseful and a real page-turned. |
I received this from netgalley.com in exchange for a review. The story is told Before Anna and After Anna. Before she was killed, and after she was killed. The majority of 'After' is told from her supposed killer point of view, her step-father, during his murder trial. This is where I feel the story got bogged down, the back and forth dialog was ... blah. 3☆ |
Maggie Ippoliti lost the custody of her daughter Anna almost seventeen years ago after neing diagnosed with postpartum psychosis. Her ex-husband moved to France and she hasn’t seen her daughter since. Now she is happily married to Dr. Noah Alderman, a widower and the father of a young boy. When Maggie’s ex-husband and family is killed in a plane crash, Anna comes to move in with her mother and family. Things begin to go from good to bad to worse for Noah as Anna accuses him of unspeakable things. The story is told from both Maggie’s point of view when Anna moves in with them and Noah’s point of view during and after the trial. A fascinating concept and I was enthralled by the whole experience and realized things didn’t seem right. Adding to the mystery, was some thrills, but by the conclusion, everything seem to move too quickly and the resolution to manufactured. I loved 95% of the book. That last 5% ruined it for me unfortunately. |
Marialyce W, Reviewer
4 kept me reading stars This was my first book by this author and I have to say that I did like what I read. The story, although it did have a few hiccups at the end, flowed well and kept this reader fully engaged until the last page was read. Maggie and Noah have recently married. Noah is a doctor and a widowed father of a ten year old son. Maggie, his wife, formerly suffered from postpartum psychosis after the birth of her daughter, Anna, with her first husband. This rare illness causes Maggie to lose custody of her daughter, She also loses any kind of contact with Anna. Anna's father, who had divorced Maggie, is a very wealthy man living in France and as Anna grows she is sent to a boarding school in Maine. However, Anna is searching for her birth mother and when Maggie gets word of her search and connects with her, she travels to the boarding school. to meet her. Anna is so unhappy and lonely at the school that Maggie decides to bring Anna home with her and incorporate her into her fairly new family without consulting her husband. Anna is seventeen, and due to a fatal accident that happened to her father, she is quite a wealthy girl. One would think that all would go ever so well and that is what Maggie hoped for. However, things start to go downhill very quickly as Anna targets Noah and there develops a "he said, she said" scenario of sexual abuse. As the story continues things get ever worse for Noah and it seems to be up to Maggie to discover the truth. This truth is ever so dark and one that she is not prepared for. Can this family be saved? This was an exciting domestic thriller that although had some holes in the story line, it keep me quite interested in the outcome. Thank you to Lisa Scottoline, St Martin's Press, and NetGalley for an advanced copy of this riveting novel. |
Stepfather (Noah) accused of murdering his stepdaughter (Anna). Did he do it? Or, is there something more sinister at play? Perhaps "something darker than she ever could have imagined." After suffering from postpartum psychosis, an extreme form of postpartum depression, Maggie lost custody of her six month old daughter, Anna, to her ex-husband, Florian. Seventeen years later (after the tragic death of Florian, his wife, and kids), Anna reached out to Maggie, and both were beyond thrilled to reunite. After spending much of her childhood living at a boarding school, Anna was excited to have a "real" family. Unfortunately, as soon as she moved in with Maggie, her husband, Noah, and Noah's 10 year old son, Caleb, Anna's relationship with Noah was rocky, tumultuous, and volatile. In fact, when Maggie asked Noah, "When did you turn into such a control freak? ... Noah had an answer, except one that was unsayable: After Anna." Told in alternating timelines (aka "Before Anna" and "After Anna") and perspectives (Maggie and Noah), this story follows Maggie's reunion with Anna and Noah's murder trial. If you enjoy courtroom dramas and twisty thrillers, then be sure to read After Anna! Thank you to the author, the publisher, and NetGalley for a free advance copy of this book! All opinions are my own. |
Prepare to take a thrilling ride as you read Lisa Scottoline's newest book, "After Anna" which will have you immediately hooked! Dr. Noah Alderman and his wife Maggie Ippolitti have a happy marriage and family life as they care for Caleb, Noah's son. Although they are happy, Maggie struggles with the fact that she has not seen her 17 year old daughter, Anna, since she lost custody to her ex-husband after suffering from postpartum psychosis many years beforoe. Reeling with regret and the inevitable "what if's" that haunt her, Maggie focuses on the happy she has in her life. Then one day, she hears from Anna. Things get turned upside down once Anna moves in with Noah, Maggie, and Caleb. Things change quickly, and Maggie begins to question everything she thought she knew about her husband and their seemingly happy life together. This story is told from the perspective of both Noah and Maggie and is written so well, you can't help but keep reading. As the perspective changes, questions come to mind, which are then answered or prompt more questions as the other person's perspective comes into focus. There were times I thought I knew what was going to happen, but as I neared the end of the book, I realized I was not only wrong, but didn't even suspect this book would end the way it did. My biggest advice...clear your schedule! You will not want to put this book down! Thank you NetGalley, St. Martin's Press, and Lisa Scottoline for the opportunity to read and review this amazing book prior to publication! |
Becky B, Reviewer
From the first page I knew this would be a fantastic read! Always one of my favorite authors, Lisa Scottoline, does not fail to deliver. Every time I thought I had the ending figured out there was a twist that threw it all up in the air again! |
I am never disappointed by Lisa Scottoline, but this one just might be my favorite so far by her. I really enjoyed the way this story was told from the two different perspectives: before the murder and after the murder. It kept me guessing and I wasn't sure what the outcome was going to be. I order Scottoline's books for my coworkers at school and have some high school students that enjoy them as well. Another job well done! |
I feel like I must have read a different book than a majority of the previous reviewers for I spent a bulk of my time thinking how poorly this book was written. Both the beginning and the ending were ridiculously and unrealistically compressed. Maggie gets a phone call early in the week that her estranged daughter (who thinks Maggie physically abused her as an infant) wants to meet her. The conversation is stilted and fake. They sound like 2 teenage girls who find out they both have crushes on the same One Direction singer (pick a boy band). They meet for dinner that Friday night. After dinner (on a Friday night) Maggie meets with Anna's therapist who completely agrees that Anna should move in with Maggie and her family immediately. What? No therapy sessions for the two of them? No scheduled visits and then weekends, etc? No slow acclimation and getting to know each other? This is not reality. And what about Anna thinking she was abused? Isn't the therapist worried about those thoughts? I could go on but you get the point. Later that same night, Maggie meets Anna's trust attorney. Now he doesn't really have much authority so that wasn't as ridiculous as the therapist. But what time is it at this point? And then the next day they skip home. Oh, wait, I forgot: Maggie called and let her husband know that Anna was coming home with her. Yep! No conversation. He hasn't met her. Totally realistic, right? The story goes on from there. You can read the summary to know how it all goes downhill. Downhill to the ending which was just as unbelievable, contrived, and magically time compressed as the beginning. It really makes me sad to give this 1 star. The previous book I read from Ms. Scottoline I gave 5 stars. I don't get it. |
Reviewer 287317
Great read...twists that I didn’t expect and it kept me glued. |
3.5 stars! Thank you to Netgalley & St Martins press for this ARC, in exchange for my honest review. The story alternates chapters, Before Anna and After Anna! Anna is Maggie's teenage daughter, who she lost custody of as an infant and was estranged from until now. Anna's father dies in a plane crash and she calls Maggie out of the blue after no contact for all these years. Maggie is happily married to Noah and raising his son Caleb when their life is turned upside down with Anna's arrival. The "before" chapters talk about Noah & Maggie's life, relationship and how it is affected when Anna arrives. She is only moved in for 3 weeks when she is found murdered. The "after" chapters are all in the court room, after Noah is charged with her death. This was definitely a 3 star book for me, I found it somewhat unbelievable and hokey at times - until the last 60 pages! It really picked up and made me think, okay now its finally getting good! |








