Cover Image: The Library Book

The Library Book

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Great narrative nonfiction. I loved the history of the Central Library and found it even more fascinating than the mystery behind the fire!

Was this review helpful?

Rambling narrative with no resolution. Made me feel like reading this book was not a good use of my time.

I received a free e-galley from netgalley.com.

Was this review helpful?

‘The Library Book’ by Susan Orlean documents the devastating fire that raged for seven hours at Los Angeles Public Library in April 1986 and destroyed or damaged over one million books. Investigators quickly concluded that the fire was probably an arson attack but the cause has never been solved and the main suspect, Harry Peak, was arrested but never charged.

The fire broke out just as the news about the Chernobyl disaster became known around the world. Interestingly, while publications such as Pravda remained silent about the worst nuclear accident in history, it found space to cover the Los Angeles library fire in some detail, whereas Chernobyl dominated media coverage across the rest of the world and the fire was overlooked and forgotten relatively quickly. Orlean’s book will hopefully bring this episode to light for a new audience of those like me who had never heard about it before.

As well as the fire itself and the aftermath, Orlean weaves in the history of Los Angeles Public Library and the colourful characters who ran it from when it was founded in 1872. Ray Bradbury, author of the most famous novel about book burning ‘Fahrenheit 451’, was a frequent visitor in his youth. Orlean also covers the history of libraries in general and library fires. An estimated 100 million books were burned by the Nazis and even though the destruction of libraries might be an inefficient way of waging war from a military perspective, the deliberate destruction of books still has enormous emotional and cultural resonance.

The true crime element of ‘The Library Book’ sees Orlean explore the investigation surrounding Harry Peak’s alleged involvement in starting the fire. It is left to the reader to decide for themselves whether or not he was a deluded, attention-seeking fantasist or a practised liar. However, ‘The Library Book’ is predominantly a tribute to the public institutions at the heart of communities around the world and Orlean provides a thoughtful and thorough examination of the value of libraries as one of the few public spaces which can be used by anyone at no cost. The themed library catalogue listings complete with Dewey decimal numbers at the beginning of each chapter are also a nice touch.

‘The Library Book’ is an excellent piece of narrative non-fiction and it goes without saying that I would recommend it to bibliophiles everywhere. Many thanks to Simon & Schuster for sending me a copy of ‘The Library Book’ via NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

Honestly, even as a fan of history and non-fiction, this was a little TOO granular. It was a bit like watching something happen in instant replay (to borrow a sports term) from... every... single... angle. I was not enticed to finish it, though the writing was excellent.

Was this review helpful?

The Library Book is mandatory reading for every book lover. I work exclusively with libraries and this book struck a particular sweet spot with me. It serves as an illustration of how fundamental libraries are to a community and explores what they mean. I can't recommend this book enough!

Was this review helpful?

I feel like this book was written specifically for me. A whole book about books, the library and an unsolved crime. Everything I love in one well written and witty package. I have always been a huge library lover and learning not only about the history of the Los Angeles library but the future of library's world wide was awe inspiring. I can not recommend this book enough.

Was this review helpful?

I started this as an eBook courtesy of NetGalley, but finished with audio. As a librarian, of course I enjoyed this! There are so many quotable parts that I actually checked out the physical book as well, and read some aloud at a library conference.

Now I only wish that I could visit the Goodhue Building! It was interesting how Orlean wove a bit of women's history, California history, and more through the book. At times, I felt there was more detail than necessary (the listing of books burned went on for several miles as I listened, and I'm not sure if I'll need all that info on arson ever again.)

It was very ironic that as I was finishing the book, the fire at Notre Dame happened, so I found myself drawing parallels: unknown cause so far (will they ever know?), loss of irreplaceable things, yet an astonishing number were saved.

Some of the parts I found the most interesting: the telethon to raise money after the fire, some of the personalities, the map collection, the depictions of librarians. The long section on arson right before the end felt like it was keeping me from the end, but I agreed with Orlean's conclusion in regards to Harry Peak's innocence or guilt. Orleans herself read the book, which made it seem as if she were telling the story (she was).

With all of Orleans' visits and research, I was somewhat surprised that she didn't see a connection between Legos and the current influx of makerspaces; maybe she does now!

Was this review helpful?

This looked like a great book, but unfortunately it was archived before I could read it. I will pay more attention to that before requesting. Thank you.

Was this review helpful?

As I was born the same year, I had never heard of the fire at the Los Angeles Public Library. Here, Susan Orlean set out to tell the whole story of the fire, but she ends up telling the entire history of the LAPL. And both stories - that just of the fire and the entire history - are fascinating, illuminating, and hilariously full of eccentric characters. Along the way, she intersperses anecdotes of her time spent in the LAPL of today, and I must say she did a marvelous job of capturing the true essence of the modern public library and steered well away from the stereotypes and misconceptions I frequently see. She is a true library lover from a young age, and it shows - from the well-researched story she presents to the marvelous descriptions of the library itself. A must read for everyone!

Was this review helpful?

What might have been a mere factual account of a library disaster has instead proven to be a book that soars with incandescent writing and is an homage to libraries and books. For anyone who is fond of reading, of libraries and of the role they play in our society, this book will resonate. But even those who aren’t enamored of miles of book shelves and helpful librarians, Orlean’s writing sparkles with interesting anecdotes and people who enliven the story of the Los Angeles Public Library that suffered tremendous loss from a disastrous fire in 1986. It is artful the way the book holds the reader's interest and recounts so many details of the fire as it destroys countless treasures.

Personally having a connection to the topic was the initial incentive for reading this book, but it surpassed all expectations. Orlean has an exceptional way with words. Her descriptions are lyrical and profound. She is gifted at writing about the essential role libraries play in the lives of individuals who utilize a library’s resources – both physical and human. This is a true testament to a public establishment that often is overlooked for the essential role it has played throughout time. Clearly, the author is a champion of reading and libraries and her book should inspire everyone with its enthusiasm and poignant love for an institution that is crucial to our society.

Was this review helpful?

I am obsessed with this book and all things library! This one is now at the top of my all-time nonfiction favorites and I will surely be buying it for my librarian friends as a gift.

Was this review helpful?

I honestly thought that I was going to enjoy this book but I just couldn't get into it. It was dry, boring, and I had to force myself to read about 40 pages before I couldn't take it any longer and didn't finish.

Was this review helpful?

Being the book lover that I am, I love love love libraries. As a child, this is where I spent most of my free time when I wasn't hanging out with my friends. The thought of my childhood library burning down, would have devastated me as a child (and let's be honest, if my current library burned down I would be just as sad)

At first, I had said that I would not give feedback to this title. However, after finding it on my Kindle app again, I realized that I actually really did want to read this one!

I had never heard of the fire that burned down the Los Angeles library (I blame it on living in Belgium). It took me a while to finish it, but in the end I did enjoy it!

Was this review helpful?

Superb book; narrative non-fiction at its best. Beginning with the devastating fire at the LA Public Library in April 1986, Susan Orlean, a very fine journalist, explores every aspect a tragedy of this magnitude exposes, from the thoughts and feelings of library employees, to the workings of public libraries in general and the weaknesses inherent in these systems. And what avid reader wouldn't be enthralled and horrified by such a story!

Was this review helpful?

"You don't need to take a book off a shelf to know there is a voice inside that is waiting to speak to you, and behind that was someone who truly believed that if he or she spoke, someone would listen. It was that affirmation that always amazed me. Even the oddest, most particular book was written with that kind of crazy courage - the writer's belief that someone would find his or her book important to read. I was struck by how precious and foolish and brave that belief is, and how necessary, and how full of hope it is to collect these books and manuscripts and preserve them. It declares that all these stories matter, and so does every effort to create something that connects us to one another, and to our past and to what is still to come."
This book spoke to me. I enjoyed this book quite a bit. Susan Orlean writes a lot of her observations as she tries to understand what happened during the fire in the Los Angeles Public Library in April of 1986. She visits different departments of the library, interviews many different people who worked there over the years and researches the history of the library since it's beginning.
The book starts off by introducing Harry Peak, the main suspect of the library fire in 1986. Then it delves into the different directors of the library over the years and their main areas of focus. From there it goes to libraries over the world, how libraries have changed and evolved into what they are today, and what they can become in the future.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book. I appreciated the various observations the author shares without a bias. I like that it wasn't just on the Los Angeles Public Library fire, but it delved into deeper and more substantive topics about libraries in general.
If you are a book lover, a history buff, a library nerd, or anything in between, this is the book for you!

Was this review helpful?

Not going to lie - I struggled to get into this book. But I'm thoroughly glad that I stuck with it and gave it a bunch of tries until it crawled under my skin and into my heart. Incredibly well researched and beautifully told, Susan Orlean has written something special here. Get past the first 50 pages. You won't regret it.

Was this review helpful?

I felt this book was very much aimed at people who love books but weren't librarians. I was very engaged in the first half, the initial fire, the devastation (it was incredibly well written and heartbreaking), but the second half I felt was stuff I perhaps already knew, and so was less interested. All in all though, very well written and engaging.

Was this review helpful?

A wonderful book in so many ways. I lived in LA when the fire happened, and worked high up in a building two blocks away. We watched nervously as the building burned. Fires in LA are almost always scary: this was among the scariest of all.

Was this review helpful?

This is perfect for those who love libraries or love to read.

As a librarian, I found it interesting. I was not able to fully download it and so I also did the audio. Susan Orlean isn't the best narrarator and I found myself really bored with the book because of it. I didn't enjoy it as much as I wanted to because of that.

I also wish there was more on Harry and how he dealt with the fire afterwards, especially after being accused. I felt like the book just dropped him.

Was this review helpful?

What a delightful read for a librarian. Or really, for anyone who loves libraries and books. I'm so glad I found it.

Was this review helpful?