Cover Image: The Clockmaker's Daughter

The Clockmaker's Daughter

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

So I finally finished this. I usually like Kate Morton's books but, unfortunately, I found this one a great struggle. The main reason for this is that the story has so many characters it becomes fragmented and disjointed at times. For me, the most frustrating was that when I started to get into a character's story it got cut off and only resumed much later somewhere in the book if you managed to connect all the dots. It's a good story and it's well-written but has some passages that are too long and a structure I, personally, don't like. You need to have lots of time to read this in one go if you want to enjoy it.

Was this review helpful?

THE CLOCKMAKER’S DAUGHTER by KATE MORTON

I have always loved Kate Morton’s books from the time I read the House at Riverton. She is a real story teller and she really paints a picture with words so that you feel as if you are actually there. Her characters are larger than life and she writes with real empathy for the people she writes about. I have always loved the way her stories weave about from one period in time to another. However, although I enjoyed the Clockmaker’s Daughter I felt she had almost gone too far with this. In many ways this book is very confusing. I was particularly puzzled when Leonard was introduced to the story half way through the book and it took me ages to work out where he fitted in. There is also the name change of Birdy and so working out who was who was tricky. There are so many different periods of time in the book from present day to World War 1, World War 2 and beyond, that it was difficult to keep track of who was who and what period of time it was. It was a very long book which is what she tends to write and it took me a few weeks to read as I have not had much spare time for reading lately. I think it would have been better to have been able to read it quickly as it would have been easier to keep up with the story. Overall it was a pleasing story with lots of intrigue but not my favourite by this author.

Was this review helpful?

I have read 2 other books by Kate Morton, thoroughly enjoyed them, and really looked forward to starting this one. I am so disappointed. I found that it was nowhere as riveting as the other books, in fact I found it hard to follow the story threads. Sorry this one is just not for me.

Was this review helpful?

I'm so sorry. There are lots of fans out there that I'm about to annoy.
Indeed, the story is beautifully written. The descriptions and the details are superb. But I felt I needed a spreadsheet to keep track of all the characters and eventually I gave up.
And I really wanted to love it!
Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for the ARC

Was this review helpful?

Edward Radcliffe is an artist, his muse and lover Lily Millington, a girl with a blemished past. Birchwood Manor is also a muse of sorts - it pulls at Edward's memories and he purchases it. Then follows a summer of tragedy and mystery - the shooting of Edward's fiancée Fanny, and the disappearance of Lily alongside that of a valuable diamond, the Radcliffe Blue.

Years later, an archivist, Elodie Winslow, arrives at the Manor and slowly the house reveals its secrets.

A lot of characters, and narrative that flips back and forth through time, but a great read - stick with it, I found the second half much more compelling and gripping than the first.

Was this review helpful?

I have read a number of Kate Morton books in the past and enjoyed them so was looking forward to reading this one.

Unfortunately for me this is not one of her better ones. This for me was three stories that loosely tied together, but it was a bit of a push.

In fact, one stories was so flimsy I was left wondering why it was included as for me it added nothing extra to the novel.

The ghost theme did not gain enough momentum, and all in all I felt that this was a damp squib. To long and with too many threads.

Was this review helpful?

The Clockmaker’s Daughter by Kate Morton is about a murder in the summer of 1862 and in present day a young lady trying to make sense of of the mystery. I enjoy reading this author's books but this story was a little slow for me and didn't have the charm of her previous books.
I would like to thank NetGalley and Pan McMillan for my e-copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Another beautifully told story by Kate Morton. This book as always has been really well thought out and really cleverly put together. My only gripe is that I found it to be a bit long in places.

Thank you to Netgalley for my copy.

Was this review helpful?

Kate Morton is one of my absolute favourites. I found the start of this book difficult to get into - I'll be honest. But once I persevered the strands started to come together. Lovely descriptive passages and writing. Not a speedy or easy read but a very interesting one. Looking forward to the next book from this clever writer. .

Was this review helpful?

Kate Morton is one of those writers that i've always felt convinced I'd love, so have two of her previous novels on my shelves waiting to be read. She also seems to be one of those writers that I never got around to reading, perhaps because her books are so flipping big! Very happy to report that this was as pleasant a read as I'd hoped for.
I'll get my only real gripe out of the way first, and as it seemed to irk a few other reviewers I don;t think it'll come as a surprise, but wow, there are a lot of characters to keep track of! I really admire the way that Morton weaves together all of their stories, and it felt satisfying witnessing her pulling all of the different threads together, but at times, as a reader, it could feel quite cumbersome and a tiny bit of a slog, and it can't help but remove you from the flow of a story when you have to pause to try and remember who this person was, or why that person did that. That being said, the characters did pop out of the page, they were so realistic, and I was happy to spend time with them. The thing that really helped keep it all together for me though was the location - Birchwood Manor. This place was like a character of it's own, and it was fantastic. I want to buy it and live there. I felt invested in the people, I wanted them to find their way in their lives, and I really enjoyed meeting people at different points in their lives and seeing the effects of previous actions.
Birchwood Manor is a magical, haunted place, so I can fully appreciate this will be a popular read upon it's release in a few months as the nights start drawing in, but i'm so pleased I got the chance to read it now, as the descriptions of the house and it's setting felt so fresh and bright that it felt right to read it during these hot summer days we've been having.

Thanks to NetGalley and Pan Macmillan for my copy in return for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Elodie works as an archivist in London when she stumbles upon a sketchbook that unlocks a mystery at a house and a complex love triangle. To Elodie, the house represents her childhood and she is convinced she recognises the house.

I was so excited to start this, finally another book by Morton that I relished getting stuck into. However, I could not get stuck into this, disappointingly I did not develop a connection to the plot or the characters really and I fought to keep up with it. This has quite a slow start which may have contributed to the problem, for me it never really got going and I was bored at multiple times throughout. 

Morton does have a skill at depicting beautiful houses and landscapes and this is no different, I was transported to the house Elodie discovers. Morton also seamlessly entwines the past with the present, mixing the two together, until there is an overlap. 

The characters in this are good and certainly interesting but again I struggled to connect with them and to care about what was happening. In this instance, the past was superior to the present and Elodie is almost left for large portions of the book. Eventually I was connected to the plot and characters, the last fifty odd pages were gripping and I enjoyed seeing how it all tied up, but that is about it. 

'The Clockmaker's Daughter' is okay but not as good as Morton's other reads. 

Thank you to Netgalley and Pan Macmillan for an advance copy.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley for an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.. I was so exited to receive this, being a huge Kate Morton fan from the very beginning. “The House at Riverton” was superb, followed by the even better “The Forgotten Garden”. Kate Morton, in my eyes could do no wrong. But oh dear ! I’m afraid that this review is going to echo many similar. I can’t believe I’m only giving three stars and that with an effort. Two and a half would have been more accurate. What has gone wrong this time?

A great idea for a story and the usual beautifully written prose. I was tempted to note a few memorable passages to include in this review but there were just so many, But that‘s it. Obviously a lot of research has gone into the work, e.g. literary references to the likes of T S Elliot and Dickens. But naming the group of artists “The Magenta Brotherhood“ was, I thought, a little cringe worthy, given that the real and world renowned Pre Raphaelite Brotherhood were in existence at the same time.

The book begins with a slow but imaginative opening chapter, but it failed to grip me from the word go. I was about 25% in before. I began to engage with anyone, then the story changed tack and time and we were asked to connect with different characters. First it was one person’s story and then another’s and in between all of them a ghost kept popping up. To begin with I wasn’t totally clear where she came into the story. There’s an old country house and estate of the type which frequently features very successfully in Kate Morton’s books, but this time even this failed to exert the usual charm and atmosphere. About 60 % through the book began to make sense and I was able to engage. Remember the title. “The Clockmaker’s Daughter” which with a Kindle edition one loses, and it will become clear. She and Birchwood Manor hold the various disparate stories together. The ghost can’t leave the house so inside the narration is in the first person and outside in the third, which just adds to the confusion..

Having conceived an excellent idea for a book, has the author perhaps got bogged down in it and lost the clear track of the story ? It’s rambling and ill disciplined with too many character and too much time invested in each of their stories. This reader couldn’t connect with anybody or anything.. Let’s just hope that the real Kate Morton will be back on form in the next novel.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to netgalley.co.uk for providing me with a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest and open review.

The Clockmaker's Daughter is the first book I requested from NetGalley where I knew the author and have read books by them before; I even have another book by Kate Morton that has been sitting on my shelf for over a year. So far I have had mixed reviews of her work, but I still had high hopes for this one. I'm glad to say that these hopes were met as a book as big as six hundred pages was still able to hold my attention like this one.

I thought this book was exceptionally well written as Morton guides us through the different time periods with success as I did not feel lost while reading the novel.

So far, this is my favourite novel of Morton and I can't wait to get around to the book sitting on my shelf.

Was this review helpful?

I am a big fan of Kate Morton 's books, so I was thrilled for the opportunity to review this ARC! I was also a bit worried, as I know that the author likes to follow a certain writing style, with different timelines interwoven to create a multi voice narrative. I was not sure if I wouldn't find it too repetitive, too samey, too predictable. But somehow, although the multiple narrators are still there, Kate Morton managed to surprise me again.

"The Clockmaker's Daughter" is a mysterious, haunting story of a certain house and it's occupants. It starts with a discovery made by archivist in 2017 of a satchel, a photograph and a sketchbook with a drawing of the house. We then go back to 1862, when a group of artists led by talented Edward Radcliffe spent a blissful summer in Birchwood Manor, before the tragedy led to the demise of the house and its owner. But who is the mysterious narrator of the story and what other secrets are sleeping hidden in Birchwood Manor?

Although I was not very convinced by the contemporary heroine, Elodie, (I admit I was exasperated over her lack of spine and inability to make any decisions!), all the other characters were very engaging and I genuinely cared what happened to them. I must say that I absolutely loved the book and I have found the premise of it fascinating - it is not so much a story of the mystery being solved after hundreds of years, but also a history of the house in its pivotal moments, a tale of lost identity, unexplained disappearance, a theft, a tragic love story, With so many pieces to juggle with it could have finished badly, but somehow the story flows, the mood darkens, the summers swelter and only Birchwood Manor is a constant reminder that certain places and people haunt us forever.

Was this review helpful?

I have always enjoyed Kate Morton's books and was definitely not disappointed with this new title. The story starts in the modern day with Elodie cataloguing a box of miscellaneous items, but she realises there is more to this box than she first thought. Over the course of the book we learn about the history of one particular property in an idyllic setting on a bend of the River Thames, Birchwood Manor. From the time when the house was first seen by the artist Edward Radcliffe right up to the modern day, we are taken on a journey of the inhabitants of the house and their experiences within the walls of this beautiful building. As always, the the characters are varied and we are treated to a magnificent variety of situations that befall them. I was hooked on this book from the first page and would recommend it to those who enjoy becoming fully engrossed in a time travelling tale of mystery and suspense. It is not until the end of the book that the final part of the puzzle is revealed and slots into place to reveal the full story.

Many thanks to both the publishers and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this book in advance of publication in return for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I have very much enjoyed all the Kate Morton books I have read, and this one is no exception.
It has a similar feel to her other books, but this one has several different narrative threads rather than the usual dual time line. We start with the story of Elodie, living in present day London. She finds a sketch pad belonging to a Pre-Raphaelite painter and a photo of his muse. There was a tragedy at a house party, when a valuable diamond was stolen and his Fiancee was shot, sending him into depression. The story then takes us through the history of the house, Birchwood Manor, on the banks of the Thames, and several different generations living there, from Ada Lockwood, who attended when it was a girls school to Juliet (Elodie's Great-Grandmother) who went there with her children to escape the Blitz.
These different threads to the story mean it can read as several different stories ,that all centre around the house but I liked each one, however it makes the story slightly less compelling than other books of hers. Of course it all comes together in the end.

**Thanks to Netgalley for a copy of this book in exchange for a review**

Was this review helpful?

Such a long rambling book. It felt like reading lots of different stories in one book. I began to think that what had seemed to be the main character in the beginning would never reappear. As the book meandered to a conclusion I was struck at how improbable the loss of life in it had been. A very unsatisfactory read.

Was this review helpful?

Kate Morton never fails to disappoint. She is the master of historical fictions, interconnected narrations and character histories, family sagas and mystery .
The writing is always beautiful, vivid, and descriptive. Making you feel like you have transported in time.
This is my favourite Morton novel to date.

Was this review helpful?

I am huge Kate Morton fan having read all her books and this didn't disappoint.
The story is a beautiful interleaving of several stories all based around Birchwood Manor and although a different means of story telling for the author the story pulls you in and I was gripped from the start and I loved the slightly open ending.
A beautiful story by a fabulous author

Was this review helpful?

Kate Morton is on top form,
Great book with great character's that flow together well, the storyline is put together well and I felt really drawn in to the book.
The description on the house made me almost believe I could see it.
In one word.....fantastic!

Was this review helpful?