Cover Image: Saving Meghan

Saving Meghan

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Die 48-jährige Immobilienmaklerin Becky Gerard hat gerade das Flugzeug von Boston nach Los Angeles betreten. Ihre kränkelnde15-jährige Tochter Meghan lässt sie nicht gerne bei ihrem Mann Carl zurück, aber ihre Mutter liegt im Sterben und trotz einer schwierigen Beziehung seit Kindertagen, will sie in ihren letzten Stunden bei ihr sein.

Doch noch bevor das Flugzeug starten kann, muss ihr Mann plötzlich mit der Tochter ins Krankenhaus, da sie beim Spielen bewusstlos geworden ist. Becky erkämpft sich hysterisch den Weg raus aus dem Flugzeug, hin zu ihrer Tochter ins Krankenhaus, obwohl es ihr schnell wieder besser geht. Sie eilt in die Notaufnahme.

Sie setzt wieder mal Himmel und Hölle in Bewegung obwohl die Familie die Arztbesuch, Untersuchungen und Tests schon gar nicht mehr zählen kann und der Notarzt nur eine Dehydrierung diagnostiziert hat. Ihr Mann ist da nicht ganz dabei, er ist etwas skeptischer. Er hält es für möglich, dass seine Frau die Symptome auf die Tochter reflektiert.

Wenig später daheim, nach einem weiteren Streit der Eltern, stellt sich zu Beckys großer Freude heraus, dass auch ihr Mann trotz seines Unglaubens recherchiert hat und eine neue mögliche Erkrankung und einen anderen Arzt gefunden hat. So wird Doktor Zachary Fisher eingeführt.

Später bekommen sich dann sogar die verschiedenen Ärzte in die Haare. Ist es eine seltene unheilbare Krankheit, psychosomatisch verursacht oder liegt hier gar ein Münchhausen Syndrom vor? Die Entwicklung ist sehr spannend und berührend, man liest gefesselt weiter. Auch Zach steckt in dem Fall mit mehr Emotionen drin, als für einen Arzt gut ist. Es ist überwältigend, wie sich all solche aufgestauten emotionalen Probleme manifestiert und sogar andere Menschen mit aus der Bahn werfen können.

Nach dem ersten Drittel konnte ich dann leider aus persönlichen Gründen nicht mehr weiter lesen. Der Inhalt hat mich zu sehr berührt und aufgewühlt, was aber wiederum für die Qualität der Geschichte spricht...

Was this review helpful?

**Thank you to the Publisher and NetGalley for an advanced reader copy to review**
Once I started Saving Meghan, I simply could not/would not put it down! I read it over a day, taking breaks here and there to attend to my family and complete necessary tasks.
15-year old Meghan has been in and out of the hospital time and time again over the past few years. Doctors have performed test after test and cannot find anything wrong with her. Yet her parents insist on getting a diagnosis. Becky, Meghan's mother is her protector, calling her an attentive parent would be a huge understatement. On the brink of possibly finding a diagnosis, a GI specialist at the hospital, brings up concerns that Becky might have Munchausen Syndrome and that Meghan may not actually be sick. Becky and Meghan's Dad, Carl must then fight the system in order to prove that Meghan has an illness and needs treatment.
I became completely engrossed in the story from the start, needing to know what was going on. I went back and forth a few times, disbelieving one character after another. There were a few twists, and I didn't see the ending coming. Saving Meghan is a compelling, suspenseful page-turner that will suck you in from the start!

Was this review helpful?

Becky Gerard is on a mission to find out what is wrong with her daughter Megan. Becky learned from her Mother at a very young age to manipulate the medical profession to get what she wants and right now she wants confirmation Megan has a little know rare disease. Becky's husband Carl believes Becky has gone too far in pushing for a cause of Megan's illness. To complicate matters, Megan is keeping something from her Mother that is adding to her distress. Is Becky making Megan sick? It makes you wonder just how far you would go if it were your child.

This is an interesting book with lots of twists and turns that keep you guessing until close to the end. I did like how the author tied up all the loose ends at the end of the book. The characters were well developed and rang true. The character Becky was so complex I could never tell who she really was. I did like the character Zach but I didn't like the ending. I would have hoped for something better for the doctor! This would make a good movie.

I would recommended the book.

I voluntarily reviewed an ARC of this novel.

Was this review helpful?

This is a family driven drama with a hint of suspense/mystery. At first captivated by the plot and writing, I was totally on board and immersed in the writing. Where was Palmer taking us. So many different directions ... was Meghan sick? Was it a case of Munchausen by Proxy? Somewhere in the middle it just started to bog down for me. It became repetitive and even though I figured out what was actually happening, it became inconceivable, was it really going to go in that direction? Entertaining, but a bit beyond belief.

Was this review helpful?

Not knowing why your child is constantly sick is a huge dilemma for a parent. You run from one doctor to the next searching for the reason, the why of your child's constant sickness. Your child suffers, your marriage suffers, and you, the mother, suffer so fearful of the unknown, thinking that someway somehow cancer is the malady.

Becky Gerard, has so much to contend with, her mother dying, a husband who seems disinterested, a daughter, Meghan, who is constantly ill. When on her way to say goodbye to her ailing mother, she receives a frantic phone call from her husband, she scurries to the hospital where Megan has been taken and so begins a chain of events that will have a devastating outcome.

The question that plagues all of them is why is Meghan always sick when there seems to be no medical cause for it? What seems likes dozens of doctors, visits and hospital stays have produced little more than frustration, worry, and a nagging feeling that something is terribly wrong. Then however, one doctor in the hospital where Meghan has been brought, seems to have an answer, mitochondrial disease. Unfortunately, this disease is very difficult to diagnose and since over time Meghan has developed an aversion to needles, there is trepidation to the procedure to find out if indeed it might be mitochondrial disease.

There is, on the other hand, something else which might be occurring. The mother begins to be suspected of Munchausen's By Proxy Disease, an psychological illness where a caretaker imagines and ultimately foster illness upon the one in their care, seeking attention, drawing sympathy, all in an attempt to make people feel sorry for them. Is this ultimately what Becky is doing? Is there really no illness suffered by Meghan but the desire of her mother for her to be sick?

There are other forces afoot and as the hospital, the mother, and the doctors fight over Meghan's care, the father seems to withdraw further until the ultimate happens and Meghan is placed under the protection of CPS.

This was a different look at how people manipulate and see conditions that are sometimes not there. It is also a look at the devious nature of some as they twist things to achieve what they want. This was a quick enjoyable story but I will admit it had some flaws. It seemed at times to be long winded and overplayed. The writing was good, but the story line at times had me rolling my eyes. There were details that were somewhat far fetched but overall the shocking conclusion at the end carries this story.

Recommended to those who like a psychological thriller and family dramas.
Thanks you to D.J. Palmer, St Martin's Press, and NetGalley for a copy of this book due to be published on April 9, 2019.

Was this review helpful?

A medical "thriller" revolving around a daughter, Meghan, who is continually sick, and her mother, Becky, who was raised by a mother who taught her to cheat the system and get disability. Throughout the first 80% of this story I was trying to figure out if Meghan was really sick or if she was afflicted with Munchausen by proxy. The last 20% took a rapid departure from the original storyline and got bizarre. People were murdered.....there was a kidnapping. This one just wasn't for me. Thanks to Netgalley for the opportunity to review!

Was this review helpful?

Saving Meghan, by DJ Palmer

Short Take: Ripped from the headlines! But like, not in a lame way.


I know it’ll come as a shock to some of you, but I occasionally look at things that aren’t books. Don’t get me wrong, fiction is my longest-running love, but once in a while, I peek out of my nerd cave and get a look at the real world. I’m not going to go into a political rant (although there are PLENTY of topics ripe for a good one), but believe me when I say that some of the real-life stuff I have seen lately is crazier than fiction.

For example, I’ve been following the case of Susan Schofield Cabana for some time. This psycho has been poisoning her kids with elephant-size doses of antipsychotic drugs for conditions they’ve never been diagnosed with, and documenting it on social media for years. Those kids were recently removed from the home, thankfully, although it’s yet to be determined how much permanent damage their little brains have suffered. And everyone’s heard of Gypsy Blanchard, of “Mommy Dead And Dearest” fame, and Lacey Spears, and who knows how many others.

What I’m getting at is, Munchausen Syndrome by proxy is a very real, very terrifying thing, and the medical community and court system are just now starting to get hip to it. The idea that a mother would intentionally harm her children, and in many cases be rewarded with attention and financial gain is shocking, but it keeps happening, and usually is only discovered when the “nurturing” parent goes too far and accidentally kills the child.

Which is where Saving Meghan comes in. It’s a fairly simple story: sixteen-year-old Meghan’s health has been declining for two years, with no apparent cause. Becky, Meghan’s mother, was raised by her own mother Cora to learn all the tricks of medical manipulation. Cora taught Becky how to cozy up to doctors and fake symptoms in order to keep the disability money rolling in

Now an adult with an increasingly ill child of her own, Becky is willing to use every ploy in her arsenal to get Meghan the help she needs. But IS Meghan sick, or is Becky harming her?

It’s not a complicated question, but Mr. Palmer does an incredible job of surrounding Meghan and Becky with richly complex characters. Carl, her father, is aware of Becky’s past, and although he wants to protect Meghan, she has her own reasons for not trusting him. Dr. Zachary Fisher thinks he may know what’s going on, but he has an agenda of his own, making his motivations questionable and putting him at odds with both colleagues and superiors at the hospital.

And as parents, doctors, and attorneys fight it out, Meghan keeps getting sicker.

In order to stick to my “no spoilers EVER” rule, I’m not going to say anything else about the plot. I mentioned above that the characters are brilliantly drawn, but what really makes Saving Meghan a standout is how well the characters drive the plot, and vice-versa. Becky, Carl, Dr. Fisher, and the others are human and flawed, and even when they are doing the wrong thing, they are doing it from a place that I think most of us can sympathize with.

Now for the bad stuff - I couldn’t get a single thing done till I finished this book. My dirty clothes hamper is overflowing, dirty dishes are piled up, and Vincent the cat had to head-butt me like five times to get his food bowl filled. He will be the first to tell you that’s completely unacceptable. Worst of all, I found myself thinking “unputdownable” and I HATE that “word”, but the lead-up to the final twist demanded it. In other words, this book is so great that it messed up my housekeeping, cat, and brain. Ok, the brain wasn’t in great shape to begin with, but you get the idea.

The Nerd’s Rating: FIVE HAPPY NEURONS (and a snack that is most emphatically NOT chicken soup.)

Was this review helpful?

Thank you St. Martin's Press and Net Galley for an early copy of this Fantastic book. WOW, WOW, WOW. Can I say it once more WOW!!!! I figured out one part pretty early BUT the other main stories in the book were soooooo a roller coaster of a ride. Many emotions on different levels. Just wonderful. Thank you D. J. Palmer for a Great read.

Was this review helpful?

Saving Meghan will keep you on the edge of your seat flipping the pages well into the night! I absolutely loved this book....it was filled with soo many twists and turns throughout the book! Meghan is a teenage girl who has an an illness that can not be diagnosed by any doctor, yet her mother Becky continues to take her to doctor after doctor seeking a diagnosis, and then is accused of Munchausen syndrome by proxy. We as the reader are tasked with determining whether or not this is true, or if there is something else going on that is causing Meghan to have the symptoms that she has. This was a very exciting book to read, and definitely keeps the reader engaged and on the edge of their seat. This is one book that is not to be missed! I would like to thank St. Martin's Press and Netgalley for providing me the opportunity to read and review this book in exchange for my review.

Was this review helpful?

Imagine having a sick child and her parents can't figure out what's wrong with her? After seeing many different doctors and undergoing countless test that are all inconclusive, there are still no answers. Finally the suspicion turns onto the parents. Are one of both of them actually making her sick in order to gain attention? No one can figure out what's wrong with Meghan. Who will help her?

The story is told in several points-of-view and always keeps the reader guessing. The author is masterful at leaving the the reader hanging at the end of every chapter, so the only choice is to continue reading. I almost read the entire book in one sitting because of this. I felt the anguish of the parents, the frustration of the doctors, and the fear from Meghan. The ending seemed a little too unsuspected, and possibly I missed some foreshadowing, but overall I was satisfied with how it ended.

Rating: 4/5 stars

Thank you to St. Martin's Press and NetGalley for a digital ARC of this novel in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Wow! Where to even begin with this book! It was incredibly suspenseful, with twists along the way that I had not anticipated. I was on the edge of my seat and unable to put down this book once I started! I won’t give away any details but will say that the ending was a HUGE twist I did not see coming. If I could give this book 10 stars, I would! Highly, highly recommend it!

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to netgalley and the publisher for an advanced copy in return for an honest review. I'm stuck between 3.5 and 4 stars. It was very slow to start and didn't pick up for me until about halfway through. I'll admit it kept me guessing. I went back and forth #protectmeghan or #believebecky The only question left unanswered for me was what was Meghan hiding in the box her mom found in the closet but never opened?? This was a new author for me...I'd be willing to read something else.

Was this review helpful?

A really amazing book, Meghan is a 15 year old girl who suffers from a series of strange illnesses brought on instantly for a variety of symptoms..

We meet her over protective mother Becky on an airplane bound for California to see her dying mother.. Becky gets a text from her husband informing her that Meghan has fainted. This alarms Becky to the extent that she suddenly demands to be let off the plane while it is about to begin its taxi for takeoff.

She fight with the flight attendants and the air marshal who restrains her and she is forcibly removed from the plane when it returns to the terminal. She faces serious charges until TSA intervenes after listening to her explanation.

Meghan has seen a number of doctors and meets anew one who specializes in Mitochondrial deficiency.
He feels Meghan may have it (his son died from it 5 years before) . He wants to test her but she has a severe fear of needles as result o being subjected to them repeatedly.

When tests rule out a physical reason for her symptoms a new doctor feels her symptoms are psychosomatic.
The doctor feels they are related to some type of stress: Meghan 's secret drinking, a secret she knows about her father or her parent's fighting.

The doctor also feels that Meghan is being harmed by her mother: Munchausen by Proxy. and bans her parents from seeing her while she is being observed in the hospital's behaviorial health unit and subsequently they lose guardianship over her.

Once when her mother is visiting her she tells Meghan if you get sick they'll let you come home. Soon after Meghan develops a severe stomach ache..

The doctor feels the Munchausen issue is brought about mothers having attachment issues. In this case Becky got physically ill when she was working and someone else was taking care of Meghan when she was a baby.

Other factors are losing their son Sammy to SIDS at 4 months of age and Becky's own family history: her mother tricking the government for fake disability payment and using her daughters to lie about her illness symptoms in order to collect disability payments.

A young doctor (s found dead of an apparent heart attack and one of Becky's earring is found nearby..

Becky manipulates the doctors and others to get what she wants: tests for Meghan,

Becky devises a plan with Meghan for her escape.

Becky learns from Meghan about her husband's affair (the secret Meghan knew about her dad).

The doctor is charge of the Mitochondrial deficiency study convinces them to come back to the hospital by telling them there's been a new problem with her condition.

However he is forced to resign from the hospital.

When Becky becomes ill again the doctors think Meghan's dad might be the one making her sick.
He is later discovered dead and is thought to have been trying to kill Meghan and then having Becky face prison for murdering her daughter so he could start a new life with his mistress.
However his mistress had a different plan and kills him. She is actually one of Meghan's doctors and tries to kill Meghan,.
New testing is .done and Meghan is indeed suffering from Mitochondrial deficiency.



.

Was this review helpful?

I really wanted to enjoy this but I found myself flipping pages and skimming. The book got really long and the situations felt so unrealistic. It’s gotten really good reviews so I’m probably in the minority. I like thriller/suspense but this one just didn’t appeal to me. Thanks for the opportunity to read it.

Was this review helpful?

This book was good, but not perfect. 4.25 stars.
*
*
The book centers around Meghan, a 15 year old girl who was formerly healthy before becoming very, very sick over a long period of time. Her mom, Becky, has basically devoted her life to solving the answer - but at high risk to herself. Becky's mom had Munchausen's, a disease where people fake being sick (and if they make other people sick, like their kids, it's Munchausen's by proxy) for the attention. And Becky's dad Cal basically feels like Meghan could just magically make herself better if she just tried a little harder.
*
*
It is very, very hard to review this book without spoilers. Suffice it to say that some aspects of this book were not entirely credible, but the actual writing was so good it mostly made up for it. I really enjoyed most of the story. I wanted to smack some of these characters across the face - but that's part of what made the story so good, believable bad guys. So yes, if you enjoy medical novels (I do), legal dramas (I really do), or family stories with interesting dynamics (I really really do), then you should definitely give this one a shot!
*
*
Thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for both the e-book and physical copy!

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately this book didn't work for me. Meghan and Becky are not written very well, I thought their dialogue was weak and sometimes out of character,

Was this review helpful?

I want to thank St Martin’s Press for the ability to read this advanced copy.

How could I not want to read this book, when the title character has the same name as me! I enjoyed this book very much. The beginning of the book was a little slow for me, but I flew through the second half of the book.

From the start, I felt like Becky was doing what what they were accusing her of doing, especially with the background of her childhood. I really felt for Meghan throughout the book. I wish they explored a little more of her her relationships with her friends that were briefly touched on.

I was surprised by the twists at the end, and I liked the build up getting to the ending. Overall, I enjoyed this book very much.

Was this review helpful?

I was sent this book from the publisher. My ratings and reviews will be my own personal opinions and are in no way influenced by publishers or authors who may have sent me books to review.

Going into Saving Meghan, I knew this story was going to involve Munchausen by Poxy. I was not expecting the medical mystery, legal drama, and the some of the twists and turns along the way. It was really hard to like these characters, and at times I found myself shaking my head with some of the decisions they made. There was a lot of information around procedures and legal aspects that take place within the story.

This story switches between three characters POV: Meghan, her mother Becky, and one of her doctors. I understand the importance of the doctor after reading the whole story, but I did not his parts of the story always relevant to what was going on. Yes, it all ties together around his dedication to finding what is wrong with Meghan, but I could have done without some of it.

Some things I did not see coming such as a murder thrown in and the ending. At times I thought it was one thing happening to Meghan, and a few chapters later I would question my thoughts. It kept my interest and the pacing was great. I ended up finishing this in one day.

Overall, this was not like any other story I read, so I ended up enjoying it.

Was this review helpful?

Wowza! This book was amazing. Thank you Netgalley! The parents of Meghan, Becky and Carl are desperately trying to figure out what is ailing their daughter. She has shown many symptoms but not one doctor has been able to make a diagnosis. In comes Dr. Amanda Nash who comes to the conclusion that Meghan isn’t really physically sick, that she’s actually a victim of Münchausen syndrome by proxy (medical child abuse 😱😱). Is that truly what’s been going on with Meghan? Or is there something even worse lying below the surface of this family? I was totally blown away this book. It has mystery, deception, twists and turns.. everything you look for in a great thriller novel. The character and plot development was great. The ending was like a sucker punch to the gut.. I was that surprised! Definitely pick this one up next month on its release date.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for an eARC of this book.
An interesting read that did at times become tedious. All about a bunch of dysfunctional people, none of whom were likable. The plot is not totally believable but does remain interesting. Somehow I think there are better ways to spend ones time.

Was this review helpful?