Cover Image: Where Secrets Lie

Where Secrets Lie

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

The author wrote a thriller that started with a bang and just kept going! The twists kept coming, so I couldn't put it down. I cannot wait to read more from this author!

Was this review helpful?

Where Secrets Lie, the second novel in the Detective Karen Hart series, is a fascinating, multi-layered whodunit, and right from the beginning I enjoyed the dual storyline; both the cold case that suddenly heats up again thirty years later and the present day crime means there are two different killers to identify, convict and imprison. Butler manages to fool this seasoned crime reader for the duration as it didn't matter how far I read into the story the killers were well hidden. This led to unpredictability when the conclusion arrived after the captivating twists, turns and tension. I enjoyed it more than the previous book and appreciated Ms Hart as an astute and intelligent investigator. She is empathetic and emotionally strong and a force to be reckoned with.

This is a fast-paced and gripping novel that is refreshingly real and the characters flawed and human. Although I had the pleasure to read the predecessor, this works perfectly as a standalone too. I am already looking forward to seeing how things evolve, so roll on the next instalment.

Many thanks to Thomas & Mercer for an ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I really liked this story, even without reading the first book. It kept me guessing! I plan on going to read the first book now!

Was this review helpful?

Where Secrets Lie by DS Butler is the 2nd in the Detective Karen Hart Series

First, let me thank NetGalley, the publisher Thomas & Mercer, and of course the author, for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Series Background (Warning – May contain spoilers from previous books):
DS Karen Hart lost her husband Josh and her daughter Tilly in a car accident. Years later, she struggles to move on, living in the same large house, afraid to move lest her memories of them weaken. She pours her energy into her work. Hart, who relies heavily on her instincts and hunches, has a new boss, DI Scott Morgan, who takes a very logical/fact-based approach to the job (and his life), leaving little room for emotional thoughts. Hart is trying to keep her own emotions in line, while also trying to keep her constables reigned in. DC Sophie Jones is fairly new, and ambitious. DC Rick Cooper is more experienced but dealing with an aging mother. The two constables are constantly bickering.

My Synopsis:
When elderly Albert Johnson takes a fall in his home, the police find, in an upstairs bedroom, the skeletal remains of a body in a suitcase. It is quickly determined that the bones belong to the missing Oliver Fox. He has not been seen for 30 years.

Fox’s family are not exactly forthcoming with information, and his brother is making things worse. Attempting to solve this cold case is further complicated by the fact that the witnesses the team try to interview keep turning up dead. This is no longer a cold case but an active murder investigation.

Meanwhile, Karen’s sister tries to set her up on a blind date, Sophie is thinking about a career change, Rick is trying to understand his mother’s dementia, and DI Morgan’s past is about to become public knowledge.

My Opinions:
This series is getting very good. These books are an easy read, and although I thought the last book moved slowly, this one did not. The pace was good, and there was enough going on that you were never bored.

The characters are getting deeper as we learn their pasts, and we see that they are now becoming a team. The author is slowly building a family of the four detectives, and she is doing a good job.

I m looking forward to the next book!

Was this review helpful?

Old men, an old corpse, old secrets = a cold case for the Linconshire, England police detectives. Who is trying to expose old secrets and who is trying to hide them, and who is lying?

If you are a fan of UK police mysteries, this might be the new book you are looking for. After reading "Where Secrets Lie", you'll likely agree that hiding the truth never truly solves anything and actually makes life worse. Well written with a swift, easy yo read pace, this pre-pub release would have been on my "purchase" list. I'll look for more by this author.

Was this review helpful?

With thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for this ARC in exchange for an open and honest review.

Where Secrets Lie is the second book in the DS Karen Hart series.

The book began with the death of website designer James Hunter. James was a recovering alcoholic who fell off the wagon after two years. During a drinking binge James told a friend from his AA group a secret he had kept for hidden for years. Later James stood on the balcony of his luxury flat and he was thrown over the balcony by his companion.

SIx months later the police were contacted by the neighbour of retired headmaster Albert (Bert) Johnson. She had not seen Bert that morning and called the police when she heard groans coming from behind his front door.

Bert was angry the police were in his house and told them not to go upstairs. Intrigued the officers went to Bert`s bedroom and found a suitcase containing a dead body. In Bert`s home they find a recent letter saying its time to pay for your crime.

Kate and her boss DI Scott Morgan soon discovered the body was Oliver Fox who had gone missing thirty years earlier. Oliver was a teacher at Bert`s school.

Detective Constables Rick and Sophie discovered an allegation of child abuse was made against Oliver. However his older brother was a senior policeman who managed to bury the allegations.

Bert had a heart attack once he was admitted to hospital. Before he died he told Rick it was not an accident and he had been pushed downstairs.

When another colleague of Bert and Oliver is viciously murdered. Karen and the team have to solve a cold case with links to a more recent murder.

Meanwhile Karen is persuaded to go on a blind date which goes wrong. Scott is blackmailed by his ex boss and Sophie is not sure if policework is her true vocation.

Where Secrets Lie was a good solid police procedural. I read the first Karen Hart book and it was like meeting old friends.

I was intrigued by the plot from the beginning and found it hard to put down. As well as the crime I also enjoy reading about the teams home lives . I like Karen who is a good officer, but uses her job to hide her grief.

I recommend this book and can't wait to read Karen`s next investigation.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed his book. It is a fast paced drama with plenty of action in it. When a suitcase containing a dead body is found in an attic it leads to the solving of a 30 year old murder. I liked the characters in this book and their stories. I like being able to imagine peple and their surroundings and feel empathy for them.

Thank you to Netgalley for my copy.

Was this review helpful?

The first thing that called to this book was the cover it just looks amazing and calls it to be a good book. I thought I had the suspect figured out but as the story kept unfolding I realized I was far off. I like books like that!

When Detective Hart and DI Morgan are pulled into the case of a body being found in a suitcase they knows there is a case here but, who would put a person in a suitcase? When we discover who is in it we learn that there is a reason this person was put there. Yet, it will be a race against time as it seems those who may have answers to who this person is are dying. Could there be a connection or just bad luck headed these people's way. I really like how everyone who was involved in the case had a job to do, and I could relate to Sophie how she was building her dreams up and just would feel defeated. Even at her job she questioned her abilities and yet she stood though it and was able to help bring a killer to justice. Even though Sophie was a secondary character it was good I could relate to her in some way.

I haven't read the first book as I didn't realize this was book two but I will be looking into reading it as I am intrigued with Detective Hart.

The suspense was great and built up perfectly and I loved how there was some personal problems or issues going on with the characters but that it didn't deviate from the story.

Was this review helpful?

Three schoolboys keep a terrible secret, as do two of their teachers. Years later, the secret comes out – and all hell breaks loose.
This book starts ominously with the callous murder of a drunk pushed to his death from his balcony. Soon the deaths mount and it’s up to Detective Karen Hart and her team to investigate.
I really liked Hart, who is wonderfully normal and gets on well with her team. There are just enough sneak peaks into the lives of her fellow police officers to make them familiar and likeable. There are also some deliciously awful characters, such as the retired policeman who continues to throw his weight around as he interferes with the investigation.
I enjoyed this well-written, quick read. In a strange way, despite lots of death, this is quite a cosy, homely and comfortable read. Or maybe that’s just me. This is the second in the Karen Hart series; I hadn’t read the first but this didn’t detract from this read at all.

Was this review helpful?

An old man not going out for his paper as usual arouses his neighbour to call for help. What happens next spirals and lots of families are affected by something that happened 30 years ago. You won’t want to stop reading as this story unfolds. There are twists and turns with lots of lives about to be changed forever. Two teachers trying to help some troubled pupils unfortunately do something that will change everyone involved lives forever.

Was this review helpful?

Reading this book was like riding a horse: first you go for a gentle stroll and you are enjoying the ride and wonder if your horse likes to go a little faster, then things ramp up a bit and you are trotting....and then next thing you know, you are going at a full gallop! My horse skipped the cantering completely ;)

Seriously though, this was one good read! DS Karen Hart is back in her second adventure and even though I read the first book, it absolutely doesn't need to be read first for this story to make sense.

Karen gets caught up in a case which is puzzling but it is a cold case and therefore that sense of urgency is not quite there, as there would be in a current case. That soon changes and Karen and her team find themselves running here, there and everywhere trying to figure out how everything fits together. Then the murders start....

There was so much going on in this story, but the author did a great job of keeping the threads going and then making sure all those threads made sense at the end. I enjoyed getting to know the various team members a little better, all those things make a big difference to my enjoyment of a book. It is not just about the case, but all the various people involved in the case and their personalities that makes for a well-rounded book.

I give this book 4.5 stars.

Thank you to NetGalley and Thomas & Mercer.

Was this review helpful?

First time reading this author but will definitely seek out her other books. I love British crime tv shows and this book is written as well as any of them. Lots of twists and turns and when you think you know 'who dunnit', you will be wrong! I don't give 5 stars often but this one definitely is a 5+! Jacket cover is adequate descriotion, no book report or spoilers from me!

This book was provided by the publisher via NetGalley for an honest review. The opinions expressed are my own. Thank you for allowing me to read this book!

Was this review helpful?

I struggled to get into this book at first until I was about 20% in and I must say I'm pleased I stuck with it. Although it was based on a cold case I was really rooting for the team investigating it. I disliked the fox family immediately but the other characters were great. The end shocked me to be honest but in a good way. I'd definitely recommend it to others as I thoroughly enjoyed it

Was this review helpful?

Good solid story, interesting characters. This is my first story by this author and the second in a series. It does work as a stand alone.

This story does have a decent amount of twists and red herrings. The key characters were fleshed out enough to give you a feel for them and their relationships as a team. They also evolve throughout the story and it appears that each sequence will build on that. The final reveal was satisfying.

Thanks to NetGalley, the author and Amazon Publishing UK for a copy in exchange for a review.

Was this review helpful?

I thoroughly enjoyed this book. It takes hold from the very beginning when a suitcase with a decomposed body in it is found in the upstairs home of an elderly man. As the investigation into this thirty year old murder begins many things come to light that brings more crime into play. This kept me guessing until the very end. I highly recommend this book. This is the first book I have read by this author but I will read more in the future.
Thank you Net Galley for the advanced copy.

Was this review helpful?

This book had me hooked from the first page, so much so that I hated having to put it down to do other things.

I loved the plot- the catalyst of which being the discovery of a 30 year old decomposed body in a suitcase within an elderly man’s house - and the twists and turns of a cold case becoming a very current one.

This is the second book in the series, but having not read the first I can say that Where Secrets Lie can be read as a stand-alone. I am, however, very much looking forward to reading the first instalment.

Thank you to Netgalley for this advanced copy.

Was this review helpful?

This is the second book if the series but can be easily read as a stand alone. The story was interesting and had many layers. The main characters definitely had their work cut out for them trying to solve this mystery. There was lots of different people involved and the twists and turns meant it was a guessing game throughout!

Was this review helpful?

Thoroughly enjoyable and highly recommended. This is the first of D.S. Butlers books that I have read but I will be reading more.

Was this review helpful?

The discovery of a decomposed body in a suitcase leads Karen Hart and her team on a journey to understand how and when the victim died. Discovering the victim was a teacher who disappeared more than 30 years ago the team learn that sometimes some secrets need to be uncovered and justice brought to the fore

Was this review helpful?

I went into this book straight on from the first book and I'm really glad that I did as I enjoyed this book as much as I enjoyed the first book. I really like the characters in the book, especially the relationship between Karen, Rick and Sophie and also the rapport between Karen and DI Morgan. The writing is fluid and quick and enjoyable. I loved the way the entire investigation and trying to figure out the killer was written. Overall a really enjoyable book and a really good series so far. Looking forward to her next book. Would not hesitate to recommend this book. And a big thank you to NetGalley and Thomas & Mercer for giving me the chance to read this ARC in exchange of my honest review.

Was this review helpful?