Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I really wanted to like this book. The premise is great. The writing irked me. I disliked the characters.

An all-male secret book club reading romance novels and helping one another with their relationships is so fun but the execution was lackluster.

Gavin barks and growls more than their dog. He was bland, and rude, and entitled. Thea is so hard to read, and even after finishing the book I didn't find her story-line redeeming at all. I had no connection to them as main characters, I was just waiting for the predictable HEA ending so I could be done with this. I am not against swearing in a book, but the F word is basically every fifth word which really begs for some different descriptive words.

Thank you to Netgalley for the copy in exchange for an unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book. Gavin and Thea had a ton of problems caused by miscommunication. They also each had their own issues to work through so that they could be better together. I'm excited for the next book in the series!

Was this review helpful?

I highly reccomend this book. I loved this book. It was cute, sweet and humorous,
A very uplifting enjoyable read

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Berkley Publishing Group for the advanced eBook to read! I thought this book was great! It's not only hilarious but uplifting. I love Lyssa's writing from the different perspectives of both the husband, Gavin, and wife - Thea about their ups and downs and resolving their marital problems. The interactions of the Bromance Book Club were hilarious as well. To see men overcome their ego of reading romance books and even knowing the different types of time periods. The writing was witty and charming. You felt for both Gavin and Thea Scott. The writing wasn't trashy and kept you involved in the story and what was happening between everyone. The scenes with Gavin and Braden Mack were hysterical. I also enjoyed the occasional glimpse of the book the book club read. I would read snippets of the book to not only my coworkers but to my husband who thought it was hilarious. I highly recommended this book to lovers of romance, newcomers to the genres, and even men!

Was this review helpful?

The Bromance Book Club is a laugh-out-loud, fun and easy read that will definitely have you reading “just one more chapter”. Gavin is having major problems in his love life when he gets help & advice from a very unlikely source. What ensues is a hilarious yet emotional journey into forgiveness and patching up a relationship. I really enjoyed the dialogue between characters and the excerpts from the parallel romance novel.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun, fast read.
What I loved: This went above my expectations. I thought I had it all figured out from at the beginning, but I did not!
What I liked: This was an interesting spin on romance reading!
What I hated: In the beginning, I hated Thea. Then I hated her sister. In the end, I saw the beauty in all the characters, but still only marginally liked the sister. :-)

Just a good fun read! A perfect recommendation for romance readers!

Was this review helpful?

The first rule of book club:
You don't talk about book club
Gavin is a MLB player who thinks he has it all together until his wife breaks it to him that she has been faking it in bed. When she asks him a divorce he decide to turn things around .... insert bookclub.
This is the greatest concept I have read in a long time. A bunch of guys getting together to talk about romance books and how they relate to life? Where do I sign my husband up. Thea irratated me at different points but I still felt this book was a great new spin on romance in marriage. Loved it!!

Was this review helpful?

Literally laugh out loud funny but also sweet and sincere. Marriage is hard work and it would be great if all guys had this level of support.

Was this review helpful?

This romantic novel focuses on the relationship between Galvin and Thea. He recently found out his wife had been faking it in the bedroom, which shocks and angers him but also has him wondering what else could she be faking in their lives. With their marriage on the rocks, Galvin will do anything to save it, even joining a romance book club.

I was initially drawn to the novel by the premise of a men’s romance book club, I thought it’d be interesting to read their takes on the genre. And we do hear some of it, but mostly the novel focuses on the relationship of Galvin with this wife and family.

Overall, it’s a humorous, lighthearted romance. I recommend it to readers of contemporary fiction and romance (of course!).

ARC provided by Publisher via Netgalley

Was this review helpful?

This is one of the best marriage in trouble books I have ever read. Both Gavin and Thea have a lot to sort out about their fears for their marriage and themselves before they can truly reconcile. They really have to work for it and this is much more than needing to have an honest conversation. They have to build up trust and be honest with each other.

The Bromance Book Club is both sweet and bittersweet at times. Thea is done with putting herself last in all things and her sister Liv is cheering her on as she tries to rebuild a life with going back to school and pursuing her own dreams. Gavin is aghast that the life he's been obliviously enjoying without noticing she is faking everything about it except for her love for their daughters.

The Bromance Book Club group is great. They really try to help Gavin get things together and actually listen to Thea and build trust with her again. It's not about the wooing, it's about committing and trusting. I loved their scenes, and Gavin reading a romance novel as he muddles his way through moving back in temporarily and trying to start over with Thea. The pacing is great between Gavin and Thea, their scenes with their support networks, and the novel (the title, hilariously, keeps changing) that Gavin is gaining life lessons from. I really liked that Gavin wasn't this cocky, alpha baseball player that was in this to win it because of ego. He's more of a quiet guy who is really struggling with how clueless he was and how it affects his self-esteem.

Contemporary readers will love this marriage being rebuilt romance. I couldn't put it down once I started and I can't wait to see what the Bromance Book Club reads next!

Was this review helpful?

THIS BOOK IS GENIUS. Genius I tell you. A group of macho guys getting together READING ROMANCE NOVELS, helping each other fix their relationships?!?!?! ARE YOU KIDDING ME?!?!?!? I loved every. single. aspect. Of this damn thing. Like I want this to be a really, really great review but I think it’s going to end up being one of those where I flail around like a crazy person because I am so in love. Like everything about this entire book was PERFECT. EVERYTHING.

Like at one point, when the main character, Gavin, is being initiated into the group, one of his friends is telling him why they read romances and that women LOVE reading them and secretly want that kind of stuff in their life. Gavin denies that his wife, Thea likes them because she doesn’t have any around the house. His friend saying something along the lines of “does she have an e-reader? I guarantee you that thing is full of romance novels.” HAHAH I FELT PERSONALLY ATTACKED. I have so much smut on my Kindle that it’s not even funny.

But in all seriousness, other than me loving the funny of a bromance book club in general, this book had a lot of important things you don’t see in every day romance. #1 it had a couple working to fix their relationship on the brink of a divorce. I don’t think I’ve ever read a book like that before. #2 Gavin had a stutter and it came out during every day conversation and was just a normal thing. There were several things brought up about it (him tell Thea he had been teased about it in high school, Thea bitching a woman out for being incredibly rude about it, him saying that one of the reasons he fell in love with Thea was because she never acted weird around him for it, never interrupted him, etc.) and again, I’ve read books where character have had stutters in the past but have worked past them so that it only comes out when they’re nervous or something. This was just a part of Gavin and I just loved it. Just one more book that people can relate to in a world where so many characters are too perfect.

There was the tiny, temporary fall out in the end but I think it was really necessary to their overall story and to Thea’s healing and self-discovery. The ending was perfect in every way and I seriously hope this series is a million books long because I will CHERISH EVERY ONE. Seriously, if you guys don’t go out and read this when it comes out, you’re all nuts!!! Lol, but really.

<b>Huge thanks to NetGalley and Berkley books for allowing me to read an eARC in exchange for an honest review!&hearts; </b>

Was this review helpful?

This is a very good marriage in trouble story. The Bromance Book Club plot is well-handled and there is lots of charming stuff with those guys that made me laugh.

I have some complicated feelings about the way the sex stuff plays out--mostly that someone not coming for three years isn't going to get magically fixed, but sure. He's paying more attention to her and that's nice.

I liked that they have to really become honest with each other and themselves. It's very well done.

Was this review helpful?

I read the description and knew I needed to read this. It was everything I never knew I needed. A bromance book club where guys read romance novels to help with their relationships?? Sign. Me. UP!!

Going in, I will admit I was worried I had built it up too much in my head and I wouldn’t end up liking it as much as I had hoped I would. Thankfully, it was everything I wanted and more. I ended up completely and fully loving it.

This book was great. Well and truly great. I read one page and didn’t put it down until I was done. It hooked me fast and it hooked me hard.

Endlessly witty, completely endearing, and exceptionally written. I can’t wait for book 2!

Was this review helpful?

This is a super sweet, fun romance. Gavin and Thea's marriage is in trouble and he's willing to go to any length to save it, including joining a romance book club. I liked the different perspective of this book, about repairing a relationship instead of building a new relationship. The book was really sweet, and I enjoyed the historical romance chapters interspersed throughout.

Was this review helpful?

The Bromance Book Club was even better than I expected! It was laugh out loud funny, sweet, frustrating, sexy, and just everything I could ask for in a romance novel.

Gavin and Thea's marriage is on the rocks, with Gavin having moved out of the family home after an "incident" in the bedroom. Alone in a depressing apartment, he falls into the bottle. When his friends come to his rescue their plan for getting Thea back - using romance novels as a how-to guide -is unorthodox, at best. Still, Gavin will try anything to get back in Thea's favor.

I loved fresh angle of the male perspective and friendships. Reading about men who are committed to monogamy and marriage? Yes, please! I cannot wait to read more from Lyssa Kay Adams.

Was this review helpful?

Based on the snippet about the book, I was expecting something a little different from what this book turned out to be. I did enjoy the book, nonetheless. The story is about Gavin and Thea, whose marriage is in deep trouble. Thea is ready to end it, but Gavin talks her into giving him another chance. At first her reactions and attitude toward Gavin and the marriage seem too harsh, but eventually we learn why she feels and reacts the way she does. Gavin and Thea both need to learn how to truly open up and be vulnerable with the one they love.

The "bromance" book club offers the comic relief in this story. They are a group of professional men, most are athletes, that invite Gavin into their book club to help him save his marriage. Gavin's best friend Del, who is also his teammate on a professional baseball team, is a member of the club. The men read romance novels to help them understand women. Gavin takes what he learns from these novels to try to woo Thea back into his life. The other members of the book club are a hoot.

I recommend this book. It offers comedy, romance, heartbreak, and hot sex! Thank you NetGalley for the arc of this book.

Was this review helpful?

4.5/5 This book was heartbreakingly adorable! Exactly what I was looking for in terms of modern romance. Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

It’s been said that husband and wife protagonists don’t work in romance novels, but THE BROMANCE BOOK CLUB blows that arbitrary rule out of the water. Gavin and Thea’s relationship has the perk of being comfortable, real, and live-in, while still managing to be sparkling and new. I loved following their second-chance romance throughout the story. I felt such a strong connection to them from page one and was truly invested in their future. The Nashville setting was vivid, well-drawn, and put to good use. And the actual Bromance Book Club? Holy comic relief! I loved their advice and their zingers. I can’t wait to hear from more of them in future books!

Was this review helpful?

Between work, home, kids and back-to-school time, my stress level has been higher than usual. That could be why I''m on a bona fide romance novel kick. I've plowed through three upcoming releases in the last week or so.

I think that romance books often get a bad rap. I realize that they are not for every reader, but I am finding they are the perfect salve to calm my current day-to-day strain. I am highly entertained and relish the escape.

The premise of The Bromance Book Club gripped me right off the bat: A group of guys form a covert romance book club to help better understand women and save their relationships. There was even snippets of the romance novel the club read interspersed throughout. It totally worked for me.

It was refreshing to read a story about a married couple working on some real and relatable issues. And I loved the dynamics between the characters, especially the members of the club.

It was clever, funny, and endearing.

Thanks to Netgalley and Berkley for the review copy

Was this review helpful?

I loved it, loved it, loved it! I literally laughed out loud! Gavin's marriage is in trouble and here comes fellow professional baseball teammate, Del, to the rescue. Del and a group of other professionals have found the key to winning back and keeping their women and historical romance novels serve as their manuals. I was rooting for Gavin and Thea from the start. This had it all - a loving sweet couple, kids, a dog, a snarky sister, and hilarious friends who mean well. Honestly, what man wouldn’t benefit from reading at least one spicy romance novel in his lifetime! I can’t wait for the sequel.

Was this review helpful?