Cover Image: The Magicians Original Graphic Novel: Alice's Story

The Magicians Original Graphic Novel: Alice's Story

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

The first book of Lev Grossman's <i>Magicians</i> trilogy told through the eyes of Alice. Just to be clear, this is based on the novel, not the TV show so there will be some minor differences with the first 2 seasons of the show. Typically, comic adaptations of novels aren't very good. I was happily surprised with this one. Sturges does a good job of reengineering the story to tell it from Alice prospective. Some elements, such as much of what happens to Julia, are left out because that's Quentin's story, not Alice's.

For those of you not in the know, the Magicians is sort of a darker version of Harry Potter mashed up with <i>The Chronicles of narnia</i>. Our main characters are going to college to become magicians. Most of them are also obsessed with the books about Fillory which they eventually find out is a real place. Fillary is clearly a darker version of Narnia.

Bak's art is solid. It has a less refined Peter Gross feel to it.

Was this review helpful?

Although I do prefer the telly show to the actual novels, I really enjoyed seeing the characters we know from Alice's eyes. She's really developed from the person we saw in the first book. And I especially liked seeing past events in this comic with her brother Charlie.

The artwork was also very pretty.

My main problem was that the plot was rather lacking and slow. I'd definitely recommend it to fans of the books and show though, who want extra content and background on Alice.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley for a review copy of this book.

Unfortunately, this was not my kind of thing. The drawings were OK I guess but the storyline had no rhythm. Perhaps it is because I had not read any others, I'm not sure but didn't float my boat so to say.

Was this review helpful?

I was able to read this graphic novel early thanks to NetGalley. I will admit that I only read the first book in the Magicians trilogy and really did not care for it. I just could not get past how whiney and ungrateful the main character was... But I found the one redeeming quality of the book was Alice. She was this universe's Hermione: smart, tough, and easily lovable. I was excited to see that she got her own venue to tell her side of the story set in the Magicians wold. Honestly enjoyed her viewpoint much more than Quinten's...

Was this review helpful?

I requested The Magicians: Alice's Story even though I'm unfamiliar with Lev Grossman's series and the television show. I know both are popular... but this graphic novel is what finally piqued my interest. I thought it would give me a good feel for the characters and the setting, and I was intrigued by the promise of magic and a mythical world.

Unfortunately, the story felt long and was unexciting. We see what Alice was like as a child, observe her relationship with her parents, watch her obsess over an unresolved issue with a sibling, and then witness her time spent at school. Things picked up when the group went to Fillory, but it was also unimpressive. I felt like certain aspects of this story could've been left out to make this a quicker read, but the details started to feel tedious after awhile. I'm sure it was an interesting story for people familiar with the series, since they're already acquainted with the characters and the setting, but I would not recommend this for someone just starting out.

If you are familiar with this series, did you expect the ending? I thought it was rubbish and unnecessary. It made me angry. I did enjoy how everything eventually connected, but I felt like a lot of bad had to happen before something good came out of it.

An interesting story, a peculiar setting, and unique characters make up The Magicians: Alice's Story. I may try the series at some point in the future, and that might make me like this one more. As it stands, it was mostly enjoyable but ultimately unremarkable.

Originally posted at Do You Dog-ear? on September 7, 2019.

Was this review helpful?

This was quite good!
There were parts when the novel dragged a little, but I liked the art style.
“The Magicians Original Graphic Novel: Alice's Story” was overall enjoyable and I’d recommend it to fans of the tv show.

Was this review helpful?

I haven't read the Magicians so obviously, this one made no sense to me. Still, I was expecting to get at least half the story, but it seemed to feel very heavy and dense since the start, so I had to abandon it.

Was this review helpful?

Overall, I did enjoy this graphic novel. I love the story of The Magicians. I actually would’ve rated most of the book as 3 stars. I personally would prefer more detailed artwork and the whole of the story wasn’t anything new. The end is what bumped it up to 4 stars. If you’ve read the books and watched the show, you’ll know the events of this graphic novel. It’s still interesting to see Alice’s story in a different medium, I just expected more story that I didn’t already know.

Was this review helpful?

*ARC received from NetGalley in return for an honest review*

The Magicians was a book I found hard to get into but a show I adored. While Alice wasn't a character I felt very connected to in the show this graphic novel brought her to life and made her a more understandable character to me. Her drives and wants were so clear that it was totally clear why she was acting certain ways. The art and flow of the story was gorgeous and I never felt like I was confused about what was happening in any panel or where to read next. I highly recommend this book to fans of either the show or the movie that want to remember just why they fell in love with The Magicians in the first place.

Was this review helpful?

As a fan of the Magicians trilogy, I loved this adaptation of Alice’s story! While so much of it was familiar to me from my reading, it was incredible to read it again, this time from Alice’s point of view. The art style fit the storyline perfectly and I found myself just as captivated by this as I did the original books.

Was this review helpful?

I haven't read The Magicians, but this book sounded interesting to me. It's sort of like a darker version of Harry Potter and The Chronicles of Narnia. The setting is wonderful. It drew me in pretty quickly and I found myself wanting to know more about these characters. The book is paced well too. It did drag a little towards the end. I thought the way the story wrapped up was worth it though. I can't compare this to Grossman's novels, but it feels like a nice primer for them.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks Magicians is such a fantastic book and finally getting to read Alice's story is amazing. Her fierce determination stole my heart and I'm so glad to get more of her.

Was this review helpful?

I was very intrigued by the synopsis of this graphic novel when I read it. Though I have yet to read the actual novels of The Magicians, I wanted to dive into this. I really enjoyed the illustrations and how the authors brought the story to life. I do admit to feeling a bit lost in some parts, mostly toward the end, but I was still able to enjoy the overall story. Definitely geared to a more mature audience, this will appeal to lovers of fantasy and graphic novels.

Was this review helpful?

This graphic novel is perfect for fans of Lev Grossman's "The Magicians" trilogy. It gives readers a look into the story from a new perspective. The book is visually beautiful and the transition of the writing from novel format into a graphic novel was very well done. I thoroughly enjoyed this title and hope to see more of the trilogy in graphic novel form in the future.

Was this review helpful?

Alice Quinn strives hard to be the best. She is magically very powerful, ahead of her age group and capable of adapting to any situation. She attends Brakebills College for Magical Pedagogy where she witnesses a terrifying creature from another dimension murder a fellow student in her class. After graduation, Alice wants more from her life than using magic for her own gains, she wants to make a difference. She is soon given the chance when another student who dropped out of school offers her the chance to find the magical world of Fillory, a place she had believed only existed in the pages of her favourite childhood story. But the best stories are based on an element of truth, and Fillory is real, just not as it was in the stories. There is a darkness there and Alice must overcome all of her fears and anxieties to find her true calling and save her friends.
This is the first book of The Magician’s trilogy in graphic novel format and it sticks to its source material faithfully, but from Alice’s point of view. This is interesting perspective to take and Alice is an immediately accessible character, suffering with the need to prove herself after the death of her brother, and social anxiety. She goes through all the highs and lows of being away at college or university including navigating sexual relationships and superior bullies, but with the added threat that if she doesn’t master magic, then it can cost her her life.
Running through is the theme of comparing real life to an imaginary one Fillory. As Alice grows, she realises that Fillory is unsatisfying and so she realises her own life is unsatisfying. She doesn’t want endless empty parties, all her needs catered for by magic. She wants to prove herself. She sees the good in her boyfriend, Quentin, when his actions show him as shallow and self-centred.
There are some changes from the TV series, if that’s the angle bringing you to this, physical appearances of the characters, but that shouldn’t stop you enjoying the story if you’re a fan. It does start a little slowly, setting the scene and building up to the death of a student which sets the characters on this path to find Fillory. From there the action is interspersed with developments in the relationship between Alice and Quentin as they self-destruct in such a realistic manner that I’m sure most of us will identify with them.
With so much focus on Alice, some of the other characters, such as Janet, don’t have the same character development as the books and TV series, but then you can’t have everything with such an indepth study of one character. What we lose in the other characters, we gain in a greater understanding of Alice’s courage.
The artwork is simplistic in a positive way. Instead of each panel being overcrowded with detail and dialogue, space is given for the reader to work things through themselves. Because of its heritage, they could have gone overboard in recreating this much-loved fictional world. Instead we have enough detail for place setting, and concentrates on the emotions of the characters. The panels where Alice and Quentin are at odds are charged with their pain and suffering caused by their own actions, or inactions.
An interesting read, definitely worth getting if you’re a fan of the series already, and if not, there is enough to grab your attention to go and explore more.

Was this review helpful?

Having never read the Magicians book series or knowing anything about it, I very much enjoyed this book! The story was really good as was the artwork. Not knowing anything about this series or the characters did not hinder me in any way while I was reading this. The characters were fully developed and all had good story arcs as the book progressed. I would love if there were more books that centered on each character like this one did one Alice. Overall this was a very interesting read and I would recommend it if you are into fantasy books such as The Chronicles of Narnia and similar titles.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this as I am a fan of the show. Graphic novels are not what I generally read, but I thought the way it flowed was really great. Loving the way it seamlessly blends with the story of Alice.

Was this review helpful?

It was just the same story as the first book, and that would have been okay if the dived a little deeper into who Alice was, but instead we just read the same thing in comic form.

Was this review helpful?

I love Grossman's Magicians trilogy, and the show loosely based on them. Quentin, however, is not the most likeable character, so it's great to see the events of the first novel from the point of view of another character. Alice is a character that I've always wished got to stay around for more of the story, and I really liked getting her perspective.

Was this review helpful?

I loved it! As a fan of the original Magicians Trilogy, I was excited to read the story from Alice’s point of view, especially to find out how she felt as she changed form. I think a graphic novel was the perfect format for this story. From the magical walls of Brakebills to the supernatural creatures in Fillory, the illustrations were fantastic. I hope the author will write more graphic novels from the Magicians universe.

Was this review helpful?