Skip to main content

Member Reviews

A deceptively understated book, If... by Sarah Perry inspires readers to imagine a fantastical world of “what if’s” that will have children laughing and adults reminiscing their childhood imagination. With beautiful illustrations and themes, this book is a lesson in slowing down and revisiting the joy and wonderment that made the childhood experience so lovely; I even had to do a double take of the cover halfway through the book!

Thank you to NetGalley for providing a free copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

As an adult I found some of the images a little creepy but I can completely see how t would appeal to children whose mind are constantly questioning how and why.

Was this review helpful?

I received a copy of this book via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

A collection of thought provoking and wondrous pieces, full of fascinating details.

Was this review helpful?

This book has wonderful illustrations. It's unusual, strange but it is entertaining. Reading this book make me feel like I am in a completely different world where fishes are leaves, where whales lives in outer space, where the moon is square, etc. It is a highly imaginative book and helps the kids to be creative. It is wild and fun! The reason of why I gave it a 3 stars is because I just don't feel it is for me. But I really think a lot of kids would love this book :) It is the book that parents can talk about with their kids. Perhaps having an interesting and fun conversation? :D.
All in all, a great great book!

Was this review helpful?

This is such a wonderful book for exploring silly or thoughtful questions, stretching imagination, and visualizing these new ideas. Each simple "If" statement is paired with a creative and beautiful illustration, and those were really engrossing. They brought out giggles and thoughtful reactions from my young son.

Thank you to NetGalley and Getty Publications for the copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This is an old favorite that always seems to do well with K-6th grades, so I'm very pleased to see that it is being reprinted. There's nothing like a caterpillar perched on a toothbrush, spiders reading Braille, and toes for teeth to provoke an uproarious response!
The new version has 2 additional spreads (I love the turtle!) and end notes that invite further reflection.

Was this review helpful?

This is such a cute children' book! It allows children to imagine all sorts of things, even the 'impossible' ones. The illustrations are extremely beautiful as well, I was mesmerised. Rating: 5/5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

LOVED this! I'm definitely going to use it in my Language Arts classroom, I just have to figure out how...

Was this review helpful?

Dear God, how did I somehow miss this book over the past 25 years? It is an absolutely stunning piece of work and needs to be a part of every child's library! It stretches the imagination with wacky ideas like what would happen if frogs ate rainbows and then turns them into illustrated interpretations of each statement. The drawings/paintings are breathtakingly beautiful and really make you think. You could have so many discussions about different ways to interpret each of these sayings and try to create your own interpretations. Plus the book is almost open-ended, allowing you to think of even more on your own. And again, it just gorgeous. I think my favorites are the dogs as mountains and holding music. Although the toes as teeth is amusing. They are all just wonderful and a great introduction to surreal art, which is one of my favorite styles.

There's a Readers' Guide at the end of this with some explanations as well as other thought-provoking questions.

I quite emphatically give this book 5 stars.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for providing me a review copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

A beautiful picture book book that would work wonderfully as a stimulus for creative writing and art work.

Was this review helpful?

'If...' by Sarah Perry is a picture book that makes the reader pause and think, and has done so for 25 years!

The whimsical cover of a tree with leaves made of fish drew me in. From there, I was introduced to flying cats and magnetic turtles and other wonders. Each page offered strange wonders and and an open ended sentence, like 'If dogs were mountains....' Imagination and creativity abounds here and encourages the reader to think differently.

The book ends with a readers' guide into The Secrets of If.... The pictures are ones you might just pass over, then you notice the odd details. I really enjoyed pausing to read this.

I received a review copy of ebook from Getty Publications and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. Thank you for allowing me to review this wonderful ebook.

Was this review helpful?

A beautiful book about unleashing you imagination and creativity. With a series of prompts pairing unusual and disparate things, and followed by lovely illustrations to match, "If..." can be enjoyed by people of all ages. I envision this book as a fun starting point or conversation starter for teachers, parents, and even for personal mind-jogging.

I received this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This book left me wowed. It was a wonderful and strange book, exploring what ifs and reminding the reader it's always nice to dream on and enjoy the worlds only existing in dreams. This is not only for children but for anyone at any age, who enjoys a bit of adventure. Highly recommend this book.

Was this review helpful?

Twenty-five years later, Sarah Perry's "If..." remains as full of whimsy and wonder as ever. Readers of all ages will enjoy studying the beautiful pictures time and again for details they may have missed. The hybrids and fanatastical images are thought provoking and indeed make one wonder, "What if?"

Was this review helpful?

I showed this book to my younger siblings and they loved it. It contains gorgeous and clever illustrations and it really instigates children's imaginations and creative side. Definitely recommend.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fantastic coffee-table type book for people to enjoy creative juxtapositions of imagery with words. It is also great for reading and pondering over the images. Perhaps this would be a good book for children to read with adults who want to ask questions and think deeply about the concepts presented. The content is great and it is challenging to think of the answers to the questions at the back. That exploration seems like it is A PART of the reading process, and should not be separated. I. wish that the questions were closer to the artwork, as it would be a great "in-situ" type of prompt for readers, rather than requiring them to go to the back of the book to explore. Perhaps having the question text be on the periphery, or a call out? Anyway, a novel book for exploring language and creativity. Would love to see more like it.

Was this review helpful?

If by Sarah Perry. A interesting book said my grandson. He liked it that ants made the number eight because he is eight. He goes these are like riddles. I asked him do you like it. And he said he does. One other thing Sarah Perry is my grandmas name.

Was this review helpful?

I can see why this was republished! It is a surreal classic, reminiscent of 'Tuesday' by David Wiesner. I adored the captivating and strange illustrations. This book is perfect for kids around 4-6 as they will easily be able to spot what's wrong/different about each picture vs. reality. My 5 year old loves picture books like this so I can't wait to show it to him.

Thank you NetGalley and Getty Publications for providing this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

A collection of ponderings of what it would be like if music could be seen or turtles were magnetic, or a whole host of other improbable and impossible ideas were true? Each spread includes a pondering on one side and a illustration imagining it true on the other.

I’ve never come across this book until I saw the 25th anniv. ed. up for review on NetGalley. I decided to see what it was like. It certainly does spark the imagination. This book would make a great story starter or conversation start tool. The situations dreamed up are wild, crazy, and very out of the box. Recommended for dreamers, those with healthy imaginations, and those who like to wonder “what if…?”

Notes on content [based on the ARC]: One illustration shows a child with a bare butt.

I received an ARC of this title from the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

If . . . is a reformat and re-release of a gorgeous picture book from 1995 by Sarah Perry. Due out 3rd March 2020 from Getty, it's 48 full color pages and will be available in hardcover format.

This is a very short book, but overwhelmingly lush and beautiful. The pictures are surreal and realistically rendered. The artwork is precise and engaging, it draws the eye and invites a lingering contemplation. I have revisited the book a couple times since my original read-through, and I've found myself thinking about one picture or another many times in the intervening hours.

Each of the 23 paintings (not counting endpieces) has a one sentence introduction "if" ants could count, hummingbirds told secrets, dreams were visible, with the artwork illustrating the posit on the facing page. The illustrations are surreal and dreamlike with lots of semi-hidden subtleties and sly details.

This is an all-ages book. Adults will appreciate the beauty and creativity while children will likely appreciate identifying the features of each of the illustrations and everyone can enjoy hunting the hidden 'easter eggs' in each painting.

This 25th anniversary edition also includes a reader's guide with some background info on some of the pictures as well as 2 new paintings and some new spot illustrations.

Gorgeous book, haunting in a good way.

Five stars.

Was this review helpful?