Member Reviews
Some years back five teens were picked, after they fulfilled a prophecy, to fight the dark one, they fought and won but at what cost. Slone has given much and what the other have called her PTSD may be more. Now on the tenth anniversary of the dark ones death they find out that the dark one is still alive and in another parallel universe trying to come back and kill everyone he see fit. Do the heroes, especially Slone have what it takes to fight him again. This wonderful book was packed with action, suspense and twists and turns that will leave you holding your breath. This book had me captivated and I know I stayed up way past my bedtime until I finished the book. Ms. Roth has another hit on her hands. This review will appear on my blog on April 7th |
I have to admit that I was a bit disappointed in this book. I had such high hopes for Ms. Roth's foray into adult fiction but I found this story to be subpar compared to her young adult novels. Chapters jump back and forth between the story, news articles, and communications. The plot was all over the place. I found myself skimming through a lot of the book trying to get to the point of the story. I'll purchase this for my library, but I think some fans will be disappointed. |
Bookseller 304730
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher I was able to read this book in exchange for an honest review. *** What comes after your duty as the chosen one is fulfilled and peace is bought and your innocence is stolen from you and no one has prepared you to return to the normal, real world? Chosen Ones by Veronica Roth follows Sloane, one of 5 chosen ones. She feels she hasn’t adjusted as well as the other four and struggles with PTSD and a guilt she can’t seem to voice, a secret she isn’t ready to give words to. Where the Dark One appeared mass damage and death followed, the chosen ones found various magical items in an otherwise magicless world to take on their big bad at cost to themselves. On the 10th anniversary of their victory over the Dark One, one of their own dies. When the remaining chosen ones gather for the funeral something happens that has Sloane asking lots of questions and wondering if everything she and her friends went through was for nothing and if she has it in her to go through it all again because the Dark One had a goal and maybe he’s gone but something is happening. *** I liked the pacing of this story, it was slow and thoughtful and careful, at least until the end where lots of things started to happen again, but at the beginning you’re post defeat of the dark one and Sloane has not been taking care of herself. She’s twitchy, has nightmares of the things she went through, and has decided she needs more answers to what happened so is digging through confidential information surrounding the things she went through, can’t be good for her mental health. She’s prickly and uncomfortable around most people except for those who went through the same nightmare she did. She’s also extremely awkward and more punch first and ask questions later. I loved Sloane. I found her believable. I found her plight sympathetic. She fought like she was trained to do, taking on the Dark One, but it appears no one took the time to prepare her for a life post Dark One. Ten years after the fact, some of it is on her sure, but someone whose been burned as many times as she has it's also no surprise she doesn’t look for help or know how to ask for it properly. I liked the breaks in chapters, the documents, articles, interviews, etc.. that helped offer more insight into the worlds you witnessed and helped fill in some background info. This was an intriguing read and Sloane at the end, just wow. I can’t wait for more people to read this so I can talk about it with them. |
Rebecca G, Librarian
A tale for adults who loved reading stories about "chosen ones" as teens, but who may have outgrown YA. |
Librarian 622136
Well-known author, Veronica Roth, has deviated from her normal writing style in this book. It is really intriguing. What does a super-hero do AFTER killing the bad guy? How does life return to normal....or does it? Using flashbacks and unique narrative, like newspaper clippings and chat forums to flesh out the story of what happened in the past, the character is presently dealing with all that happened, and trying to move forward. As her life moves into the future events, there is a surprising twist that really drew me in. I will admit, there were some points where I was confused by the "excerpts" in between chapters, but they really make you think about what is happening in the book and keep you reading to find out how they connect to our heroine's story. Of course this book is well-written...it IS Veronica Roth after all, but it is also the beginning of a series (I hope) that will keep you hanging on! Excellent read! |
This was an intriguing book premise. Imagine if, after the defeat of the big bad, the superheroes' story picks up ten years later and some of the good guys have PTSD, drug addictions, and are having trouble coping with real life. |
I didn't like this as much as I'd hoped, and I've been chewing over why, and I think what I've come up with is that it's TOO ambitious? I've loved similar books like The Magicians, Carry On, etc, and I think what works for this kind of book--that's clearly looking to respond in a fanfiction-like way to existing properties, to say, "Yes, these plucky teens saved the world, but at what cost? Let's really dig into their trauma!" But those books function by making their canon so similar to Narnia/Harry Potter/etc that they work as an effective shorthand. Here, whatever it was that her Chosen Ones went through...I mean, there are familiar tropes here and there but overall it's original, it can't clearly be mapped onto a Voldemort or whatever. Which is fine, except that then to start 10 years later and be reacting to piecemeal bits of information...it's not quite so satisfying or comprehensible. that said, I liked Sloane as a prickly, traumatized heroine, and I enjoyed the story well enough. I liked the diversity of her crew of chosen ones though some of her talk about microaggressions etc felt a bit clunky? (A bit, perhaps, like Roth is someone who has been taken to task about such things in previous books but still doesn't feel totally comfortable writing about them? ah well a nice effort). This is her first "adult" book but it doesn't feel too different than her YA ones except that the characters are aged up (and eg talking about marriage). I feel like she could have made more of her "adult" status by making this longer and digging into all of the worldbuilding a bit more. eh! |
Elizabeth M, Librarian
Chosen Ones is an amazing dissection of fantasy tropes. This is a beautiful book for transitioning new adults who grew up with the "chosen one prophesy" books and now are ready to examine and explore the aftermath of what those events would mean. This is an exciting and thrilling story but with thought-provoking scenarios and questions. This is a must read for any adult who grew up reading and loving Harry Potter, |
This book took a while to get going. Most of part one was explanation of the world. It was kind of like the author started at the middle of the story, went back to the beginning and finished at the end. Sloane has saved the world alongside four of her friends and ten years have passed. She suffers from ptsd but more importantly, lack of direction or purpose. She tries to hide from everything and go through the motions to make everyone else happy but life has no meaning for her. Due to an orchestrated event, her life is thrown sideways and she finds purpose again. The problem with a dream, is when it comes true. I did like the mashup at the end. The middle and the end of the book were very good. Things from the beginning of the book started to make sense and made me want to reread it just to get things I might have missed previously. In that sense, this book makes you pay attention. It’s not something you can just skim through and still understand fully. I want to thank Net Galley and Veronica Roth for the opportunity to read this arc and give an unbiased review. All in all, an entertaining read and a story that makes you think about it long after you have finished it. |
Jennifer T, Librarian
This book was unexpectedly great. I read the Divergent series and wasn't a huge fan, so I wasn't sure what to expect. Chosen Ones was completely different than Roth's previous works and kept surprising me within the story as well. The main characters in this book aren't teenagers, for a change, but they are marked by the events of their teenage years, when they were the "Chosen Ones" destined to save the world. The "teenagers save the world" story is a beloved fantasy trope, but this story takes on what happens *after* -- the psychological toll on people who weren't allowed to have "normal" childhoods but instead were marked by fear, fighting, and an expectation of not surviving to adulthood. Of course that would give anyone PTSD, right? Turns out being a hero isn't all it's cracked up to be after the world has been saved. Roth deftly explores a theme of choice, from the "Chosen One" designation given our heroes to the question they keep returning to -- what role does destiny play in shaping one's life? How does someone say no to being Chosen, and what happens if they do? Saying much more about the plot would be spoiling lots of lovely twists and turns. Let's just say the world-building is pretty fantastic and the included government reports, news articles, and social media posts make it very real. Focusing on the characters instead, it's immediately clear that they aren't your typical heroes. Of the five Chosen, three are women, one is Mexican and openly lesbian, and the leader of the group is a black man. Roth even addresses the racism & sexism inherent in how the heroes are portrayed in the press in the decade since they saved the world from the unimaginatively named Dark One. The main character, Sloane, is in appearance a stereotypical pretty, wholesome, all-American girl, but in reality is bitter, cranky, foul-mouthed, and SO over being a public figure. It makes Sloane believable and somehow likable because of her faults, not in spite of them. Best of all, although this promises to be the first in a series, there's no irritating cliffhanger. There's more to say about these characters and the world Roth created, but the threads of this story are wrapped up within the book. That in itself is refreshing and makes it something I'll recommend to readers who are just tired of waiting years to get to a denouement. |
Lori M, Librarian
I don't generally like Veronica Roth's books but I gave this one a try because I thought the concept of what happens to the heros after was interesting. The book was readable but I wont read any sequels and don't think it should be the beginning of a series. |
Breanne H, Librarian
This book was so interesting that I had a hard time putting it down! It was very different from her other books but I really enjoyed reading this book! |
I have really enjoyed Veronica Roth's previous books so when this became available to review as a Netgalley Arc, I jumped at the chance to read it. I really enjoyed reading this book and felt that the characters were all very well written, and I especially liked the main character Sloane. I liked the fact that she was struggling with her demons and that she was still finding it hard to get over what happened to her, even with 10 years and a supposedly wonderful relationship to help it all. I think it showed a more realistic portrayal of the fact that sometimes times doesn't help, unfortunately. However, I still felt that despite this being the author's first 'adult fantasy' novel, this would definitely be categorised as YA in my mind. I'm not saying that's a bad thing at all, just that I feel the genre application is incorrect in this case. I am also interested in the idea that this is 'book 1' as I feel that the ending was actually spot on for this book and, because of this, can't see where the series will go from here? Saying that I will be reading the next book when it comes out to get the answer to my question. |
Bookseller 555109
This was really entertaining and a different take for books in this genre. Imagining how the Chosen Ones would be living their lives years later, and dealing with the psychological aftermath of the events was fascinating. There was enough unpredictability to keep me reading until the end. |
Librarian 525175
This was a tough one to review. Chosen Ones is my first Veronica Roth novel. I enjoy YA, but don't necessary love the YA/fantasy genre. I was excited to try a book aimed at adults. The summary was really compelling, and then I started to read it. You are placed in the middle of something (which is so hard for me to get really into if there's not good ease into the story). It's told in two parts, and was long for me. I tried hard to get through it, and I did. It felt like a strange ending in that it was just over. It's concluded, but it felt too abrupt. I didn't hate it, and I would try other books by her, but this wasn't my favorite. |
Miranda F, Librarian
The Dark One may have been defeated years ago, but The Chosen Ones will continue to deal with the aftermath. This is story of how Sloane really comes to terms with what she has done with her life; this is the story of how she comes to terms with who she really is. This is the story of how Sloane discovers that maybe her and her friends didn't actually defeat the Dark One. Sloane Andrews is one of those characters that you don't like because she isn't a nice person. But you love her. You root for her. You want her to succeed. Roth's pacing in this novel is impeccable, and she builds complex characters that anyone can relate to if they just try. I"m still trying to figure out if there is a sequel in the future which is exactly why the end of this novel is so beautiful - we don't really know what is going to happen; we want more information, but if we don't get it, we will still be satisfied. Thank you NetGalley for this ARC. |
I tried several times to understand the structure of this book or care about the characters and failed. Not having finished this book I don’t feel I should review it. |
Librarian 585412
I have pretty consistently liked Veronica Roth, though I know her last duology was considered problematic and had a pretty divided reception. I was VERY into this book, her first adult novel, especially during Part 1. This book is about Sloane, a woman who has gained notoriety in an alternate version of our current world by being one of five “chosen ones,” teenagers who were prophesied to kill an evil magician known as “The Dark One.” Sloane is dating Matthew, one of the other chosen ones, and while he seems to have moved on from their trauma, Sloane is still all kinds of messed up about it. Her character felt very real to me, and I was all in during part 1, in which Sloane’s present alternates with news stories and government reports about the chosen ones. In Part 2, they go to another dimension, and it almost lost me. For someone who has read as many comic books as I have, I still just cannot wrap my head around the concept of the multiverse. However, I stuck with it and I’m glad I did, because the other version of earth that they go to is really interesting - it’s basically just like Sloane’s world except that most people have magic. I liked how magic was handled in this book, but mostly I liked being with Sloane for her journey. She is not always very sympathetic or likable, but I still found her really compelling. I guess this is part of a series (Goodreads has it listed as “The Chosen Ones #1), but it didn’t feel like it was just setting up for something else, and I thought it was fairly satisfying as a stand-alone novel. |
Chosen Ones by Veronica Roth was a different kind of story but I really loved it. Part one was a little confusing and I felt like I was missing pieces of a puzzle. But as I got to Part 2 the story really took off and I was hooked. If your a fan of alternate worlds/sci fi this is the book for you. Just stick with it because you won't be sorry. |
I really enjoyed this. I'm glad to see Veronica Roth back with something more compelling. I was, however, surprised to see that this clocks in at just over 300 pages. Because it felt like a million. I truly feel like I skimmed entire pages of conversations and picked this up whenever I had a chance, and still it took me a week to wrap this up. Also, not sure where she is going with this as a series? This book basically concludes an entire storyline by the end. There's potential for the characters in a sequel, but honestly, this would be a solid standalone. Anyway, definitely pick it up if you're a fan of her stuff. It's good, and explores things that I haven't seen tackled yet by YA authors. And even though this is supposedly adult, content-wise this is pretty tame. Especially compared to some of the stuff her contemporaries are putting out. |








