Cover Image: The Woman Before Wallis

The Woman Before Wallis

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Even if I found some parts quite enjoyable I couldn't connect to the story that fell flat.
Not my cup of tea.
Many thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for this ARC, all opinions are mine.

Was this review helpful?

Turnbull did an amazing job transporting me to the 1920's and I was captivated by the opulent world Thelma lives in. Even if this had been a purely fiction novel I would have been swept away by all the drama, romance and suspense. The fact that this entire story is based on historical events made this book that much more incredible. I have only read Tudor historical fiction before so I was not familiar at all with the scandal of Wallis Simpson. The whole concept of this book is fabulous including the genius of the title. This story is entirely told from the perspective of Thelma Furness and yet we know the whole way through that she will eventually be the mistress to the future King and then lose that relationship to her friend, Wallis Simpson. It was a bold choice to let the reader know all of that going into the book, although, maybe not so bold if you are already familiar with this part of history. 

Thelma Furness is a fascinating person in history and I am in awe of everything that she went through and overcame. We also get to see quite a lot of her twin sister Gloria Vanderbilt's life and she was equally as captivating. Turnbull does a great job of doing a deep dive into these characters and we see them dealing with all sorts of losses, triumphs, difficulties and "improper" relationships. There were so many times during the course of this story that my heart broke for both Thelma and Gloria. I was rooting for these characters so much, which is sort of ridiculous since their story has already happened, but I couldn't help my strong emotional connection to them. I feel like any woman will recognize a part of themselves in either Thelma or Gloria. 

Another incredible aspect of this novel is the way that it is formatted. We meet Thelma the night she meets her second husband and we follow that timeline all the way up through the majority of her relationship with Prince Edward. The other timeline that is interspersed throughout the story is one that follows Thelma as she is traveling to support her sister who is in the middle of one of America's most infamous custody battles. The suspense of watching the custody battle unfold was clever since it kept the story barreling forward at a high speed. The only downside to this book is that I started to crave more of the custody battle storyline and wasn't as enthralled with parts of Thelma and Edward's relationship as I once was. Which might also be because we know that it doesn't work out so I was trying not to get too invested in their love story. 

This story is full of complex emotions and uncomfortable moments. I am so grateful to Turnbull for writing this story because I discovered two strong women that I admire so much. I'm pretty sure this is Turnbull's debut novel which is incredible if true.

Was this review helpful?

A huge thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for providing me with an ARC of this title in exchange for an hnest review.

I had no idea that Prince Edward, Duke of Windsor was such a rebel. I had no idea that having a diplomat as a father granted you access to the glittering world of the Vanderbilts. This story absolutely fascinated me. The main charcter of the story has been painted by historians as a grasping socialite who leveraged her tenuous connections and beauty to survive. Long before the rise of the paparazzi culture, her name was synonymous with scandal.

Wallis Simpson was not the first divorcee to catch the eye of the prince. As the sister of Gloria Morgan Vanderbilt, Thelma was not a stranger to the lures of the polo set. When Edward singles her out, she becomes the paramour of the moody prince, spending less and less time with her husband. The extramarital affair is not uncommon in the social circles she moves in, and does not irreparably damage her reputation.

When a tragic death leaves her sister Gloria in an untenable situation, she vows to support her twin. As the world is rocked by a court battle that aired all of the tawdry laundry of the upper class, Thelma becomes a liability to the pristine outward appearance of the royal family. Wallis Simpson supplants Thelma in Edward's affections.

You won't regret picking up this tightly woven expose of the world of wealth and privilege in Depression-era America, or its sympathetic treatment of a family that was villainized by the press of the time.

Was this review helpful?

This is definitely one of the better written historical fictions. I love reading about the monarchy but had never read anything about Lady Furness, her life with David the future king of England and her twin sister Gloria Vanderbilt Sr.'s taudry life. Not much has been discussed about her, she unwittingly introduced Wallis to David! Intriguing and sucks you in immediately, if you like historical fiction don't pass this one up.

Was this review helpful?

This was an interesting story about the woman who loved the Prince of Wales before Wallis. This takes place during the 1920’s and the 1930’s between England and America. The story is mainly about Thelma and her life before she me met David, Prince of Wales. It also centers around her sisters trial in America for the custody of her daughter against their mother and a Vanderbilt. I wanted to feel sorry for Thelma’s sister, Gloria, but it was hard to do when she was trying to live the life of a jet setter. I found it hard to put down because I knew nothing about these people. I definitely did not agree with their lifestyle. I received a copy of this book from HarperCollins Publishing for a fair and honest opinion that I gave of my own free will.

Was this review helpful?

Disclaimer: I received this e-arc from the publisher. Thanks! All opinions are my own.

Book: The Woman Before Wallis

Author: Bryn Turnbull

Book Series: Standalone

Rating: 4.5/5

Recommended For...: romance, political intrigue, historical fiction, royal scandals

Publication Date: July 21, 2020

Genre: Historical Ficiton

Recommended Age: 18+ (romance, slight sexual content, affairs, and political intrigue)

Publisher: MIRA

Pages: 400

Synopsis: This novel is the fictionalised story of the American divorcée who captured Prince Edward’s heart before he abdicated his throne for Wallis Simpson.

In the summer of 1926, when Thelma Morgan marries Viscount Duke Furness after a whirlwind romance, she’s immersed in a gilded world of extraordinary wealth and privilege. For Thelma, the daughter of an American diplomat, her new life as a member of the British aristocracy is like a fairy tale—even more so when her husband introduces her to Edward, Prince of Wales.

In a twist of fate, her marriage to Duke leads her to fall headlong into a love affair with Edward. But happiness is fleeting, and their love is threatened when Thelma’s sister, Gloria Morgan Vanderbilt, becomes embroiled in a scandal with far-reaching implications. As Thelma sails to New York to support Gloria, she leaves Edward in the hands of her trusted friend Wallis, never imagining the consequences that will follow.

Review: Overall, this was a well done novel and it seems like it was well researched. The book is intriguing and it felt like reading someone’s private diaries. The book had a lot of well done world building and it’s the perfect book if you’re a fan of the royal family of England.

However, this book had a lot of characters and it became confusing for me to keep them straight. I also felt that the characters weren’t well developed and they just became a name.

Verdict: Worth the read!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you for the opportunity to read The Woman Before Wallis. Unfortunately, this book was not for me. Thanks again.

Was this review helpful?

There's nothing like a juicy bit of gossip to take you away from it all, and that's kind of what The Woman Before Wallis feels like to me. It's kind of like the world stands ready to soak it up every time a royal or the elite messes up, and that's where this one takes us. The story moves along at a good pace, it's well-written, and it's an entertaining way to while away a weekend. I don't read a lot of historical fiction because I get irritated when too many liberties are taken. That said, Bryn Turnbull explains the liberties she took with this story, but even if she hadn't, this one is a bit out of my wheelhouse, so I wasn't looking for said liberties. Honestly, I would say don't read it for the historical accuracy. Instead, read it for the entertainment, the feeling of looking inside the messes made by the rich and powerful, the intriguing characters, love them or hate them (and there are some of both), they are intriguing. All in all, it's an interesting bit of historical fiction that kept me interested til the very last page.

Was this review helpful?

A special thank you to NetGalley and Harlequin MIRA for an ARC in exchange for an honest review. Thank you also to Harlequin for the opportunity to be part of the blog tour.

Set in two different time periods, The Woman Before Wallis takes place in Paris in 1925, which provides Thelma's backstory, and alternates with the 1934 storyline where Thelma goes to New York City to help her twin sister, Gloria. My only criticism is that I think the narrative should've been linear, in chronological order, versus alternating timelines.

Although it is a love story, it is not a royal romance per se. It is an intimate look at the love between sisters: Thelma supported her sister in an age when being gay was seen as unacceptable except, as Gloria points out, in high society. And there is also less of the scandal that was advertised—perhaps because we all know what happened with Wallis, and this wasn't her focus. Instead, Turnbull focuses on the trial of Gloria Vanderbilt, and even then the detail was rather sparse.

And can we just appreciate the cover for a moment?

This book starts off slow, but be patient, it is meticulously crafted and worthy of your time. Given that it is historical fiction, Turnbull has taken some liberties, but she strikes the right balance between fact and fiction. If you binge watched The Crown, then I highly recommend this book!

Was this review helpful?

I do enjoy a good historical fiction book and this one really sounded interesting.



I did like this book but was it one I just couldn't put down. I found some parts of this book just dragged on. I did like the author's writing style though.



I give this 3 out of 5.

Was this review helpful?

The Woman Before Wallis is Bryn Turnbull’s debut novel. It is well written and clearly heavily researched. The novel covers two decades in Thelma Morgan Converse Furness’ life.

The Transatlantic scandal must have rocked the world, or at least, the smallish circle of high society that Gloria Vanderbilt and her sister, Thelma, travelled in. I didn’t know Gloria Vanderbilt had a twin sister, let alone that her twin was the one-time mistress of the Prince of Wales.

Thelma’s (and Gloria's) story is very interesting, and Ms. Turnbull’s dramatic period piece truly does their story justice. Social norms on the 1920s and 1930s make it hard to envy these women despite the romanticized version of them dripping jewels, dressed in gowns and traveling in posh style. Multiple divorces, affairs, a betrayal, and an ugly custody battle coupled with the flamboyant and frivolous behavior of the wealthy make for a sizzling, compulsive read. It is the type of juicy scandal that once it hits the tabloids, (current day) celebrity/royal followers couldn’t get enough of it.

I enjoyed learning about both Thelma and Gloria. Beyond their scandal-filled lives, their story is also about their bond and support of one another. Having just binge watched The Crown, I found The Woman Before Wallis to be a fascinating historical fiction.

Was this review helpful?

Thelma and her twin sister Gloria are daughters of a diplomat and are a big part of the 1920s social scene. Thelma has an affair with Edward, Prince of Wales. Gloria is the widow of a Vanderbilt and becomes ensnared in the child custody case of the century.

Oh wow! This book is full of history and famous people. I have said this before and I will say it again…I LOVE A BOOK WHICH HAS ME RESEARCHING! And boy…this one had me looking up all kinds of stuff, The Prince of Wales, Gloria Vanderbilt, Gertrude Vanderbilt Whitney. I knew a good bit about the people in the novel but, there is so much in this story and I just wanted to know more.

Now, let me say, I am giving this 5 stars but it has a few problems. It is a bit wordy in places and it is too long…in my opinion. But, this is a story about a woman in history which I knew very little about. So, I was captivated from the start. This novel is very well researched and wonderfully crafted! And isn’t this cover absolutely gorgeous!

I received this novel from the publisher for a honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Like most people I was aware of the abdication of King Edward, but mostly told from the perspective of the impacts to Queen Elizabeth and her father; The Crown on Netflix, etc. I love reading about English Royalty from authors like Phillipa Gregory and have occasionally read some about the modern royal family (The Gown, etc). What appealed to me about this story was how an American family, the Vanderbilts, intersected with the Royal Family.

This book isn't for fans of the Wallis Simpson story; she's "supporting cast" in this story because, as the title suggests, this book precedes her with Thelma's time with the future King. The story focused much more on the Vanderbilt Custody battle of "Little Gloria" (who is the niece of the main character Thelma) than I anticipated it would. If you've seen the Anderson Cooper documentary about his mother you might be familiar with the broad strokes of that part of history and this takes a much deeper dive.

My only frustration with the book was that the shifts in timeline were a clunky. The author seemed to rely purely on dates at the top of each chapter which frankly was hard to follow particularly as the two timeline moved closer together. The best authors who do the timelines in my opinion do so through a feeling of "environment" in the book or maturity in voice. For example, you know the feel of "during the war" vs. after or modern day. There wasn't that same sense of time in this book or even a shift in voice from a younger Thelma to older. Instead, I had to refer to the dates each time there was a shift which was a bit clunky.

Was this review helpful?

he Woman Before Wallis takes a bit of the classic “poor little rich girl” trope, mixes it with a splash of royal scandal, stirs it with more than a dash of the over-the-top behavior of the rich and famous and splashes into a punch bowl of history’s froth. It’s the kind of gossipy, scandal-ridden story that is easy to eat up with a very large reading spoon, because it’s just so delicious and decadent.

And both the fun of it and the tragedy of it is that we already know how it ends, because the worst excesses of the story are part of history.


Thelma and the Prince in 1932
Thelma Morgan Converse Furness was a secondary character in not one but two of the great society scandals of the 1930s, one on each side of the Atlantic. In England, as her marriage to the Viscount Furness was in the process of falling apart, she became one of the Prince of Wales’ many lovers. That she was the one who introduced him to her friend and fellow American divorcee Wallis Warfield Simpson is the stuff of which tragic romances are made – both hers and theirs.

At the same time, she left England and “David” to Wallis’ not-so-tender mercies in order to go to New York and support her twin sister, Gloria Morgan Vanderbilt, in what at the time was considered the custody trial of the century, referred to in the tabloids as “The Matter of Vanderbilt”. Thelma’s little niece, Gloria Vanderbilt (yes, THE Gloria Vanderbilt) was kidnapped by her aunt, the artist Gertrude Vanderbilt Whitney, who sued Gloria Morgan Vanderbilt for custody of the little heiress and won, based on some rather questionable evidence provided by members of both families who seem to have hated the mother much more than they cared what was best for the child. Little Gloria seems to have been a pawn of the older women in her life until she reached adulthood.

That the same person was a secondary player in both of these history-making scandals makes Thelma an ideal candidate for a salacious, gossipy, scandal-ridden story of epic proportions.

This is her story, from her ring-side seat to history. And it’s a juicy one.

Escape Rating B: I have mixed feelings about this story. On the one hand, it’s a very juicy story of debauchery and decadence, a gossipy melange of well-known historical figures with a whole lot of dirt and scandal.

On the other hand, as glitzy and glittery as this story is, the people covered in that glitz feel shallow. I think we’re meant to feel that both Thelma and Gloria, the twin Morgan girls, were in the end somewhat hard done by. That they loved and lost and didn’t have nearly enough control of the circumstances under which they lived or the choices they made. Poor little rich girls who made one hell of a lot of mistakes.


Gloria Morgan Vanderbilt with her daughter at age eight
In the end, it felt like the only person really hard done by in this story is little Gloria, whose custody and whose fortune end up being the prize in a long-running battle between her mother, her aunt and her grandmother over who hates whom the most and who can throw the most muck at whom fast enough to win. The problem with this kind of muck-racking fight is that no one emerges from it either clean or unscathed. And so it proved in this case.

Thelma, in the end, feels like a secondary player in her own life, supporting her twin sister at the cost of her own happiness. And that’s after ending her second marriage to have an affair with the Prince of Wales, only to be abandoned in favor of Wallis Simpson when the scandal of her sister’s custody trial began to turn in her direction – and his.

That all adds up to very mixed feelings. The book is compulsively readable, and I enjoyed the portrait of life among the rich and famous in the years just before and after the start of the Great Depression. But there’s a sense of “fiddling while Rome burns”, that there’s just no there there under the glamour.

I can’t help but think of the true definition of the word glamour, however. That a glamour is, according to Merriam-Webster, “An exciting and often illusory and romantic attractiveness.” By that definition, this story is glamorous indeed.

Was this review helpful?

'The Woman Before Wallis' is a debut novel from a Canadian writer. This historical fiction book is set in 1929 and 1934 and follows the life of Thelma Morgan, who is the twin sister of Gloria Vanderbilt (mother of Gloria Vanderbilt and grandmother of Anderson Cooper). Thelma had a years long affair with Prince Edward (who became King Edward VIII before abdicating)and this story is detailed in the novel. The book also chronicles the famous custody fight for Little Gloria...'the poor little rich girl'. This fascinating look at the lives of the rich and famous is a wonderful recommendation for historical fiction fans.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars

I received an ARC from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

While everyone knows about the scandal surrounding Edward VIII’s abdication in order to marry Wallis Simpson and their subsequent antics as the Duke and Duchess of Windsor, I knew less about the women he was associated with prior to getting together with her. And while The Woman Before Wallis is in part about Edward’s relationship with Thelma, it’s just as much about who she was in her own right.

While it did take a bit to get into the ebb-and-flow or the story, as it goes back and forth between 1934, after the demise of Thelma’s marriage and as her affair with Edward is crumbling and following her sister Gloria’s custody battle, and the years leading up to it, exploring both her marriage and the good times with Edward as their relationship began, I found it ultimately rewarding. I like that it centered her relationship with her sister and mother, thus helping to shine a light on how her family shaped her worldview, especially in regards to men and money.

It is also interesting to see how Turnbull approaches both Edward and Wallis from Thelma’s perspective. I was intrigued that the two associated with each other during Thelma’s relationship with Edward, although ultimately not surprised, given the way high society people tend to restrict themselves to an insular set. Wallis’ aspirations to rise socially, and the altering nature of her interactions with Thelma are well done, foreshadowing a shift in the dynamic as time goes on. And while abdication was likely not something seriously considered until 1936, I love how, even though she is in love with him, Thelma does convey a sense of Edward’s weakness and lack of suitability to step into the role as king, in comparison to his younger brother.

This is a masterful work of historical fiction, conveying real life events of notable people from the perspective of someone who may not be as well known to the average person, aside from a supporting player in others’ stories. If you love historical fiction about the Royal Family, the Vanderbilts, and historical women who aren’t that well known, then I recommend this book highly.

Was this review helpful?

THE WOMAN BEFORE WALLIS: A Novel of Windsors, Vanderbilts and Royal Scandal by Bryn Turnbull is a historical fiction book that I have been waiting anxiously to read and it did not disappoint. This is the story of the American divorcee who captured Prince Edward’s heart before Wallis Simpson.

Thelma Morgan is divorced and has no prospects until her identical twin sister Gloria Morgan Vanderbilt and her husband, Reggie introduce her to Viscount Duke Furness. After a whirlwind romance, she is married, becomes the Viscountess Furness and is immersed into the decadent and wealthy life of the British aristocracy.

When Thelma learns Duke is having an affair, she is devastated, but her friends counsel her to live her own life and ignore it. At a party she is introduced to Edward, Prince of Wales. She finds him charming and soon the two are embroiled in a love affair.

Gloria Vanderbilt is fighting a terrible custody battle against her own mother and Gertrude Vanderbuilt in New York. The scandal sheets are posting terrible stories, so Thelma decides she must sail to American to stand by her sister and niece. As Thelma leaves England, she asks her trusted friend to watch over Edward. Wallis Simpson.

I love all the characters in this story. I believe that the author did a wonderful job of bringing them all to life; foibles and all. It is always interesting to read about the rich and famous and realize the social, political and/or personal pressures they live with and their money does not really make them happy. Even though I knew what would happen with both Gloria and Thelma, and this is not a history book, but historical fiction, I could not put the book down. It pulled me into the intrigue and scandal of their lives.

This is perfect for all the Anglophiles out there that can never get enough!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC.

Bryn Turnbull's THE WOMAN BEFORE WALLIS is a startling debut novel. Turnbull's writing is crisp, the story is well-researched, the dual timelines are masterfully intertwined, and the plot is mostly engrossing. I'm a sucker for good historical fiction, and WOMAN is excellent historical fiction.

Lady Thelma Morgan Furness, the woman who came before Wallis Simpson, played a pivotal but much overlooked role in two of the biggest scandals of the 1930s: the Vanderbilt custody trial and Edward VIII's abdication of the British throne. Sister to Gloria Morgan Vanderbilt and mistress to Edward before his coronation, Thelma had a front row seat to history. The novel follows Thelma in two timelines. The first progresses from the glitz and glamour of the late 1920s, to Thelma's marriage to Lord Marmaduke Furness, and finally through her affair with David, Prince of Wales. The second timeline covers Thelma's return to New York City for the custody trial of her niece, Little Gloria Vanderbilt. Turnbull's pace is strong and her characters are well-drawn. Thelma's fears and frustrations felt real - her joys a little less so (I think this comes down to my own biases about the way high society live, though). Ultimately I was left marveling over what a fascinating life Thelma lived.

WOMAN really is an excellent novel. It would have been a five-star read if just a few more things had been fleshed out:
- Turnbull says the novel is a love story for sisters, but I actually felt the sisterly bond was a little tenuous in the narrative. Gloria and Thelma spent the rest of their lives together after the trial, but there was little in the novel to make me believe that Thelma would give up her life to take care of her sister.
- Turnbull acknowledges that she played with the timeline of Thelma and David's relationship.
I wonder if the author knows what really drew Thelma and David apart (if not the trial, David's reticence to get involved, Thelma's sense of responsibility to her sister)? I would have appreciated that closure, even if in the author's note.
- A lot of the book takes place in David's home of Fort Belvedere. It would have been nice to know what happened to the Fort on David's abdication. (I did some googling on this one myself to find the answer: it stayed in the Crown Estate and is currently home to private tenants. Notably, it was also the location of David's actual abdication in 1936.)

In summary, WOMAN is an incredibly well-researched and well-written debut historical novel. I would highly recommend it to fans of historical fiction, women's fiction, or royal history.

Was this review helpful?

Scandal on both side of the Atlantic! I'll admit that I was, before reading this, completely unaware of Thelma, Lady Furness, while I did know the story of Wallis Simpson and the outlines of the Gloria Morgan Vanderbilt custody battle over young Gloria Vanderbilt (mom of Anderson Cooper among other things.). This is the story of the elder Gloria's twin, who lived quite a vivid life of her own. Alternating between the 1920s, when Thelma met Lord Furness and the 1930s when she returns to the US, it's an interesting outline of a woman who hasn't received much attention. Her affair Edward, well, that's just one more thing I didn't know abut him. This isn't particularly in depth (it's a big life to cover) but if you're a fan of the Crown this might be right for you. I spent some time googling various people for more info. Thanks to the publisher for the ARC. For fans of historical fiction.

Was this review helpful?

The Woman Before Wallis is the fictionalized story of Thelma Morgan who had an affair with Edward, Prince of Wales before he abdicated his throne for Wallis Simpson.

The daughters of an American diplomat, Thelma and Gloria Morgan were stars of New York social scene in the early 1920s and both married into wealth and privilege. Gloria married Reggie Vanderbilt and Thelma to a viscount who she later leaves for Edward, the dashing Prince of Wales. The girl’s perfect lives are dashed by Gloria’s custody trial. Gloria is sued by members of her late husband's family on charges of negligence, unfit parenting, and homosexuality, and Gloria needs her twin's support more than ever. But as her sister gains international notoriety, Thelma fears that her own dreamlife will end.

I had a hard time getting into this book. While the book is lynch pinned around the Vanderbilt trail, the story is told in rotating time periods. It is only about halfway through the book that the scandal comes to light for the readers in a way that draws them in. It also takes this long to get through Thelma’s previous two husbands and get to her relationship with Prince Edward. These two stories are what drew my attention, and I feel the author spent too much time on the past events that could have efficiently been told in a more succinct manner.

The other issue with the novel is the historical parts are left to the Author’s Note. The outcome of the trail and Thelma’s relationship with Edward isn’t concluded within the story and that’s a loss especially with it being a historical fiction novel. I would have expected the novel to have the history and give the closure to the stories Bryn Turnbull set up.

I’ve been hard on this book, but I did enjoy a portion of it immensely. I enjoyed reading about Thelma and Edward and how she worked with him and kept him on an even keel. I enjoyed the bond between the two sister and Thelma’s great sacrifice for Gloria.

But over the entire good portion is trapped between boring prose and a lack of a true conclusion.

Was this review helpful?