I read Vernon Subutex 1 & 2 back in 2018 and really enjoyed them. I re-read both in the few days before reading this third volume in 2020 and I thoroughly enjoyed them again. I enjoyed the first volume for its storytelling and the way Despentes introduces us to a large cast of characters each of which is presented non-judgementally (despite some contradictory politics) and developed in a way that really brings them to life. I enjoyed the second volume for the way it ran with that cast of characters but at a slower pace, giving time for introspection and observation.
I was, therefore, very much looking forward to this third part. Part 1 and a large proportion of Part 2 deal with the story of Vernon Subutex and his descent from record store owner to vagrant. Vernon’s story introduces us to tape recordings by the music star Alex Bleach that set the entertainment world alight as certain individuals try to track down both Subutex and the tapes. Once found, we understand why one character in particular is keen to stop others seeing the tapes and this story starts to take precedence whilst, in parallel, Vernon becomes a kind of guru to a small community.
The third part carries this story on and opens with Vernon being forced to take a trip away from the group and take a journey to a dentist in Paris. Whilst he is there he learns about the death of a friend who has left a lot of money to the group. Having a lot of money is always a problem and this community is no exception to the trouble it can cause. The “convergences” (sort of like raves but without drugs) that the group has been organising have been transforming people’s lives through music, including something new that Alex Bleach was developing in the time leading up to his death, but all this is threatened by tensions amongst the group members. At the same time, the character who has something to hide sets to get his revenge ensure his evil ways are not exposed.
So far, so good. Part 3, it turns out, is a lot more political than the first two parts. All the way through the series there have been asides that take us into the thoughts and views of the different characters and many of these have been political. This significantly increases here and includes many actual events from France’s recent history (e.g. Charlie Hebdo, Bataclan). For this reader, it began to feel that the political commentary was taking over the book: the passages examining characters’ viewpoints get longer and longer and come more frequently and often the progress of the story seems an after thought at the end of a chapter.
But it is still interesting for the first half of the book. Having lived with these characters for 2.5 books, I felt that I was getting to know some of them pretty well. Despentes writes very believable and real people into her books.
However, from about halfway through this third volume, it started to feel as though things were starting to slide out of control. I found myself reading more and more nervously, hoping that what I felt was happening wouldn’t come to pass. Having invested a significant amount of time reading three books, I was worried about how it seemed to be running away.
And, in the end, the dramatic finale feels sudden and rushed. Not only that, but it feels almost entirely unbelievable.
And then, after the drama of the climax, there is a denouement, a sort of epilogue, which is, quite simply, bizarre.
Ultimately, then, I find myself disappointed with the book I have just read. And that disappointment then reflects back through the whole of the trilogy. In the end, I give the book 3 stars because of the characters that I came to know and believe in. But I find myself almost wishing I had stopped after 2 or 2.5 books and not read to the end.