Cover Image: The Four Winds

The Four Winds

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Such a great book. Kristin Hannah is wicked talented. I cried my eyes out. This was the first book I have read by this author, and now, I want to go back and read all her books!

Was this review helpful?

I became a Kristin Hannah fan when I read THE NIGHTINGALE -- and THE FOUR WINDS confirmed that she's the kind of author who finds her way into your heart at Page 1 and never, ever lets go. "Enjoy" is not the right word to describe how I felt about THE FOUR WINDS; it's a sad -- even brutal -- read at time, this story of Elsa, a mother from a Texas farming town trying to save her children and find a drop of dignity as she migrates to California during the Great Depression and the Dust Bowl. The hunger, the deprivation, the hatred and greed that traps her deeper and deeper into poverty all affected me so strongly -- and yet Elsa's integrity and resilience and courage made this book so gripping and such an emotional read for me. I especially loved the female relationships in the book -- notably Elsa and her daughter, Elsa and her mother-in-law, and Elsa and the friend she makes in the ditch camp. I really enjoyed the audio version of this book, which included an interview with the author.

Was this review helpful?

Kristin Hannah is an auto-read author for me - she definitely knows how to weave an emotional yet epic story about love and loss.

In this story we travel back to the 1920s and 1930s to see how one family endures the tragedy of The Great Depression coupled with the environmental disaster that was later coined “The Dust Bowl.”

Something that I love about history / historic fiction is that I always learn something about the past that can also be applied to the here and now. In this story, thousands of people migrate from The Great Plains seeking opportunity in California, only to be treated horrifically by locals who see them as outsiders. Sounds familiar, right? Meanwhile, we are reminded that we must care for our environment or face devastating consequences (and that science is a good thing!).

Solid four star read for me!!

Was this review helpful?

I had heard a lot of buzz about this book - as is the case with many of Kristin Hannah's past books. Having read and enjoyed the Nightingale I thought I would give this one a try, especially after all the hype. Well I feel like this one was hyped a little too much. It was just an alright read for me. It kept my interest and taught me about a period of history I really didn't know much about. I enjoyed the characters but just felt like something was missing a little. I will definitely give her other books a chance. She writes very well and has interesting characters and I love a good strong female relationship between mother and daughter as was depicted in this story.

Was this review helpful?

Wow! This book showed me so much of a time I knew very little about. It broke my heart, but opened my eyes! It made me feel. Books about a mother's love always seem to be tops for me.

Was this review helpful?

What a great book! Once I got started I literally could not put it down and read it all within 24 hours. It was such a compelling book that made you feel like you were right there living during the Dust Bowl times. This is the first book I've read about this time period but I was totally engrossed and loved learning about how so many traveled to California for a better life.

If you enjoy books by Kristin Hannah you will love this one! I highly recommend it.

Thank you Netgalley for the opportunity to read and review. All opinions are my own.

Published 2 February 2021

Was this review helpful?

Strong themes of who is, and who isn't, family, and that without unity workers will never overcome the manipulation of the big business and thus be enslaved in a cycle of poverty This page turner will break your heart, and at the end you will realize that “pulling yourself up by the bootstraps” sounds nice, but it is a farce.

Was this review helpful?

I really love everything Kristin Hannah writes, and I'll be recommending this to all of my fellow historical fiction lovers! It took me a while to get into this book, but I really enjoyed the writing. It was bleak and engrossing, and I just kept wanting better things for the main character.

Was this review helpful?

There is a reason this book was voted Book of the Year! The story moves quickly and has a lot of dramatic turns. Even though it's long, it won't take you a month to read. You'll want to hear more about Elsa's story, and what could possible come next.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this advanced copy in exchange for a review.

Was this review helpful?

"Courage is fear you ignore."

I enjoyed this story of Elsa Wolcott Martinelli. Twenty-five years old when the story starts and considered an unmarriageable spinster by her family, she just wants a family of her own and love.

"Elsa had survived it all by being quiet, by not demanding or seeking attention, by accepting that she was loved, but unliked."

After an indiscretion, she is forced into marriage with a farmer's son and her life begins and she finds the family she has desired.

This is a tough tale to read at times, starting in Texas in 1921 and going through the Great Depression,the Dust Bowl days, and following Elsa and her family to California as she looks for a way for her family to survive.

It is quite an epic tale of these daunting times in America's history and a strong woman who will do anything to protect her family.

I highly recommend this book - one of the best of 2021.

I received this book from St. Martin's Press through Net Galley in the hopes that I would read it and leave an unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

The Four Winds is a breathtaking story about human resilience. Beginning in the 1830s and spanning several years, Kristin Hannah paints a tale of survival and the "American dream" in the midst of the Dust Bowl and Great Depression. Like many of Hannah's other works, The Four Winds is powerful and at times difficult to read. I read this book in a single sitting and was left wondering if I would have had the strength to endure the Dust Bowl migration and subsequent hostility upon arriving in the West.

Hannah focuses her story on Elsa and her two children. Motherhood and sacrifice are prominent themes in The Four Winds, and Hannah writes characters who feel incredibly realistic and fully realized. This goes for not just the central family in this story but also all of the side characters. Whether you are rooting for or against them, the side characters felt purposeful and carefully crafted.

I highly recommend reading The Four Winds (as well as everything else Kristin Hannah has written). I can't think of another author who can perfectly interweave bleakness and hope the way that Hannah does. I can't give this book anything but five stars, and I will return to this story again and again.

Thank you to St. Martin's Press for an eArc of The Four Winds in exchange for my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for an advanced copy of this book. Elsa Martinelli and her two children decided to go west after her husband abandoned them in the midst of the Great Depression. "They headed west in search of a better life, but their American Dream was turned into a nightmare by poverty, hardship and greed." They had to learn how to be independent without a man to defend them. This is a story of love and determination of one warrior and her children. Another amazing book by Kristen Hannah.

Was this review helpful?

What can one say about THE FOUR WINDS that hasn't already been said? Hannah simply shines with prose that breathes life into her tale. Having been a fan of the author's for a long time, it was so wonderful to see her take on the time period of the Great Depression and give her readers Elsa, a character I will not soon forget. Bringing together the history behind what her characters are dealing with, Hannah also shows humanity through family, hope, and the desire for the American dream.

Was this review helpful?

The Four Winds lives up to the hype. A brilliant tale of mother and daughter set across the backdrop of the dust bowl. Some parts were repetitive, but generally I was engaged the whole time. I highly recommend it to people who love historical fiction or who read Dear America books as a kid.

Was this review helpful?

This book was not for me. I found it to be depressing. Kristin Hannah is a great writer but I felt she missed the mark with this book. I felt I was being manipulated to feel sad during emotional scenes instead of it happening naturally.

Was this review helpful?

Riveting, yet so sad. An well-researched glimpse into the dust bowl era..as usual, Hannah's characters are well developed. It's hard to fathom this was life in the United States at one time. Thank you for the opportunity to read this amazing work.

Was this review helpful?

Really enjoyed this piece of historical fiction!

The opening chapters follow Elsa as she ends up pregnant and forced to marry the man who got her that way. Working on his family farm turns out to be exactly what Elsa needs - until the drought and dust storms destroy profits and start deteriorating people’s health. She makes a break for it, taking her family to California where better lives have been promised. But with the flood of newcomers, jobs are scarce, pay is low, and it’s not the American dream they all hoped it would be. Elsa’s story is one of constant obstacles to overcome, and I enjoyed it!

Was this review helpful?

this is a story about the Dustbowl Era, a time period I was not very familiar with and truthfully not very interested in, which made me put off reading this for forever. I was surprised that I was hooked as soon as I started it, immediately drawn into the main character’s heartbreaking story. the first half of this book completely enraptured me and I could not get enough of it. by the second half though, things got reeeeeal slow and also took a turn that just felt odd to me. I hated the ending but overall I do recommend this unique work of historical fiction especially if you’re already a fan of Kristin Hannah!

Was this review helpful?

It is impossible to read this excellent book without visualizing Dorothea Lange’s stunning photos from the depression area Dust Bowl migrants.. I have uploaded several poignant photos to my review on GoodReads.

After finishing this book, the first thing I did was to begin scrolling the internet to revel in their beauty. The beauty of the photos that is, and not the beauty of the period (more photos, for anyone interested, can be found all over the internet and all are available for view on Library of Congress Internet site - just google LOC Dororthea Lange).

Kristin Hannah’s, The Four Winds, is a brief history (circa 1930's) of how the depression and Dust Bowl drought brought hunger and poverty to masses of people in the region. Many lost their homes, their livelihood, their farms. Families broke apart and many died of disease, hunger and dust pneumonia. I could describe more but the best description can be seen through the eyes of the main protagonist Elsa Martinelli and her family. This is the third book I’ve read by this prolific and consistently winning author. I think most readers will already be familiar with the history of the period and all of the circumstances described. Never-the-less, the pages flip briskly, and I found myself completely absorbed from the beginning to the very last page. Whereas Lange exquisitely captures the portraits of the down and out migrant worker families, Hannah fleshes out with realistic detailed scenes of the hardships suffered.

Elsa was a sickly child from a wealthy family and, for reasons unclear, eschewed by her parents. Unloved by her family, Elsa sought out love in an unexpected way, became pregnant, and was tossed out like the evening trash on the Texas farm doorstep of her reluctant, soon to be in-laws. Elsa’s husband was never happy on the farm, he had dreams of grandeur and spent most of his time drinking and sleeping in the barn. Eventually he succumbed to his unhappiness, upping and leaving his wife, two children, and parents, in pursuit of his dream. The farm provided well for the family for many years before that, but then the depression hit hard, coupled with harsh continuous years of drought. The crops and farm animals were gone, the barn equipment, house, and cemetery were destroyed, the bank was foreclosing on part of their land and the family was finally defeated and forced to make desperate decisions. There are terrifying descriptions of the drought, dust storms, withered crops, dirt, hunger, dust pneumonia, and the constant exhausting filth and hard work endured to barely survive. Finally, Elsa loads the children and as much of their belongings as she could onto the family’s dilapidated truck. With a small amount of loose change that the family cobbled together, she and the children headed west to the promised land of California, where she could find work and give her children a better life.

Well, as most readers already know, or can guess, there was no better life for the migrant workers. In fact, it was even worse.

This book has it all and the descriptions are starkly realistic – the Dust Bowl drought, the migrant trip across three states to California, the squalid migrant camps rife with disease, hunger, and hopelessness. The massive farms were owned by wealthy businessmen who provided inferior housing, and a Company Store where the workers were forced to buy all their food and supplies, beds and housing on credit at gouging prices more than twice that of the towns, insuring their workers' indebtedness and guaranteeing virtual slave labor. Then there are the unwelcoming town residents who ridiculed and humiliated – not to mention the communist unionizers, who brought danger while trying to organize the workers.

I think this is a must-read for anyone unfamiliar with this difficult period of U.S. history. And although there will be no surprises for those who have studied or read stories of the period, it is a humbling reminder to count our daily blessings.

Many thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for an ARC of this book (which has in the meantime been published) for my candid review. It was an excellent read.

Was this review helpful?

Read this one with kleenex nearby. I was fascinated by this novel, I never learned much about this time in history during school, and Kristin Hannah is so detailed in her research that it felt like it could be a real non-fiction story of a woman trying to survive during some of the worst of times. Not only survive, but raise and provide for her children too. A story of strength and resilience in the face of some unimaginable hardships. Highly recommend.

Was this review helpful?