Member Reviews
Tara V, Librarian
I could not put this book down! What an incredible main character! I love books about strong females, especially historic novels. A spy thriller with an educated woman at it's center, in New York City, what more can you want? |
Karla G, Educator
Katharina, an affluent mother of 2 young children wrestles with her place in life after leaving an exciting career translating for the United Nations post WWII.. Given her language translation skills and international experience, Katharina then finds herself being pursued by the FBI to be a courier of Communist documents in effort to catch a spy. The tension develops as she develops renewed vigor being a working woman in the early 1950s, keeping secrets from her rich and powerful husband, and leaving her children in the care of others. |
Phenomenal read as you follow the main character on her journey of transitioning from Upper East Side mom to FBI corespondent. The writing was beautiful and I really felt connected with the character as I watched her go through her downward spiral of alcohol, depression and disruptive marriage. Definitely would be interested in reading more from Karin Tanabe. |
Overall I enjoyed the story and I think the author wrote a main character that the reader could really get to know and sympathize with. Bits of it were improbable in somewhat predictable but it was a quick easy read. I can see it is kind of a bitch read wore a book for an airplane ride. Enjoyable and something you don’t need to think too deeply about. |
I enjoyed the end of the book far more than the beginning. It has an interesting story about a woman stuck in her position as wife to a prestigious pediatric surgeon, and mother of two young children. It's a story full of her frustration with being forced to give up her own challenging, and fulfilling, career to stay home and play house while her husband pursues his career at the hospital. For the most part the story is interesting, but seems to get just as stuck in her situation as she is. The last part of the book was the portion that kept my interest best as it pulled the pieces of the story together into a conclusion that left me feeling as though I had seen her through a difficult time. I felt happy for her, knowing that she came out on the other side stronger and better able to face the challenge that was her life. |
Tina H, Bookseller
An enjoyable read about a fascinating time in our country's history. I've read a lot of WW1 and WW2 historical fiction, but this particular time period is not one I've read much from, but found it to be a very interesting backdrop for an ageless story about a woman struggling with how marriage and children change her identity. Definitely recommend. |
Reviewer 224445
Set in 1950s New York City, Rina Edgeworth, nee West, is stifled in her current life — married to a successful doctor with two young boys, she craves independence, time for herself, and the career she had to give up with her got married. Her life is overwhelming her - the constant round the clock tending to her kids with no help from her husband who spends all his time at work is sending her into a physical, mental, and emotional abyss. The pressures of her husband’s family and their social circle further exacerbates the situation. For someone who is smart and witty, who graduated from Columbia University, speaks four languages fluently, and had a successful career working at City Hall and the United Nation, her life as a wife and mother leaves her no room for the mental challenges, adult conversation, and fun-filled time she enjoyed prior to her current life. When she’s approached by the FBI to connect with a former lover and become an informant, she jumps at the chance to inject some excitement, thrill, and mental agility into her staid and claustrophobic life. This was a good storyline - shining a light on the challenges of a marriage post-honeymoon period and the coming along of children, and the expectations of each involved. This was a good read, the story moved along at a nice clip, and the book captures well the lifestyle of the upper crust and oftentimes shallow societal goings on of the times. I thought the author captured well the drive and longing that Rina had to be her own person, be recognized for her contributions, pursue a career in her own right and not be just the wife of a doctor and the mother of two kids. She couldn’t be whole and happy without her independence, without her own self-worth, and without her own decision making. A solid three-star rating - Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review this book. |
I received this e-ARC from NetGalley for an honest review. The story takes place mainly in the 1950s while the main character, Rina, is married with two young children. From the outside she appears to have the perfect life, but it is far from it. Her doctor husband is barely around and she is mentally drowning staying at home with the children. She misses, and remembers, the excitement of her life before when she was a translator/interpreter with the fledgling UN. She starts spiraling until one day she is approached with an opportunity to get involved in a spy mission, which she takes. By the end she finds herself again and manages to assert herself in her marriage, finding happiness once more. It was a good book, but I found at times I was getting bored as she went through her tailspin. I get that we need to see her descent into desperation, but it felt a little long. |
This story really had me intrigued from the start! I love historical fiction and haven’t read much from the post-war time frame so I was excited for something different. I also really enjoyed they fact that Katharina had such a modern way about her for the era (I love a rebel). I found Katharina relatable, although I don’t have kids, I understood her desire for fulfillment outside of her marriage. Other than that, the story kind of lost it for me. I was hoping for more danger, more intrigue, and more involvement in the action on Katharina’s part. This began to feel a bit like a sob story, rather than the Feminist historical fiction I had hoped for. Overall, it wasn’t a bad story, just not what I had hoped for and as far as historical fiction goes, their are much stronger stories out there. |
As the story begins, it’s about family and socializing. It takes a moment to get to those first bits of who she is and who her husband is. And those straight forward written short pieces are the most interesting pieces of this story. The style of writing is very descriptive with dialogue which doesn’t move the story forward. We get a short glimpse of how she gets a job for UN as a translator. Then the story is filled again with family life and her social life as a student. And the next moment, she gets approached by an FBI agent in regards to a certain person and they want her to work with them. And then again, it’s filled with a lot but I didn’t find it engaging. I struggled from the very beginning to connect with this story and with the main character. She went to Ivy League school and speaks four languages, works for UN and FBI but turns out to be a character who lacks depth. There are plenty of readers who appreciate descriptive writing and will enjoy this story. Thus, I do not want to discourage anyone from reaching for this book. |
I really wanted to love this but I just wasn’t blown away. It was a good read and it was intriguing enough to keep me reading but it just fell a little flat. Love the setting of a post war Manhattan and the fact that the story revolves around a woman trying to juggle motherhood and espionage. |
Shana M, Reviewer
This novel's protagonist, Katharina (Rina), begins as a career-focused woman with a penchant for partying, but we find her as a wife to a wealthy doctor, the mother of two, and the inhabitant of a luxurious Fifth Avenue home in post-WWII New York City. Though she used to work as a translator at the United Nations, her husband expects that she will now dote on their sons 24/7, because he refuses to have them raised by nannies the way he had been. On the surface, Rina's life looks perfect, but she feels a soul-crushing boredom and helplessness that no one else seems to understand. Tanabe does a phenomenal job of describing these feelings and making Rina relatable to those of us who have also felt that lack of fulfillment after becoming a stay-at-home parent. But things pick up with Rina is contacted by an FBI agent who asks for her assistance in gaining information from an ex-lover from graduate school who happens to be a Soviet spy. Though reluctant, Rina soon finds excitement and a sense of purpose in helping the FBI, though it also brings up conflicting feelings as she reconnected with her ex and meets some nice Communists along the way. Ideologically, the book doesn't delve into too much, but it's clear that things aren't as cut and dry as the news makes it out to be. The one fault I had with this book was that there were so many false leads. Characters or events would be introduced who then seemingly had no significance in the telling of the story. Or there's be some suspense and perhaps the hint of a mystery, but that lead would fall flat too. In a sense, though, this could also be seen as a positive aspect because Tanabe remains true to the experiences of Rina. Rather than meandering into other territory, she stays focused on Rina's personal emotional journey and empowerment. All in all, an engaging read! |
If you enjoy historical fiction, you will enjoy “Woman of Intelligence” by Karin Tanabe. I have been a fan of the author since her first novel, “The List.” When she switched to historical fiction for “The Gilded Age,” that was just icing on the cake. Here, we meet Rina, wife to a wealthy pediatrician, Tom, and mother to two children. Like many women in the early fifties, Rina is not satisfied with her role as wife and mother. In particular, Rina has an extensive educational background, is multilingual and used to work as a translator for the U.N. Hence, when Tom berates her for not doing a good job caring for their children, Rina falls into disconnect. Enter the FBI, who contacts Rina to be an informant. Take care of an unsatisfied husband and two petulant children or spy on a former boyfriend who may be a Communist? Easy choice. Karin Tanabe is a master at creating compelling characters that are set in different slices of history. What makes this story enthralling is its focus on a woman struggling to find out who she is outside the roles society has set for her. You watch Rina evolve as she becomes who she is meant to be. The descriptions of 1950’s New York at the height of the Red Scare are utterly absorbing. Honestly, I could have done without the superspy stuff and parts of the story do drag, but I do suggest you give this book a try. Thanks to Karin Tanabe, St. Martin’s Press and Netgalley for my advanced copy. |
Eileen K, Reviewer
Katharina “Rina” Edgworth is a malcontent. Neither marriage nor motherhood is living up to society’s expectations. Despite the east side apartment, handsome physician husband and two healthy boys, she is dissatisfied. Her husband and in-laws are critical of her parental skills and concerned about her drinking and erratic behavior; a neighbor has accused her of infidelity. Relief comes in the form of an FBI agent, fueled by the Red Scare, who asks her to connect with a former lover from college days. In doing this, she will infiltrate a Communist ring of spies, led by this man. Lonely for her working years at the UN, she accepts his challenge and finds herself leading a second life. Energized by the thrill of being a spy and falling in love with another man feed her void. Will she continue to muddle up motherhood and marriage? Will she contact her divorce lawyer friend and give in to the passion she feels for this new man? Karin Tanabe presents a flawed, complex female protagonist who feels truly valuable when using her intelligence in the world of intelligence. A sequel seems in order. |
Carol S, Educator
I love female spies so this was right up my alley. Fun and thrilling! Loved it. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher! |
Pam C, Reviewer
I absolutely loved this book. Motherhood & espionage couldn't be a better combo. Finding herself in her marriage is such a sad subject, but Rina is such a strong character. & never really forgets herself. Thank you Netgalley for this book! |
This historical fiction book takes you to the days of New York, immediately after World War II, when a return of the soldiers brought a return to normalcy and a return to the old way of doing things. The advances that women made in the workforce during the war were turned back and women were once again expected to be the keeper of the home and nothing else. Enter our protagonist, Katharina, a well-educated, smart, and spunky working woman who speaks several languages and works as a translator at the newly formed United Nations. After marrying into a prominent family, Katharina is expected to produce babies, not translated documents. She has two small boys and an absent husband who is too busy with his altruistic job as a pediatric surgeon to notice his wife’s descent into what we would describe today as postpartum depression. This leaves her susceptible to the FBI, who wants Katharina to infiltrate a Communist organization, using her language skills and intelligence. Excited to have something of her own and time away from her small children, Katharina goes on a dangerous mission to protect America against a growing Communist threat. I really enjoyed this thrilling read and couldn’t turn the pages fast enough. Katharina is a very likable character, not without flaws but with real, complicated issues with work, family, and life balance that almost any mother could empathize with, even in today’s world. The tug between her children’s needs and her need for intellectual stimulation outside of the four walls of her apartment is palpable and understandable. Her husband’s lack of awareness of his wife’s needs and his obvious issues stemming from his childhood are infuriating. You just want to scream at him to help her, be there for her, allow her to get some help! One of the most enjoyable things about this book was the witty banter between the female characters and their willingness to help each other whether it was a touching gift from an enemy turned friend to the mother-in-law finally telling her whiny son how hard it is to be a mother. The action from the spying scenes in the book are heart-stopping and propel the story to a satisfying ending. I recommend this book for anyone who loves strong women characters who finally come into their own in books. I loved the evocative scenes of 1950s New York and the vivid descriptions of the clothes, food, and lifestyle of New Yorkers from all walks of life. The powerful messages it gives about women’s roles in work and family life are as important now as they were in 1950. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for giving me an Advanced Reader Copy to review. |
A Woman of Intelligence by Karin Tanabe 9781250231505 Pages Publisher: St. Martin’s Press Release Date: July 20, 2021 Fiction (Adult), Women’s Fiction, Espionage In the 1940s and 1950s, Katharina worked for the United Nations as an interpreter. She was an independent free spirit until she met Dr. Tom Edgeworth. After they married and she was pregnant with their first son, she quit work and became a stay-at-home mother and wife. Her life then revolved around walks to the park and chasing her toddler son. She was slowing losing herself. After a small breakdown, she met an FBI agent and was recruited to do some undercover work. Her history at university and her ability to speak several languages, including Russian got her in the door. She became a part of the investigation into official documents being smuggled to Russia. As the work progressed, she felt more like her old self and wondered if she could ever go back to being Mrs. Edgeworth again. Initially I had a problem getting into the book. Except for Rina, many of characters were unlikeable. The story had a steady pace and was told in the first-person point of view. As I was reading, I thought if this was my life, I would have run away by now. I felt so bad for the Rina and the life she lost and cheered as she gained some independence. This is a glimpse into the life of an upper class married woman at the time. If you like books with strong woman roles, you will definitely enjoy this one. |
I am a huge fan of historical fiction and this was full of historical references. Set in post-war Manhattan it followed a mother of two boys through a journey of losing herself in her marriage and motherhood but finding herself again through an unexpected turn of events. Seeing this woman struggling through motherhood and marriage being tapped to help the FBI in following Communists and give information was quite interesting. This novel was a little slow for me at times, but I did enjoy the story. I was itching for more interactions between Rina and Turner and to have their relationship move further along, but for the 1950s that was the right amount of lust and feelings for them. At moments I found myself getting angry and frustrated at Tom and the others in their elite circle judging her for excessive drinking and struggling to be a mother. I am sure a woman who has multiple degrees, can speak four or five languages and used to work for the United Nations has a hard time running after two rambunctious boys. She lost her identity in her marriage and tried to cope in any way she could which led to people thinking she is an alcoholic and having a psychotic break. I loved the parts where she was working with Turner and Lee and following Jacob and Ava. The story started off pretty slow and I wanted more of the story in the end. The ending to me felt unfinished, but I liked the fact that it was open ended and you hoped she found herself again and was able to work in City Hall and keep doing great things for the country. I truly enjoyed reading this book and I recommend it to anyone who like historical fiction! <img src="https://www.netgalley.com/badge/996ef5f55478b9c9c228544a04c8a7d5fc62c702" width="80" height="80" alt="Professional Reader" title="Professional Reader"/> |
A Woman of Intelligence is a historical fiction novel set in New York City in the early 1950’s. The main character, Katharina (Rina) Edgeworth is in her early forties, the wife of a wealthy pediatric surgeon and mother of two young boys. Prior to the domestic life she currently leads, she used her Ivy-league credentials and talent in speaking several languages to work as a translator for the United Nations- a career that was exciting, stimulating, and fulfilling. When Rina is approached by the FBI to help by being an informant about someone from her past who is involved in the Communist Party, she seizes the opportunity to not only assist in her patriotic duties in fighting communism, but sees it as an opportunity to reignite an exciting life like what she used to have, instead living in her current trappings of domesticity. This book was written in a way that I could immediately be drawn into the story. The time period of post-war America, with the threat of communism and the Cold War was fascinating. It was easy to sympathize with Rina. On the outside, she appeared to have everything, yet her husband and society expectations held her back, and no one seemed to understand her frustrations, or her actions. She was a strong woman but didn’t seem to have a voice in her own home, with her husband, or with his elitist family. At times the book did feel long, but the writing was excellent and I would definitely want to read more from this author! Publication date is July 21, 2020. Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martins Press for an ARC copy in exchange for my honest review. |








