I'm a big Jenny Colgan fan but this is not one of my favorites.  It's cute but more in the "Bridget Jones Diary" style than her others.  There is more focus on fashion and ditziness than I enjoy and I never really developed any kind of caring for our heroine which is not a good sign.  Decent writing though and charming surroundings

Posy Fairweather should be happier after her boyfriend Matt proposes to her, but she wonders if he is really “the one.”  She decides to visit her previous boyfriends to make sure she isn’t missing out on anything.  Penny has to figure out what and who she really wants, but it may be too late with respect to Matt; when he found out what she was doing, he asked for his engagement ring back.

Evaluation:  I found it hard to warm up to this book.  There is the usual obsession as in other Colgan books with weight and being thin, which onhy added to the impression of shallowness of most of the characters.  Posy herself is whiny and self-absorbed, and it is hard to tell from this book why she would have had any boyfriends at all.  She definitely seems to be more interested in the *idea* of a boyfriend or a husband than whoever might be willing to fill the role.  In any event, we never got to know any of the characters very well, although from what we were told, I’m not sure that I wanted to know them any better.