Member Reviews
Jen W, Librarian
Cruella wasn't always evil - once she was just 16-year-old Estella, an orphan with a passion for fashion designing and the skills of a master thief. Then, one summer she meets Richard and Magda Moresby-Plum and gets caught up in the whirl of high society. But, can a no-name orphan from the slummy streets of London fit in with the moneyed crowd? What happens when they tire of her? I love Maureen Johnson (her <i>Truly Devious</i> series is amazing!) and normally I can't put her books down. This one, however, just didn't live up to her reputation. It was a good, solid story that fits with the Disney version of Cruella DeVil that we all grew up hating. But, it wasn't "edge of your seat" or "lose sleep over" exciting. A solid middle grade origin story about how the orphan Estella and her two friends Horace and Jasper became the crime trio headed by Cruella. I recommend it to hard core fans of villains and origin stories. 3 stars Disclaimer: I received a free electronic copy of this book from the publisher through Netgalley.com in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own. |
This book was okay but the formatting on the arc was terrible. It seemed whenever there was a double f in a word the letters were missing but the space remained. It took me a bit to realize what was happening. It was an interesting story but I wished it went further towards 101 Dalmatians. |
To call this a retelling of Cruella is a bit of a stretch if I’m being honest. This is fully a historical fiction novel, with the concept of Cruella as an afterthought. This is very clearly a setup to be directly connected with the new Cruella movie, which is fine. The pacing of the book was strange, and while I’ve often liked Johnson’s writing for being cut and dry, this missed the mark. None of the characters in this book are particularly likable. I really wanted to like this book. The cover alone was beautiful. However, I kept waiting for the story to reveal itself as the beginning of Cruella’s story. I never got that satisfaction. If this had been marketed as just historical fiction, about a girl who tries to make it in the ranks of the elite while balancing a life of crime- it would have a higher rating from me. Unfortunately, this story allowed itself to pretend to be one thing when it really was something entirely different. This is a huge pet peeve of mine and took away from my enjoyment. |
I love a good villain just as much as the next person, so I was really excited to see what kind of back story Maureen Johnson could come up with for Cruella. I am a fan of the author from the Truly Devious series, and remain a fan after this book. I was not disappointed in the least. Estella/Cruella's story was as interesting as it was heartbreaking. Some of the descriptions of the fashion and Swinging London reminded me of Alice in Wonderland, which is another one of my favorite books. If I had to pick one thing to criticize, I would say that the book itself felt a little unfinished. I am hopeful that this will be another series to further the story, instead of just a standalone novel. Overall, I really enjoyed this and would recommend it to others. Thank you to NetGalley and Disney Publishing Worldwide/Disney Press for the ARC. |
Johnna W, Reviewer
While I do think this was a fun, captivating read on one or the worst villains, I just felt something was missing! I look forward to the movie, and hope it provides a bit more insight into who Cruella really is, but I’m still glad I read this book! I do think I got a bit more insight, but just felt it missed something on showing us how she and why she is the way she is. Overall, I do think kiddos will enjoy, as everyone loves reading about the bad gals, especially kids! Will definitely be getting my son a copy, even though Cruella is far from his favorite villain. |
With this prequel to the upcoming Disney movie, Cruella, and the pre-prequel to 101 Dalmations, Maureen Johnson gives us a fresh perspective on why Cruella turns out to be Cruella. From the start of her journey, Estella navigates traumatic loss while struggling to find her way. Throughout the story, Estella grapples with the voice inside her head (Cruella) that mirrors that voice of self-reflection we all grapple with at times. Sometimes the voice casts doubt and sometimes it gives her strength. Set in London, in 1967, Johnson weaves a tale of the swinging sixties that transports us back to the time in fits and starts. Referencing the Beatles and some other touchstones of the time place us there, but as a reader, I would have enjoyed much more detail about London at this time. Since it is a novel geared toward Young Adults in 2021, though, I believe that the level of detail was most likely sufficient. Taking us through Estella's journey to fit in while still remaining true to herself makes "Hello, Cruel Heart" a universal coming of age story with a twist. Since we already know who Estella ultimately becomes, the backstory is ever more humanizing for this character. I honestly have to say that I love Cruella even more than I did before reading this book and believe me, I already enjoyed the character immensely. I've always been drawn to the villains in the Disney canon. If you are looking for a quick, light read that dives deeper into the character of Cruella De Vil, do not hesitate to pick up a copy of this book when it comes out in April 2021. |
***Thanks to NetGalley and Disney Publishing for providing me with an advanced arc copy in exchange for my honest review. I wasn't sure what to expect of this book before reading it. I read the synopsis and understood that this would give us more insight into who Cruella DeVil is/was before her depiction on 101 Dalmatians. I also understood that this is inspired by the upcoming movie (which makes perfect sense... red hair... the Dalmatians... fashion sense). However, this book felt largely unfinished, especially in comparison to the trailer. Readers got to know Estella (Cruella before becoming a villain), her passion for fashion, and her life of stealing. We got to learn how she became connected to Horace and Jasper. Readers also got to see a more vulnerable side of Cruella (formerly known as Estella) when she made friends, was used, and was disappointed by her "posh" friends. The book ended with a string of disappointments, but I can only assume that part II will give us more insight in connection to the things placed in the trailer. Overall, I enjoyed it. This was a quick read. It was a little unexpected, but still pretty good. |
After watching the movie trailer this weekend, I had to read this title ASAP. Following around Estella, I was hoping the book would explore more of the inner Estella/Cruella’s inner conflict. Learned a few life and love lessons from Estella the hard way, but not sure if I felt this book embodied the dog-loving (or should I say hating) Disney villain in this title. Probably should have been titled “Estella: Hello, Cruel Heart”. Maybe it will make more sense after I see the movie. |
Once upon a time Cruella Devil was not a villanelle! She was just 16 years old orphan girl who tries to survive by stealing things at Swinging London in sixties! And her name is Estella who has been taught the crafts of being a skillful thief by her two accomplices Horace and Jasper who also share their squatters abode with her. She’s truly passionate about fashion and she has real talent and quite exquisite taste about it. When her path crosses with two rich twins Magda and Richard, she’s directly introduced to posh,privileged life style of London socialite. She gets attracted of charming musician Peter who also gets fascinated by her talents about fashion and made his band wear the clothes she’s designed! Everything seems going great with her life and she has hopes about her blooming fashion career, she’s happy to hang out with hipsters, discarding Horace and Jasper from her life but are new friends are right for her? As a fan of Truly Devious series I was truly hopeful about this story and it was great to get an arc copy at the same day the trailer of the movie goes viral ! ( but as far as I see Emma Stone is nothing near to Ms. Johnson’s Estella portrait we can easily sympathize with! ) I enjoyed swinging London premise and I loved to see bright sides of Estella ( we already saw dark side Glen Close showed us on the big screen and we truly enjoyed it) the art, the fashion, entertainment, vivid description of London society were enjoyable and well described! Only thing I didn’t like was haphazard ending with too many unanswered questions which made me think a sequel would come sooner. I hope it comes because I’d enjoy this easy to read and riveting, fast pacing, well developed journey! As a big fan of author’s writing style, I hope we may get more books of the series sooner. I think this is fresh, interesting, unique approach to one of the unconventional Disney villanelles! I’m rounding up 3.5 stars to 4 a delightful back story of one of my favorite villanelles before she meets with 101 Dalmatians stars! Special thanks to NetGalley and Disney Publishing Worldwide/ Disney Press for sharing this digital reviewer copy with me in exchange my honest opinions. |
The origin story of Cruella deVil except, her name is Estella and she is a thief/designer just trying to make it. The story is set up as a sort of connection to the upcoming live action film ( which surprisingly I just saw the trailer for the other day and it definitely makes sense). Estella is an orphan who makes a living by stealing, one day on one of her fabric stealing runs she runs into two rich teens, Magda and Richard, who take her into their rich lifestyle. Soon she finds herself invited to parties, meeting a cute musician named Peter, and being recognized for her designing talents. Yet, as with all good things, something is bound to go wrong, and soon she finds that maybe her new friends arent as great and maybe the boy she’s fallen in love with isn’t as honest as she thought. It was definitely an interesting take on the origin story of Cruella, and they have “Cruella” be sort of a another personality/voice in the back of Estella’s head that she has to constantly keep in check from coming out. It was a fun read and I can see how it was inspired by the live action that is going to be coming out. *Thanks Netgalley and Disney Publishing Worldwide for sending me an arc in exchange for an honest review* |
Cruella is such an interesting character and I feel like with the recent attempts at her origin story no one has ever quite managed to hit the mark on what makes her so great. “Hello, Cruel Heart” follows Estella as she navigates her world as a simple thief who stumbles upon a pair of rich new friends and finds a life outside of the lair filled with money, designer fashion and attractive musicians but the summer just come to an end and when it does the fallout is messy. To call this a Cruella DeVil story is almost laughable because the name itself is given to an almost imaginary friend/other personality that exists in the back of Estella’s mind and only shows itself when she has reached the end of her rope so for the majority of this book she is absent. That alone makes me question the entirety of the sell of this book as an origin because we never see her fully commit to the Cruella we all know and love instead we see a shadow. The pacing itself too is a rather odd with the crash coming fast, which I enjoyed as it seemed like the most realistic thing that happened in the book, but then the payoff for it is maybe 3 pages before the acknowledgments and the overall mood fell flat. I think the idea of showing her the world she wants was nice but I don’t think the loss the way it happened was enough to push her to the point that we have seen in her final form. Not quite sure what to think of this one the more I write my review the less I like it but I don’t know it feels like this should have been Act 1 of a larger story but instead it’s all we have which is a shame. **special thanks to the publisher and netgalley for providing an arc in exchange for a fair and honest review** |
Austin S, Reviewer
This was a rather decent read even if I’m really not the audience. It was a book to give some context to the forthcoming Cruella movie and it did such. I got a solid little read about 60s London. It was heavy in atmosphere which helped the book get over the hump of being a very familiar story. We know she’s going to get her heart broken. We know there’s going to be pain. But it’s all executed so well. 3/5 #DisneyCruellaHelloCruelHeart #NetGalley |
Mary W, Librarian
I thought the story was exciting although predictable. "Cruella" did not seem to fit into the story. |
DNF after the first five chapters. The writing was fine but the premise just wasn't grabbing me. I think readers who really enjoy villain origin stories would probably be more into this one than I. |
Beth F, Educator
Fans of 101 Dalmations will enjoy Cruella De'Ville's origin story as told in Hello, Cruel Heart. Cruella, who was actually named Estella, was not always cruel. She had a mother, hopes, dreams, and passions like everyone else. So, what happened? Go back to the free-wheeling 60's to explore the hipster scene in London and discover how Estella became Cruella. |
Jessica R, Educator
Pleasantly surprised but this one, though I shouldn’t have been knowing the author and her style. Full review on goodreads. |
Betcei B, Librarian
Was Cruella always so evil? Was there ever any good in her life? This story tells of her life as a teen and her "family" situation. A quick read for younger fans of Disney |
I'm not a Cruella De Vil fan, but I am a Maureen Johnson reader so I decided to skim this book. Once I started, I couldn't put it down, I was instantly enthralled and couldn't care less that I was reading a 101 Dalmations backstory. The story was fast-paced and intriguing and the characters were interesting and charismatic. I loved the late 1960s setting and references and I could just picture the vivid fashions jumping off the page. With all the nods to great bands, I should have read it with a soundtrack playing in the background. So much fun! |
I am a HUGE Disney fan and I so wanted to love this book, but I didn't. It was very difficult to "get into" and just was not holding my attention. Also there were a LOT of typos. For some reason, every word that had a double-f was missing the letters! For example, "off" would just show up as an "o". In one sentence, "Their feet were adorned with extortionary slippers and platform boots", I would assume that extortionary should have been extraordinary. |
Librarian 653300
Hello, Cruel Heart is an imaginative interpretation of the catalysts that slowly breathe actual life into the inner voice (Cruella) of a girl named Estella. I truly "saw" swinging 60's London in my minds eye as I read Johnson's descriptions of the clothes, locations, and dialog as portrayed in the story I honestly want to read more about Estella's journey and would thoroughly enjoy it if this were at least a duology. |








