Cover Image: The Witness for the Dead

The Witness for the Dead

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Set in the same world as the lovely Goblin Emperor (really, you should read it — it's very hopeful and good), this short novel follows the devout Thara Celehar in his calling as a Witness for the Dead. What does that mean? Well, it means that Celehar has the ability to get mental impressions from the recently deceased, helping solve problems regarding everything from contested wills to murders (both of which are covered in this book), as well as tracking down the occasional ghoul. This book skirts the line between high fantasy and mystery, and like the Goblin Emperor, is wonderfully realized. While Celehar is a minor character the Goblin Emperor, it would certainly help to read that book before you pick this one up.

Was this review helpful?

The Witness for the Dead is a beautifully written fantasy mystery in the gorgeous, complex world of the Goblin Emperor! It has: lush worldbuilding; detective stories with fantasy elements; a queer MC. A book which will be adored by fans of the author's earlier works!

Was this review helpful?

Where The Goblin Emperor was challenging but satisfying, I found the follow-up, Witness for the Dead, approachable but less compelling. I respect Katherine Addison's decision to move away from the court intrigue of the first book and tell a different sort of story, but it wasn't my cup of tea.

Was this review helpful?

I really wanted to like this book, but it just didn’t hit the same as The Goblin Emperor. With that book, I was invested in the characters (though they weren’t without flaws) and I was eager to see where the story went. I’ve seen some other reviewers describe Witness for the Dead as a “cozy” novel, and perhaps that’s why I struggled to enjoy it: I’ve never been much of a cozy fan.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book. It is a companion to The Goblin Emperor rather than a sequel. It features Thara Celehar who had an important but small role in the Goblin Emperor and who I didn't really remember. This book expounded on the world building which is rich and detailed. It was a mystery set in a fantasy steampunk world and it was really good.

Was this review helpful?

I have not read The Goblin Emperor but now that I've read this book I will definitely fix that fact as soon as I am able. The world here is so rich I felt lost for a minute but once I was settled it was a delight to read. We have goblins, elves, magic, and our main character Thara Celehar, the witness for the dead. What that essentially means is that is that if a person died not too long ago he might be able to see what they saw before they died, hear their last wishes. For example, a man died and did not leave a will so his children are fighting for inheritance. Thara Celehar is asked to be the witness for the dead person to find out who should be the heir. Or, a body of a woman is found in the river and needs a witness for the dead to find out who she was and how she died. He does all this and more. It is an ungrateful job, my heart was constantly aching for the main character. The plot is not linear, it is more episodic in nature. We follow Thars Celehar as he witnesses for different people with different circumstances and often times it only brings him trouble because the living want to hear some specific things that suit their needs and do not really want to know what the dead have to say. And there is a murder mystery, which I quite enjoyed. The writing is beautiful with an atmosphere of sadness to it. The main character is wonderful, he has such a big heart and tries to serve the common people as well as nobility. I only wish this book was longer but I just found out that it is a series and not a standalone, with the second book already out, so that is definitely on my radar now.
Thank you to NetGalley for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I got a free arc through Netgalley all opinions are my own.

So I've only read one book from this author before, and it was a dnf.
I haven't read the prequel/companion to this book either btw.
It started of as confusing with all those weird and long names. I really didn't have any idea what was going on the first few pages.
And I was utterly bored. The story was meh, I guess I'm just not into mysteries?
And the characters were so bland, especially the MC.
Sadly this book was a dnf because I was so bored that I almost fell asleep whenever I picked this book up.

Was this review helpful?

Full review to be posted soonish.

I would like to thank the publisher and netgalley for providing me a free copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for providing a copy for review.

I liked this more than I thought I would. I love Celehar so much. He's so quiet and unassuming, but very determined to help people. I found his friendship with the opera manager to be adorable. This is a slow paced novel, but I loved all the different mysteries he solved along the way. I will say that I wish I had read The Goblin King first as I would better understand this world. It is vast, intricate, and has so many characters I had a hard time understanding certain things, especially the politics. The names are kind of a mouthful as well but that's just a me thing. Overall though, for as lost as I was at times, I did really enjoy this. The author always creates such interesting worlds.

Was this review helpful?

If you've read The Goblin Emperor and want to spend more time in the world, I think you are very likely to enjoy this book. It's essentially a thoughtful mystery following Thara Celehar as he follows his duties as a Witness for the Dead. I only wish the names and titles were less complex because I was rarely able to remember who was who. Luckily the story made it clear within a few sentences.
Full review on my YouTube channel.

Was this review helpful?

Side-story to The Goblin Emperor, The Witness for the Dead centres around one of the previous novel’s secondary characters: Thara Celehar, a prelate of Ulis and Witness for the Dead, meaning he can experience the last moments of a person’s death if he touches their body. Celehar would rather be out of the spotlight than in it, which is why he makes for such an interesting protagonist in this short companion novel to The Goblin Emperor. Don’t get me wrong, protagonists who throw themselves headlong into adventure are fun and all, but it’s always interesting to me when a book centres on someone who would rather just be left alone.

Life, however, doesn’t want to leave Celehar alone. Poor bastard.

Taking place shortly after The Goblin Emperor, Celehar now lives in Amalo, still following his calling. This involves a variety of duties, including investigating murder. So when Arveneӓn Shelsin, an ambitious opera singer, is found dead, and Celehar confirms that she was indeed murdered, the race is on to not only find the murderer, but to uncover why they killed in the first place.

Celehar’s reluctance to engage with a lot of the world is, as I mentioned, an interesting move. It’s not something that could work for everyone, but Addison manages a good balance between showing Celehar’s introversion and actually putting him in positions where he can do some good in the world. Celehar is very relatable for me in that way. Except that I don’t have any abilities or callings that would make the world a better place, the way he does. It’s admirable, though, that even though Celehar would rather be left to his own devices, he doesn’t shirk the responsibilities that come with his calling. He might not be happy about things, but he’ll do what he feels drawn to do. More characters like this, please!

Addison’s detail-oriented writing style makes for an excellent murder mystery, that’s for damn sure. While The Goblin Emperor did have some mystery to it, at its heart it was about Maia settling into his new and unexpected role and the emperor, and all that entailed. The Witness for the Dead shifts the tone and setting away from political intrigue and a fish-out-of-water/coming-of-age story, and into a situation where a man must solve a murder in order to lay the victim’s spirit to rest and give them a proper funeral. Such a simple thing in theory, but it becomes so much more complicated when Celehar must risk offending some very powerful people, and sort through layers of potential motivation for the kill, in his mission to bring about justice for Arveneӓn.

Honestly, I think Addison has a knack for writing a good solid mystery, and I’m here for it. Her world-building is brilliant, rich and realistic, and it’s a wonderful setting for any number of mysteries. I’ve found in recent years that I have a bit of a soft spot for fantasy mysteries, so it’s no real surprise that I enjoyed The Witness for the Dead as much as I did. If you have similar weakness for fantasy mysteries, or you just enjoyed The Goblin Emperor, then I highly recommend giving this novella a go. It’s not very long, but it packs a punch, and is a wonderful companion and spin-off to the main book. Celehar is a character I absolutely love reading about, and will be quiet happy to do so more in the future.

Was this review helpful?

This was my first book by this author, It was pretty enjoyable. I would give this book a 3.5 star rating! It was a pretty Quick and easy read!

Was this review helpful?

Such a fantastic book and world! Truly magical and it goes deeper than you would think! I really enjoyed this and I highly recommend

Was this review helpful?

The Witness for the Dead by Katherine Addison is standalone sequel to The Goblin Emperor, set in the same world (obviously) with a few recurring characters. I love The Goblin Emperor and while this wasn't as good as that book, I really enjoyed reading through this as well. This would fall in the category of books I'd suggest you to savour - slow-paced, less action, with some really great writing.
Recommended!

Was this review helpful?

Interesting premise, some good twists, but ultimately felt a bit lacking. The ending felt too quick and I would have liked deeper and more complex characters.

Was this review helpful?

I love Katherine Addison. This author has quickly become a favorite of mine and was so excited to read THE WITNESS FOR THE DEAD. The writing is superb. The tale is both fanciful and real at the same time. The characters are well-developed and completely engaging. Though the book can completely standalone, I would always recommend reading THE GOBLIN EMPEROR first just to get that extra layer of fabulous storytelling.

From beginning to end, this was another amazing novel by the author.

Was this review helpful?

Addison’s spin off of her beloved The Goblin Emperor follows Thara Celehar, the titular Witness for the Dead, who can read the last thoughts and feelings of the recently deceased. Despite his success at uncovering the truth about the murder of the emperor’s father, his position at Untheileneise Court became a political hot potato, and he was (sort of) exiled to the distant city of Amaro to be an advocate for its people, living and dead.
The is a central mystery – the murder of an almost universally disliked opera singer – for Celehar to resolve in The Witness for the Dead, but a good chunk of the novel depicts Celehar dispatching the day-to-day obligations of his profession. Such dealings are far from routine and are fraught their own dangers and political pitfalls, and this complex web of subplots provides most of the memorable character interactions and set pieces that elevate this novel far above the fray. The appeal of Celehar as a hero is undeniable: he offers the reader a unique blend of generosity, integrity, and world-weariness, ranking him among the most engaging protagonists in all of fantasy literature.

Was this review helpful?

The Witness for the Dead is Addison’s follow-up to her enormously popular Goblin Emperor. Here, she takes a bit character from her epic fantasy novel and whisks him to a faraway town where Prelate Thara Celahar talks to the Dead, getting to the bottom of what happened to them, particularly when it’s an angry opera singer found floating in a canal. Although most other readers have found much to rejoice in with this new novel, perhaps reading Goblin Emperor first helps to lay a foundation and background for this book. Without the prior novel, one is left with a rather obscure religion, unpronounceable names and titles, and a general lack of action and excitement. Once again, Addison has interesting ideas, but they do not seem to result in much. A minority opinion, but an honest one.

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to like this more than I did since I was totally thrilled to find out that Katherine Addison was going to continue in the world of "The Goblin Emperor", possibly one of my favorite fantasy novels of all time. Alas what I wanted was more about Maia, the melancholy half goblin emperor, not a side quest novel about a character I really didn't remember very well. Despite Addison's amazing writing and a reasonably interesting mystery I just wasn't feeling this. More Maia please!?

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this story, not as much as Goblin Emperor, but still recommend. It started out a bit slow, but once I got past getting to know all the characters, it got much better. Would love to read more stories taking place in this world.

Was this review helpful?