Cover Image: So Many Beginnings: A Little Women Remix

So Many Beginnings: A Little Women Remix

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

This book is so good. I loved the ways it paralled with Little Women while being completely separate, and I loved getting a peek into the Colony at Roanoke, which I hadn't really known about before. It would be a good book to add to my classroom library.

Was this review helpful?

The March family set during the American Civil War with the remix that they are a Black, formerly enslaved family, living in a Freedmen's Colony in North Carolina--building it from the ground-up--and learning what it means to be truly free.

This book holds many of the same dynamics of the original <i>Little Women</i> and names: Meg, Jo, Beth, and Amy. The story was familiar for those who've read the original but remixed enough where it's a refreshing piece that tells of the struggle for formerly enslaved people to build their own communities. It feels like a parallel to the original story as it is set in the same time period.

I loved how different each girl is and how they each grow into their own personality and finding their own passions, which allows them to find a place within their respective communities and family. The ending was wonderfully hopeful as each woman begins her journey past adolescence and into adulthood.

Was this review helpful?

I found myself completely not in the mood for this when the time came to read it. I'm feeling creepy stories or adventures and since I'm well-acquainted with the source material, I'm hoping to give it a go in the future when I can fully enjoy it!

Was this review helpful?

A fascinating look at the four March sisters if their story was reimagined from a different perspective of the Civil War. Kudos to the author for creating such a fascinating new angle on a classic story!

The tone of the book is a bit more serious than the original classic. I learned about some interesting bits of history I didn't know about before, like the Freedmen's Colony on Roanoke Island (such a fascinating setting... I want to know more!). Other changes that I really enjoyed include the new names of the girls, like Amy's name is Amethyst, and Beth's name is Bethlehem (love it!). I also love Amy's story arc (which you'll have to read the book to find out about; it's good!).

Recommended for readers of historical fiction, black interest, and fans of Little Women.

Suitable for: 13 and up - Adults
(For subtle hints at mature topics.)

Was this review helpful?

Dude this was a great retelling. I was curious about how four white girls would be transformed into Black girls while remaining true to the Little Women remaining true to the narrative and I really think Morrow knocked it out of the park.

It was so creative to have the March sisters live in a free colony for newly emancipated people in the 1860's. With this twist on the classic story, it enriched it in a way that somehow kept the original story intact and yet was all its own. I wasn't reading a story I've read countless times before, but I still had the same nostalgia. I'm not sure if I'm describing it well enough, but the bottom line that I want to get across is that it was done well.

So why 4 stars instead of 5? I can't overlook that part of the middle seemed to drag. I guess that's true with the original too though so this was pretty spot on for me haha.

Now for things I loved: Although it isn't explicitly said in the novel, it is implied that Beth has sickle cell anemia which is something that really does impact the Black community. I thought this was such a clever change from scarlet fever. It was little things like this that truly made this become a Black story and not just changing the race of a classic family.

Also, the girls end up with WHO THEY SHOULD END UP WITH. Dude I would read this over and over again for the sheer fact that Morrow didn't pull that crap with a stuck up professor that wasn't good enough for our girl. FINALLY. And because of this change, I got to see Jo's relationship with Laurie in a whole new light. I even said "awww" out loud when he told her that he was always on her side. It was so freaking cute.

Well done. Very well done retelling.

Was this review helpful?

PLEASE! This book was everything. Any chance I have to get my hands on a book about black women I am going to do it. I am a huge fan of the original story as well as the many adaptions that were born from it. This was a retelling, yes, but it was so much more than that. We got to see this story told from a diverse perspective with fully developed characters who each had their own voice and story to tell. There were things about this retelling that were very reminiscent of the Little Women story that we know and love, the relationship between the girls, the relationship with their mom, how they work as a family unit. But, our cast of black characters in a post-slavery environment made for a genuinely unique story about hope, love, ambition, and family. Each sister had their own life goals and ambitions and they were clearly drawn out through the novel. It was very satisfying to see each of the girls’ journeys.

Although the book is only about 300 pages, Morrow was able to pack so much character development and story details into its pages. If the book had been as long as the original work I feel like I would have read it with the same fervor. The pacing was nice and the writing felt very comfortable and easy to get through. I would definitely recommend this to anyone who loves the story of Little Women.

Was this review helpful?

I have never loved the story of little women as much as I do now! Now this is story telling done right! I cannot wait for today’s generation of Black girl’s experiencing this book!

Was this review helpful?

I featured this book as a Book of the Day spotlight and included it in my weekly roundup and monthly post of new releases on my Black Fiction Addiction platforms.

Was this review helpful?

Probably more of 3.5.

This is my second of the remixed classics and it’s really been such a nice experience reading classics retold through the perspectives of people whose stories have never been considered classics. I have to say I don’t remember much about Little Women because I was too young when I read it and have never watched any adaptations either.

The author does a wonderful job with the setting of this story during and after the civil war, describing in perfect detail how the daily lives of Black people were in the Roanoke Freedmen’s Colony, their struggle to keep their colony running while also living fulfilling lives after having achieved freedom. It was interesting to see all the women of the March family work hard at their chosen professions, being independent thinkers and never letting go of their dreams despite the circumstances. The writing is simple and straightforward, with so much raw power and emotion that made this an impactful read. The pacing could be a bit on the slower side but that could be expected in a slice of life kinda story.

Mammy is the rock who supports them all while their father is away on war related work. Meg is the silent strength who loves teaching the newly freed people and wants a stable home life for herself. Jo is the intellectual whose words and thoughts flow and her convictions might get her in trouble a bit but she is always true to herself. Beth is an excellent seamstress who finds her purpose far away from home. And Amy is the baby whose dreams are more high profile and her exuberant nature is perfect for her profession as a dancer and private tutor. Other than the sisters, it was Lorie who left a deep impression on me. He and Jo are an amazing pair, an unbreakable deep friendship and more which can’t be defined but is as beautiful as any which is societally recognized. Their unwavering support for each other was a particular highlight of this book.

To conclude, I think anyone who loves Little Women and like it to be retold would enjoy this story. And I would definitely recommend it to anyone who would love to see more historical fiction novels featuring characters whose stories were never told, especially set in times of American history when they were never regarded as important enough to be able to deserve their stories to be told.

Was this review helpful?

This was a really well done retelling of Little Women. I liked the historical aspect (set in the Reconstruction era), and changing the March family to former slaves building their new lives. Some relationships were changed up and I enjoyed that as well. I think I just wanted a little more from some of the story lines. Definitely worth a read! Almost 3.5stars

Thanks to MCPG and Macmillan Audio for the gifted advanced copies in exchange for my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this rendition of the LIttle Women. I am big fan of the original and liked to see the similarities that the author drew out of the characters and situations while staying on your toes through the unknown. I think fans of the original will like the book but it may be confusing or not as fast paced as some readers would like who have not read the original by Louisa May Alcott.

Was this review helpful?

As a kid who loved Little Women, this re-imagining tugged on my heartstrings in a BIG way. I got both the book and the audio book (so the review will be the same). But i appreciated the new outcomes for the characters. I felt "SEEN" as a Black person who had ancestors living during this time in American history.

Was this review helpful?

It took me a while to get into this—the beginning was a little slow and the prose is not the clearest—but once it got going, I enjoyed it. Morrow did a great job of remaking the classic story with young Black women in the Freedmen's Colony of Roanoke during the Civil War. Would definitely recommend!

Was this review helpful?

<i>"It was the benefit of having four daughters. One of them anyway. They consoled each other when one needed it. Whoever was downtrodden, she had three sisters to set her right again."</i>

TL;DR: An absolutely fantastic retelling of Louisa May Alcott's classic <i>Little Women</i> which stays true to the heart of Alcott's original work and yet does something powerful and inventive with the premise.
<b><i>I received an ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.</b></i>

Vibes: Alcott's <i>Little Women</i> merged with history.
As Morrow notes in her Author's Note -- and which I didn't know -- the Roanoke Island FreedPeople Colony actually existed. I'd like to learn more about it.

Genre: Historical Fiction / Retelling
I think this book has a wide appeal, and should resist classification as YA or New Adult. I often find retellings -- of classics and fairy tales in particular -- difficult to categorize, because they seem to transcend classification. That is, if you enjoyed the original story, you're probably likely to enjoy the retelling, regardless of how old you are.

Character MVP: Jo, forever and always.

Verdict: This book is proof that you shouldn't write an author off because you don't like one of their books. I was...not a fan of Morrow's <i>A Song Below Water</i> books, at all. While I appreciated what Morrow was trying to get across with her messages about the power and silencing of Black women, the world-building wasn't there, and the mythology wasn't conveyed. (Plus, Naema, the MC of the sequel was just awful for 75% of the book.) And, to be honest, reading those two books made me really hesitant to read Morrow's retelling of Little Women, which I was really looking forward to.

I should have read this book first.

This book was fantastic.

And, no. It's not cultural appropriation as I've seen some of the negative reviews insist. It's not cultural appropriation just like Gregory Maguire didn't appropriate <i>The Wizard of Oz</i> or like Aiden Thomas didn't appropriate <i>Peter Pan</i>. For one thing, being "white" isn't a culture. And two, you can't appropriate the dominant culture because appropriation, by definition, hinges on that power dynamic.

But I digress.

As someone who is a diehard fan of <i>Little Women</i>*, I thought Morrow's retelling was reverent yet inventive.
*I tend to just pretend that Part II doesn't exist, because it undoes the best parts of Part I. Beth still lives and Jo and Laurie end up together.

✔︎ -- Morrow captured the heart of the March women and maintained it in her retelling. Mrs. March is still the stalwart matriarch; Meg is still domestically inclined and nurturing; Jo is still rebellious and literary; Beth is still calm and Good and ill; and Amy is still the youngest, and artistically inclined.

✔︎ -- There are subtle allusions to the original story like Meg and Jo dancing at the party or Jo, Lorie, and Amy ice-skating, and Mr. March's name here is Alcott -- all of which respectfully pay homage to the original story.
If anything, I thought Morrow focused more on Meg, than Alcott did -- at least in the sense that Meg and Jo are at the heart of this story. There's more depth and nuance to Meg here, and she's presented more complexly. In Alcott's text, I felt like Jo and Amy dominate the narrative, perhaps because their personalities are the strongest, and their tension propels the story forward.
On the plus side, here, Amy is significantly less bratty -- and while she and Jo bicker, there is no burning of manuscripts or other fights. Amy is still the youngest and is uniquely indulged, but it makes sense within Morrow's story.
My only quibble is that Jo and Beth's relationship isn't the same. In Alcott's text, the two sisters are essentially polar opposites, and Beth has a unique ability to understand Jo, and soothe her tempestuous outbursts. That relationship isn't in Morrow's text -- if anything, it feels a bit <i>Pride and Prejudice</i> with Meg and Jo having a very Jane-and-Lizzie bond. It's a very minor quibble, though.

✔︎ -- But Morrow makes it her own: the Marches are no longer the white family safely ensconced in New England; they are emancipated slaves building a new life for themselves the Freed People colony on Roanoke Island.

This book, powerful as it was, made me uncomfortable sometimes, but in a constructive way. And saying that I was uncomfortable isn't a criticism -- it's a testament to how much further I think we as a society have to go. I don't think it was Morrow's primary goal to educate white readers and/or make them uncomfortable: such an opinion would be extremely self-centered and narcissistic; it isn't Morrow's job to educate her white readers or write primarily for them. Instead, I think it's a logical consequence of a white reader reading the story that Morrow told, from the perspective she told it from.

This was a 5-star read for me, regardless, but one of the main reasons is that I will absolutely read this with my children and recommend it to everyone. I think it should absolutely be taught in schools alongside Alcott's original story -- although, sadly, I doubt it will.

One of the passages that stood out to me the most was when Meg was describing "the old life," when she was the companion of the little white girl who lived in the Big House. In my Disney class, we talk about <i>The Princess and the Frog</i> -- a landmark text for Disney, since it features their first animated Black protagonist/princess. And while it's wonderful for Tiana to have a real, human, female friend in Charlotte, there is something awful idealistic about their friendship. On the one hand, yes: seeing two women support each other is something we've been missing in Disney animated films; but PatF tried to do too much. As the film which kicked off the New Golden Age of Disney, it had to be progressive and present its female characters differently than it had over the past 60 years. But, in the end, it's a film set in the 1920s Deep South, and it tries to neatly sidestep any real racial tension. Meg and the white girl could have easily been Tiana and Lottie -- but Morrow presents the unDisneyfied version of their relationship.

✔︎ -- Finally -- and this is super spoilery -- but this book earned an automatic Bonus Star from me because (1) Beth DOESN'T die and (2) Jo and Lorie end up together. Had I been on the fence about anything else about this book, that narrative resolution would have won me over.
Every time I watch an adaptation of read the story, I hope that Amy and Laurie don't end up together because while I fully understand that Amy is the youngest and insufferable, I can't forgive her early brattiness. And Jo ending up with some stodgy old professor? Bestill my heart. NO.
I love and appreciate how Morrow was true to their characters but gave them more satisfying endings. That is, Meg still ends up married and, presumably, in domestic wedded bliss.
Amy still ends up in the spotlight, with a bright future her charm and talent have afforded her.
But Jo? Jo ends up with Lorie who loves and respects her, who KNOWS her, truly, and accepts her. I...just...loved their relationship in Morrow's version.
And Beth? I don't fully know what illness Beth is supposed to have (and I am curious to try and learn more), but Beth gets her own happy ending -- she still ends up home in Heaven, although it's thankfully more metaphorical here, and not literal.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed the fresh take on Little Women and that it was an African American family. The clever way in which the book kept to the original while adding it's own unique spin was well done.

Was this review helpful?

A fresh and inspiring twist on a classic tale that adds new depth and thoughtfulness while still shining a light on sisterhood at its finest!

I read and enjoyed both the original Little Women and this book, so I can say without a doubt that anyone criticizing this for “appropriating” the original is doing so in bad faith. Retellings are very much ingrained in our culture and entertainment media. Hell, this novel is part of a retelling series called REMIXED CLASSICS, so there’s no way you don’t know what you’re getting into! I don’t see this type of vitriol for reimaginings like 10 Things I Hate About You or even Jo & Laurie and hmmm… I can’t imagine why! [/end sarcasm] The spirit of Little Women is there, but there’s also a lovely consideration of how these women’s lives would be transformed under different circumstances.

The story begins in the Roanoke Island Freedman’s Colony in 1863, where the Marsh family has settled after escaping slavery. Mr. Marsh is still battling in the Civil War while his wife and four daughters help found one of the few safe havens for black people in the South during that time. The personalities of Meg, Jo, Beth, and Amy are all quite similar to what we’ve come to expect from these characters, but they have distinct stories. Meg is a teacher working to educate the children of the colony with little aid. Jo is a sharp writer, but rather than writing books and plays, she’s writing literary pieces on the Southern black experience for Union readers. Beth is still sickly and frail, but she’s learning about her needs and new possibilities through her illness. Amy is a typical youngest sibling, but she’s got spunk and talent that takes her places.

Let’s be clear: The March family is unapologetically black in this novel. The author never shies away from the way their blackness affects their lives and yes, it affects very many things, because again this starts in the midst of the Civil War. It sometimes does this by showing everyday racism by “well-meaning” (usually white) folks. There’s only one white side character we see more than once and she often has to sit with the wrongness of her assumptions in front of the March family. And she should! It’s actually refreshing to see a novel that doesn’t glorify its white ally as “always getting it” or “one of the good guys,” while also refusing to vilify her. There’s actual nuance and it’s GREAT.

Despite the era and its tumultuousness, there’s also a lot of joy to be had. We see these characters going on adventures, going to parties, finding themselves, and falling in love. I especially loved the story of Jo and her Lorie, which features some unexpected rep and some really endearing moments. This novel also does more justice to Meg, who I personally believe drew the short straw of the storylines in the original tale. Jo is still my favorite of the bunch, but we get a thorough dive into each sister’s life that will help readers relate to all of them.

So Many Beginnings tells fresh stories for these characters, reconsidering major plot points from the original and turning them on their head. The result is something that’s ultimately more hopeful than the original, but it still has some equally bittersweet moments within. Even without measuring it against its inspiration, this is a sweet historical fiction that tells its story well (better than most historical fiction, in my opinion!) and will leave you absolutely charmed in the end.

Was this review helpful?

On this episode of Everything is Canon, Steve talks to Bethany C. Morrow all about her new book, So Many Beginnings: A Little Women Remix, which is described as “Four young Black sisters come of age during the American Civil War in this warm and powerful ode to Black joy and sisterhood, a YA remix of the classic novel Little Women.”

Retelling classics that ignore certain aspects of American history would be one thing, remixing them in an honest and forthright way is something else entirely. Bethany takes this head on in So Many Beginnings delivering not only an incredible character study, but a historically accurate one about a Black family who happens to be called March living on Roanoke Island in 1863. Expecting nothing less from her, this beautifully written and highly entertaining remix is the definitive version of Little Women for me now, there’s no question about it.

Steve and Bethany talk about a variety of things including race relations past and present, Patricia C. Click’s Time Full of Trial: The Roanoke Island Freedmen’s Colony 1862-1867, some process, So Many Beginnings of course, and how the minute you make the March sisters Black during that time and in that part of country, it changes everything.

For the full interview, click the link below...

https://www.cinelinx.com/off-beat/shows/everything-is-canon-so-many-beginnings-a-little-women-remix/

Was this review helpful?

I have always loved "Little Women" and any and all adaptations that have been created over the years - if you tell me that the March sisters are coming back in some new media, I am immediately bookmarking it. So when I heard that Bethany Morrow was writing a remix of "Little Women", I knew to be even more excited, as I adore her book "A Song Below Water." I figured that what I was going to read would be a cutesy retelling but nothing really new or invigorating - a comfort read at its' best. Boy, was I (delightfully) wrong. "So Many Beginnings" takes the base material provided by Louisa May Alcott and turns it into a delightful introspective at the Civil War era, that does not shy away from the harsh realities that historical fiction tends to gloss over. I will most definitely recommending this to future readers who ask for historical fiction or classics!

Was this review helpful?

I haven't actually read Little Women but I've seen the movie and read other retellings that have really resonated with me and this one hit me with everything that I ever wanted in a retelling. Not only did it totally blow me away with the "remixing" of the characters, it also added such an intense and heartwrenching discussion about American History. I'm genuinely not even smart enough and definitely probably not qualified to talk about the effect of slavery on the nation and how it was woven into this story. I definitely learned a lot about the aftermath of the freedom of slaves and the colonies that were created for the newly freed Black Americans and will be thinking about this for a long time. I didn't even know that there were specific Freedmen's colonies created in america and I definitely want to learn more about that after reading this!

In regards to the actual story, I was totally blown away. It kept the simple structure of the original story (from whatever I know about it) but added so much more because of the historical setting. I appreciated the depth of the characters, especially with Beth! It was so interesting to see this story told with more viewpoints from all the sisters!

I highlighted so many quotes in this book, especially with Joanna's writing. The Author hit hard with the facts and didn't hold back which I really appreciated!

Was this review helpful?

It’s been a while since I finished a book and it left me with a sense of joy. Let me remind you before you go any further, that this story is a remix, not a retelling. It is a new story and such a great one! I count this as a must-read!

So Many Beginnings is a remix of Louisa May Alcott’s book, Little Women. This remix takes you to the Freedpeople’s Colony of Roanoke Island, North Carolina during the Civil War in 1863. The March family has built a home for themselves after fleeing their enslavers and Mr. March has gone to Corinth, Mississippi to see how another colony has obtained success in their endeavors.

The story follows: Meg, the oldest daughter. She is a teacher who longs to find love and start a family. Jo, a writer whose words are too powerful to be contained, Beth a talented seamstress searching for a higher purpose. Amy, a dancer eager to explore life outside her family’s home.

This story is about the power of family, language and love. It is a story of young Black girls becoming independent young Black women. It is a reclaiming of Black family and childhood and love in a time period that saw so many families separated and destroyed and childhoods that were non-existent. You get to witness how the girls process their traumatic childhood and existence when they were enslaved. But they control that narrative and their processing is conveyed in a manner that lets you know that they have taken back their power and they know it. I appreciate that the trauma never dominates the narrative and the girls get to focus on becoming women and living their lives to the fullest now that they are free.

Morrow’s attention to the language of how the March women refer to the white people in the “old life” as enslavers and captors and wealthy white girl, instead of the words that have traditionally been used, was so critical in conveying how they processed their pain and healing. It is super powerful and I will say healing from my own perspective. Heck, you see I’m not even using those words in this review! You come to the realization that when you use the old terms, you put those who were enslaved into a constant victim status and a role where things only happened to them. This way of using language gives them back their power and makes them whole human beings again who have dreams and wishes and aspirations just like the March girls do.

This book isn’t just a remix, it’s a classic unto itself. I hope educators and parents see this and encourage children to read it as such. Adults and children alike will love this story. I can’t wait to share it with others. Thanks to @Netgalley @turnthepagetours and @fiercereads for providing the arc in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?