Member Reviews

My first thought on reading this book was that it was too long. There seemed to be a lot of filler and going over the same thing constantly. Was there a family curse? Who caused the show to fail and why? In fact, I put the book down and read another book before I came back to this one One other thing that I found to be very annoying was the constant use of the phrase "mashup." Once you get to about 60%, it starts to be a pretty good story, if you get that far. I know this is an ARC, but it badly needs editing. Thanks for the chance to read it.

Was this review helpful?

Tempest Raj is a twenty-six (26) year old magician who found herself in a near-death stunt which landed her living at her childhood home with members of her family who cook, coddle & coo around her & tend to her every need. Tempest is on the brink of what she fears might be rock bottom; having lost whatever good graces her magician’s act had given her. In this first instalment of what one might presume to become a series, Tempest finds herself in the middle of a murder mystery; how can a recently deceased body be found behind an aged wall?

Well, most unfortunately for me I did not enjoy this story at all & I will preface this long-winded review by stating simply that this was not meant for people in my age group. I am a couple years older than Tempest & found her behaviour ranging from absurd to ludicrous & then began to wonder if this character was written as someone who might reflect what younger audiences might think someone in their mid-twenties to be. My reason for questioning the authenticity of Tempest’s character was truly brought about because the writing style employed in this book is very juvenile; the transitions between thoughts, scenes & events circle around a select few catch phrases which would behold the interest of a young audience. This is certainly not a negative thing, if the book were targeting young people. Unfortunately, it is being put forth as an ‘adult’ read & for that reason, I found it fell very flat.

I would like to highlight that books are not necessarily restricted to us based on our ages. One can find themselves, for example, appreciating “Le Petit Prince” at any age because the writing style is filled with artful transitions & beautiful prose. What differentiates this story from one which might be appreciated throughout the ages of the human life span is the fact that nothing was very magical. By this I mean that, the writing was not bewildering; it was bland & lead us around the same corner, over & over again. We see this in the first chapters when Tempest continuously repeats how important a meeting is for her. We understand that the meeting is important, this does not need to be told to us more than twice. For this reason, I felt that the storyline might appeal to younger audiences as they might be more willing to forgive redundancy than I.

As someone who can, more often than not, clock the twist in the opening chapters of a book, I found this story to not hold much depth in the plot to lead me to want to continue reading until everything was revealed. Being an avid reader of Agatha Christie’s I find myself always paying close attention to wording; even the most mundane phrase is often where the reveal is found. For this reason, I again was lead to reflect upon the target audience of this story.

The premise of the plot holds a great deal of potential; the book will be beloved by many a young reader, that I am certain. However, as someone who has lived in the adult world for many years & has spent many a stormy night reading brooding mystery novels; I found this story to not be anything particularly pleasing for me. The actions that the characters took touched the surface of what they could be. Tempest herself has very shallow interactions with people who are described as being very close to her. I suppose this comes down to the writing style; things were told to the reader rather than them being shown. This is not to say that there were not detailed descriptions, there were, often ample.

Ultimately, this book was not for me. Should you read this review & wonder if you should read the book I would encourage you to give it a chance. Everything I stated was from a very subjective standpoint. If you’ve not delved into closed-door mysteries, this story might appeal to you. If you are fine with redundant descriptors, the length of this book will not bother you. I will say that I appreciated the touches of combined culture which presented themselves within the cooking practices of the characters. This trait did bring the characters together & forged what one might view as a genuine family experience which was authentic to the story we were reading.

I’m sure we will see this story find it’s way to the ideal target audience as time moves forward & I am glad for every person who reads this story & adores it.

Thank you to NetGalley, St. Martin's Press & Gigi Pandian for the free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review!

#UnderLockAndSkeletonKey #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

I have very mixed feelings about this story. There were quite a few positives including the strong relationships among Tempest Raj and her family. The setting was great. I really enjoyed all the various puzzles that were part of Tempest's family home. I enjoyed the loving descriptions of all the various foods prepared by Tempest's grandfather. Vegans will be glad that the book includes recipes.

I also enjoyed all the references to Golden Age mysteries and magicians. The Locked Room Library is a place I would love to visit.

There were also a number of things that I didn't especially enjoy. I'm all for a twisty plot but this one was a bit over-the-top for me. Misdirection upon misdirection made the plot confusing. I also had some problems with the keeping the large numbers of cast straight. I felt like I had entered on book 2 of a series where all these people had been introduced previously.

The basic story seems to be that magician Tempest Raj has come back home after her career in Las Vegas was sabotaged by her assistant Cassidy. She nearly died in a stunt gone wrong. She lost all her money and her career. Now, it looks like her problems have followed her home when the body of that assistant is found in a secret room in what is the latest project of her father's Secret Staircase company.

Tempest wants to figure out the trick of the locked room and, incidentally, who murdered Cassidy. Did someone mistake Cassidy for Tempest? Is this another incidence of the Raj family curse that has killed the oldest child in each of five generations?

Fans of magic-infused and twisty mysteries will enjoy this one.

Was this review helpful?

WOW, we have a winner!

We learn that Tempest has gone home to California where she plans on eating lots of her grandfather's home-cooked meals. During her stay, she visits her father's recent renovation project to find a dead body. One that is behind a wall that was supposedly sealed for more than a century. And, so the mystery begins.

Under Lock & Skeleton Key is a masterpiece. I could not put this book down, and the storyline and well-crafted characters left me wanting more.

Was this review helpful?

I thought this started out well enough, a magician in a cozy mystery, cool! But it started getting repetitive fairly quickly (maybe the editor will see it and redact some of that stuff) and convoluted. This book was a bit messy! And some parts were extremely unbelievable and just didn't make sense. I loved the idea of all these hidden rooms and such in a house, made me think of the Winchester House in CA (! But I won't be continuing the series. I may try one of Pandian's other series though, just to see if it's her or just this series.

Was this review helpful?

A very enjoyable read.

The first in a series, we follow Tempest as she has returned to her family home, after her Magic show in Las Vegas was cancelled because of an accident. While Tempest is enjoying the time spent with her grandparents, she is trying to decide what her future will bring.

He father runs the Secret staircase construction company - specializing in creating secret rooms, hidden staircases etc for their clients. When a dead body is found inside the wall at one of their construction sites, Tempest realizes she knows the deceased - and she cannot have been inside the wall for more than a short while. What follows is Tempest and her friends trying to solve a 'locked room' mystery while they are concerned that a family curse is pointing towards Tempest being the intended victim,

This was a quick and easy read, with some delightful characters. Tempest's Grandfather is Indian, and loves to cook and her Grandmother is Scottish, providing foods that are a mashup of both cultures. Some of the recipes are included at the end of the book.

I found the writing rather simplistic, and wondered for a while if this was a YA book. However, I think the style fit the plot - as it was all about the art of magic, secrets, misdirection and the suspense of belief.

I found the book delightful. It reminded me of a favorite British TV series from the 1990's - Jonathan Creek - in which a magician used his skill in magic tricks to solve murders. I will be looking to read the rest of the books in the series.

Was this review helpful?

Such a fun mystery full of masterful illusions, innovative architecture, and food! Tempest comes from a family of magicians/illusionists and has always heard there is a curse on her family that the eledest child dies from magic - and this has been true for five generations. Tempest doesn't know if she believes in the curse or not. Tempest was a headline performer in Vegas until an onstage incident that she was blamed for, caused her to se everything and go home to Hidden Creek to stay with her family. Trouble follwowed her - a body of a co-performer was found in a wall in an old house Tempest's father's company was remodeling. Other things were happening around Tempest that were very odd. She and her friends start inveslotigating to find out what is happending and who is behind it.

There are great characters in this book and I really enjoyed them. I also liked the plot and found the architecture of the hidden rooms and puzzling locks fascinating. Tempest's grandfather's cooking and love of food is peppered through the book. The mystery had enough complexity to keep my attention.

Thanks to St. Martin's Press through Netgalley for an advance copy. This book will be published on March 15, 2022.

Was this review helpful?

This mystery is a departure from my typical reads, but in a fun way! Tempest is an intriguing main character. I enjoyed the setting very much, from her multicultural family to the descriptions of the hidden features and secret rooms throughout the family's home.

I did feel like the book had a little too much superfluous information, particularly in the beginning, which caused a bit of a slow start. It was also a little hard to pinpoint the audience or subgenre for this one... it's definitely a cozy mystery but also YA? NA? It's an enjoyable story nonetheless.

Thanks to Net Galley and Minotaur for the complimentary digital review copy of this title.

Was this review helpful?

There are so many things to love about this book! This fun cozy mystery brings a disgraced stage magician back to her family and their secret staircase construction company, adding in a locked room mystery, fantastic architecture, and lots and lots of magic. I couldn't wait to find out the solution to the mystery, and now I can't wait to find out what comes next. Tempest's wonderful multicultural family and all of their veg/vegan food was a great bonus, and I'm looking forward to getting to know them all better. Thanks to Netgalley and Minotaur Books for the advance digital copy!

Was this review helpful?

I immediately got hooked with this one. Tempest Raj is 26 years old and has recently returned home to Hidden Creek, California, after an accident during a magic performance in Las Vegas almost killed her and did kill her career. Her childhood home, Fiddler's Folly, is full of hidden passages and secret staircases and her grandparents live in a treehouse in the backyard. Her father runs the Secret Staircase Construction company "to bring magic to people through their homes." He began the company with Tempest's mother who was also a magician ... until she disappeared on stage five years ago. The disappearance wasn't part of the act, but was thought by many to be linked to a family curse going back five generations.

Shortly after Tempest returns home she is convinced to help with the family business -- currently doing renovations to a 110 year old mansion. The blueprints don't seem to match up what they're physically seeing, and they soon discover a body in a wall that apparently hadn't been touched in the 110 year history of the house. It literally falls out of the wall onto Tempest and wasn't a 110 year old body, at all -- it was Tempest's stunt double from Las Vegas. Her doppelganger. The one Tempest believed caused the career-ending accident.

There are so many questions facing Tempest, her friends, and her family (and the police, of course, even though they make an arrest very early on):
Who put Cassidy in the wall and how?
Was it meant to be Tempest?
Is it all related to the supposed curse?
And is her mother really haunting her?

Like I said, I got hooked early. I have always wanted a secret room or hidden staircase which, of course, would lead to a nook where I could read my beloved mysteries and watch old classic movies and just hide from the world in general. Tempest and her best friend, Ivy, are also mystery buffs so there's plenty of name dropping that made me smile. Nancy Drew, Agatha Christie, Alfred Hitchcock and so many more. They plan to use their knowledge of mysteries -- both fictional and non (Ivy's sister is a true-crime writer), Tempest's knowledge of magic (along with her grandfather's though he hasn't performed in decades and hot hot hottie fellow magician Sanjay), and the combined knowledge of secret construction from her father and his crew (experts in "architectural misdirection") to figure out what really happened, how, and why.

I have had Gigi Pandian books on my TBR for years now. I am ridiculously glad that St Martin's agreed to let me have an advanced copy via NetGalley ... and I'm just as glad that I have so many other Pandian books available while I wait for the next Secret Staircase Mystery. Between the compelling mystery that kept me guessing the entire time, the rich details of the settings I will dream about for ages, and the mouth-watering food cooked up by Grandpa Ash, I'm definitely a fan.

Was this review helpful?

An enjoyable read with a likable protagonist and characters you can root for.

Tempest Raj (cool name) is a stage magician who has returned home after being accused of a careless and risky magic accident, where she was ‘apparently’ witnessed preparing for the unsafe stunt. She firmly believes her former stage double, Cassidy, was responsible for the accident.

But when Cassidy is found dead inside a wall of a building being constructed by Tempest’s parents’ company, called the Secret Staircase Construction business, she and her best friend Ivy, have to solve the murder before someone kills Tempest, or accuses her of it.

This was a fun read, with diverse and quirky characters. Tempest’s grandparents, Grandpa Ash is of Indian ancestry, and Grandma Mor of Scottish, together with their brilliant fusion recipes, and Tempest’s rabbit, Abracadabra, they add a lot of fun in what is an intriguing mystery.

I’d certainly recommend this for cozy readers who like mysteries with a healthy dose of magic thrown in. I hope Gigi Pandian follows this up with more of this group of interesting characters.

Thank you Netgalley and St. Martin's Press/Minotaur Books for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

While I loved the idea of The Secret Staircase Construction Company, overall this book was not for me which I know puts me in the minority of readers. The writing felt clunky, the characters one-dimensional and I felt things jumped all over the place all and so I was never able to fully engage in the story

Was this review helpful?

Under Lock & Skeleton Key is a unique and adorable book with a quirky cast of characters and oodles of hidden rooms. While the start was a little slow, I enjoyed getting to know all of Tempest's quirky friends and family, and reading about all the different secret rooms her parents created in their home. To name a few, we meet Tempest's grandfather who is always cooking for everyone from his treehouse, her artist grandma, fellow magician Sanjay, observant stone-carver Gideon, and her friend Ivy who is (helpfully when a body is found) obsessed with locked-room mysteries.
All these elements of mystery, architecture, cooking, magic, and history really kept me entertained and I can't wait for the next installment.

Was this review helpful?

this book was so good!!! also an arc so as usual, no spoilers at all!! the characters in the books are so real and loveable, and the mystery is slow-moving which is super interesting. it's also an ode to classic mystery books which, of course, i love and it's incredible how it acknowledges the moden challenge between whodunnit and whydunnit. tempest's whole family is so fun to read about and she's a character you want to root for beginning to end. shoutout to the whole mystery squad (especially ivy, sanjay, and gideon) for keeping everything so magical and funny even when tensions were high. so so so well done!

Was this review helpful?

A unique mystery, to be sure! Tempest Raj in an interesting protagonist: a young magician/illusionist until during her show in Las Vegas, an illusion went wrong and nearly killed her. She and her pet 15-pound rabbit Abracadabra have retreated to her family’s home (really a tree house, of sorts), and she has agreed to help her father with his company, Secret Staircase Construction, which specializes in building hidden rooms. When a body is found at her father’s construction site, the mystery truly begins.

Although I enjoyed this read, my quibbles are that the novel contained too many repetitious portions and needed to have a tighter narrative. That said, I can see this becoming a movie that I believe would be especially popular with a young audience.

Was this review helpful?

By: Gigi Pandian
Review By: Librarian

Under Lock and Skeleton Key is a whimsical mystery set with exotic characters peopling the professional magician's world. Tempeste Raj is home again, out of work, and looking for a job while trying to discover who sabotaged her career and nearly got her killed. Her family home built into the side of a mountain is a warren of secret rooms and magical staircases. The discovery of a body in one of the mansion's walls brings suspicion on Tempeste. She will stop at nothing to find the killer even if she must use her famous disappearing act. The book features great food, baffling red herrings, and finally comes to a satisfying end when everything is solved. An enjoyable romp.
Thank you #NetGalley and Publisher for the opportunity to read the book in exchange for my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

This was a difficult book for me to finish. The setup was certainly enticing, but for me, the writing style and characterizations were just too clunky. The introduction of many new (and superfluous) characters and jarring flashbacks made it difficult to follow or sink in to. Definitely suffers for telling instead of showing. I really wanted to like this one, but it would not be something I could confidently recommend to readers.

Was this review helpful?

3.5/5 stars

Thank you to NetGalley and Minotaur Books/St. Martin’s Press for sending me a free ARC copy in exchange for an honest review.

Under Lock and Skeleton Key is a locked-room mystery with an impossible crime, where plot twists and misdirection will keep you guessing until the last page. Mysteries aren’t my most-read genre, but I’ve been picking up more and more of them recently. In this book, misdirection is a major theme in the plot and is used many times throughout the story. I will definitely need to reread this book to see what I missed the first time through, and I think it will stand up well for rereading multiple times.

Three things really stood out to me in this novel: the seamless blending of cultures in Tempest’s family, the magical sense of place, and the number of twists. Tempest’s family is a blend of American, Scottish, and Indian and food plays a major role in their family. I loved reading about their family dynamics and the mouthwatering dishes they make throughout the story. Tempest’s father also owns Secret Staircase Construction, which specializes in secret magical spaces, and their family home is designed with every puzzle and secret room we’ve all ever dreamed of. Their home, Fiddler’s Folly, is such a cool, magical, and mysterious place that I hope gets even more chances to shine in future books.

I made my guess for the murderer fairly early on but was unprepared for the amount of twists throughout the story, which left me second-guessing my choice throughout almost the entire book. Every time I thought there couldn’t possibly be anything else, another twist would sweep onto the page. Most of the twists were delightful, but a few I didn’t enjoy. The clues I noticed were fun to work out and mull over as the story progressed.

However, I wish the pacing was faster throughout the story: I was 56% through the book before I really felt engaged with plot and couldn’t wait to find out what happened next. I think this was partly because there was so much information introduced in the first part of the book, and every time a new place or character was introduced we also were introduced to Tempest’s full backstory with said place/character. At the start, this was just too much information to keep straight, but once the introductions were complete and we were through part one, things did pick up.

I think I will appreciate Under Lock and Skeleton Key more after a reread, but it will probably be most accessible to fans of mystery who’ve read widely in the genre. Thank you again to NetGalley and Minotaur Books/St. Martin’s Press for the opportunity of reviewing an ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Sent to me by Netgalley for review…mystery and ,Ashe,…intrigue…career…family…old crimes…haunted house? Who did it? Questions the main character might answer if…this is a quick read…

Was this review helpful?

I'm having a hard time naming what my critique of this book is, because I quite liked the characters and the "set pieces" of the solution. I also appreciated that this was a cozy that didn't feel overly twee. I guess my main issue is that the connective tissue between key moments in the book felt sort of rushed or phoned in? Like the book was just in a hurry to get to the next cool moment. Those moments were definitely cool, so I still enjoyed this, but it would been better for me if it had had a few less cool moments and more room to breathe

Was this review helpful?