Member Reviews

What a good, twisty mystery/psychological drama about obsession with famous people & bands in particular. I never knew quite where the story was headed, which to me is a good thing. Though I wish the ending was different I can appreciate why the author chose to end it the way she did. I especially liked the dual POV that kept you going back & forth from the present to the backstory.

Was this review helpful?

I found the story well written with great character development. She did an excellent job flipping between the two timelines without confusion. This was a really good book.

Thank you to the author, NetGalley, and St. Martin’s Press for the advance reader copy.

Was this review helpful?

I Would Die for You by Sandie Jones - A Thriller That Hits All the Right Notes

Remember the wild days of Duran Duran and neon everything? Sandie Jones's new thriller takes us there and back, bouncing between 1980s London and modern-day California like a perfectly crafted mixtape.

Meet Nicole Forbes, living her best quiet life by the California coast - until a nosy writer shows up at her door. Suddenly, the past she's spent decades burying threatens to surface. We're talking teenage obsession, dark secrets, and the kind of fandom that gives you chills.

Jones knows how to keep you hooked. She splits the story between sixteen-year-old Nicole in 1986 London, caught up in the intoxicating world of rock stars and teenage dreams, and present-day Nicole, whose carefully built life is starting to crack like an old vinyl record.

The book isn't perfect - some twists you'll see coming like a bass line in a pop song. But Jones nails the atmosphere, making the '80s feel alive without drowning in nostalgia. She turns what could've been just another thriller into something deeper: a story about how far we'll go to protect our secrets, and what happens when those secrets start playing their own tune.

If you're into psychological thrillers with a beat, complex characters, and enough suspense to fill a stadium, this one's worth your time. Just don't blame me if you stay up late turning pages.

3.5/5 - A solid hit with a few B-side moments

Was this review helpful?

I Would Die for You was just one more book from Sandie Jones that I completely devoured and loved every minute of it!

Nicole has a secret past that involves the downfall of one of the largest British bands of the 80's, Secret Oktober, and when a strange young woman suddenly knocks on her door asking about it, she's brought right back. The same day, someone claiming to be her daughter's aunt shows up at school and takes her daughter, yet Hannah has no aunt.... So who took her and why? And does it have to do with her past?

The story flashes back and forth between the present day (2010) and 1986 London where a younger Nicole first meets Ben Edwards, lead singer of Secret Oktober. But what she isn't aware of is her younger sister, Cassie's recent run-in with Ben which left her dreaming of a life with him and the two sisters know nothing about the other's involvement with him. As you can imagine, things get ugly when they do.

This book was twisty and kept me hooked from page one! I love a book with musical influence/characters and this one was engaging and original. Also, as someone who grew up in the 80's, it made it that much more fun for me! Highly recommended book and author!!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley, the publisher and author. I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

This book started off slow for me then it got better when the mystery part kicked in. I liked the past and present POVs but the ending was left open for me and it was very frustrating.

Was this review helpful?

Sandie Jones delivers an emotionally charged thriller in *I Would Die For You*, intertwining past secrets with present dilemmas and the fragile bond of family.

The story follows Nicole Forbes, who has escaped her tumultuous past for a quiet life in a small Californian seaside town. Her world is turned upside down when a writer arrives, probing into her connection to the downfall of a legendary British band. Things take a darker turn when her daughter goes missing, forcing Nicole to confront her haunting past to uncover the truth.

Jones skillfully builds suspense, weaving Nicole’s backstory with her desperate fight to protect her family. The novel explores themes of fame, betrayal, and the heavy cost of secrets, with a gripping pace that keeps readers engaged. Nicole is a relatable protagonist, wrestling with guilt and fear while showcasing a fierce maternal instinct.

Though some twists may feel predictable, the emotional depth and urgency of Nicole’s journey make these flaws easy to overlook. *I Would Die For You* is a thrilling read that lingers long after the final chapter, reminding us that the past has a way of catching up with us.

Was this review helpful?

This was a slower read for me compared to the authors other novels. It goes back and forth from 1986 and 2010. I was not overwhelmed with the story but it was a nice read and I thank St Martins Press for the early copy. Be sure to read the authors note, as it tells how and why she chose this to write about. Very interesting.

Was this review helpful?

Circling between California in 201 and London 1986, the story flows between the past and present life of Nicole. Living in Colorado, the story starts by showcasing the idyllic life of Nicole and her family. Everything seems perfect until two things happen: someone from her past arrives at her door and then Nicole's daughter Hannah goes missing.

Weaving between the past and the present, Nicole has to share parts of her life she's kept hidden to help her find the answer to what's happening in the present. Can she figure out what is happening and why things are coming up now? Or will her life as she knows it fall apart at the seams?

Was this review helpful?

I really need to check if author's have been recommended by Reese Witherspoon, because we have very different takes on books. I love a band story, I grew up on VH1 but this one didn't have likable characters and there wasn't really any one to root for, even in a fun go with the villain kind of way.

Was this review helpful?

Nicole Forbes — LaJolla seal protector, living with her husband Brad who works at the nearby naval base, has a surprise visit from a smirking reporter/author who wants to know about what happened 25 years ago when Nicole’s involvement with British rock star blew up (a tidbit she never shared with Brad). On the same day, Nicole’s 8 year old daughter Hannah isn’t on the returning school bus — an “aunt” supposedly picked her up. Except, in this version of Nicole’s life, neither she or Brad have a sister.

Two timelines — 2010 and London 1986: the version of her life when twenty something aspiring singer Nicole does have a teenaged sister, Cassie, who’s obsessed with pop star boy band Secret Oktober. Cassie does the obsessed groupie stalking of the band’s lead singer and relinquishing her body and common sense to the entire band scene; Nicole actually meets the primary guy under different circumstances when he visits the club where she sings part time. But even with both sisters whitewashing their experiences, the three guys in Secret Oktober, Ben, Michael, and Lukas, are absolute predators regarding women.

Nicole’s current life is turned upside down by mysterious women suddenly appearing with knowledge of her hidden past. Her marriage is put to the test when Brad learns Nicole was a suspect in the death of one of the band members. But he’s also been meeting with a woman that he failed to ask Nicole about. Brad and Nicole do not have much respect for each other — immediately distrusting each other instead of working together even when their daughter is in danger. Who took Hannah? What does this have to do with the band that rivaled Duran Duran in the 80s? Oh, yeah — who really did kill the guy?

The pop star obsession part with rival sisters is fascinating, but the present day drama is frustrating. I wish Nicole and Brad had been better developed and just talked more to each other. But their faults lead to a longer time for the story to unfold. The action all seems to take place in the last 15% of the book. And then the ending: abrupt and confusing. I reread it multiple times, but maybe the characters are in the know, but not me. For that cliffhanger, the undeveloped relationship between Nicole and Brad, and the uneven pacing, I can only give this book 3 stars. There was so much potential to give the reader a clearer narrative, but it didn’t happen.

Literary Pet Peeve Checklist:
Green Eyes (only 2% of the real world, yet it seems like 90% of all fictional females): NO No eye colors are mentioned.
Horticultural Faux Pas (plants out of season or growing zones, like daffodils in autumn or bougainvillea in Alaska): NO No plants or flowers are included.

Thank you to St. Martin’s Press and NetGalley for an advanced reader copy!

Was this review helpful?

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫 (4.5/5, psychological thriller)

My first ARC!!! 🥹😭
Thank you to @netgalley and the publisher for this eARC!
Pub date: March 25th, 2025

Listen. I was hooked!! Whenever I read books about a dreamy leading man in a rock band falling in love with a “regular normal girl” I am living out a teenage fantasy thinking Joe Jonas would see me and instantly fall in love with me LOL. 😂🤭

Told in two timelines. 1986 England & 2010 California. I enjoyed the jumping back and forth between the decades to keep the pacing fast and intriguing. The characters were well developed and I got so mad at some of the stupid decisions that they made.

1986 England: Nicole’s sixteen year old sister, Cassie is the biggest fan girl of the hottest British rock band, Secret Oktober. Cassie has an intense overly obsessive crush on the lead singer, Ben Edwards and would do anything to capture his attention. When Ben sees Nicole singing in a local bar one night he can’t help but notice her. Their whirlwind relationship sets in motion the destruction of their family and ultimately their lives.

2010 California: Nicole lives a quiet life with her husband and daughter. When her daughter goes missing after school one day Nicole calls the school for information, they tell her that her daughter’s aunt picked her up. The only problem is that her daughter doesn’t have an aunt.

I thought that the author’s notes at the end of the book were really cool. She said that she used to follow the rock group Duran Duran around and that gave her a little bit of inspiration for this book (minus all of the crazy things that happen!)🤘🏽🎸

Was this review helpful?

I WOULD DIE FOR YOU by Sandie Jones was a bit of a disappointment for me, but it might be the ideal read for another reader.

It’s 2010, and Nicole Forbes is focused on saving the beach with her husband Brad and 8 year old daughter Hannah. When a woman named Zoe comes to her door, it forces her to confront what happened back in London with the band Secret Oktober back in 1986.

This dual timeline takes the reader back to 1986 where teenage Cassie is obsessed with Ben Edwards from Secret Oktober, and she and her friend Amelia become immersed with the band.

I had a problem with the characterizations. Everyone had such a superficial lens on them, including Cassie, and I wanted to know more than the superficial. Especially when Cassie is dealing with a mental disorder, I thought the author could have done more than just paint her in an unfavorable light. The problem bled into other characters as well, with many not formed as multi-dimensional as I think they deserved to be. I didn’t “get” Nicole and Brad’s marriage. And who was Hank? He was mentioned several times, but I didn’t understand who he was.

Thankfully, the mystery didn’t have twist after twist, which I appreciated. I liked that the reader could see how plot points were building.

Thank you to NetGalley and Minotaur Books for an Advance Reader Copy in exchange for an unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

I am a huge fan of Sandie Jones ! Love all of her books ! And this one did not disappoint ! The main character, Nicole, has the perfect life. She left behind a troubled past and fled to the US, leaving it all behind her. Married the man of her dreams, beautiful daughter, well respected in the community. Until there is a knock at the door and suddenly her past is right in her face She tries to ignore it. She tries to avoid it. But her daughter goes missing. And one thing after another goes wrong as her past comes back to haunt her. And it is shocking ! Great from beginning to end. Lots of twists.

Was this review helpful?

I received a complimentary copy of this book "I Would Die For You" and all opinions expressed are my own. The ending - WHAT!?!? I don't understand it. I did finish the book but I didn't like it.

Was this review helpful?

I had no idea where this book was headed but it was fun that way! There are a lot of characters so sometimes I got a little confused but overall a fun thriller! The fictional boyband was fun to read about and I love things set in London.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Minotaur Books for the gifted digital ARC.

I unfortunately decided to DNF this one at 33%. I was having a hard time connecting with the story, and the plot didn't move along as quickly as I like it to when reading a thriller. I was also insanely frustrated with one particular character but I won't say too much so I don't spoil for future readers.

Nevertheless I will absolutely pick up the next Jones novel without hesitation!

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately this one felt disjointed for me for the majority of the book. And while I am all for being unsure and on the edge of my seat during a thrilling read…this one took it a bit too far for me in feeling more confusing than anything. The time jumps and various POVs were a lot, and I don’t feel we really got any sort of full explanation. The ending was very abrupt, without a clear conclusion.

Overall, I would not discourage the read if you’re a fan of the author or the sound of the synopsis. But it isn’t one I’ll add to my list of regular recs.

Thank you to the publisher for the gifted ARC

Was this review helpful?

I would Die for You alternates between London in 1986 and Coronado, California in 2010. The dual timeline keeps the story well paced and interesting. There is some suspense and mystery, but not a ton of jaw dropping twists. However, the unlikeable characters and ode to an 80's band with star-struck fans keeps this entertaining. The ending leaves on a cliffhanger so if you like things tied up nicely with a bow at the end, this may not be the one for you. Read if you like 80's bands, dual timelines, and family drama.

Thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press | Minotaur Books for a digital ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I started this one but couldn't get into it. I am sure others would enjoy it but it just wasn't for me.

Thank you Netgalley & St. Martin's Press | Minotaur Books for the advanced reader copy.

Was this review helpful?

A stellar “who did what to whom, when, and how” where the spins keep coming and you’re on the edge of your seat even after the very last sentence. The Acknowledgments are great, too!

Thanks to #NetGalley and the publisher for access to this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?