Very cool idea for a book, and an excellent execution of that idea. A thoroughly enjoyable read. Recommended.      .

I'm torn with this one. On one hand, I read it and I found it enjoyable enough to keep reading it. On the other hand, I just didn't connect. There was never that "ah-ha!" moment that happens when I've landed on something I really love. 
And that is why I'm torn. 
I want the book to move me. 
And I wasn't moved.

WWll, Scotland, the Loch Ness monster and characters with hearts reminiscent of The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Society.  As a child tales of the Loch Ness had always fascinated me and with the Outlander series highlighting the romance of Scotland, I couldn’t resist Sara Gruen’s At the Water’s Edge.  Reading this made me long for simpler times with less technology where mysteries were more easily believed and not so easy to solve.

It took me a while to get to this one but I'm glad I kept it in my Netgalley downloads. I've always admired Sara Gruen's writing and thought this was well researched, moving, and interesting, and I especially loved the Scottish setting.

Well, if you can’t be a colorblind soldier during WW@, you may as well go to Scotland and hunt the Loch Ness Monster... (urgh)

This book starts out with some real winners (insert sarcasm here). I have a real problem with unlikable characters and this novel is chocked full of them. It starts out with an unredeemable embarrassing situation that results in the main characters being cut off financially and set out to fix it by going to Scotland and hunting the Loch Ness Monster - seriously THAT is the plot line for this book. 
Of course there is more to it: love, abuse, lies, deceit, war, Hitler. This book has it all. What is doesn’t have is someone to root for. 

I am a huge fan of Gruen’s novel *Water for Elephants*, but this offering kind of missed the mark for me.

I absolutely loved Water for Elephants, but this one just didn't rise up for me. As I'm only giving it 3 stars, not sharing on social media

This was a very good read. It is much more than just a fun read, it is a brilliant adventure with some of the most well developed characters in recent memory. The context of World War and the details that are included make it a very believable story.

As usual with Gruen's books, her characters are fully realized: struggling, irritating, and appealing. It's also a great story, and even though I figured out the main dynamic early on, I stayed to enjoy the good story, her great ability with setting and atmosphere, and characterization. If you liked Water for Elephants you'll enjoy this one.

While the ending is a bit predictable, and sometimes the characters were either a bit all-too-good or all-bad, but this historical romance was a fun read with a beautiful setting and compelling story line.

Good vacation reading.

"In this thrilling new novel from the author of Water for Elephants, Sara Gruen again demonstrates her talent for creating spellbinding period pieces. At the Water’s Edge is a gripping and poignant love story about a privileged young woman’s awakening as she experiences the devastation of World War II in a tiny village in the Scottish Highlands.

After disgracing themselves at a high society New Year’s Eve party in Philadelphia in 1944, Madeline Hyde and her husband, Ellis, are cut off financially by his father, a former army colonel who is already ashamed of his son’s inability to serve in the war. When Ellis and his best friend, Hank, decide that the only way to regain the Colonel’s favor is to succeed where the Colonel very publicly failed—by hunting down the famous Loch Ness monster—Maddie reluctantly follows them across the Atlantic, leaving her sheltered world behind.

The trio find themselves in a remote village in the Scottish Highlands, where the locals have nothing but contempt for the privileged interlopers. Maddie is left on her own at the isolated inn, where food is rationed, fuel is scarce, and a knock from the postman can bring tragic news. Yet she finds herself falling in love with the stark beauty and subtle magic of the Scottish countryside. Gradually she comes to know the villagers, and the friendships she forms with two young women open her up to a larger world than she knew existed. Maddie begins to see that nothing is as it first appears: the values she holds dear prove unsustainable, and monsters lurk where they are least expected.

As she embraces a fuller sense of who she might be, Maddie becomes aware not only of the dark forces around her, but of life’s beauty and surprising possibilities."

Anyone else thinking what I'm thinking? That Sara Gruen has to have "water" in all her book titles?

At the Water's Edge by Sara Gruen

For a rich girl, Maddie's had it pretty rough. Her upbringing was less than ideal and now she's married to a man who seems like a good choice, but quickly turns out to be a jerk at the very least. His main interaction with her is telling her what to wear.

Maddie's husband, Ellis Hyde, was sadly rejected from service in WWII because he's colorblind. This has lead to lots of drinking and disapproval from his wealthy parents. What's the solution for this? Well, in Ellis' opinion, it's finding the Loch Ness Monster! This is a task at which his own imperious father failed and which will bring everlasting glory to the Hyde name.

So Ellis, Maddie, and Ellis' handsome BFF, Hank, pack up and head for Scotland. Once there, the boys promptly dump Maddie in an inn filled with enigmatic Scotsmen and sassy women. While the menfolk spend hours on the frigid Loch with a camera, she desperately attempts to fill her empty days and get to know some of these new acquaintances. For instance, Angus, the innkeeper.  But Angus, it turns out, has a secret!  And so does the Loch! So really, no surprises there. A fairly predictable plot ensues with a few unexpected turns.

At the Water's Edge is a pleasant read with well drawn characters. Other reviews refer to them as shallow, but what's happening here is that some of the characters are shallow people, not shallowly depicted. Maddie starts out as one of the shallowest, but we learn alongside her that there is more to the world than it seems. A happy ending for most includes a brush with a mysterious force.

I obtained my copy for free through NetGalley.

Rating: 4 stars out of 5

At Water's Edge by Sara Gruen was a unique story, It took a long time to get through. Good luck!

I haven’t seen much about this fifth (?) novel by Canadian author Gruen, perhaps because it’s so different from her big hit Water for Elephants.

Although there have rumours of a ‘monster’ in Scotland’s Loch Ness for centuries, in 1933-34 a couple of “out-of-the-pond” sightings and two photos purported to be of the monster stirred world-wide attention. At the Water’s Edge is set on locale just after this ‘discovery’.

Gruen evokes not only the Scotland of the time, but also high society in Manhattan. Very droll.

4 stars

We all know there are self centered, egotistical, SOB's out there in the world, but that doesn't necessarily mean we want to spend time with them, even if it is only amongst the pages of a book.

Seems that's one of the problems of At the Water's Edge by Sara Gruen. Ellis Hyde and his pal Hank are privileged, silver-spoons-in-their-mouths, sons of wealthy gentlemen who spend their time in frivolous pursuits, going to parties, drinking too much, and cavalcading throughout high society, annoying the patrons and getting into trouble. The two best friends have a cohort, Madeline, a woman who enjoys their company and madcap adventures. Despite her wealthy father, Maddie has a black mark against her due to the antics of her now deceased mother, so that when she marries Ellis her welcome is anything but friendly. Then on New Years Eve in 1944, the trio are especially obnoxious, and Ellis' parents are, shall we say, not amused with the resulting gossip, so when Ellis insults his father they are ejected from the family estate and left to fend for themselves.

Ellis, whose father (the Colonel) can't forgive him for being rejected from the military due to a case of color blindness, decides to go to Scotland and find the Loch Ness Monster, an adventure that tainted his father's reputation several years earlier. If Ellis could just prove the monster exists, then his now proud papa would welcome him back with open arms and reinstate his allowance. 

Unfortunately there is a war going on, so they must travel overseas bunked down like commoners in a military convoy and to make matters worse, once they arrive in Scotland their welcome is less than cordial. The search for the monster is a lot more difficult than expected, and the two friend's behavior gets more and more outrageous fueled by alcohol and the little pills prescribed to Maddie for her "nervous condition". Maddie soon distances herself from her husband and Hank, finding more in common with the humble folks who live and work at the inn. The true personalities of each of the characters are revealed as they deal with their struggles and Maddie comes to terms with her choices in life making a decision which totally alters the fate of everyone involved leading to a twisted resolution.

While the story takes place towards the end of WWII, the war is more of a backdrop than an integral part of the story although there are black out curtains, ration books, gas masks, and several air raids. Scotland, complete with castle, is the main focus of the narrative as the inhabitants try to eke out a living in difficult times. 

This was a hard book to get into, not grabbing ones' interest until almost half way through, probably because of the despicable characters. I did borrow the audiobook, dramatically read by Justine Eyre, to get me over the hump, then finished with the written word. 

I'm not sure if I buy this tale, it's a little far fetched and I question the shift in Ellis from a spoiled brat into an evil man. Although I usually look for the good in people (in life as well as in literature), by the end of the book he had no redeeming qualities left to discuss. There was also a romance which seemed to come out of nowhere, even though there were some subtle hints of this possibility along the way. 

Three stars and a thank you to Netgalley for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review. 

This review also appears on my blog, Gotta Read.

A great love story and amazing characters.  A bit slow getting started, and the characters are somewhat self centered, but stick with it as they come to life.  The details are well thought out and the setting, during WWII, was appropriately detailed.  The story line itself followed a very similar trajectory to the Author's 2006 book, Water for Elephants.  Still this was a great read and i would recommend it to others.

I loved the setting of this book- Scotland.  Great story of hunting the Loch Ness monster and one I will recommend to others.

I lost interest within the first few chapters. Sorry, I couldn't finish it.