Cover Image: The Girl Before

The Girl Before

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

JP Delaney is a new author to me. I enjoyed the psychological suspense, and that the chapters alternated between past and present.

Was this review helpful?

Cannot wait to see how the movie directed by Ron Howard turns out! This book was definitely psychological! From the very picky architect who "screens" applicants to stay in his intricately-detailed home in London to the quirky applicants themselves who take the chance to live there, this book was quite a ride.

Edward Monkford has specific (and I mean, specific) ideas for the tenants who reside in his pristine home, and only after the applicant meets the requirements is SHE allowed to stay. At the beginning of the novel, I thought it was odd at first, but as I read on, the reasons why he has such high standards begins to unfold, and to say that the owner of the home is narcissistic is an understatement.

The story jumps back and forth between Jane who lives in the home now, and Emma, who lived there before, hence the title. Similarities begin to emerge in their personalities, and interactions between the owner and others who notice the women living in the home begin to shed light on what is really happening inside of the four walls. I loved the suspense and the ending. I was annoyed with Jane at some points, because her strength seems to get stripped away as the book moves forward, however it is essential to the plot line. Some of it was predictable, but some of it wasn't, and to me, that makes for a fun read! I would read from this author again.

Thank you to NetGalley, JP Delaney and Random House Publishing for the opportunity to read this ARC. You can find my review at https://gracielynn.blog/2017/10/09/book-review-the-girl-before-by-jp-delaney/

Was this review helpful?

Actual rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

There were a lot of mixed reviews on this book so I had some apprehension going in. In the end, I really enjoyed the book. It was different. Right from the start the story grabs your attention and it's fast paced so it went by quickly. However, I was a little disappointed with the ending. I look forward to watching the movie adaptation. With Ron Howard directing, how can it not be great?

I would like to thank NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine for supplying a copy of J.P. Delaney's "The Girl Before" in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Had me on the edge of my seat the entire time I was reading. Loved it!

Was this review helpful?

I think this is one of the many books that have come out trying to capture the feel and the audience of the book Gone Girl. There really should be a genre for "Gone Girl-Type" now. I didn't love this book. I did find it interesting to a certain point and hoped for above average but there were just some things about the plot that I did not like. I consider it an average read, though and would recommend it as a library read.

Was this review helpful?

I received a free ARC fron Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

This story follows two women that chose to move to a unique and minimalist house with an excentric and controlling landlord with Peepi Tom like tendencies. Parts of this book reminded me of Fifty Shades of Grey because of the relationship between the women in the house and the landlord.

When the most recent tenant, Jane moves in, she learns of her similarities to the previous tenant who died in an accident at the home. Jane. Grins to figure out that things don't quite add up in their home and that she might be in danger as well.

A quick engaging read that you will not want to put down!

Was this review helpful?

The Girl Before left me reeling. Who is the stalker? It would almost seem evident, but that would be too perfect. Or would it? The two women are similar until they're nothing alike. The villain is obvious, until the answer is more opaque, and then as clear as mud.

The only real problem I had with it is pacing, I guess. It builds and builds and builds well, teasing readers as to a dramatic conclusion. And then it gets to the climax, the book is pretty much done. Very much a movie set-up; it's no wonder that the move rights for The Girl Before were swooped up, and a film directed by Ron Howard is in the works.

Was this review helpful?

Psychological Thrillers are not normally my go to genre but Delaney did a great job helping us to live this story of Emma and Jane.

Was this review helpful?

Read this book!

Let's start there because, well, you should read this book. If you like drama, suspense, thrillers, psychological stories, and a little romance... you should read this book. Like yesterday.

It's one of the rare ones that absolutely breaks the 5 star scale. I'd rate it higher if I could, so let's pretend that I did. If I were fan of psychological thrillers, 5 stars would do fine. But I'm not usually a fan of this genre. Some of the books I've tried in it get way too complicated.

And, much like the houses Edward Monkford designs in THE GIRL BEFORE, it is the stark simplicity of this story that makes it absolutely TERRIFYING.

Terrifying in a special, can't put it down, gonna give me nightmares but I'm okay with that sort of way.

Which is funny to type but... the truth can't be avoided.

I thought I had this book figured out. I thought I knew who was stalking who and who was killing who. There was a lot of stalking and killing going on too.

I didn't know ANYTHING.

And that made this book amazing.

I'd say more but... just read the book? Yeah. Good.

(I received a copy of THE GIRL BEFORE through NetGalley and the publisher in exchange for an honest and original review. All thoughts are my own.)

Was this review helpful?

First experience reading JP Delaney! Read this one on the plane coming home from Maui. Kept me mesmerized . . . and guessing as the tension built & the answers were finally Revealed after several plot twists I didn't see coming. Anxious to read more from this author.

Was this review helpful?

It was a mystery that did keep me turning pages, but mostly because I thought I had figured out whodunit and wanted to make sure I was right (I was). I prefer a few more twists and turns with my mystery, but this was still pretty atmospheric and dramatic.

Was this review helpful?

A unique house with a peculiar land-lord. A lot of rules, with a harrowing application process.
One Folgate Street, it was built by a techno-minimalist architect named Edward Monkford. Everything about Monkford is intense-from his 200 question application to the face-to-face interview. If you are accepted into this house, you have to live by strict rules and adapt to Monkford's idea of a minimalist lifestyle. It is all in the contract, which states no pets, no curtains, no rugs. Everything must be put away at all times (including dishes, clothes, etc), no books, nothing left out on floors, etc. Also, you are required to keep the same cleaning service, must open the house to visitors for architecture tours, and must take assessments every month to see how you change throughout your stay at One Folgate Street.

I'm sure I will be in the minority on this, but here goes....I did not care for this book much. Besides the general idea being so far-fetched, there was so many things going on, at times it was hard to keep up.

Was this review helpful?

REVIEW CONTAINS MINOR SPOILERS

I really loved how this story was told. Alternating every chapter between each girl and their stories added to the suspense so much. What adds even more to the suspense is that Jane tells her story from the past and Emma is in the present. Having their lives intertwine so much was at times a bit creepy and really helped me to fall in love with this book. I loved the mystery element of Jane trying to figure out what happened to Emma and how it is the plot of the story, but it didn’t take over the story.

There were many parts of this book that I found myself surprised that the author was a male. Usually, I don’t think it matters who is writing because this is fiction and the author is using their imagination to tell a story so I judge the book based on their writing and depth of story. In this case though, JP Delaney wrote so vividly about things that only a woman can go through that I was very impressed with his writing. He also did a wonderful job keeping me guessing the whole story and this book had so many twists and turns that it was a hard book to put down.

Both Emma and Jane felt so real to me that I was invested in both of their stories from the get go. Jane has just been through a home invasion and is looking for somewhere new to live with her boyfriend because she, understandably, doesn’t feel safe anymore where she is living. Emma has recently suffered a stillbirth and is trying to recover from the loss of her child. Both of these events are the motivation behind each girl’s choices and behaviors. Even though both of their stories are taking place at different times many of the side characters are the same for both narratives, which just further entwines their stories. Both Emma and Jane were messy and relatable women and I found myself so caught up in each of their stories that I wasn’t even trying to look for clues to the mystery. Also, knowing that something is going to eventually happen to Emma kept the suspense level high throughout the whole story.

The Girl Before was way more dark and twisted than I thought it would be. I’m not really sure what I was expecting but it was definitely more rated R than PG13. I love how dark it was and it was a great addition to all the other elements in the book. This story has a lot of sexual content which may make some readers uncomfortable or may even be triggering so please keep that in mind if you’re deciding to read this book or not. JP Delaney balanced everything in this book so well and it was a very enthralling read.

Earlier in the month I posted about a challenge I was doing, where I’m wanted to read 15 thrillers before the end of the year. This was one of the books on the list and I’m so happy that I was finally pushed to read this because I loved it so much. I was also happy to find out that The Girl Before is being turned into a movie. It is going to be such a great movie if done right and I will definitely be seeing it in theaters.

~Cassie

Was this review helpful?

I had requested this book from Netgalley before I saw all the mixed reviews on it. I’m still glad I ended up reading it, but it definitely wasn’t as good as I was expecting, and ended up being more of a fence sitter.

The story is told through alternating POV. The newest resident of One Folgate Street, Jane, and the girl before, Emma. We know right from the get go something had to have happened, obviously, because One Folgate Street is back on the market and not still being lived in by Emma. I found the premise of the house itself to be more intriguing than the lives of the women and the people in their lives. Hell, I wanted to move into One Folgate Street after reading the descriptions of the location and how the house itself was set up.

This is tagged as mystery/thriller/suspense, and really all of that revolves around Jane trying to figure out what happened to Emma. The author really tries to make the reader suspect one person right from the get-go, but I’ve read too many mysteries to fall for it, and gradually came to the conclusion myself who the perp was before it was revealed.

Overall, when I finished the story I was left with the thought that you really never know anyone 100%, and Every. Single. Person. has secrets. Ever person in this story has had something traumatic happen to them:

-Emma: House was broken into and she no longer feels safe.
-Jane: Had a personal tragedy regarding a pregnancy.
-The Architect: Lost his wife and child years before in an architecture related accident.

But when it really came down to it, I kinda felt like the architect was the only one that was sort of coping with what happened to them, and trying to move on. Emma and Jane always came off to me like they were just trying to fill a void in their lives, rather than accepting the fact that you can’t fill the voids that struggles have left you with. Square peg, round hole. A thing can never be broken or cracked and be remade to be exactly what it was before.

I would recommend this book to those who don’t have strong background in reading mystery. I think those readers are the ones that would enjoy this the most. I guess I’m just too jaded so everything was really obvious to me. Still really happy I read this, finally, and would most likely look into something else from this author.

Copy received through Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Wow. This book and what lies between the pages of it are so intriguing. I don't feel like that word encapsulates the book to the fullest extent but this was amazing to read. It was a page turner, for sure, and I'm still reeling from it.

Was this review helpful?

1 Folgate Street is no ordinary house, it is cutting edge and won the Stirling Prize. It is an example of extreme minimalism and incorporates the latest home technology. It was originally designed by the techno-architect Edward Monkton as his family home but his wife and son died there which means its now available for others to live. Only there is the slight problem of over 200 conditions that have to be adhered to by whoever lives there. And they have to be interviewed and approved by Monkton personally.

The narrative focuses on Emma from the past, and Jane in the present. Both are troubled women. Emma was held at knife point by burglars and she is struggling to come to terms with this. This event drives her decision to apply to live in the house, despite her boyfriend, Simon's reservations. The conditions for residing there will turn her into a new person with more control, Jane has had a stillborn baby and grieving. This house will be her new start and she just happens to fancy the architect. She is receiving a flower delivery of gentians which she assumes is from the architect until she reads the card....and realises there is more to the house than she thought. Emma died in the house.

A concerned Jane begins to investigate Emma, the girl before to ascertain whether she was murdered, and if so by whom. There are uncomfortable similarities between her and Emma. From both resembling Edward's wife, to having a no strings attached affair with him which runs a similar if not identical course, to both having risque sex. Jane meets the people in Emma's life including Simon, the aggrieved boyfriend, and Carol, the therapist. Meanwhile, the house appears to develop an entity of its own as strange and random things happen. Is the controlling and manipulative Edward a killer? Is Emma a reliable narrator? An air of menace hangs over the house as danger begins to close in around Jane.

The writing is lucid, sparse and beautiful. Pretty much like the house, and there is an air of claustrophobia in the story. This is a house with tragic beginnings and a strong character that is destined to trouble those who live there, you can just feel this. It is a good psychological thriller that keeps you reading without ever losing interest.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Net Galley for the ARC!

This was wonderful and suspenseful! I have been trying to sit back and enjoy the ride when reading mysteries and suspenseful books...I think I'm getting better.

The parallel stories of Emma and Jane were a unique twist and their tumultuous relationship with Edward unfolds with such fluidity, that you cannot help but get swept up in the current.

Emma's character comes off as spoiled and entitled.

Edward's character is a bit 50 Shades in his discipline and rules.

Jane's character is awesome! I loved her resilience and ability to just keep going!

Was this review helpful?

NetGalley provided this book for me to read and review.
THE GIRL BEFORE is being likened to GONE GIRL or GIRL ON THE TRAIN. This reader likens it to THE STEPFORD WIVES (girls) meet FRANKENSTEIN while SLEEPING WITH THE ENEMY. Ha!
Seriously, this book is seriously ludicrous. Women who willingly agree to sign a lease for a house whose tenant must agree to the TWO HUNDRED RULES of occupancy? Absurd! Said house is fully automated (so the tenant has no control over lighting, temperature, etc) ? Asinine! I couldn't begin to enjoy the suspense because I couldn't suspend my disbelief of such a preposterous and wacky storyline. This one gives new meaning to the word bizarre. I didn't relate to or connect with any of the characters. Weird plot. Weird characters.

I realize I'm in the minority. I realize Ron Howard is making a movie based on this book. I guess it is a 'not for me' kind of book.

Www.goodreads.com
Www.amazon.com

Was this review helpful?

Oh, where to start??? This was a wild ride and kept me guessing their every move--- loved it and loved that it kept me on the edge of my seat!! Way to go!!!!!

Was this review helpful?

Two strikes, you're out.

DNF @24%

I tried, twice, but I don't want to read this. There's something a bit shallow about these characters and this world that doesn't interest me. And the way the author just handled a sensitive scene sealed the deal for me. I'm not investing time in this.

Was this review helpful?