Lincoln in the Bardo

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date: 14 Apr 2017

Member Reviews

One of the best, gripping, emotional, thrilling reads I've encountered in a long time. Saunders deserves all the praise he's received for this book. He's a national treasure whose work I will always devour.
Was this review helpful?
American chorus

Lincoln in the Bardo: A Novel by George Saunders (Random House, $17).

Anytime someone asks for a novel rec, I’m giving this one. That’s not because it’s the most recent or even the most absolutely literary, but because it is the most American–and that’s what we need right now.

Simply enough, the novel takes place over the days immediately after the burial of young Willie Lincoln in the deep winter of 1862. It triggered the bout of melancholy that lasted until the president’s death three years later. The graveyard where Willie is interred in a mausoleum (his body was later moved to Illinois) serves as the physical location of the bardo, the intermediary place between life and death.

The various residents of the bardo–save one–are in deep denial about their state. Most of them, detached from time and the flesh, cannot imagine that they will not “recover” and return to the lives they left; as they slowly transform into figures unrecognizable as human, the psychological machinations through which they delude themselves become even more elaborate and they envision moving on as death, rather than what they have already experienced.

Meanwhile, Lincoln has returned to the mausoleum to hold Willie’s body, so deep in his grief that he is nearly mad with it. Some of our “ghosts,” for lack of a better word, see the president’s presence as a chance to escape the bardo.

While we toggle between the voices of a deceased newspaper publisher, a suicide, and a minister, we also get a sense of the United States as a mishmash of histories, ideas, dreams and desires. And no, it’s not fully inclusive–women are minor characters; there are no Native voices; slaves are relegated (with a singular exception) to a nameless ditch.

In other words, it’s the same as it ever was.

But it is also a specific moment in time, one in which Lincoln is confronted with the loss of a beloved son and so understands the deep grief of a nation losing sons on the battlefield daily. It is a moment in which one man’s decision made all the difference–and that is the crux of this novel.

So, no, it’s not perfect. But it is so very American that it is true in every way.
Was this review helpful?
Like The Graveyard Book for grown-ups. 

https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/1898560806?book_show_action=false&from_review_page=1
Was this review helpful?
What has Saunders done here?! Amazing! The audio edition of this is not to be missed.
Was this review helpful?
What an incredible feat of writing!  George Saunders, has, once again,  provided an experience that will keep you pondering the meaning of existence.
It is early 1962 and the country is now in the throes of the Civil War amid the realization that it will not be over quickly.  President Abraham Lincoln is the leader in conflict,a compassionate, heroic figure for the times.  His beloved son, Willie, dies, and resurfaces in the bardo, that transitional state of being.  
To attempt to describe that place between life and one's final resting place would do an injustice to the frightening, beautiful world that Saunders has created.  The question he poses about life, love and its purpose will leave you thinking for so long after you finish.
Was this review helpful?
A fascinating look at death, grief and the afterlife, told through a panoply of the dead. The unusual writing style does take some getting used to, but the story carries through to an outstanding crescendo.
Was this review helpful?
I don't ever remember making this much of an effort to read a book before. The first time I picked up George Saunders' novel, Lincoln on the Bardo, I was halfway through the book when I stopped reading after realizing that I just wasn't getting a complete picture and was too confused to continue any further. I was also having difficulty categorizing this avant garde piece. Not magical realism despite the graveyard setting with the apparitions moving the plot forward, nor a horror story even though the ghostly characters, whose features reflect the moment of their death, come with a complete set of questionable behaviors, but a tale without any narration, purely quotes from both the living and the dead - a dramatic farce
, of sorts, without any stage directions, depicting events through the "dialogue" as the players disclose their personal sagas. 

The "plot" begins at the White House where Mary Todd and Abraham Lincoln are hosting a gala, feting the community with all manner of delicacies, while upstairs their son Willie, who has contracted Typhoid, lies dying instead of being on the mend as the doctor had promised. The death of their beloved son leaves not only the Lincolns bereft, but also touches the hearts of all those who knew the young lad. While the community mourns along with the President, many castigate the parents for continuing with the celebration at such a time. All this is explained through quotes from various publications and diaries depicting the event, with numerous contradictions about the details - there was a full moon, the moon was new, it was a cloudy night, the sky was clear, etc. The funeral was well attended and little Willie was laid to rest in a borrowed Crypt. Lincoln, unable to accept the loss of his son, visits the graveyard, removing the deceased boy from his casket to hug and caresss the lifeless form, promising to return. All this is based on true events. 

Next comes Saunders extrapolation of the dead who have not gone into the beyond, remaining in the "Bardo", a sort of holding center. The spirits watch this aberration of behavior, wondering. Willie wants to remain in the graveyard awaiting his father's promised return, but the three main characters, Roger Blevins III (suicide victim) Hans Vollman (possible heart attack), Rev Everly Thomas (appalled at his future awaited fate) urge him on to the afterlife. Young ones are not to stay behind, although others have chosen to remain, not trusting the beyond. Each lost soul wants to share their particular tale of death with the lad, in the hopes that his luck might touch them as well, with an undertone that Willie might yet return to his old life through the power of his father. Never before has anyone touched, let alone hugged, a body after being laid to rest. It is this unusual feat which draws everyone close to the boy. As the story unfolds the reader is exposed to the idiosyncrasies of the graveyard where the souls still exist, returning to their "sick boxes" each day, even as their bodies decay, resisting the call from those who try to trick them into leaving the mortal realm. 

This extremely confusing book needs some explanations before the reader opens the first page. With so many characters, it is difficult to follow so I decided to give the audiotape a try. Still, with a multitude of voices, (166, including the numerous quotes, many from real sources), I needed to simultaneously read the book as I listened to get the gist of the story. Only then could I decipher what was actually happening.

I must say that deciding to use this large number of separate narrators to tell the tale was a moment of brilliance. While some of the readers are unknown, many are A list actors with big names such as Nick Offerman, David Sedaris, Ben Stiller, Julianne Moore, Susan Sarandon, Bill Hader, Megan Mullally, Ben Stiller, Don Cheadle, and even the author, George Saunders, taking part. Nick and David, portraying the main characters, did a phenomenal job, with their interpretations bringing the graveyard to life. While Saunders had a credible performance, he could not compete with the other two actors who definitely earned their pay. The others taking on smaller roles were delightful, especially Bill Hader and Megan Mullally portraying foul mouthed white trash who lived in the black community, allowing some discourse on the slavery issue. As I followed along with the text, the words came alive in a way my mind could never imagine, especially some heart felt sections when the true plights of the "victims" are finally revealed. 

So, while still a bizarre book, I finally was able to finish and appreciate the author's intent, with the last quarter of the book providing some hope and inspiration about life beyond the grave, although there are still a myriad of questions which I would like the author to answer. Since this book utilizes an unusual format to advance the plot, It was a shock to hear Lincoln on the Bardo won the 2017 Man Booker Award, (especially considering an American won last year as well). I wonder how many other readers will take the time necessary to appreciate this offbeat book and Saunders' unique approach to literature.

Four stars and a thank you to Netgalley for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Was this review helpful?
This book reads like the literary achievement that it is. It's unique and bold and told in a style that I haven't come across before. Any challenges I had were because of my own personal reading taste - the shift in narrator was jarring at times, but was what made it interesting I think. And honestly - it just won the Man Booker. That says more than I ever could!
Was this review helpful?
I was not a fan of this book as I had supposed I would be. Author has brilliant short stories however this novel had working to hard to love from the start. Once I fell into to sync with the writing style it got better, but it's not what I had hoped from this author and fabulous premise.
Was this review helpful?
Fascinating and original, George Saunders' first novel uses a unique format utilizing real and fictional information and a variety of haunted voices to tell the story of Lincoln's grief over his young son's tragic death. The conceit wears a bit after a while, but well worth the read. More, please, sir.
Was this review helpful?
I believe the author should stick to short stories.
Was this review helpful?
I was surprised by how much I loved this book. I picked it up being very wary since I've never gotten into George Saunders' writing before, but I wound up wanting to go back and revisit all his earlier works now that I have a firmer grasp on his writing style. The prose and dialogue in this book seem disjointed at first, but ultimately, Saunders weaves it all together to build a beautiful story of the loss of a child, the afterlife, and how we are haunted by those who have left our life. His style is quirky and witty yet sends a profound message to his readers about a part of history about which so few people know. I found myself researching more details about Lincoln and the death of his young son. Simultaneously beautiful and haunting, I would definitely give this book as a gift, particularly to those who are fascinated by the human aspects of history and novels with a gothic feel. I'm impressed by Saunders' ability to weave together a beautiful story with abstract writing.
Was this review helpful?
While this book was not my personal favorite, I understand why many people would enjoy it.  The multiple narrators left things a bit jumbled, but the premise allowed me to power through.  An interesting read and an interesting perspective.
Was this review helpful?
This book is amazing. Pure brilliance. I think it's safe to say that this will be the best book I'll read in 2017, not even knowing what I'll read the rest of the year.  The book is incredibly difficult to put down, the compelling story and beautiful writing made disrupting the flow of the sentences feel like a crime.
Was this review helpful?
At first go, it didn't grab me. Once I picked it up for a second attempt, I read over 100 pages. Simply beautiful, bittersweet, sublime. You feel the weight of grief, subtle humor & hope all at once.
Was this review helpful?
People are going a little crazy about George Saunders' Lincoln in the Bardo and I have to say I understand why. It was a singular reading experience and I now feel the need to read everything Saunders ever wrote.

Lincoln in the Bardo tells the story of the death of Willie Lincoln, which occurred within the first year of Abraham Lincoln's presidency and at the onset of the Civil War. Saunders imagines what happened when Lincoln went to visit and hold his son's body while it resided in a crypt in Oak Hill Cemetery. Willie does not immediately leave the earth, but instead is in the Bardo, a purgatory-like place with a diverse multitude of inhabitants who he interacts with.

This novel gave me goosebumps, made me gasp, brought tears to my eyes, and elicited laughter. I listened to a bunch of interviews with Saunders (including the Professional Book Nerds Podcast and Mashreads Podcast) and was struck by his statement that he wanted readers to feel speechless at the end, then emotional, then to start analyzing. This is exactly I experienced.

I want to tell you why this book was so different, but I also don't want to spoil it for you! Suffice it to say that I definitely recommend it.

(I was tempted to give this book five stars because it is unlike anything I've ever read. I withheld that last star as a one woman protest of literary fiction's tendency to ALWAYS include a completely unnecessary sexual reference in effort to shock the reader. If you read Lincoln in the Bardo, you'll know exactly what I'm referring to.)
Was this review helpful?
I wasn't sure after finishing this very strange novel , whether to give it a 1 star or 5! So I settled
On 3, I found the hardback paper version easier to follow as their are just so many voices.
I enjoyed it , wouldn't say I loved it & I can understand the mixed reviews . I would not recommend the book, however I have talked about in within my Bookclub circle after I choose it
As our may 2017 book. Again v mixed reviews, and why did the author not elaborate on why the Reverend would be going downstairs rather than up, what did he do or didn't do during his life. A very confusing read.
Was this review helpful?
this is a difficult book to review it feels. but I liked it. here are some thoughts. 

1. have you guys seen who does the audio book????? because it is EVERYONE. Nick Offerman, David Sedaris, Don Cheadle, Lena Dunham, Ben Stiller, Susan Sarandon, Megan Mullally, this list goes on and on and on. it's amazing.

2. but ALSO this book is not written for audio listening. it's weird and confusing with the quotes and the different character speakers. I think it would be great if you'd read it in print and then listened to it a year later or something. it's still good. just more difficult to crack, I think. I had trouble following sometimes. 

3. this book is a panoply. so much is going on and the style is perfect for what it is. I love the quotes. I loved the serious crassness of the dead. I loved the repetitive terminology of sick boxes and the light matter.

4. listening to the beginning about people censuring president lincoln for throwing lavish parties and then watching our current president jet off on tax payer dollars to his resort/golf course every weekend was an interesting comparison. 

5. I would strongly recommended this to adults. not so much young adults just because I feel they would have trouble appreciating some of what it's doing.
Was this review helpful?
George Saunders is known for his brilliant short story collections, “The Tenth of December” being his most recent one loved by critics. He tackles historical fiction in his first novel, “Lincoln in the Bardo,” which is a tour de force in literary fiction.

“Lincoln in the Bardo” takes a real event — the death of Abraham Lincoln’s young son Willie — and creates a masterful novel, positing what happens after death. Saunders has multiple characters speaking here, most of them residing somewhere between death and the afterlife, and they tell the stories of their own lives and how they came to be “in the bardo.”

His Lincoln is a father torn asunder by grief, mourning not only his own son, but all the sons he has sent to death in war. Interspersed is dialogue from people who knew Lincoln, some real excerpts and some Saunders himself has written. It is unique and inventive.
Was this review helpful?
Published by Random House on February 14, 2017

The dead want nothing so much as to be loved. At least, that’s what we are told by the dead characters in Lincoln in the Bardo.

Much of the novel, in fact, consists of conversations held by dead characters. They watch, and comment upon, the death of Abraham Lincoln’s young son, Willie, who soon joins them.

That death and the circumstances surrounding it also the subject of scholarly commentary and contemporaneous documents (often less than scholarly) that are liberally quoted, snippets woven together to make chapters of their own. The same technique is used to construct chapters about the Civil War dead, displeasure with Lincoln’s presidency, and criticism of Lincoln’s parenting style.

The dead turn to Willie for inspiration as he tries to remain in the material world, hoping to see his father once more. Some of the (dead) characters, however, believe that Willie needs to move on, although they have not done so themselves. In fact, their inability to accept death, to accept their own deaths, just as Lincoln struggled to accept his son’s death, seems to be the point of the story. Acceptance of anything that holds us back is liberating.

Parts of the novel, particularly the dialog of spirits who criticize and backbite each other, are quite funny. In a random assembly of the deceased, sins are confessed, grievances are aired, secrets are revealed. The dead have been silent too long, and Willie’s appearance, his ability to communicate with his father, albeit briefly, gives them a chance to be heard. Or so they hope. Mostly they want one more chance to talk about themselves, just as they did before they died.

Parts of the novel, particularly Lincoln’s thoughts of his lost son, are quite moving. And parts, suggesting that bigotry and pettiness survive death, would be depressing if they were not lightened by the humor that pervades the story.

I give George Saunders credit for inventiveness. I’ve never read a work of fiction quite like Lincoln in the Bardo. The story has a worthy message about the burden of suffering that we all carry in varying degrees, and our responsibility to lighten the load of others when we can. I can’t say I was entirely captivated by the story Saunders tells, but it made me laugh, and it made me think. Any novel that consistently does those things merits a recommendation.
Was this review helpful?