Cover Image: She Who Knows

She Who Knows

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

A delightful work. In a strange and distant future. While it’s great to have read Who Fears Death first, , it is not necessary. Nnedi Okorafor is a master of worldbuilding. When I pick up one of her books I know the societies and cultures she crafts are going to be rich and complex. The technology that is so much a part of our lives in 2024 has but a small part to play.

At the heart of this story is Jeeba, who starts the story by defying tradition and developing abilities that change not just her life, but that of her family and community. While there are rich rewards, there are also consequences that she could not have foreseen.. The reader gets to experience Jeeba maturing into someone beautiful and occasionally something terrible as she fights those who would oppress her family and community.

I want more stories in this harsh yet often touching universe. I put it down with a sense of wonder and amazement.

Was this review helpful?

I read this courtesy Net Galley. Salt is life, we are told, and in this wonderful work of Afrofuturistic fantasy/science fiction, we have a coming of age story in which a girl experiences an instinctive call to travel the Salt Roads, to accompany her father and brothers to the Dead Lake to mine the most attractive and useful blocks of salt. But girls don’t do that - yet she does, and she discovers there is more to her life, and her people, than she could have ever considered. The reader can nearly touch the world in the description that Okorafor gives us, and we find ourselves entwined in the culture, the people, the very environment.

Was this review helpful?

She Who Knows is a novella with a compelling main character, great worldbuilding, and straightforward yet slightly poetic prose. This is the backstory of one of the characters from Who Fears Death. While I haven't read this book, I was still able to enjoy this story on its own, and I am intrigued enough that I not only one to continue this new prequel series, but I'll definitely be going back to read Who Fears Death as well.

This story focuses on a 13-year-old Najeeba, who has recieved the mystical "calling" to travel the Salt Roads to a great dried lake where their people harvest salt that they then sell and trade to support themselves financially. Problem is, women aren't traditionally allowed to travel the Salt Roads -- but despite tradition and judgement form others in her village, she begins to accompany her father and brothers on this annual expedition, leading to adventure, discovery of hidden talents, and occasionally, perilous situations. Najeeba ultimately has to grapple with how becoming the person she wants to be sets her apart from the society that raised her.

Okorafor's writing is creative, confident, and immersive, and my only real complaint is that I wish this were longer: there are enough things going on with Najeeba's conflict, her relationships to her family and friends, and the fascinating lore and worldbuilding that I felt it left me wanting much more. Better than the alternative, for sure, and granted this is the first of three prequel novellas, and there's Who Fears Death that I can read, so perhaps doing that will round out the experience.

Overall I definitely recommend it!

Was this review helpful?

It’s been a few years since I have read a book by Okorafor but her approach remains as compelling and distinctive as I remember. She Who Knows is a prequel for Who Fears Death and is the story of Onyesonwu’s mother Najeeba. The central theme of this novella is, as the author writes in the opening notes, that ‘there are always and descendants’, and the text follows Najeeba’s discovery of this through the middle and later part of her teens.

When the story opens, Najeeba is thirteen and she has been called to accompany her father and brothers to collect salt – a task previously exclusively undertaken by Osu-nu men. The novella is set in the Earth’s distant future, a time in which there are remnants of our current technology (including caves full of computers, air-conditioned archives, and portable devices with mobile phone-like functions), but in which salt is the most precious commodity.

Najeeba is a curious, driven, self-assured, and spontaneous young woman, who pushes against and through the boundaries of acceptability to defy cultural norms as well as redefining her spiritual and mystical capabilities. She refuses to accept the hypocrisy of a society in which only men are allowed to visit a place discovered by women and through being the most honest and uncompromising version of herself creates profound change in her own life and her community. However, she must struggle with reconciling her desire for acknowledgement with the readily apparent costs that come from breaking taboos, and grapple with the consequences, results and fruitions of her nonconformity.

Okorafor is an expert in complex world building and this novella is a masterclass in doing so much in a succinct, enthralling, and powerful manner. This is listed as being book 1 in a series and I’m excited to read the next instalment.

Thank you to NetGalley and DAW Books for this ARC in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

A powerful and unforgettable coming of age novella, about breaking generational curses, and daring to answer your own call. Really enjoyed it.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to DAW and NetGalley for this ARC of She Who Knows. There were elements of this that I very much enjoyed. The world building was solid and I enjoyed the mystical/magical elements of it all but was disappointed in how little is mentioned beyond that these powers exist. Najeeba's struggles felt very real world and I enjoyed her family dynamics but her as a character I found kind of bland. Everything came too easy to her. Even when her powers manifested it was like, "Guess I meditate a few times and I'm good to go." Then they became even stronger transforming her (which was dope) but she just knew what to do. Her skills at the market were the same and half the time her response to how she could do things was, "I don't know, I just can." The plot was simple and easy to follow but felt very mundane a lot of the time and there were moments I could feel my mind wandering at the mundane or repetitive nature of the story. Well written as all Okorafor is but this one didn't keep me very invested. The very last page seems to speak of events in the connecting book and that got me interested in more/that book. To quote the last page of the book, "Ah, I see now...his interest finally piqued." Really sums up my reading but I trust Okorafor in the novella game so I will probably be back for more in this series.

Was this review helpful?

A young girl in a pseudo-dystopian desert of Africa dares to challenge cultural norms in this absolutely stunning coming-of-age novella steeped in tradition and magic.

I read it in one sitting. The world-building is beautiful, the writing is flawless, and the mysticism that feels so casual and effortless. But all of it flows together in the most epic backdrop for the protagonist to shine.

Najeeba embodies that curiousness and defiance present in every teenage girl. We follow her journey and growth over a few years as she tries to embrace a calling, only to be ostracized, berated, and gaslighted until we see the inevitable fire of feminine rage flicker to life within her.

Was this review helpful?

Okorafor is quickly becoming an auto-buy author for me. I’m on a quest to read her entire backlist, as everything I’ve read from her has blown my mind. She Who Knows takes place in the same world as Who Fears Death and kicks off a brand-new trilogy.

This book is incredible and I can’t wait to check out more of the universe from this one. I loved the blend of cultural roots, tradition, and the supernatural set alongside technology the likes of which we have never experienced. One of the camel’s being named Noor also took me out. 🥺 🐫

I don’t read as much fantasy nowadays as I used to, but I can easily say Okorafor is in my top 3 for fantasy authors. Check this one out if you like scifi with emphasis on the science, fantasy, witches, and bad-a$$ women challenging social norms.

If you are looking for a place to start reading this author, She Who Knows would be a great place to jump in! I also absolutely adore the Binti trilogy and Noor was a recent favorite. Check my stories for past reviews!

**Thank you to NetGalley and DAW Books for the eARC of this beautiful title!**

Was this review helpful?

An enlightening story of Onyesonwu's (protagonist of Who Fears Death) mother's journey. Immersed in Okorafor's world-building from the first page, I found the book hopeful despite the hardship experienced within. Najeeba manages to affect change in her culture over the span of a few years, turning gender roles on their head. While this comes at a personal cost to her, it seems to be just the beginning of her journey and I look forward to reading the rest of her story.

Was this review helpful?

Finishing this novella made me yearn for more. Najeeba’s story is absolutely fascinating, full of depths, magical and mythical, but also so human and so relatable. This is another amazing work of Nnedi Okorafor: fantastic storytelling, a fresh and creative idea, a unique, yet relatable leading character, great references… it’s such a wonderful read.
Najeeba is a unique character, a girl who gets the call that usually happens only to boys and men, and starts travelling with her father and brothers to extract salt in order to sell it. She manages to discover that she has unusual abilities, that make her not fit with her usual group of friends, relatives or even local communities and societal norms. The way her story unfolds is so engaging, that i couldn’t put the book away, i had to know what’s gonna happen next.
Can’t wait for the other books of the trilogy.

Was this review helpful?

A solid prequel to Okorafor's Who Fears Death, this novella focuses on the extraordinary talents of Najeeba, a young woman who carves a path for other women in undertaking what has previously been men's work. It's a nice coming of age story, and can serve as an introduction to this whole universe of Okorafor's.

Was this review helpful?

I received this via NetGalley as an ARC for review. I found the book easy to read and the plot moved quickly. The relationship development in the family was solid and I felt like I could connect with main character.

The novella is the story of Najeeba, the only daughter in a family of 5. Throughout the book she struggles to remain true to the confines of traditional expectations for women, versus what her drive is and what she is good at. I found her character interesting and appropriately rebellious. The magic system albeit not flushed out as fully as it would be in a novel, were easy to follow. There were elements of mystery to it that I'm sure are explored in Who Fears Death.

I do not generally read Sci-Fi and this was a prequel to an existing Sci-Fi novella. Although I did not rate this book 4 or 5 stars, I am intrigued enough with the plot and characters to now explore Who Fears Death. I would also be willing to revisit this story again after reading the existing novella. Overall, I would recommend to someone who enjoys Sci Fi novellas.

Was this review helpful?

Salt, dust, wind and a powerful will - this is Najeeba's tale.
- Nnedi

These words from the author's note are a perfect description of the novella, as well as Nnedi Okorafor's writing style. She Who Knows: Firespitter is Najeeba's origin story, as it were, and set in the same world as another series (Who Fears Death). It starts with Najeeba's Knowledge of the ancient Call to the salt mines, traditionally heard only by the men, and follows her as she faces all the consequences of answering it in the next few years. This is a standalone and I was able to follow the story even without reading Who Fears Death.

The world-building is Nnedi Okorafor's trademark africanfuturism (or africanjujuism, see Nnedi Okorafor) and I am amazed afresh at the vivid worlds she can build in just a few short pages. The book is set in a sort of post-apocalyptic world where the use of portables for communication is seen but their manufacture doesn't seem to be common. The story is steeped in myths and folklore however and it's wonderful to read such a rich story.

Nnedi's writing style is almost poetic, and describes certain moments, magic and mysticism beautifully. We see Najeeba's character arc as a response to the magic unfolding in her and all the other characters in relation to her. I did wish we could have seen more character development for Najeeba, especially in the latter half of the book (late teenage years). But I've been completely invested in this tale, as well as this world, since the first chapter of this novella and I look forward to reading more of this series, this world, and of Nnedi Okorafor's work!

🌟🌟🌟🌟
[One star for the premise and the whole book; One star for the writing; One star for the world-building and description; Half a star for the characters and arcs; Half a star for the story - Four stars in total].

Thanks to NetGalley, Nnedi Okorafor and DAW Publishing for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

She Who Know: Firespitter is a prelude to my favorite book by Okorafor, Who Fears Death. While the novella can stand on its own, I really loved getting insight to Onyesonwu's mother's journey. This novella is a testament to women making a way and I loved the voice Okorafor used.

In summary, in the novella, Najeeba is a young girl who does not conform to the expectations of her gender and was criticized for it by her family and friends. Every year her father and brothers would venture out to the Salt Roads to sell their findings in the market. However, this user Najeeba gets "the call" and joins her father and brothers on the road, despite the danger that can be found there for women. This propels us into a story of surpassing gendered limits and adventure.

I cannot wait to dive deeper into this universe that Okorafor has been weaving for over a decade.

Was this review helpful?

She Who Knows by Nnedi Okoroafor is a prequel to Who Fears Death. I read the latter a while ago and this was a good reminder and also provided some perspective to Who Fears Death. Quite intriguing. Now, I feel like rereading Who Fears Death.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own. Thank you, Netgalley

Was this review helpful?

This novella captures the story of Najeeba, the first girl in the memory of her village to feel the mystical call to journey to travel the Salt Roads. The story introduces a rich and complex African-futurist world: a town of a scorned people, built on the sale of salt, and the young girl who can ‘travel,’ allowing her a view of the world and of herself beyond what her family or town can understand. Though the novella is quick to read, it builds a deep and complex world and explores the intersection of gender roles and cultural norms in an engrossing coming-of-age tale. I thoroughly enjoyed reading She Who Knows: Firespitter and am excited to read the rest of this trilogy as it is released.

This book is set in the same world as some of the author’s other works. After reading this novella, I certainly plan on reading more in the series. I found She Who Knows to be very approachable and complete even without reading other novels in the universe.

I rate this book 4.5 out of 5 stars. It was incredibly beautifully written and a very enjoyable novella; though the ending was a tad rushed, I am excited to continue Najeeba’s story in the rest of the trilogy.

Was this review helpful?

"She Who Knows: Firespitter" is an engaging novella about a young woman named Najeeba and her otherworldy skills. I loved this African-futurist fiction and look forward to more books in this triloy. Nnedi Okorafor is able to convey so much character and setting development in a short novel. I also loved the bonds of love shown among Najeeba's family, and the pushing of gender boundaries in this book. Looking forward to more of this trilogy. Thanks to Penguin Random House and Netgalley for an eARC.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Random House for providing an arc to this for an honest rating.

First, this was a novella but it read like a full novel, in a positive way. I really enjoyed this. Najeeba, our main character, realizes she has the calling to go to the ice fields with her father and 2 brothers, which isn't a usual thing, as men are normally the people who go. Determined to break down barriers and answer her calling she tags along. She sooon realizes she has more than just a calling and will do anything to help her people and find out more about herself.

Najeeba is a loveable character, I connected with her and really took her seriously, especially for a teenager. I don't want to spoil anything so I will say this, the writing was great. As I mentioned I felt like I was getting a lot of necessary information in just a short amount of pages, 176, and really felt like it wasn't rushed. That is until the end. It's 4🌟 simply cause I felt like the end was rushed and I worry too much was left open for the second book in this trilogy, especially if that book is also going to be a novella.

Overall I enjoyed this and encourage you to give it a chance when it releases in August!

Was this review helpful?

This was an experience since I haven’t read the original book, but I trusted in Okorafor’s storytelling to get me where I needed to go. I’m still not sure if I got there, but… we traveled, for sure.

There’s a really interesting conversation about gender roles and expectations that starts early in this novella — the main character, Najeeba, looks more masculine and participates in activities that only boys/men can but still clearly identifies as a girl. What I liked most was how this was clearly acceptable in her family unit, joked about with tenderness and care. It contrasted wildly with her treatment by the community, providing a stark vision of the reality many women face for not presenting openly feminine or engaging in make-dominated spaces/activities.

Where I got lost was between the salt-selling and the shift into the magical. I still don’t really understand the purpose behind the fantasy elements — Najeeba being a firespitter after she learns to “travel” through meditation and ultimately using those powers to save herself. The disconnect between the early stages of the novella and the progression to her accepting her magical self felt wild to me.

I understand that her magic is the result of her father’s desire for retribution and vengeance, but I feel like there must have been a more cohesive way to get from point A to point B. This novella left me feeling like I had missed something, like there was a neon sign flashing a theme or idea I hadn’t grasped that knotted the narrative neatly together.

I can’t say I’ll be reaching for the original novel to fill in my blanks.

An ARC of this book was provided by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

4.0/5.0 Stars

Thank you to DAW books and NetGalley for an advanced copy of this book to review!

She Who Knows is a Sci-Fi/Post-Apocalyptic setting with West African influences. It is a prequel or prelude to a previously published work from this author "Who Fears Death" and this is explained at the beginning of the novella. I was worried that it would be difficult to understand the characters or world building but I was able to jump right in.

The writing is very clear and descriptive, not much fluff and I'm not sure if this is the author's writing style or the character's narration style - either way I enjoyed it because I was able to devour this novella quickly! The pacing is consistent and hooks you in, the plot was interesting and characters felt real. I loved the tone of the book had me on the edge of hopeful and defeated, which made the reading experience dynamic for me.

The story does feel a little rushed or concluded quickly at the end, but this seems to be the writing style with lots of time jumps between important scenes. I wish there was more elaboration or reveals about our main character at the end, because I enjoyed reading about her and following her journey.

Overall it was a quick, enjoyable and unique read. It hooked me into the world and motivates me to continue reading this series!

Was this review helpful?