Member Review
Review by
Randi S, Reviewer
Anyone who has a sibling knows that it is a relationship that at times can be rather complicated. That is certainly the case for the main characters in Erin Bartel's All That We Carried. In this book, we meet estranged sisters Olivia and Melanie as they are about to embark on a hike in Porcupine Mountains. With 10 years of distance between them, the trip was set to be difficult and dramatic before they even began. The journey itself only added to it, with things going wrong at every turn. What follows is a fantastic parable-type story about sisterhood, forgiveness and the burdens we carry with us.
When we first meet the sisters, they aren't what we would typically expect to see in lead characters in a Christian novel... after all, neither were Christians. Olivia believes in nothing, while Melanie believes in everything... in fact there are talks of tarot cards and reincarnation that one might not expect in the genre. Throughout their difficult journey we are able to see this grow and change. The character of Josh added a great balance to the sisters, and really made the story. I only wish we'd have seen more of him.
Oftentimes in books we expect it all to be wrapped up in the end, and I personally felt that this one didn't really do so. While part of me definitely missed that happily ever after and wanted to have some of the loose ends tied up, particularly in regards to Josh's character... I also like that it was left open to interpretation a bit too. While I cannot say much more without giving too much away, it certainly was something that made you think and set the story apart.
Overall, this was a beautifully written story that I truly enjoyed...and one that I'm certain will stick with me with it's beautiful messages of God's presence, forgiveness and the burdens we carry. It is definitely one worth checking out.
**I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher via Netgalley for consideration. All thoughts are my own.
When we first meet the sisters, they aren't what we would typically expect to see in lead characters in a Christian novel... after all, neither were Christians. Olivia believes in nothing, while Melanie believes in everything... in fact there are talks of tarot cards and reincarnation that one might not expect in the genre. Throughout their difficult journey we are able to see this grow and change. The character of Josh added a great balance to the sisters, and really made the story. I only wish we'd have seen more of him.
Oftentimes in books we expect it all to be wrapped up in the end, and I personally felt that this one didn't really do so. While part of me definitely missed that happily ever after and wanted to have some of the loose ends tied up, particularly in regards to Josh's character... I also like that it was left open to interpretation a bit too. While I cannot say much more without giving too much away, it certainly was something that made you think and set the story apart.
Overall, this was a beautifully written story that I truly enjoyed...and one that I'm certain will stick with me with it's beautiful messages of God's presence, forgiveness and the burdens we carry. It is definitely one worth checking out.
**I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher via Netgalley for consideration. All thoughts are my own.
*This page contains affiliate links, so we may earn a small commission when you make a purchase through links on our site at no additional cost to you.