Skip to main content

Member Review

Cover Image: The Woman in the Library

The Woman in the Library

Pub Date:

Review by

Sandra R, Librarian

4 stars
4 stars
4 stars
4 stars
4 stars
4 stars
4 stars
4 stars
4 stars
4 stars
"Clue" vibes, "Misery"-esque, meta murder thriller!

When four strangers hear a blood-curling scream while in the reading room of the Boston Public Library, it seems like just a weird coincidence. But when a dead body is found, a complicated web of lies and revenge traps them in a nightmare. Strange text messages, violent threats, and shady histories weaves together a story of a fiction within a fiction, perfect for fans of the game/movie Clue. Interspersed at the end of each chapter is another character who becomes increasingly obsessed with this fictional story, making this a meta-murder mystery with total Misery vibes that will have readers turning pages not knowing who to trust in order to figure out both mysteries.

Thoughts: I'm a huge fan of the game and movie Clue, so the fictional story making the up the bulk of this work had me hooked. I honestly didn't know who to trust. At one point it does become a bit predictable, but the underlying story-within-a-story is what really kept me invested. It's hard to describe, but basically readers are treated to a fictional murder mystery chapter by chapter along with a struggling author and fan who's offering suggestions to help the mystery's author. But as each chapter passes, the struggling author/fan providing feedback becomes increasingly aggressive and agitated. As the story escalates, so does this author/fan -- until everything comes to a dramatic conclusion. I like that we don't hear from the actual author but instead hear their perspective through their fictional chapters as the two stories unfold. While the murder mystery had some predictable aspects, the story-within-a-story is a twist I've only encountered a few times before and Sulari Gentill really hits the right notes with this format. It definitely enhanced the suspense of the story and kept me reading late into the night. As mentioned, this mystery is perfect for fans of Clue and Misery.

**Thank you NetGalley and Poisoned Pen Press for a DRC in exchange for an honest review.**
*This page contains affiliate links, so we may earn a small commission when you make a purchase through links on our site at no additional cost to you.