Skip to main content

Member Review

Cover Image: Every Rogue Has His Charm

Every Rogue Has His Charm

Pub Date:

Review by

Rae R, Media/Journalist

5 stars
5 stars
5 stars
5 stars
5 stars
5 stars
5 stars
5 stars
5 stars
5 stars
One of the tropes near and dear to my heart is Marriage of Convenience. What usually goes hand and hand with MOC? Let’s all say it together, class, “cockle crushing angst”. You know me; you know I hate car crash angst. The worst of these is the trope in which the husband (most of the time) leaves either the wedding night or shortly thereafter and years have elapsed. Usually the husband returns for whatever reason, usually taking on a title, inheriting a fortune, or just missing that sweet sweet…love. In the time apart, the partner left behind has either become a misanthrope or this extroverted enigma who champions every social cause, but especially those for puppies and orphans…together...orphaned puppies. And that’s how Pound Puppies were created.

When I say I was intrigued but weary of Every Rogue Has His Charms by Susanna Craig, you can guess the set up. Caroline (Caro), Marchioness of Chesleigh, has been married for 6 years, of those years, she has spent 5 years and 361 days separated from her husband, Maxim. After a compromising situation forces them to the altar, Maxim determines that Caro’s life would be easier, happier, and eventual without him in it. He flees back to France, where his assignment as a British foreign agent requires that he assumes the life of a Frenchman across enemy lies. With the death of his Grandfather and his ascension to his ducal title, Maxim has returned, but this time is it for forever?

The Compliment Sandwich
The Top Bun (The Pro)

Caro Is Making it Work
When Fanny, Caro’s companion, is describing her, she indicates that women in Lady Chesleigh’s position either become hardened and defiant or defeated and cleave in on themselves.
“Lady Chesliegh was neither. Despite a stated preference for novels, Fanny had in fact read enough philsophy to call her stoic. She moved about town with her shoulders bac, but her face covered. She lived frugally, particularly for a marchioness. She entertained rarely and did not dress in the latest fashions. If she had ever taken a lover in the six long years of her husbands’s absence, no one, not even the servants, breathed a word about it. She was difficult to either to pity or to judge”
I feel as though there is realness with that description and so very true to the time. With this trope, why must the person left behind be either a wet sop or a harridan? When you read about women of this time, most just ‘got along’ because they didn’t have an option nor did they have any recourse to do anything different. The life in which Caro grew up was difficult, at times one could consider it abusive, so in this situation she adapts well to living a low key existence. The loneliness pervades her interactions though, especially prior to the return of her husband.

Similarly, Maxim, has quartered himself in the farthest reaches of France, seeking out fistfights and brawls in order to feel something. At 11, Maxim was horribly injured after being trapped under a horse while attempting to bring medical assistance to his father. The hooves almost completely severed his leg and left the majority of his body scarred. For this reason, he considers himself not much more than a beast, unwilling to allow himself real feelings for those closest to him, in particular, his wife.

The Meat (The Con)
At times the various perspectives were a bit much

We have a lot of side characters that at certain points, drive the narrative. It feels as though somehow, one of the supporting characters wandered into the recording booth and someone handed them a microphone..”oh, okay, now I’m telling the story…” I know that the information we gain from these side characters is important to the overall plot, but I really wasn’t invested in them. I liked them, but not enough to really care what happened to them at the end.

The Bottom Bun (The Pro)
Love Takes Time

I’ve left a lot of the story here vague because we have a subplot with attempted murder and I, one, don’t want to spoil anything, and two, it’s not a forefront part of the plot. The attempts on both Caro and Maxim, while not at first considered to be malicious, give the characters the opportunity to spend more time together. With each of their defenses lowered and six years of solitude between them, both are raw but willing to work. Maxim especially finds himself intrigued by the woman he encounters upon returning home. He expected a shrill, angry, shrew and instead he finds a stoic yet cold woman.

“When Caro had steppedn into the room, Maxim had fully expected her to erupt in anger. Anger was understandable, justifiable. Familiar. He’d lived with ager all his life. Her calm put him at a disadvantage. But he could work with cold dismissal..
“Why would you assume I don’t inted to stay, my dear?”
“Past experience, I suppose.”
“Where else would I go?” he prodded, determined to break through her facade.
“To hell, for all I care.”

The two do not immediately fall into each other, even after Caro’s medical emergency. As she lies in bed convalescing, Maxim attempts to make inroads by spending time at her bedside. But as they were strangers when they married and have been estranged 6 years since, Caro is wary.
After a quarter of an hour, he snapped the book shut. “You despise this - despise me.”
She had turned toward the sound of the book closing but did not meet his eyes. “I hardly know you.”
Maxim nodded curtly, stung by her words, though he had no right to be. “And for that, I suppose you must account yourself lucky.”
‘Why?” she snapped back. “Why must I do any such thing? Why are you doing this? A few days ago, you walked back into my life, daring me to vent my furry at you, and now you - you’re sitting at my beside, reading poetry, all but daring me to to -” She broke off on a strangled cry of frustration and dropped her head into her hands.
To provide some context, this exchange occurs almost halfway through the book. When I say this is a slow burn, I mean it. Also, we have two very different sex scenes in this book which speak to where Maxim and Caro are in their relationship: one is all about consummation and the others are sensuous and loving. The progression their relationship takes while abbreviated in terms of length of duration, is catapulted into motion with major upsets that force the h/H to display a united front and begin understanding one another. A slow burn that goes from 0 - 60 at the 50% mark.

Overall, I adored this book. Caro was the perfect heroine for Maxim and their story, while angsty, definitely left me wanting more. This novel is the 4th in the Love and Let Spy series. I enjoyed the side characters (although I didn’t need their narratives) so much that I picked up the book just prior to this, Better Off Wed. I am assuming that we will get a 5th book that focuses on Fanny and Fitz at some point too. This was my first Susanna Craig (outside of a possible novella in a collection) and I certainly dug her style and her through line. I did guess who the villain was, but I’ll forgive it, as it wasn’t really the most central storyline.
*This page contains affiliate links, so we may earn a small commission when you make a purchase through links on our site at no additional cost to you.